Homeowners in Webster, NY have access to a strong field of painting contractors, with several companies earning top marks across Google, Facebook, and the Better Business Bureau. The painters reviewed here stand out for hands-on ownership, named in-house crews, and a consistent ability to handle everything from century-old homes with plaster walls to modern cabinet refinishing and specialty epoxy floors.
Sekula's Precision Painting leads the Webster, NY area with a Chooz Score of 87.9%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 75 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating, along with 100% recommended on Facebook across over 50 recommendations. Accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2017, Sekula's has been in business for over 8 years across the Rochester and Buffalo markets. What stands out in the reviews is how often the office staff - specifically Caitlyn - gets praised alongside the field crew, suggesting a smooth operation from first call to final brushstroke. Reviewers describe crews working quietly on multi-week projects, keeping equipment neatly organized, and handling large or complex jobs like multi-family dwellings, commercial spaces, and century-old cedar homes without cutting corners. If you want a structured company that handles large or multi-phase projects, Sekula's is a strong choice.
- Several reviewers describe coming back after an exterior project to book interior work - sometimes years later - with the same crew standards holding throughout
- Commercial referrals come from remodeling contractors who regularly direct their own clients to the company, a level of professional trust that goes beyond consumer reviews
- Named crew members including Ray, Nick, Uriah, Christian, Alex, and Dave appear consistently across independent reviews spanning different years and project types
"From the very first phone call to the last day of painting, Chris and his team was incredibly patient, kind, professional, organized and went above and beyond!" - Amy F., Google Review
For homeowners looking for owner-led work and a verifiable track record of perfect ratings, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings delivers. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.5%, and the last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis they had over 200 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating - a perfect score at that volume is rare. Owner Mark Rivoli personally handles estimates, color consultations, and works alongside his crew on-site. The company covers a wide range of projects: interior and exterior residential painting, deck and porch staining, commercial spaces, and even specialty work like painting a military helicopter on display at a veterans' post. If you want direct owner involvement from estimate through completion, R&R is worth a call.
- Mark consistently reschedules exterior work around weather conditions for the best possible outcome, rather than pushing ahead and hoping for the best
- A Sherwin-Williams store manager chose Mark for her own parents' exterior project - a credibility signal from someone who sees professional painting work every day
- Customers describe Mark returning the next day to correct minor imperfections without being asked
"As a manager of Sherwin Williams, picking a painter can be hard. Having several options who I would trust with my parents exterior, I hand picked Mark and his crew." - Erika W., Google Review
For older Rochester-area homes with plaster walls, water damage, or original woodwork, Monarch Painting has built a specific reputation. With a Chooz Score of 87.3% and over 95 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, owner Eric Anderson and his crew have worked on century-old Craftsman-Tudors, 1920s colonials, homes in the Highland Park and Park Avenue neighborhoods, and other properties requiring experience with difficult surfaces. Monarch Painting earned Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite recognition in both 2021 and 2023, is fully insured, and holds lead-safe certification for work on pre-1978 homes. Homeowners with complex original details they want preserved are a natural fit here.
- Multiple long-term customers describe using Monarch for over a decade, returning for both interior and exterior work as new projects come up
- Eric stops by job sites personally to check progress and has returned a week after project completion to touch up an exterior porch at no additional charge
- The company completed specialty restoration work on a 50-year-old custom 8-foot mahogany front door, and removed textured ceilings for a client who was away for the winter - handling furniture and cleanup without the homeowner present
"My recently purchased 1954 ranch home needed lots of repair - water damage on the ceiling, flaking and loose plaster on walls. Monarch Painting attended to every detail, and my walls look perfect!" - Nancy K., Google Review
When it comes to cabinet refinishing and specialty floor coatings, Painting Plus Professionals stands out with two distinct service specialists under one roof. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5%, with over 75 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, 4.8 stars on Angi across over 35 reviews, and an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau accredited since 2016. Tyler handles cabinet refinishing with a factory-quality approach - including bringing physical sample doors to estimates so homeowners see and feel the result before committing. Alex leads epoxy floor installations that have saved customers thousands over full concrete replacement. If you're focused on a specific specialty upgrade, this company brings dedicated expertise to each service line.
- Tyler has resanded and restained cabinet sections mid-job when the material was not absorbing correctly, without prompting from the homeowner
- Alex's epoxy process has leveled severely sloped garage floors and filled heavy pitting on concrete from the 1950s, in cases where other contractors quoted full replacement as the only option
- The company won the 2022 Best of Rochester Award in the Painting category and has been recognized by Expertise.com as a top Rochester painter
"Tyler was meticulous. He re-stained and resanded parts because they were not taking the stain well. The finished cabinets look beautiful." - Michelle E., Google Review
With over 13 years in business, Golden Boys Painting & Staining has built a specific reputation for exterior work and outdoor surfaces. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.0% with over 75 Google reviews at a 4.8-star rating, 5.0 stars on Angi across over 25 reviews, and 94% recommended on Facebook. Crew chief Aaron Palmer brings over 20 years of experience, and Tadd Tilton has been with the company since its founding. One reviewer with a log cabin home described how Golden Boys recommended targeted touch-ups rather than a full re-stain, saving him nearly half the cost that competing companies had quoted. If you want honest recommendations and outdoor surface expertise without upselling, Golden Boys is worth considering.
- Owner Dan and his crew handled plaster wall removal and painting in an older home, earning specific praise for their approach on difficult original surfaces
- Multiple reviewers confirm pricing came in exactly on the estimate with no additions at billing
- A hail-damaged pergola was completed with the same care as a full exterior job - one reviewer noted "small job, big care"
"We have a log cabin home and they recommended only doing touch ups and addressing the weathered portions - other companies wanted to re-stain the whole home and were almost twice as expensive." - Erik S., Google Review
Rounding out the top contractors serving Webster, NY, Colors of Rochester brings a hands-on owner and Monroe County MWBE-certified operation to residential painting. Owner Hope Worthington took over in late 2023 and holds OSHA 10 Construction certification along with crew credentials in Lead and Silica Awareness. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.1% with over 55 Google reviews at a 4.8-star rating and 100% recommended on Facebook across over 20 recommendations. Hope works on-site across all projects and handles color consultation directly with clients. When one customer decided to change colors on day two of three, Hope and her crew pivoted first thing the same morning. If you want an owner-operator who handles the unexpected without pushback, Colors of Rochester is a good fit.
- An 1924 home with radiators, chipping trim, and multiple rooms was handled without issue, with crew praised specifically for handling older surface challenges
- Hope has managed projects for clients who were out of town, coordinating access and sending updates remotely throughout the work
- Named crew members Julia, Grace, MaryBeth, Makayla, and Scott appear consistently across independent reviews
"On day 2 of 3, I decided to change the color. I called them first thing in the morning, and they pivoted without hesitation!" - Ann Marie D., Google Review
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB, Angi
