6 Best Painters Near Webster, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Webster, NY have access to a strong field of painting contractors, with several companies earning top marks across Google, Facebook, and the Better Business Bureau. The painters reviewed here stand out for hands-on ownership, named in-house crews, and a consistent ability to handle everything from century-old homes with plaster walls to modern cabinet refinishing and specialty epoxy floors.

Sekula's Precision Painting leads the Webster, NY area with a Chooz Score of 87.9%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 75 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating, along with 100% recommended on Facebook across over 50 recommendations. Accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2017, Sekula's has been in business for over 8 years across the Rochester and Buffalo markets. What stands out in the reviews is how often the office staff - specifically Caitlyn - gets praised alongside the field crew, suggesting a smooth operation from first call to final brushstroke. Reviewers describe crews working quietly on multi-week projects, keeping equipment neatly organized, and handling large or complex jobs like multi-family dwellings, commercial spaces, and century-old cedar homes without cutting corners. If you want a structured company that handles large or multi-phase projects, Sekula's is a strong choice.

• Several reviewers describe coming back after an exterior project to book interior work - sometimes years later - with the same crew standards holding throughout
• Commercial referrals come from remodeling contractors who regularly direct their own clients to the company, a level of professional trust that goes beyond consumer reviews
• Named crew members including Ray, Nick, Uriah, Christian, Alex, and Dave appear consistently across independent reviews spanning different years and project types

"From the very first phone call to the last day of painting, Chris and his team was incredibly patient, kind, professional, organized and went above and beyond!" - Amy F., Google Review

For homeowners looking for owner-led work and a verifiable track record of perfect ratings, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings delivers. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.5%, and the last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis they had over 200 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating - a perfect score at that volume is rare. Owner Mark Rivoli personally handles estimates, color consultations, and works alongside his crew on-site. The company covers a wide range of projects: interior and exterior residential painting, deck and porch staining, commercial spaces, and even specialty work like painting a military helicopter on display at a veterans' post. If you want direct owner involvement from estimate through completion, R&R is worth a call.

• Mark consistently reschedules exterior work around weather conditions for the best possible outcome, rather than pushing ahead and hoping for the best
• A Sherwin-Williams store manager chose Mark for her own parents' exterior project - a credibility signal from someone who sees professional painting work every day
• Customers describe Mark returning the next day to correct minor imperfections without being asked

"As a manager of Sherwin Williams, picking a painter can be hard. Having several options who I would trust with my parents exterior, I hand picked Mark and his crew." - Erika W., Google Review

For older Rochester-area homes with plaster walls, water damage, or original woodwork, Monarch Painting has built a specific reputation. With a Chooz Score of 87.3% and over 95 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, owner Eric Anderson and his crew have worked on century-old Craftsman-Tudors, 1920s colonials, homes in the Highland Park and Park Avenue neighborhoods, and other properties requiring experience with difficult surfaces. Monarch Painting earned Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite recognition in both 2021 and 2023, is fully insured, and holds lead-safe certification for work on pre-1978 homes. Homeowners with complex original details they want preserved are a natural fit here.

• Multiple long-term customers describe using Monarch for over a decade, returning for both interior and exterior work as new projects come up
• Eric stops by job sites personally to check progress and has returned a week after project completion to touch up an exterior porch at no additional charge
• The company completed specialty restoration work on a 50-year-old custom 8-foot mahogany front door, and removed textured ceilings for a client who was away for the winter - handling furniture and cleanup without the homeowner present

"My recently purchased 1954 ranch home needed lots of repair - water damage on the ceiling, flaking and loose plaster on walls. Monarch Painting attended to every detail, and my walls look perfect!" - Nancy K., Google Review

When it comes to cabinet refinishing and specialty floor coatings, Painting Plus Professionals stands out with two distinct service specialists under one roof. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5%, with over 75 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, 4.8 stars on Angi across over 35 reviews, and an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau accredited since 2016. Tyler handles cabinet refinishing with a factory-quality approach - including bringing physical sample doors to estimates so homeowners see and feel the result before committing. Alex leads epoxy floor installations that have saved customers thousands over full concrete replacement. If you're focused on a specific specialty upgrade, this company brings dedicated expertise to each service line.

• Tyler has resanded and restained cabinet sections mid-job when the material was not absorbing correctly, without prompting from the homeowner
• Alex's epoxy process has leveled severely sloped garage floors and filled heavy pitting on concrete from the 1950s, in cases where other contractors quoted full replacement as the only option
• The company won the 2022 Best of Rochester Award in the Painting category and has been recognized by Expertise.com as a top Rochester painter

"Tyler was meticulous. He re-stained and resanded parts because they were not taking the stain well. The finished cabinets look beautiful." - Michelle E., Google Review

With over 13 years in business, Golden Boys Painting & Staining has built a specific reputation for exterior work and outdoor surfaces. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.0% with over 75 Google reviews at a 4.8-star rating, 5.0 stars on Angi across over 25 reviews, and 94% recommended on Facebook. Crew chief Aaron Palmer brings over 20 years of experience, and Tadd Tilton has been with the company since its founding. One reviewer with a log cabin home described how Golden Boys recommended targeted touch-ups rather than a full re-stain, saving him nearly half the cost that competing companies had quoted. If you want honest recommendations and outdoor surface expertise without upselling, Golden Boys is worth considering.

• Owner Dan and his crew handled plaster wall removal and painting in an older home, earning specific praise for their approach on difficult original surfaces
• Multiple reviewers confirm pricing came in exactly on the estimate with no additions at billing
• A hail-damaged pergola was completed with the same care as a full exterior job - one reviewer noted "small job, big care"

"We have a log cabin home and they recommended only doing touch ups and addressing the weathered portions - other companies wanted to re-stain the whole home and were almost twice as expensive." - Erik S., Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Webster, NY, Colors of Rochester brings a hands-on owner and Monroe County MWBE-certified operation to residential painting. Owner Hope Worthington took over in late 2023 and holds OSHA 10 Construction certification along with crew credentials in Lead and Silica Awareness. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.1% with over 55 Google reviews at a 4.8-star rating and 100% recommended on Facebook across over 20 recommendations. Hope works on-site across all projects and handles color consultation directly with clients. When one customer decided to change colors on day two of three, Hope and her crew pivoted first thing the same morning. If you want an owner-operator who handles the unexpected without pushback, Colors of Rochester is a good fit.

• An 1924 home with radiators, chipping trim, and multiple rooms was handled without issue, with crew praised specifically for handling older surface challenges
• Hope has managed projects for clients who were out of town, coordinating access and sending updates remotely throughout the work
• Named crew members Julia, Grace, MaryBeth, Makayla, and Scott appear consistently across independent reviews

"On day 2 of 3, I decided to change the color. I called them first thing in the morning, and they pivoted without hesitation!" - Ann Marie D., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB, Angi

Quality and workmanship consistently top the list of reasons homeowners in Webster, NY leave five-star reviews for their painting contractors. What separates the top-rated companies from average ones is not just the finished look - it is the visible care taken on prep work, edge cutting, and surface repair before a brush ever touches the wall. Reviewers at Monarch Painting frequently describe crew members patching plaster, addressing nail pops, smoothing old wallpaper glue residue, and restoring surfaces that had not been touched in decades before painting begins. At Sekula's Precision Painting, multiple reviewers describe work on 100-year-old cedar homes and large commercial spaces handled with the same level of care, with complex surfaces and drastic color changes managed without shortcuts. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings earns specific praise for prep on aging cedar decks and siding, with owner Mark Rivoli personally inspecting surfaces before and after painting to confirm results meet expectations.

The theme of workmanship carries across the rest of the top companies as well. Reviewers at Painting Plus Professionals call out Tyler's cabinet refinishing process - he resands and restains sections mid-job when material is not absorbing correctly, rather than moving on and hoping the finish holds. At Level Up Painting, the brush-only exterior painting approach stands out - no spraying, which produces cleaner lines and better coverage on older homes with detailed trim. Golden Boys Painting & Staining regularly earns specific mentions for clean edge lines and multiple coats on exterior surfaces, with customers describing results that looked better than they had imagined going in.

"Kudos to Nicholas and Patrick of Sekula's Precision Painting for the job they did on our hallway and entranceway. 12 doors and a ton of detail in a couple of days. We couldn't be more pleased." - John M., Google Review"Meticulous attention to details. Excellent communication with the customer. Everyone was friendly and congenial. My house never looked better!" - Carol L., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB, Angi, Yelp

Clear communication before, during, and after a project is one of the most frequently mentioned positive themes across reviews for painting contractors serving Webster, NY. Customers repeatedly describe consistent updates from companies like Bates Brothers Painting, where owner Max Bates conducts daily evening check-ins with customers until each project is complete - a rhythm multiple independent reviewers describe without prompting. At R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings, owner Mark Rivoli is praised for responding promptly to texts and calls, adjusting schedules around weather conditions, and checking in after completion to make sure results hold up. Sekula's Precision Painting earns specific praise for its office staff - multiple reviewers call out Caitlyn by name for handling scheduling, color coordination, billing, and questions throughout multi-week projects without anything falling through the cracks.

Pre-project communication stands out across the other top-rated companies as well. Level Up Painting co-owner Clyde Miller is described by multiple reviewers as providing detailed, itemized estimates with clear scope discussions, so there are no surprises when work begins. Colors of Rochester owner Hope Worthington draws consistent praise for explaining arrival times, suggesting paint options, and staying accessible from estimate through final walkthrough. At Monarch Painting, owner Eric Anderson is mentioned stopping by job sites periodically and reaching out to clients who were away during work, sending photos and progress updates throughout. When scheduling gets complicated - weather delays, last-minute changes, or remote client coordination - the top-rated companies in this area consistently handle it without drama.

"Max communicated daily, stopped over frequently, and his crew was more than professional. Our house has never looked better." - Marie H., Google Review"Hope gave helpful advice regarding colors and was excellent at communicating arrival times. We highly recommend Colors of Rochester!" - Kathleen T., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB, Angi

Prep work and daily cleanup are two of the most consistent signals separating well-reviewed painting contractors from average ones in the Webster, NY area. Across the top-rated companies, reviewers regularly describe furniture being moved and fully protected before work begins, floors and surfaces covered before any paint is opened, and job sites left clean at the end of each day. At Monarch Painting, one reviewer noted that after a full ceiling project, the crew had covered every square inch of floor, counters, and cabinets - with no stray paint found anywhere in the home when the job was done. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings earns high marks for pre-paint prep on older homes: power washing siding, scraping old paint, removing mildew, and addressing drywall issues left behind by previous contractors - all before the first can is opened. Reviewer Cindy S. noted that after R&R finished a kitchen and cabinet job over freshly installed hardwood floors, the care and cleanup were the standout details.

The same pattern carries across other top-rated companies. Level Up Painting crews are described scraping, vacuuming debris, caulking, nailing loose siding, removing gutter downspouts, and priming surfaces before applying a single coat of exterior paint. A & L Painting reviews for cabinet projects consistently mention a door numbering system, garage staging during Rochester winters, and thorough cleanup at the end of each day. At Bates Brothers Painting, Max and his crew draw specific praise for prep work on aging cedar siding - power washing, sanding, and surface repair before any coating goes on. The consistent message from customers: cleanup and surface preparation are not afterthoughts for the top-rated painters in this area.

"The prep work, patching, filling holes and sanding on 30-year-old walls and kitchen cabinets revived them - everything looks like a new install! All done over freshly installed hardwood floors. The care and cleanup taken were appreciated." - Cindy S., Google Review"They made sure to cover every square inch of floor, counter and cabinets, and we have not found a stray splash of paint anywhere." - Nicole N., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB, Angi, Yelp

Reliability is one of the stronger themes running through reviews for painting contractors serving the Webster, NY area. Reviewers consistently describe crews arriving when they said they would, finishing on or ahead of schedule, and following through on commitments even when weather or logistics add complications. At Sekula's Precision Painting, one reviewer described a large two-family painting project that went ahead despite a stretch of rainy May weather, with a crew of up to six working diligently and consistently throughout. Bates Brothers Painting owner Max Bates is specifically noted for detailed estimates and realistic timelines - reviewer Ed G. called out the crew as always on time and cleaning up every day. Multiple reviewers at R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings describe Mark completing projects just before family events or seasonal deadlines, working around constraints without compromising the result.

Other companies earn similar marks for showing up and following through. Level Up Painting crew leaders are described extending hours on exterior projects to meet deadlines even with poor weather, and co-owner Jake is praised for clear scheduling communication in the weeks leading up to a project. At Colors of Rochester, one customer described a scheduling change on their end that was handled without issue, with Hope and her crew adapting the same morning with no complaint. Painting Plus Professionals completed a full exterior project in under two weeks to meet a rehearsal dinner deadline - with neighbors stopping the homeowner to ask who did the work before the crew had finished packing up. The general consensus from homeowners who have hired these contractors: when you are on their schedule, they show up and get it done.

"Despite having to fight the rainy weather in May 2025, Sekulas did an excellent job painting a large two-family dwelling. The task involved a large crew who were diligent and conscientious." - Jessica B., Google Review"Jon and his crew extended hours to meet the job requirements even with terrible weather." - Nate D., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB, Angi, Yelp

While the top-rated contractors serving Webster, NY are not the lowest-priced options in the market, customers across all companies consistently describe the value as worth the cost - often after comparing multiple quotes. At R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings, reviewer Juliana B. described gathering seven quotes and choosing R&R because they came in as the most reasonable by a significant margin. Sekula's Precision Painting reviews frequently use the phrase "very fair" and "very reasonable" alongside descriptions of quality work, with several noting the final cost matched the estimate with no additions. For Bates Brothers Painting, owner Max Bates is praised for presenting detailed, itemized estimates that make costs transparent before work begins - reviewer Thomas M. B. described how Max's estimate, professionalism, and pricing together stood out from all the other quotes he had collected.

The value conversation gets more specific on certain service types. Painting Plus Professionals earns strong value marks on epoxy garage floors - Alex's process has saved homeowners an estimated $9,000 or more compared to full concrete replacement quotes from other contractors. A & L Painting reviews on cabinet painting regularly describe results that exceeded expectations at a price point customers found hard to match elsewhere, with one reviewer noting the company was more affordable than replacing cabinets while delivering what felt like a full new install. Golden Boys Painting & Staining is specifically noted for honest pricing with no upselling - one reviewer with a log cabin was advised to do targeted repairs rather than a full re-stain, cutting his cost nearly in half compared to other quotes. The consistent message across these companies: the top-rated painters in this area earn their price.

"We gathered 7 quotes for our home interior - by far the most reasonable quote, and they did an amazing job. They were very kind, professional, and went above and beyond." - Juliana B., Google Review"The differentiator was Max himself - timely, transparent, knowledgeable and professional, and the pricing was perfectly fair and aligned to the job." - Thomas M. B., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB, Angi

Cabinet painting and kitchen refinishing have become one of the most sought-after specialty services for painting contractors serving the Webster, NY area, and several of the top-rated companies have built focused reputations around the work. A & L Painting appears across dozens of reviews for cabinet work completed in a single day, with owner Matt Coniglio and a coordinated crew handling removal, prep, painting, and hardware reinstallation in one visit. Reviewers describe kitchens updated from 1960s and 1970s oak to modern finishes that still look sharp a year or more later. At Painting Plus Professionals, senior crew member Tyler brings physical sample doors to every cabinet estimate - reviewers describe being able to see and feel the finished product before committing, which multiple independent customers noted no other company had offered.

Other companies serving the area have built solid cabinet reputations as well. Golden Boys Painting & Staining has completed cabinet and door projects described as seamless blends between existing frames and new doors, with reviewers noting the finished product looked like it had always been that way. Bates Brothers Painting has taken on cabinet projects including kitchens with stripped wallpaper walls, with Max coordinating the full scope and keeping homeowners updated daily. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings has handled kitchen and cabinet painting with specific praise for color recommendations and walking customers through their options before any work begins. For homeowners in Webster, NY considering cabinet updates as an alternative to full replacement, the options in this market are strong across multiple price points and service styles.

"Tyler did an amazing job of painting the kitchen cabinets to create a new look. The paint surface looks like it came from the factory. I would highly recommend this company for any painting projects." - Beth, Google Review"Matt and his team of skilled painters just finished our 1990s oak cabinets - from the initial quote to the final coat, the entire process was smooth, efficient, and professionally handled." - Annette Z., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB, Angi