Homeowners in Henrietta, NY have access to several highly reviewed painting contractors, many of whom bring years of experience and consistent customer satisfaction across the greater Rochester area. Whether you need a full exterior refresh, a kitchen cabinet update, or detailed interior work on an older home, the contractors ranked below have earned strong reputations through verified reviews and repeat business.
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Sekula's Precision Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.9%, with 100% recommended on Facebook across over 50 recommendations. Owner Chris Sekula runs a tight operation with named, dedicated crews who show up in branded company vehicles. Several reviewers mention that the crew finished ahead of schedule and left job sites cleaner than they found them. If you're the type of homeowner who wants to hand off the keys and come back to a finished product, Sekula's is a good choice.
What stands out across the reviews is how many customers describe feeling comfortable enough to leave while the painters worked. Reviewers also frequently mention the office staff by name, noting that communication was professional from the very first phone call through the final walkthrough. Chris has been recognized as the Greater Rochester Chamber of Commerce Business Person of the Year, and the company has been BBB accredited since 2017.
- Multiple reviewers describe crews arriving promptly at 8 AM each day and maintaining a clean, organized workspace throughout multi-week exterior projects
- Commercial clients, including a remodeling contractor who refers his own customers, describe consistent reliability across repeated engagements
- The company offers virtual color mock-ups so homeowners can preview paint choices on a digital overlay of their actual space before committing
"If I could give them more stars, I would! Chris and his team are consummate professionals. They ticked every box: prompt, hard-working, skilled, friendly, and respectful of our home." - Elizabeth Palmer, Google Review
For homeowners who value a hands-on owner and a perfect review record, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings earned a Chooz Score of 87.5% with over 200 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating. Owner Mark Rivoli personally handles estimates, assists with color selection, and works alongside his crew on many projects. R&R also specializes in concrete coatings and deck staining, backed by a limited lifetime warranty on their Penntek concrete coating installations. If you're looking for both painting and garage floor or patio resurfacing from a single company, R&R is a good choice.
Across the reviews, customers frequently describe Mark returning the next day to address even the smallest imperfections without being asked. Several homeowners in Rochester's historic neighborhoods praise the crew's ability to handle challenging exterior work on older homes, including cedar shake replacement and multi-story painting on structures that had been neglected for years.
- A Sherwin-Williams store manager chose Mark and his crew to paint her own parents' home, a detail mentioned independently in the reviews
- Customers with commercial properties describe Mark fitting jobs in on short notice and completing work without disrupting business operations
- Multiple reviewers note that R&R's pricing came in lower than competitors while the quality exceeded expectations
"We had an excellent experience with R&R Painting, who did the entire exterior of our house. Mark was a good communicator, and always responded promptly to texts and phone calls." - Anatole Kleiner, Google Review
When it comes to older Rochester homes with plaster walls, water damage, and decades of paint buildup, Monarch Painting stands out. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% with over 95 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating. With over 5 years in business, lead-safe certification for pre-1978 homes, and recognition as a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite in 2021 and 2023, Monarch has carved a niche in the Highland Park and Park Avenue neighborhoods. If you own a century-old home and want a crew that understands the challenges of historic surfaces, Monarch is a good choice.
Reviewers consistently describe the crew's patience with difficult surfaces, including hand-painting original storm windows and carefully patching plaster before any paint is applied. Owner Eric earns praise for his responsiveness and for returning after project completion to handle touch-ups at no extra charge. The crew handles everything from two-story foyers with cathedral ceilings to full exterior stucco restoration on Craftsman-era homes.
- One homeowner with a 1954 ranch was impressed that a specialized sander with vacuum attachment left virtually no dust in the house during plaster prep
- A property manager describes using Monarch exclusively for over 20 years and recommends scheduling early due to high demand
- The crew regularly handles wallpaper removal, drywall repair, and furniture moving as part of their full-service approach
"You want professional? Choose Monarch! You want precision lines? Choose Monarch! You want quality? It's Monarch all the way. Our home has never looked better!" - Jessica Metras, Google Review
Rounding out the top contractors with a specialty in cabinet refinishing, Painting Plus Professionals earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 75 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating. They hold an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau (accredited since 2016) and 4.8 stars on Angi across over 35 reviews. Winner of the 2022 Best of Rochester Award in painting, this company is a good choice if you want to update your kitchen without the cost of full cabinet replacement.
What sets them apart in the reviews is the cabinet refinishing process. Crew member Tyler brings physical sample doors to estimates so homeowners can see and feel the finished product before committing. Customers describe cabinets that look factory-new, with smooth finishes that hold up over time. The company also offers epoxy garage floor installations through crew member Alex, who reviewers credit with saving them thousands over full floor replacement.
- Multiple reviewers describe the crew using orbital sanders, heavy-duty floor coverings, and careful taping that left not a single drop of paint where it shouldn't be
- Owner Mike personally handles color consultations and keeps homeowners updated daily throughout the project
"My cabinets are solid wood and good quality but definitely looked outdated. Tyler did an amazing job of painting the kitchen cabinets to create a new look. The paint surface looks like it came from the factory." - Beth, Google Review
A woman-owned operation serving the Rochester area, Colors of Rochester earned a Chooz Score of 85.1% with over 55 Google reviews and a 4.8-star rating, plus 100% recommended on Facebook. Owner Hope Worthington took over the business in late 2023, and the company holds Monroe County MWBE certification along with OSHA 10 Construction credentials. If you want a painter who personally guides color selection and works alongside the crew, Colors of Rochester is a good choice.
Reviewers consistently describe Hope's hands-on style, from walking customers through the entire process to engaging warmly with their families and pets during the project. Several homeowners with 1920s-era houses praise the crew's ability to handle tricky trim, precise edges, and ceiling work that other painters might rush through.
- Customers describe Hope offering honest advice about colors and finishes, sometimes talking homeowners out of choices that wouldn't work well in their space
- Several reviews mention same-day or next-day completion of multi-room projects, with the crew leaving the home spotless
- Cabinet painting projects earn particularly enthusiastic reviews, with homeowners describing results that made existing kitchens feel brand new
"Hope and Grace painted three rooms in our home. Their work was top notch! Edges were precise. Hope gave helpful advice regarding colors and was excellent at communicating arrival times and schedule." - Kathleen T., Google Review
With nearly 5 decades in business, Whelehan Painting is the longest-running operation on this list. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.0% with over 175 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating, 98% recommended on Facebook, and 5.0 stars on Yelp. Founded in 1977 by Chuck Whelehan and now run by his son Pat, this family business operates with 16 in-house employees who work as established teams. If you want a company with deep community roots and crews you'll see again on your next project, Whelehan is a good choice.
What comes through clearly in the reviews is the sheer number of long-term customers. One homeowner has been using them for over 17 years. Another describes neighbors stopping to give honks and thumbs up after the exterior was finished. The company handles everything from 1880s-era homes getting their first-ever paint job to modern cedar siding staining and deck work.
- One reviewer notes that Whelehan came in with the lowest bid among multiple companies but delivered a result that was anything but low-quality
- Customers with large-scale projects describe crews of six or more arriving on time and working in organized, efficient teams
- Pat personally provides estimates, explains the full scope of work, and stays in communication throughout the project
"The Whelehan gang is the best! They painted our 1880s house for the first time ever. We had no idea what to expect, and they did an incredible job that exceeded our expectations." - Thomas Falbo, Google Review
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, BBB, Angi
