6 Best Painters Near Penfield, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Penfield, NY sits in the heart of Monroe County's eastern suburbs, where a wide range of home styles, from mid-century colonials to newer construction, means local painting contractors deal with everything from old plaster walls and chipping trim to fresh drywall and epoxy-ready garage floors. The top-rated contractors serving Penfield, NY on Chooz Painters have built their reputations through consistent crews, attentive communication, and a strong record of repeat business from customers who come back project after project.

Leading the rankings for Penfield, NY, Sekula's Precision Painting earned a Chooz Score of 87.9%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 75 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating, along with 100% recommended on Facebook across over 50 recommendations. Owner Chris Sekula and his named crew run a tight operation recognized by the Greater Rochester Chamber of Commerce as Business Person of the Year, with over 8 years in business serving both residential and commercial clients across the Rochester and Buffalo markets. If you want a painting company with a consistent, named team on every visit, for residential or commercial work alike, Sekula's Precision Painting is a strong choice.

Reviews describe a crew that runs on punctuality and careful organization. Customers with historic homes describe the team working through complex exterior conditions without cutting corners on prep. One business owner hired the company for a family commercial space and noted the same reliability that prompted the referral in the first place.

• Owner Chris is mentioned by name across reviews, with customers noting his involvement from estimate through final walkthrough
• Both residential and commercial projects are part of the portfolio, with business owners citing the same consistent quality they expected from residential referrals
• Crew organization draws steady praise, with reviewers noting tools and equipment kept in tidy order even during multi-week projects
• Historic home exteriors have been part of the work history, including a 100+ year old house exterior handled without skipping surface prep

"We had Sekula come to our 100+ year old house to give the exterior of our home, garage and side fence a refresh with exterior painting. From start to finish Sekula employees were complete pros." - Abby K., Google Review

While Sekula's is recognized for its long-term client relationships and consistent named crew, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings has built one of the most impressive review records in the Rochester area in a short time. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.5%, and the last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 200 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, a rare mark at that volume. Owner Mark Rivoli personally handles estimates and color consultations and works alongside his crew on job sites. If you want direct owner involvement throughout your project and need exterior, interior, or concrete coating work done, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings is worth a call.

What comes through in the reviews is a clear distinction between professional painters and casual contractors. Mark and his crew serve both residential and commercial clients, including short-notice commercial projects completed on schedule. Homeowners preparing to list their homes have also turned to Mark for guidance on which painting investments make the most sense before going to market.

• Mark personally handles color consultations, with customers describing his patience through multiple revisions before a final decision
• Commercial and residential clients both appear in the review history, with short-notice commercial projects described as completed without issue
• Concrete coating and patio staining are part of the service mix alongside traditional interior and exterior painting
• Mark's direct responsiveness gets multiple mentions, with reviewers describing consistent communication from first contact through project completion

"We originally hired a 'painter' who turned out to be a 'guy who can paint.' We moved on from him and hired Mark, who is a professional painter. There is a BIG DIFFERENCE. Painting is mostly about the prep work." - Nicholas B., Google Review

For homeowners dealing with the specific challenges of older Rochester-area homes, Monarch Painting stands out. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3%, with a perfect 5.0-star rating across over 95 Google reviews. In business for over 5 years, Monarch has earned Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite recognition in 2021 and 2023 and holds lead-safe certification for work on pre-1978 homes. If you have an older home with plaster walls, water damage, or other challenging surfaces and want a crew that will not rush through prep, Monarch Painting is a standout choice.

Real estate professionals and long-term homeowners both appear in the reviews. Agents have brought Monarch in for quick staging turnarounds, and longtime homeowners describe returning to the company across multiple projects spanning many years. High-volume spaces like 2-story foyers and great rooms with cathedral ceilings appear in reviews alongside praise for the crew's ability to handle tricky multi-level access cleanly.

• Lead-safe certification makes Monarch a dependable option for pre-1978 homes where surface prep requires additional care
• Real estate agents have hired the crew for staging projects, citing quick turnarounds alongside quality results
• High-ceilinged spaces and 2-story foyers appear across reviews, with customers describing well-managed access to challenging interior spaces
• Named crew members like Jimmy, Brent, Brian, and Angelica appear across reviews from different seasons and project types, pointing to a stable team

"You want professional? Choose Monarch! You want precision lines? Choose Monarch! You want quality? It's Monarch all the way." - Jessica M., Google Review

When cabinet refinishing and specialty floor coatings are on your list, Painting Plus Professionals covers ground that goes well beyond standard wall painting. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5%, with over 75 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating and 4.8 stars on Angi across over 35 reviews. Accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2016 and a winner of the 2022 Best of Rochester Award in the Painting category, the company has built a consistent local track record. If you want a team that handles cabinets, epoxy floors, and full-room painting without disrupting your daily routine, Painting Plus Professionals is a solid fit.

The reviews consistently note how unobtrusively the crew works. Multiple homeowners describe going about their normal routines during the workday without feeling the need to check on progress. Tyler, a senior member of the crew, specializes in cabinet refinishing and epoxy floor work, with one reviewer describing a garage floor original to 1953 that looked completely new after the project finished.

• Epoxy garage floor installation is a notable specialty, with strong results described even on concrete dating back to the 1950s
• Tyler brings physical sample cabinet doors to estimates, a practice that multiple reviewers credit with building confidence before committing to the project
• The crew works quietly enough that homeowners describe not noticing their presence during the workday
• Cabinet refinishing serves as a cost-effective alternative to full kitchen replacement, with customers noting the savings alongside the quality of results

"Tyler is professional, punctual, trustworthy and has a keen eye for detail. He works with state of the art equipment. If you're home during the day, you wouldn't even know he's there." - Barb S., Google Review

With over 13 years in business, Golden Boys Painting & Staining brings a depth of experience across a wide range of project types. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.0%, with over 75 Google reviews at a 4.8-star rating and 94% recommended on Facebook. The company also holds 5.0 stars on Angi across over 25 reviews and earned Angie's List Super Service Awards in 2014, 2015, and 2016. If you have a complex or unusual exterior surface, from log cabin siding to plaster walls to a deck ready for staining, Golden Boys Painting & Staining brings the experience to approach the work honestly.

One review stands out for what it says about how the company operates: a homeowner with a log cabin described Golden Boys recommending targeted touch-ups rather than a full repaint, focusing on weathered sections and carpenter bee damage. That straightforward approach, rather than recommending maximum scope, is a pattern that runs through other reviews as well. Wallpaper removal followed by plaster wall painting is also in the service range, with at least one reviewer praising the results on older walls after removal.

• Honest assessment of what work is actually needed, rather than pushing for maximum scope, is a recurring pattern through the reviews
• Wallpaper removal and plaster wall painting are part of the service range, with specific praise noted for results on older walls
• Owner Dan is mentioned by name across the review history as the primary contact from estimate through project completion
• Crew chief Aaron Palmer brings over 20 years of experience, with core members like Tadd and Luis having been with the company from its early years

"We have a log cabin home and they recommend only doing touch ups and addressing the weathered portions of the home as well as fixing bor holes from carpenter bees. Other companies recommended a complete paint job." - Erik S., Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Penfield, NY, Colors of Rochester brings a hands-on ownership style that shows clearly across the reviews. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.1%, with over 55 Google reviews at a 4.8-star rating and 100% recommended on Facebook across over 20 recommendations. Owner Hope Worthington took over this established Rochester company in late 2023 and has maintained its reputation through the transition. If you want an owner who works directly alongside her crew, handles older homes with chipping trim and multiple exterior colors, and prices fairly, Colors of Rochester is worth a call.

Hope's personal involvement is a thread running through nearly every review. Customers describe her engaging directly during estimates, color selection, and on-site project phases. Reviewers with older homes note that chipping trim and multi-color exterior arrangements were handled with care and expertise. Pricing earns favorable mentions more often here than at some competitors, with multiple customers noting that rates were fair relative to the results delivered.

• Owner Hope Worthington works alongside her crew on many projects, with multiple reviewers describing her on-site presence during their jobs
• Older Rochester homes with chipping trim and complex exterior color schemes have been handled well based on review accounts
• Pricing draws favorable mentions across multiple reviews, with customers describing fair and reasonable rates relative to quality
• The crew shows scheduling flexibility, with at least one reviewer noting the team adjusted plans for unexpected personal circumstances without issue

"We have an old house with a good amount of chipping trim, and they handled it with care and expertise. We had four colors on the exterior and they managed it all seamlessly." - Andrea P., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Responsive communication is one of the most consistently praised qualities among top-rated painting contractors serving Penfield, NY. Across companies, customers describe contractors who answer calls and texts promptly, give clear timelines before work begins, and check in throughout the project without needing to be asked. Sekula's Precision Painting draws praise for running their operation with prompt responses from the first inquiry and clear crew communication throughout the job. Monarch Painting owner Eric is described in multiple reviews as responsive by phone and text, with at least one customer noting he returned to touch up a section a week after finishing at no extra charge.

Several contractors serving Penfield, NY stand out for owner-level involvement in day-to-day communication. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings customers describe owner Mark Rivoli keeping them informed as the project progressed and correcting any issues promptly. Colors of Rochester owner Hope Worthington receives direct praise for accessibility and clear communication during quoting and color selection. Painting Plus Professionals customers note that crew members checked in at the start and end of each workday to explain what had been completed and what was coming next, a pattern that multiple reviewers described as rare and appreciated.

"This company runs as a business should - prompt response time, great communication from start to finish. Team was courteous and prompt." - Suzanne C., Google Review"Mark was a good communicator, and always responded promptly to texts and phone calls. Staff were courteous and professional." - Anatole K., Google Review"Always responsive, professional, and he went above to touch up the porch a week after they had finished. I would recommend Monarch to anyone looking for a quality painter." - Elliott A., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Thorough prep work is the most common thread across top-rated painting contractor reviews from customers in the Penfield, NY area. Contractors like Monarch Painting and Painting Plus Professionals are described in multiple reviews as spending more time on surface preparation than customers expected. Monarch Painting has built a specific reputation for older home surfaces, including plaster patching, water damage repair, and careful sanding before any paint is applied. One customer with a 1954 ranch home noted that a vacuum-attached sander left virtually no dust in the house during the process. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings customers draw a direct line between professional prep work and finished quality, with several reviewers distinguishing between contractors who prepare surfaces properly and those who skip those steps.

Exterior prep draws similar praise across multiple companies serving Penfield, NY. Sekula's Precision Painting handles complex exterior surfaces, including century-old homes, with reviewers describing careful work without skipping steps. Golden Boys Painting & Staining receives notes from customers about targeted prep on tricky surfaces like log cabins and plaster walls following wallpaper removal. Colors of Rochester customers with older homes describe the crew carefully addressing chipping trim before painting, even on multi-color exterior projects. Painting Plus Professionals customers note the team fixed every dent, scratch, and hole in walls before any paint came out, with several reviewers finding not a drop of paint anywhere it shouldn't be.

"They powerwashed, patched and repaired the stucco, and then painted the entire exterior of our challenging 103 year old Craftsman-Tudor home and the results are outstanding." - Andrew C., Google Review"Most amazing was their attention to detail in the prep work. There was not even a drop of paint on the appliances or the floor." - James M., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

On-time arrival and project completion within the promised timeframe are mentioned frequently across reviews for top-rated painters serving Penfield, NY. Customers across multiple companies describe contractors who arrived at the stated start time each morning, kept to the timeline discussed at the estimate, and wrapped up without unexpected delays. Sekula's Precision Painting draws consistent mentions of the crew arriving promptly each day, with reviewers noting the team showed up on time every morning and finished when they said they would. Monarch Painting owner Eric is described in multiple reviews as giving realistic timelines and sticking to them, even on large multi-room interior projects with high ceilings.

Contractors serving Penfield, NY have also handled time-sensitive situations well. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings completed at least one commercial project on short notice without sacrificing quality. Monarch Painting has taken on real estate staging jobs requiring quick turnarounds. Golden Boys Painting & Staining customers describe projects completed on schedule, with more than one reviewer noting they had already referred the company to others by the time the job wrapped up. Painting Plus Professionals earns praise for communicating timelines clearly from the estimate stage forward, with crew members explaining day-by-day plans to homeowners before starting.

"They were on time every morning and completed the job when they said they would. The crew was very friendly and respectful." - Makini B., Google Review"Quality work done in a timely manner, with frequent updates and clear communications. Bob and Rachel were a delight to work with: neat, tidy and respectful of our home." - Steve J., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Fair pricing relative to the quality of work is a recurring theme in reviews for contractors serving Penfield, NY. Customers across companies describe receiving detailed, itemized estimates with no surprise charges, and several note they compared multiple bids before choosing the contractor they hired. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings receives specific mentions of pricing being competitive alongside strong attention to detail, with owner Mark Rivoli described as upfront about costs from the first conversation. Painting Plus Professionals customers describe cabinet refinishing and epoxy flooring as cost-effective alternatives to full replacements, noting the quality of results alongside the savings compared to new installations.

Several contractors serving Penfield, NY draw praise not for being the cheapest option, but for the value they deliver at their price point. Colors of Rochester earns favorable mentions on pricing relative to quality more often than some competitors, with customers describing rates as fair and reasonable. Golden Boys Painting & Staining customers note transparent pricing alongside an honest assessment of what work actually needs to be done. One reviewer described receiving candid feedback about what materials were and weren't appropriate for a given surface without any attempt to push additional scope. Sekula's Precision Painting customers describe finishing projects at a reasonable price for results that exceeded expectations.

"They beat everyone else's pricing and the attention to detail is second to none. Fully would recommend them to anyone." - Dustin M., Google Review"Much more affordable than replacing my cabinets entirely, and the quality is far superior." - Jennifer B., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Clean job sites and thorough daily cleanup are mentioned across reviews for top-rated contractors in the Penfield, NY area. Customers describe companies that lay drop cloths, protect furniture and floors before work begins, and leave the space in better condition than they found it. Monarch Painting reviews note that crews protect surrounding areas carefully, and one customer with a 1954 ranch commented on how little dust remained after a full sanding session thanks to specialized vacuum-attached equipment. Painting Plus Professionals customers describe finding not a drop of paint where it shouldn't be, on appliances, floors, or fixtures, even after full interior repaints.

Daily cleanup habits draw specific mentions as well. Sekula's Precision Painting customers note that crew equipment was kept neatly organized throughout multi-week projects, with the site clean at the end of each workday. Golden Boys Painting & Staining receives direct mentions of careful daily cleanup, with customers describing the crew as neat and tidy throughout exterior and deck projects. Colors of Rochester reviewers use words like neat, clean, and organized repeatedly when describing the crew on site. One reviewer specifically noted that the team cared for their space and belongings throughout the entire project.

"The team kept their equipment neatly organized over the weeks they were on site, which we appreciated." - Kathleen M., Google Review"Hope and Julia were On Time, Neat, Clean, Cared for our Space and Stuff and BEST of all, BESIDES their very reasonable rates, how ACCOMMODATING they were." - Ann Marie D., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Repeat customers are a strong signal across the top-rated painting contractors serving Penfield, NY. Reviews from returning clients appear across multiple companies, describing second and third projects booked with the same crew after positive first experiences. Sekula's Precision Painting has a particularly consistent pattern of repeat business, with customers like Lisa Woodhouse describing hiring the crew for exterior work and then returning years later for a full interior project and finding the same standards. Multiple other Sekula's reviewers mention they had already planned or scheduled their next job before the current one wrapped up. Monarch Painting has customers spanning over two decades, with one reviewer noting they have had all of their home painting done by Eric and Monarch since moving in.

The pattern extends across other top contractors in the Penfield, NY area. Golden Boys Painting & Staining customers describe returning for a second project after a positive first experience, with reviewers praising the same crew members on both visits. Colors of Rochester has earned early repeat business and referrals from customers who hired Hope Worthington for one project and immediately started recommending her to friends and family. Painting Plus Professionals reviewers describe recommending the company to others, with at least one customer noting they chose the company based on others' reviews and then left one of their own. Word-of-mouth referrals connecting back to existing customers appear regularly across these reviews as well.

"Eric and his team are wonderful to work with. Very professional and provided great communication through the process. They have done 2 jobs for our family and we couldn't be happier with the results!" - Emily B., Google Review"This will always be my go-to for painting or staining. We have had our house and deck stained by Dan, and the quality and attention to detail is outstanding." - Cassidy M., Facebook Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook