6 Best Painters Near Gates, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Gates, NY have access to some of the strongest painting contractors in the greater Rochester area. Across hundreds of verified reviews, customers consistently highlight reliable scheduling, careful prep work, and crews who treat homes with respect. Here are the top-rated companies based on our Chooz Score analysis.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Sekula's Precision Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.9%, with 100% recommended on Facebook across over 50 recommendations. Owner Chris Sekula has built a team that customers trust enough to leave alone in their homes - several reviewers describe running errands while the crew works, completely comfortable with painters on site. One reviewer even shared that the crew found and carefully saved a sentimental hospital band from under a couch rather than discarding it. If you want a company with named, consistent crews and a track record of going beyond the paint job itself, Sekula's is a strong choice.

• Multiple reviewers describe the office staff, especially Caitlyn, as highly organized and responsive when coordinating estimates and scheduling
• Commercial contractors in the Rochester area actively refer their own clients to Sekula's, a level of professional trust that stands out
• Customers with large exterior projects on older homes note the crew's willingness to work through weather delays and schedule adjustments without frustration

"If I could give them more stars, I would! Chris and his team are consummate professionals. They ticked every box: prompt, hard-working, skilled, friendly, and respectful of our home." - Elizabeth Palmer, Google Review

For homeowners who want an owner personally involved in every stage of their project, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings delivers exactly that. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.5% with over 200 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Mark Rivoli is named in nearly every review, and customers describe him not just overseeing work but physically painting alongside his crew. R&R also specializes in concrete coatings and deck staining, making them a good fit if your project extends beyond walls and trim.

What stands out in R&R's reviews is how often customers describe Mark's patience with color decisions. Multiple homeowners mention him helping pick colors on the fly, offering product recommendations, and even picking up all the paint so the customer doesn't have to visit the store. A Sherwin-Williams store manager chose Mark to paint her own parents' home, which speaks to the level of confidence industry professionals have in his work.

• Crew members Tyler, Bethany, Donny, and Rob appear consistently across reviews spanning months, indicating a stable team rather than rotating subcontractors
• Several customers note R&R completed work ahead of schedule, including one who needed a project done before a birthday party and another before a summer gathering
• Homeowners in Rochester's historic districts praise R&R's ability to replace weathered cedar shakes and work with original materials

"As a manager of Sherwin Williams, picking a painter can be hard. I hand picked Mark and his crew. He did a fabulous job and his crew is amazing." - Erika Wolfe, Google Review

With over 5 years in business and a perfect 5.0-star rating across over 95 Google reviews, Monarch Painting has carved out a reputation for working on Rochester's older homes. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3%. President Eric Anderson holds a Bachelor's degree in Marketing from SUNY Brockport, and that background shows in how he guides customers through color selection with genuine expertise. Monarch is lead-safe certified and a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite, making them a good choice for pre-1978 homes in the Gates, NY area.

• Reviewers with homes from the 1920s through 1950s specifically praise how the crew handles plaster repairs, wall smoothing, and wallpaper removal before painting begins
• Eric personally checks in during multi-day projects and sends photos to homeowners who are traveling, keeping them informed remotely
• Several customers describe hiring Monarch for one room and immediately booking additional projects before the first one was even finished

"The work is impeccable. None of the splatters or drops I've seen from other painters. Eric even came back to check on us and make sure we were happy." - Liz Bunger, Google Review

When it comes to cabinet refinishing and epoxy flooring, Painting Plus Professionals stands out. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 75 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, plus an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau (accredited since 2016). Tyler handles cabinet work and is the only contractor reviewers mention who brings physical sample doors to estimates so homeowners can see and feel the finish before committing. If you're considering a kitchen cabinet refresh instead of a full replacement, Painting Plus is a solid option.

• Epoxy garage floor installations have become a growing part of their work, with Alex earning consistent praise for turning pitted, cracked concrete into showroom-quality surfaces
• Winner of the 2022 Best of Rochester Award in the Painting category, with 4.8 stars on Angi across over 35 reviews

"Tyler brought over sample cabinet doors when he came to do our estimate and was the only company to do so. Seeing a finished product and feeling the texture really set us at ease." - Emily Audet, Google Review

A husband-and-wife-style operation under owner Hope Worthington, Colors of Rochester takes a hands-on approach that shows in their reviews. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.1% with over 55 Google reviews and a 4.8-star rating, plus 100% recommended on Facebook. Hope took over the company in late 2023 and has maintained its long-standing reputation. She is Monroe County MWBE certified and OSHA 10 Construction certified. If you value working directly with the person who owns the business and want a painter who communicates arrival times precisely, Colors of Rochester delivers that personal touch.

• One reviewer changed their paint color mid-project and Hope accommodated the switch without issue, returning the next day with the new color ready to go
• Crew members Julia, Grace, and MaryBeth receive individual praise for precise edging and thorough wall preparation
• Landlords and property managers note that Hope's team handles move-out repaints efficiently, even managing items left behind by previous tenants

"Hope and Grace painted three rooms in our home. Their work was top notch! Edges were precise. Hope gave helpful advice regarding colors and was excellent at communicating arrival times." - Kathleen T, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Gates, NY, Level Up Painting handles everything from single-room refreshes to complex multi-story exteriors. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.5% with over 275 Google reviews and a 4.8-star rating. Co-owners Jacob Rabideau and Clyde Miller built the company over 8 years, and their brush-only approach to exterior painting (no spraying) produces cleaner lines on older homes. They are EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certified, making them a strong pick for homeowners with pre-1978 properties.

• Repeat customers make up a notable share of their reviews, with one customer on their sixth project and several already booking future work before the current job wraps up
• Reviewers with historic properties, including 100-year-old Queen Anne houses and cedar-shingled exteriors, praise how crews adapt their techniques to complex surfaces

"This is the sixth time we have used this company and we have always been extremely impressed with their work. Anthony is a pleasure to work with and we will always use this company." - Mary Ross, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, BBB

Painting contractors serving Gates, NY consistently earn praise for the quality of their finished work. Reviewers describe results that make 20-year-old kitchens look factory-new and century-old homes appear completely revitalized. Painting Plus Professionals receives particular attention for cabinet refinishing, where Tyler's process of bringing sample doors to estimates gives homeowners confidence before committing. Monarch Painting customers with older Rochester homes describe wall repairs and plaster patching so thorough that years of wear disappear before the first coat goes on. "The painters fixed ALL of the dents, scratches, holes in the walls, making everything look like new!" - James Maxwell, Google Review. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings earns similar praise, with customers noting Mark's crew addresses wall imperfections that previous drywall contractors missed.

The brush-only exterior approach used by Level Up Painting stands out among reviewers who own older properties. Multiple customers with homes over 100 years old describe how the crew scrapes, vacuums, caulks, and primes before applying a single coat, resulting in cleaner lines and longer-lasting finishes. Sekula's Precision Painting customers note that their crew exceeds expectations on scope, frequently completing more work than quoted within the original timeframe. "The rooms I had painted look amazing! When you find a company you can rely on, there's no reason to look anywhere else!" - Lisa Woodhouse, Google Review. Colors of Rochester reviewers highlight Hope Worthington's precision on trim and edges, with one customer noting their radiators, ceilings, walls, and doors all received equal care. "None of the splatters or drops I've seen from other painters" - Liz Bunger, Google Review. Across all companies, the pattern is clear: preparation drives the quality that Gates, NY homeowners consistently describe.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB

Communication is one of the strongest themes across painting contractor reviews in Gates, NY. Owner-operators like Mark Rivoli at R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings and Matt Coniglio at A & L Painting answer calls and texts directly, which customers consistently note as a relief compared to larger companies. Sekula's Precision Painting stands out for the coordination between office staff and field crews, with reviewers praising Caitlyn and the office team for clear scheduling updates and quick responses. "This company runs as a business should - prompt response time, great communication from start to finish." - Suzanne Calia, Google Review. Monarch Painting owner Eric Anderson combines his marketing background with hands-on involvement, personally walking customers through color options and checking in throughout multi-day projects.

Several companies earn praise for how they handle unexpected issues. R&R Painting customers describe Mark taking full accountability when a crew made an initial mistake, immediately correcting it without hesitation. Bates Brothers Painting owner Max Bates follows up every evening during active projects, discussing the next day's plan and confirming the homeowner is satisfied. "Max followed up every evening and discussed next steps until the project was completed. They said what they were going to do, and did what they said!" - S G L., Google Review. Colors of Rochester owner Hope Worthington keeps clients informed of arrival times precisely, and when one customer changed their color mid-project, she returned the next day with the new paint ready. Across Gates, NY area painters, the companies with the highest ratings share one thing: they treat communication as part of the job, not an afterthought.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB

Timeliness is a recurring strength among the top painting contractors serving Gates, NY. Level Up Painting reviewers describe crews arriving at the scheduled time each morning, with co-owner Jake providing schedule updates in advance. One customer noted the crew extended their hours to meet a deadline even during stretches of poor weather. Sekula's Precision Painting customers repeatedly mention the crew arriving on time and leaving on time each day, with one reviewer noting they completed more work than expected within the original timeframe. "They showed up on time and left on time. They completed the work and more than what they expected to have to do, still within the timeframe they quoted us." - Danielle Privitera, Google Review.

R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings customers highlight Mark's ability to meet tight deadlines, including finishing a project just days before a birthday party and another before a summer event. A & L Painting reviewers praise Matt's crew for completing kitchen cabinet projects in a single day, arriving early and working efficiently. Monarch Painting customers describe Eric providing accurate time estimates upfront, with one reviewer noting the crew finished a two-story foyer quickly and with minimal disruption. "They were in and out in a couple days and did a great job." - Frank Selice, Google Review. For homeowners in Gates, NY who need work completed around a specific deadline, these contractors have demonstrated they can meet the timeline.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Prep work and cleanup rank among the most frequently praised qualities across painting contractors in Gates, NY. Monarch Painting reviewers describe crews that cover every surface, including floors, counters, and cabinets, before any work begins. One customer with a split-level home noted they could not find a single stray speck of paint after their ceiling project. Level Up Painting takes a particularly detailed approach on exteriors, with crews scraping loose paint, vacuuming all scrapings, caulking gaps, removing gutter downspouts, and priming before any finish coat is applied. "Rebecca and her crew showed up, worked straight through for two days, scraped, vacuumed scrapings, caulked, nailed siding, removed gutter downspouts, primed, and painted my cottage." - Andy Liszkay, Google Review.

R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings customers note that Mark's crew addresses wall imperfections before painting, with one homeowner describing how they smoothed out issues a previous drywall installer had missed. Painting Plus Professionals reviewers specifically mention not finding a single drop of paint where it should not be, with heavy-duty floor covering used on every project. Sekula's Precision Painting crews store their equipment neatly over multi-week exterior projects, which customers with visible work areas appreciate. "The crew kept their equipment neatly organized over the weeks they were on site, which we appreciated." - Kathleen Meisenzahl, Google Review. Colors of Rochester customers describe Hope's team cleaning up thoroughly at the end of each day, leaving the work space tidy enough to live normally during the project. For Gates, NY homeowners who worry about mess during a paint job, these companies consistently deliver clean sites.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Value and fair pricing are common themes across reviews for painting contractors serving Gates, NY. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings stands out here, with multiple reviewers noting they gathered several quotes and found R&R to be the most reasonable while still delivering high-quality results. One customer collected seven estimates and found R&R to be the best value by a clear margin. Bates Brothers Painting customers describe owner Max Bates as transparent with pricing, presenting itemized estimates on the spot during the initial visit. "I received many quotes from many companies. The differentiator was Max himself. He was timely, transparent, knowledgeable and the pricing was perfectly fair." - Thomas M. B., Google Review.

Colors of Rochester reviewers consistently describe Hope's rates as very reasonable, especially given the level of care and thoroughness she brings to each job. Painting Plus Professionals earns praise for offering a cost-effective alternative to full cabinet replacement, with Tyler's refinishing process giving kitchens a new look at a fraction of the replacement cost. Monarch Painting customers note the company is competitively priced for the Rochester market while delivering premium preparation and finish quality. "We couldn't be happier. They were by far the most reasonable quote and we gathered 7 quotes before choosing them." - Juliana Baratta, Google Review. Level Up Painting reviewers who own large or historic properties note that the company quotes only what is needed, addressing high-priority areas without padding the scope. Across Gates, NY area contractors, the best-reviewed companies combine fair pricing with quality that justifies the investment.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB

Many homes in the Gates, NY area were built decades ago, and several painting contractors have built expertise around the challenges older properties present. Monarch Painting is lead-safe certified and regularly works on homes from the 1920s through 1950s, with customers describing careful plaster repair, wall smoothing, and specialized sanding techniques. One homeowner with a 1954 ranch noted the crew used a sander with a vacuum attachment that left virtually no dust in the house. Level Up Painting is EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certified and takes on complex projects including Queen Anne houses, cedar-shingled exteriors, and homes over 125 years old. Their brush-only exterior technique is specifically designed for older surfaces where spray painting would not produce clean results. "Level Up painted the outside of my 125-year-old house and did a great job. They quoted me just what I needed and accomplished the job quickly and professionally." - Doug Kelley, Google Review.

Sekula's Precision Painting handles both residential and commercial projects, including a daycare center ceiling repair after water damage and a 100-year-old home exterior refresh. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings customers in Rochester's historic districts describe the crew replacing weathered cedar shakes and working with original materials to meet preservation requirements. Painting Plus Professionals has expanded into epoxy garage floor coatings, with installer Alex turning heavily pitted concrete into durable surfaces that other contractors said would need full replacement. "We were previously told by others that the floor would need to be completely replaced at a cost of over $9,000. Thankfully, we found Alex." - Howard Brenner, Google Review. For specialty projects across Gates, NY, these contractors bring both the certifications and the hands-on experience to handle what standard painters cannot.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, BBB, Angi