Golden Boys Painting & Staining
About Golden Boys Painting & Staining
Serving Rochester and the surrounding communities of Pittsford, Penfield, Brighton, Fairport, and Webster, Golden Boys Painting & Staining has built a respected presence in Western New York since 2012. The company was founded by Dan Cavagnaro, who began his apprenticeship under a master painter at age nineteen and has carried those guiding principles of customer satisfaction, hard work, and precise attention to detail into every project since.
The team offers interior and exterior painting, cabinet refinishing, deck staining, power washing, and wallpaper removal for residential and commercial clients throughout the greater Rochester metro area. Crew chiefs Tadd Tilton and Aaron Palmer, who brings more than 20 years of industry experience, lead job sites alongside lead painters Luis Planteny and Nicholas Daniluk. The same core crew has remained consistent across projects for years, with many team members named by name in customer reviews.
Golden Boys earned the Angie's List Super Service Award in 2014, 2015, and 2016, recognizing consistent quality and customer service across those years.
Updated: 02-25-2026
Q&A Based On What Customers Are Saying About Golden Boys Painting & Staining
Q: Does Golden Boys Painting & Staining deliver final pricing that matches the original estimate?
Multiple customers note that invoices came in at or near the quoted amount. Jennifer Forrest called the price "spot on the estimate" and named the experience the "best contractor experience we have had, ever." C Downey described the work as both professional and offered at a "reasonable price" even for a smaller pergola repair job. Jeanne Randall echoed this, noting the pricing was "excellent." A B confirmed the team did not attempt to upsell beyond the agreed scope.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What do Golden Boys Painting & Staining customers describe about the cabinet refinishing results?
Cabinet refinishing work draws strong responses from customers. Michael Dengel noted that the crew "took their time, was thorough and the cabinets look great." Trey Black was struck by how seamlessly old frames blended with new doors, writing "you can't even tell that it's a mix of old cabinets with new doors." Black also highlighted the team's scheduling flexibility, working around other active kitchen renovations throughout the project without any disruption.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What happened with the negative reviews left about Golden Boys Painting & Staining?
Both negative reviews involve the same customer, Heidi Yip on Google and Heidi Lynn on Facebook, relating to scheduling difficulties around a playset staining project. The owner responded on Google with the company's perspective on missed appointments and communication gaps. The Facebook post received no owner reply. Andrew Goldman's review of a very different experience captures the broader pattern, describing service that "exceeded every one of my expectations by light years" and an "extra layer of thoughtfulness and workmanship."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Facebook
Q: How do Golden Boys Painting & Staining customers describe the deck staining and outdoor work?
Outdoor work draws consistent praise for honest consultation and transparent pricing. A B noted the team was "up front with pricing for labor and material costs" on a deck staining and front door project. Erik Stoneham highlighted a valuable recommendation when the crew suggested targeted touch-ups on his log cabin rather than a full re-stain, noting other companies "wanted to re-stain the whole home and were almost twice as expensive." Jeanne Randall called her completed deck "terrific."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What do customers say about how Golden Boys Painting & Staining crew chiefs Aaron Palmer and Tadd Tilton run their job sites?
Both crew chiefs earn frequent praise by name. Phil Maves noted that Aaron "made sure his crew took the extra steps needed to ensure a thorough job," while Justin Krog described Tadd as having "such a positive attitude, great attention to detail, and is a great leader to the team." Krog also noted that minor issues after completion were addressed promptly when Tadd returned to fix them, demonstrating follow-through beyond the final walkthrough.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Does Golden Boys Painting & Staining handle commercial projects beyond residential homes?
Commercial work is part of the company's portfolio. Jim ONeil described a full restaurant renovation, writing that everyone involved went "above and beyond" from start to finish and that he "can't say enough about the excellent service and experience." Cassidy Michelle Macca on Facebook described the company as her permanent "go-to for painting or staining" after having both her house and deck done, noting the quality and attention to detail is "unmatched."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Facebook
Q: Why do so many Golden Boys Painting & Staining customers call out communication as a standout quality?
Communication appears as a consistent theme across reviews from both residential and commercial clients. Dan Hogan appreciated "the continuous communication around the schedule of my project," while Jennifer Forrest described how the site manager "communicated every step of the way" and addressed concerns daily. Jenelle Rosano noted the crew arrived on time and communication was "great." This pattern suggests a company-wide emphasis rather than an occasional strength.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How does Golden Boys Painting & Staining handle cleanup during and after projects?
Cleanup receives consistent attention in reviews across project types and sizes. K Koetter noted the crew "cleaned up after each day they were here" throughout a multi-day exterior house project. A B described both the work and cleanup as "amazing" on a deck and trim project. Jeanne Randall praised the team as "organized and efficient from start to finish" on a deck and arbor staining job. Customers across multiple reviews note that the finished space is left ready for immediate use.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Updated: 02-25-2026