Golden Boys Painting & Staining
About Golden Boys Painting & Staining
Founded in 2012 by Dan Cavagnaro, Golden Boys Painting & Staining grew from a one-man operation into a respected Rochester-area painting contractor. Dan began his career at nineteen, apprenticing under a master painter who emphasized customer satisfaction, hard work, and precise attention to detail. More than fifteen years later, those principles remain at the core of the company.
The team includes crew chiefs Tadd (with the company since the beginning) and Aaron (over twenty years of industry experience), along with lead painters Luis and Nicholas. Together they handle interior and exterior painting, cabinet refinishing, deck and fence staining, wallpaper removal, drywall repair, and power washing. Every exterior project begins with thorough power washing to ensure proper surface preparation.
Golden Boys Painting & Staining serves Rochester, Brighton, Pittsford, Victor, Fairport, Penfield, Greece, Henrietta, and surrounding communities within a 25-mile radius. The company is a three-time Angi Super Service Award recipient (2014, 2015, 2016) and earned 2025 Nextdoor Neighborhood Fave recognition. They actively support Habitat for Humanity and Rochester Rotary.
Updated: 01-12-2026
Q&A Based On What Customers Are Saying About Golden Boys Painting & Staining
Q: Has Golden Boys Painting & Staining ever recommended against more expensive work to save customers money?
Erik Stoneham's log cabin experience stands out. After competitors quoted full restaining at twice the price, Dan assessed the home and recommended targeted touch-ups instead. Stoneham noted "he could have easily sold us the moon" but chose the right solution over maximum profit. This pattern of honest assessments over upselling appears throughout customer feedback.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What do customers say about Golden Boys Painting & Staining's cabinet refinishing work?
Cabinet projects generate strong responses. Trey Black shared before-and-after photos showing "an amazing job" that transformed dated cabinets. Michael Dengel described the kitchen cabinet painting as "thorough" with every detail handled carefully. Multiple customers mention cabinet refinishing saves thousands compared to full replacement while achieving results that look brand new.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Do customers see the same Golden Boys Painting & Staining crew members across different projects?
Reviews consistently reference the same team members by name. Michael Dengel praised "Tad and Nick" for cabinet work, while Trey Black mentioned "Tadd and his crew." Aaron appears across multiple exterior projects, and Dan personally handles estimates and final walk-throughs. This consistency indicates in-house employees rather than rotating subcontractors.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How did Golden Boys Painting & Staining handle their one negative review?
The single negative review involved scheduling difficulties on a playset staining quote. Owner Dan responded professionally, explaining the timeline including a missed appointment. Rather than becoming defensive, the response provided factual context while expressing regret the project did not proceed. With over 100 reviews across platforms showing consistent satisfaction, this appears as an isolated communication breakdown.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What makes Golden Boys Painting & Staining's exterior painting approach stand out according to customers?
Thorough preparation defines exterior work. K Koetter's whole-house project including garage and deck earned praise as "our favorite transformation of the summer" in Dan's reply. Jennifer Forrest called the experience "the best contractor experience we have ever had." Power washing every exterior surface before painting ensures proper adhesion and longer-lasting results.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Do Golden Boys Painting & Staining customers come back for additional projects?
Multiple reviews confirm repeat business. Peter Zuris noted this was his "second interior painting job" with the company. Susan Spear mentioned she "already requested them to clean my deck this spring" after her staining project. Phil Maves stated he "will be hiring them again." This return customer pattern suggests satisfaction extending beyond initial projects.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Does Golden Boys Painting & Staining provide accurate estimates that match final costs?
Jennifer Forrest's exterior painting project demonstrates estimate accuracy. She reported "the best contractor experience we have ever had" with the final price matching the original estimate exactly. Erik Stoneham described receiving a "fair and transparent estimate" for his log cabin. Customers consistently mention pricing discussions are straightforward with no surprise charges at completion.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What types of specialty projects has Golden Boys Painting & Staining handled successfully?
The company tackles diverse challenges. Jim ONeil's commercial restaurant renovation showed the team "went above and beyond" for business clients. Tricia Maher praised the "meticulous, neat, and professional" approach during wallpaper removal and subsequent painting. Andrew Goldman's interior office project "exceeded expectations by light years." From historic homes to commercial spaces, capabilities extend well beyond standard residential work.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Updated: 01-12-2026