Question 1

Who are the top-rated painters in Walworth, NY on Chooz Painters?

Accepted Answer

Painting contractors serving Walworth, NY bring a consistent emphasis on thorough prep work, responsive owners, and crews that show up on time. The three top-rated companies in the area cover a wide range of projects - from full exterior repaints and deck staining to cabinet refinishing and specialty epoxy flooring - and customers across all three describe results that went well past their initial expectations. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings had over 200 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating - a perfect score at that review volume is rare. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.5% , with strong marks for review quality and recent activity. Owner Mark Rivoli is on the job from the initial estimate through the final walkthrough, personally handling color consultations and quality checks along the way. If you're looking for an owner-led crew that handles both residential and commercial projects with equal care, R&R is a strong choice. The range of project types in their reviews is notable: an orthodontic office, a VFW post (where the crew painted a UH-60 helicopter on display), and a three-story historic-district home with cedar shake replacement all appear alongside interior rooms, decks, and porch staining. Several customers who were preparing their homes to sell turned to Mark specifically for color advice and guidance on project scope. Repeat customers are common across the reviews, and multiple reviewers mention plans to call R&R again for upcoming projects. Mark followed up after project completion to address even minor imperfections, with reviewers noting issues were corrected without hesitation The crew rescheduled staining and exterior jobs around weather conditions to protect finish quality Named crew members including Tyler, Bethany, Tom, Janice, and Jose appear consistently across multiple years of reviews and project types "At R&R Painting it's not just about painting!!! The prep work (patching, filling holes, sanding, etc) on 30 yr old walls and kitchen cabinets revived them - everything looks like a new install!" - Cindy Smalley, Google Review For homeowners weighing whether to replace or refinish - whether kitchen cabinets, garage floors, or surfaces that look past their prime - Painting Plus Professionals has built its reputation on delivering finishes that make older surfaces look factory-new. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 75 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating , a 4.8-star rating on Angi across over 35 reviews , and a Chooz Score of 86.5% . The company has been BBB-accredited since 2016 and earned the 2022 Best of Rochester Award in the Painting category. If you're considering replacement before getting a refinishing quote, this company is worth calling first. Two specialists drive much of the company's work. Alex leads epoxy garage floor refinishing and has saved customers thousands over full floor replacement by leveling sloped concrete and applying professional-grade coatings. Tyler handles cabinet refinishing and is known for bringing physical sample doors to estimates, letting homeowners see and feel the finished product before committing. Their review history also includes a 100-year-old home with significant mildew, where the crew correctly identified which sections needed full treatment and which did not across a complex, multi-section project. Alex leveled a severely sloped garage floor before the epoxy application - a step competing contractors hadn't mentioned to the homeowner Tyler re-sanded and re-stained portions of a cabinet project that weren't taking the finish correctly, without being asked The crew organized a three-room interior project so the homeowners could continue their daily routine throughout "Working with Mike and his team was a breeze. We had 3 rooms done at once and it was all very organized so we could still live our daily lives during the process." - Patty Bates, Google Review With over 13 years in business , Golden Boys Painting & Staining has earned a reputation built largely on repeat customers and referrals. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.0% , and at the time of our analysis, they had over 75 Google reviews with a 4.8-star rating , along with 5.0 stars on Angi across over 25 reviews , 94% recommended on Facebook , and 5.0 stars on Yelp . The company was a three-time Angie's List Super Service Award winner in 2014, 2015, and 2016. If you value a contractor who gives honest recommendations rather than overselling the scope, Golden Boys is a strong option. The honest-assessment approach comes through clearly in their reviews. When a log cabin owner inquired about a full re-stain, the crew recommended targeted touch-ups and repairs instead, saving the customer roughly half compared to competing bids. Small jobs receive the same level of attention as major projects: a hail-damaged pergola drew the same detailed care as full exterior repaints. Owner Dan oversees projects directly, and crew chief Aaron Palmer, with over 20 years of experience, has been called out by name across multiple recent reviews. The company handles specialty work including wallpaper removal, plaster wall restoration, and commercial space renovations Reviewers consistently note the final price matched the estimate closely, with no surprise additions at completion Customers describe the team as responsive from the initial quote through project completion, including on multi-day exterior jobs "The paint job was perfect. The price was definitely right. Spot on the estimate! Best contractor experience we have had, ever!!!" - Jennifer Forrest, Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Angi, Facebook, BBB, Yelp

Question 2

What do customers say about the quality of work from painters in Walworth, NY?

Accepted Answer

Quality is the most consistently praised aspect across painters serving Walworth, NY . The top-rated contractors in the area treat quality not just as a final result but as something built through preparation - whether that means sanding old walls, replacing weathered shingles, or re-working sections of a finish that aren't holding up before calling the job done. At R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings , customers consistently note seamless wall patches, clean cut-in edges, and exterior results that neighbors stop to compliment. One reviewer who had the entire exterior of an older home redone described the crew removing weathered cedar shakes and restoring three full stories of siding in under two weeks. At Painting Plus Professionals , Tyler's cabinet refinishing work is repeatedly described as looking like it came from the factory - and on one project, he re-sanded and re-stained portions that weren't taking the finish correctly before the job was considered complete. Golden Boys Painting & Staining rounds out the quality conversation, particularly on trim and cabinet work where reviewers describe seamless blending between old frames and new doors. On exterior projects, multiple coats and thorough surface preparation are a consistent part of the crew's process. "All holes were spackled and sanded. The walls were also sanded, the patches were seamless, and there were no roller marks on the walls. The paint job came out perfectly and the trim was immaculate." - Corey Gefell, Google Review "We have had our house and deck stained by Dan, and the quality and attention to detail is unmatched. This team truly cares about your home!" - Cassidy Michelle Macca, Facebook Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Question 3

How do painting contractors in Walworth, NY handle communication with customers?

Accepted Answer

Communication is one of the most frequently mentioned themes in reviews for painters serving Walworth, NY . Customers across all three top-rated companies describe being kept informed not just at the start of a project but throughout - with check-ins, prompt replies to questions, and clear expectations set before work begins. At R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings , Mark Rivoli is cited by name for his responsiveness, with multiple reviewers describing same-day replies to texts and calls. One customer who was away during a staining project noted that Mark handled all questions via email and phone without delay. At Painting Plus Professionals , daily check-ins are a distinguishing feature: the crew would open each morning by asking homeowners about questions from the previous day's work and explaining which rooms they'd be working on that day. Golden Boys Painting & Staining earns similar praise, with reviewers describing a site manager who addressed questions and concerns on the spot each day throughout multi-day exterior projects. The common thread is owners and crew members who treat communication as part of the job, not an afterthought. "Mark was very responsive and patient in answering all our questions. We appreciate him willing to reschedule the paint job several times until the weather was good." - Hsiuling Wong, Google Review "The communication was excellent and so was the work done." - Olufemi Adunse, Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Question 4

Do painting crews in Walworth, NY thoroughly handle prep work and cleanup?

Accepted Answer

Prep work and cleanup come up in nearly every review for top-rated painters in Walworth, NY . The contractors serving this area treat surface preparation as a core part of the job, and customers consistently note that homes are left clean and organized at the end of each day. At R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings , interior prep means furniture moved and protected, floors tarped, outlet covers and railings taped, and holes filled and sanded before painting begins. On exterior projects, power washing and scraping old paint come before any primer goes on, and the results hold up over time - several customers who had poor experiences with previous painters describe R&R's prep-first approach as the difference. At Painting Plus Professionals , reviewers consistently note that not a drop of paint was found out of place after the job. A BBB-reviewed project on a 100-year-old home with significant mildew stands out: the crew correctly identified which sections of the complex, multi-section house needed full treatment and which did not, without missing a detail. Golden Boys Painting & Staining crews clean up daily on multi-day projects, with customers noting that the site was left organized each afternoon. "I hired R&R Painting to paint the entire exterior of my house. Mark and his team did everything from power washing the siding to scraping off old paint and removing the mildew, all before they opened the first can of paint." - Jim Ver Steeg, Google Review "All members of his team were professional, polite and they cleaned up after each day they were here. We are so happy with the finished product - the attention to detail and quality of work is top notch!" - K Koetter, Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google, BBB

Question 5

What do customers say about pricing and value from painting contractors in Walworth, NY?

Accepted Answer

Value comes up frequently in reviews for painting contractors in Walworth, NY - not just in terms of competitive rates but in terms of what customers get for the money. The top-rated companies in the area have earned strong marks for delivering results that hold up well relative to what was paid. At R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings , multiple reviewers specifically cite competitive pricing as a factor in their decision. One customer who gathered seven separate quotes found R&R to be the most affordable by a clear margin, while still rating the quality of work highly. Staining projects that peeled quickly with previous painters held up after R&R's prep-focused approach. At Painting Plus Professionals , the value conversation often comes back to avoiding replacement costs entirely - Alex's epoxy floor refinishing has saved customers thousands over full floor replacement quotes, and Tyler's cabinet work is consistently described as a fraction of the cost of new cabinetry. The company is upfront that they aren't always the cheapest, but the results justify the investment in customers' accounts. Golden Boys Painting & Staining earns consistent praise for accurate estimates, with reviewers specifically noting the final bill matched the quote with no surprise additions. "They beat everyone else's pricing and the attention to detail is second to none. Fully would recommend them to anyone and everyone." - Dustin Marcello, Google Review "Much more affordable than replacing the cabinets, I would highly recommend this company for any painting projects." - Jennifer Buscemi, Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Question 6

Who are the humans that helped create the Walworth, NY Chooz Painters listing page?

Accepted Answer

This page was created by our dedicated team members. Chooz Listing Page & Profile Creator: Cher B., Almira A.. Chooz Score Reviewer: Ed Anthony D., Mike N.. Each team member contributes to ensuring the accuracy and quality of our painter listings and reviews.

Best Painters Near Walworth, NY - Chooz Score Ranked

Painting Plus Professionals

Chooz Score 73%

Why Customers Choose Painting Plus Professionals

The Details Matter Here

Years of Consistent Results

Familiar Faces, Consistent Results

Other Reviews & Ratings

Q&A Based On What Customers Are Saying About Painting Contractors in Walworth, NY