Best Painters Near Macedon, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Painting contractors serving Macedon, NY draw from one of the region's most competitive markets. The greater Rochester area has produced several crews with deep project histories, loyal repeat customers, and consistent ratings across platforms. Whether you need exterior work on an older home, an interior refresh before a move, or specialty services like cabinet painting or epoxy flooring, the contractors below have proven track records backed by verified reviews.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Sekula's Precision Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating, along with 100% recommended on Facebook across over 50 recommendations, earning a Chooz Score of 87.9%. One of the patterns that stands out across their reviews is the depth of customer loyalty - reviewers like Lisa Woodhouse describe hiring the company for exterior work in 2021 and returning three years later for a full interior project, finding the same standards held. Commercial clients appear alongside residential customers, with a daycare center and a professional remodeling contractor among the review contributors. Owner Chris Sekula's operation has been accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2017, and the company has been recognized as the Greater Rochester Chamber of Commerce Business Person of the Year. If you want a crew you'll likely call back for future projects, Sekula's Precision Painting is a strong choice.

The crew structure here is worth noting. Named painters including Ray, Nick, Patrick, Uriah, Christian, and Alexander appear across independent reviews spanning several years, pointing to a stable team rather than revolving subcontractors. Several customers mention scheduling weather-dependent exterior work and receiving proactive updates from the office team on timeline adjustments throughout.

• Multiple reviewers mention feeling comfortable leaving the crew unsupervised in their homes - one noted the team carefully set aside a hospital birth band they found under a couch rather than discarding it with other debris
• Commercial clients including a local remodeling contractor describe routing their own customers to Sekula's as a trusted partner for painting on high-end projects
• Office staff - specifically Kaitlyn - is mentioned by name in multiple reviews for handling scheduling, color questions, and billing with the same care shown by the field crew

"If I could give them more stars, I would! Chris and his team are consummate professionals. They ticked every box: prompt, hard-working, skilled, friendly, and respectful of our home. The job was finished sooner than expected, and everything was perfect." - Elizabeth Palmer, Google Review

Also serving the Macedon, NY area, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings brings owner Mark Rivoli into nearly every job in a hands-on way that reviewers consistently describe as rare. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings had over 200 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating - a perfect score across that volume - earning a Chooz Score of 87.5%. Mark personally handles estimates and regularly works alongside his crew on site, and this comes through across dozens of independent accounts. The company's work spans residential interior and exterior to commercial clients including an orthodontic office and a Veterans of Foreign Wars post. If you want the owner directly involved from estimate through completion, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings delivers that.

Deck and exterior staining is a particular strength based on review frequency - multiple customers describe neglected decks brought back to life, and at least one reviewer mentions considering full deck replacement before calling R&R and finding a far more cost-effective solution. Mark's willingness to reschedule exterior work around weather conditions is mentioned in multiple independent reviews.

• Customers describe Mark picking up the paint in the customer's requested color himself, removing that errand from homeowners' plates entirely
• One reviewer who manages a Sherwin-Williams location describes hand-picking Mark for her own parents' exterior job - a notable endorsement from someone in the paint industry
• Several commercial clients mention Mark completing tight-deadline work on short notice without any compromise to quality

"They showed up on time, worked hard the entire day, helped me through my color choice indecisiveness, cleaned up at the end of each night, and most importantly, they were trustworthy. There aren't enough adjectives to describe how happy my husband and I are with the job they completed." - Annemarie Boccardo, Google Review

While R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings covers a broad range of painting and staining work, Painting Plus Professionals has built a notable specialty reputation in cabinet refinishing and epoxy floor coatings. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Painting Plus Professionals had over 75 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, along with a 4.8-star rating on Angi across over 35 reviews and accreditation with the Better Business Bureau since 2016. This company earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% and was recognized with the 2022 Best of Rochester Award in the Painting category. One practice that shows up in several independent reviews: Tyler brings physical sample cabinet doors to estimates, letting homeowners see and feel the finished product before committing. If you are specifically considering cabinet refinishing or an epoxy garage floor and want to see what you are getting before signing off, Painting Plus Professionals is a strong fit.

The company's epoxy flooring work has grown as a distinct service area. Multiple reviewers describe floors in poor condition - one was told her garage floor would need full replacement at a cost of over $9,000 - finding that Alex from Painting Plus offered a quality alternative at a fraction of that cost. A reviewer whose 100-year-old multi-section house had significant mildew describes the crew managing the complex exterior project with precision, keeping track of which sections needed work and which did not.

• Tyler's cabinet process involves bringing doors off-site for finishing to achieve a factory-quality surface - a detail multiple independent reviewers describe without prompting from each other
• The company has completed epoxy flooring for commercial settings including a food-service dishwashing room, in addition to residential garage floors
• Alex, the company's epoxy installer, is noted in several reviews for walking homeowners through ongoing care and maintenance before leaving the job site

"Tyler brought over sample cabinet doors when he came to do our estimate and was the only company to do so. Seeing a finished product and being able to feel the finish made it easy to imagine in our kitchen." - Emily Audet, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Macedon, NY, A & L Painting has built a loyal following over 10 years in business, particularly for kitchen cabinet work that customers consistently describe finishing in a single day. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, A & L Painting had over 80 Google reviews with a 4.8-star rating, 100% recommended on Facebook across over 85 Facebook recommendations, and a 5.0-star rating on BBB. This company earned a Chooz Score of 84.3%. Owner Matt Coniglio personally walks through finished work with customers and follows up after completion to confirm satisfaction - a step multiple reviewers single out as rare. If you have kitchen cabinets you have been putting off refreshing, A & L Painting has the process and track record to do it efficiently.

Cabinets account for a large share of their review volume, and the consistency of the story is notable. Crews of three to five typically complete full kitchen cabinet jobs in a single day, working through hardware removal, prep, paint, and reinstallation in coordinated stages. A December Facebook review describes the crew using a customer's heated garage to sand cabinet doors during a cold Rochester winter, a practical adaptation that kept the project on schedule. Multiple customers describe hiring the crew back within months of a first project for additional work.

• Ryan Ford's Google review notes this was the third time he hired A&L and his entire home interior was completed in two days after a move
• Matt is noted in multiple reviews for researching hardware solutions on customers' behalf, including sourcing hinge widths other contractors said could not be matched on older cabinet doors
• A Facebook reviewer notes their cabinets still look as good as the day the work was completed a full year later

"They work like a well-oiled machine and the finished job was perfect. It was done in a day. Hiring Matt and his company was one of the best decisions I've made for my home improvement." - Sue Wahl, Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB, Angi

Across the contractors serving Macedon, NY, workmanship quality is the most consistently praised theme in customer reviews. At Sekula's Precision Painting, reviewers single out thorough preparation before any paint touches the wall - caulking, filling, and careful sanding come up in multiple accounts. One reviewer describes the full exterior of a cedar home repainted with a dramatic color change, with results that drew compliments from neighbors. At R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings, reviewers frequently describe edges cut precisely and trim work done with a level of craftsmanship that sets owner Mark Rivoli's crew apart. One Google reviewer describes originally hiring a less experienced contractor before switching to R&R - specifically citing prep work as the dividing line between a professional painter and someone who simply knows how to apply paint.

Painting Plus Professionals and A & L Painting both draw frequent mentions for results that hold up over time. Painting Plus reviews describe Tyler re-sanding and re-finishing cabinet door sections that were not accepting the stain correctly before declaring the job complete. At A & L Painting, a Facebook reviewer notes their kitchen cabinets look as good as the day the work was done a full year after completion. Crew members at both companies are described in multiple reviews as approaching the work with the care they would bring to their own homes.

"We originally hired a 'painter' who turned out to be a 'guy who can paint.' There is a BIG DIFFERENCE. Painting is mostly about the prep work. And Mark and his team did a fantastic job." - Nicholas Benedetto, Google Review "The prep work, patching, filling holes, and sanding on 30-year-old walls and kitchen cabinets revived them - everything looks like a new install. All done over freshly installed hardwood floors. The care and cleanup taken were appreciated and especially the attention to detail and workmanship." - Cindy Smalley, Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Communication stands out as one of the stronger recurring themes in reviews across contractors serving Macedon, NY. At Sekula's Precision Painting, the office team handles scheduling, color coordination, and billing with the same responsiveness reviewers describe from the field crew. Office contact Kaitlyn is mentioned by name in multiple independent reviews for keeping customers informed on schedule shifts - including weather-related delays during exterior projects - and responding promptly to questions throughout the job. At R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings, owner Mark Rivoli is described across dozens of reviews as answering texts and calls quickly, walking customers through color choices, and reaching out proactively as projects progress. One reviewer describes Mark as patient through multiple color indecision moments without any sign of frustration.

At Painting Plus Professionals, reviewers describe daily crew check-ins at the start of each morning - asking if customers had questions about the previous day's work before explaining which rooms would be tackled that day. A & L Painting owner Matt Coniglio follows up after project completion to confirm satisfaction, a step multiple reviewers highlight as uncommon. For all four companies, reviewer after reviewer notes they never felt out of the loop - from initial quote through final walkthrough.

"The communication on the project was outstanding throughout - starting with the estimate, color recommendations, and through the execution of the job itself." - docfisher97, Google Review "Sekula's was communicative and in consistent contact for scheduling, color coordination, billing, and everything else." - Hillary Olson, Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Cleanup habits come up as a consistent theme in reviews for contractors serving Macedon, NY, and the standard across these companies is notably high. At Sekula's Precision Painting, reviewers describe the crew covering furniture and belongings, moving items out of the way before work begins, and returning everything in place when done. One reviewer notes the crew stored their equipment neatly each day across a multi-day exterior project. At R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings, multiple reviewers describe crews tarping floors, carefully moving furniture and delicate items before any work starts, and leaving the space clean at the end of each day on longer projects. One review notes the crew removed outlet covers and thermostats before painting and replaced them cleanly on completion.

At A & L Painting, a BBB reviewer describes Matt ensuring everything was cleaned up before leaving and personally confirming satisfaction before the crew departed. Another Google reviewer describes the team completing a full kitchen cabinet job and cleaning up "like they were never there," with no residue on floors or appliances despite the volume of cabinet pieces moving in and out during the process. At Painting Plus Professionals, a Google reviewer notes there was not a single drop of paint found anywhere it should not have been after a complete kitchen and cabinet job - a standard multiple independent reviewers attribute to the crew's attention to prep and covering work.

"The crew was very friendly and respectful of the items in our home. They covered items, moved furniture out of the way, and returned the furniture when they were done. They also work very clean - no messes were left behind." - Makini Beck, Google Review "There were no messes or cleanup needed after the job was completed." - Otto Soechtig, Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google, BBB

Showing up when promised and completing work on time is a consistent pattern in reviews for painting contractors serving Macedon, NY. At Sekula's Precision Painting, on-time arrivals are mentioned across multi-year reviews as something customers explicitly note - not because it is exceptional, but because it is so reliably delivered. Robin Donlon describes a phase-two interior project finishing ahead of schedule, and another customer describes the entire exterior of their home completed sooner than expected without any reduction in quality. At R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings, owner Mark Rivoli is highlighted in several reviews for hitting tight external deadlines - one customer describes R&R finishing just before a son's birthday party hosted at a new house, and another describes a deck completed in time for a summer gathering she was hosting.

A & L Painting reviews describe one-day kitchen cabinet completions as a reliable feature of their process, with multiple reviewers noting the job finished a day ahead of schedule. One Google reviewer writing about a four-week interior project on a full home describes Matt's crew showing up every day with consistent energy and attention to detail from the first day through the last. At Painting Plus Professionals, one reviewer describes the team finishing ahead of a two-week goal - completing the work the day before a wedding rehearsal hosted at the home, where the deadline was not flexible.

"They showed up on time and left on time. They completed the work and more than what they expected to have to do, still within the timeframe they quoted us." - Danielle Privitera, Google Review "I had A&L paint kitchen cabinets, crown molding, baseboard, and ceilings in my main living area. They were able to push through it in two days. We ran into a few hiccups but Matt and his team were more concerned about my satisfaction than getting to the next job." - Shawn Keeler, Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google