6 Best Painters Near Brighton, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Brighton, NY have access to several highly reviewed painting contractors serving the greater Rochester area. These companies earn consistent praise for reliable crews, owner involvement, and careful preparation that protects homes during every project.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Sekula's Precision Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.9%, with 100% recommended on Facebook across over 50 recommendations. Owner Chris Sekula runs a team that customers trust enough to leave unsupervised in their homes, and several reviewers describe work finishing ahead of schedule. If you have a multi-phase painting project or want to break your work into stages, Sekula's is a good choice for flexibility. The company has served the Rochester and Buffalo markets for over 8 years and is accredited with the Better Business Bureau.

• Commercial clients, including a remodeling contractor and a daycare center, trust Sekula's with professional spaces
• Multiple customers describe splitting large projects into phases with easy rescheduling

"Chris and his crew did such a great job on the exterior of our house! They were so careful, showed up on time and were very helpful and considerate, even exceeding our expectations." - Ann Geyer, Google Review

For homeowners who want a perfect 5-star track record, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings stands out with over 200 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 87.5%. Owner Mark Rivoli personally handles estimates, works alongside his crew, and customers describe him correcting small details the very next day. If you want an owner who stays hands-on from first quote to final walkthrough, R&R is a strong pick.

• A Sherwin-Williams store manager chose Mark's crew for her own parents' home
• Staircase, railing, and deck projects appear frequently with praise for smooth finishes

"We were very happy with the interior painting work performed by Mark and his diligent crew. The painting was of exceptionally high quality - edges perfectly cut-in." - Kate Rubin, Google Review

With over 5 years in business and a perfect 5.0-star rating across over 95 Google reviews, Monarch Painting has built a strong following among owners of older Rochester homes. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% and are lead-safe certified for pre-1978 properties. If you own a century-old home and need someone comfortable with plaster, stucco, and complex trim, Monarch is a natural fit.

• Wallpaper removal, plaster patching, and stucco repair happen before any paint goes on
• Named a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite in both 2021 and 2023
• One longtime customer reports using Monarch for over 20 years of projects at the same home

"You want professional? Choose Monarch! You want precision lines? Choose Monarch! You want quality? It's Monarch all the way. Our home has never looked better!" - Jessica Metras, Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Painting Plus Professionals, which earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 75 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating. They are accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2016 and carry a 4.8-star rating on Angi across over 35 reviews. If you are considering cabinet refinishing rather than full replacement, this company is worth a call. Winner of the 2022 Best of Rochester Award in the Painting category.

• Tyler, the cabinet specialist, brings physical sample doors to estimates so homeowners can see the finish firsthand
• Epoxy garage floor coatings earn praise for showroom-quality results

"Tyler did a wonderful job on my kitchen cabinets! He was very professional and communicated with me every day on his plan. Much more affordable than replacing the cabinets." - Jennifer Buscemi, Google Review

When it comes to log cabin homes and specialty exterior staining, Golden Boys Painting & Staining stands out with over 13 years in business. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.0% with over 75 Google reviews at a 4.8-star rating, 94% recommended on Facebook, and 5.0 stars on Yelp. If you value honest estimates and a crew that won't upsell unnecessary work, Golden Boys is a good choice.

• Angie's List Super Service Award winner in 2014, 2015, and 2016
• Crew chief Aaron Palmer brings over 20 years of experience

"We have a log cabin home and they recommended only doing touch ups and addressing the weathered portions rather than re-staining the whole home. Other companies wanted to re-stain everything." - Erik Stoneham, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Brighton, NY, Colors of Rochester earned a Chooz Score of 85.1% with over 55 Google reviews at a 4.8-star rating and 100% recommended on Facebook. Owner Hope Worthington took over the business in late 2023 and has maintained its strong reputation. If you want a woman-owned painting company with hands-on ownership and careful color guidance, Colors of Rochester is a solid pick. The company holds Monroe County MWBE certification and OSHA 10 Construction credentials.

• Older homes with chipping trim and radiator painting earn praise for the crew's patience
• One-day turnaround projects for kitchens and bedrooms are a regular offering

"Working with Hope and her crew was a breeze! The quoting process was fast and detailed. We have an old house with a good amount of chipping trim, and they handled it with care and expertise." - Andrea P., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Painting quality in the Brighton, NY area consistently earns high marks across hundreds of reviews. Customers describe clean edges, smooth finishes, and thorough prep work that makes the final result last. Companies like Monarch Painting, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings, and Painting Plus Professionals all carry perfect 5.0-star ratings on Google, which reflects the standard homeowners have come to expect in this market.

Many reviewers single out prep work as the difference-maker. Customers of Sekula's Precision Painting describe crews patching walls and protecting furniture before any painting begins. Golden Boys Painting & Staining earns praise for blending new cabinet doors with existing frames so seamlessly that customers cannot tell where old meets new. Colors of Rochester customers frequently mention precise edge work on trim and ceilings. "Eric and his team are fantastic, they take great pride in the quality of their work and make sure that holes are patched effectively so that the end result is outstanding." - Fred Beer, Google Review. "Most amazing was their attention to detail in the prep work. There was not even a drop of paint on the appliances or the floor." - James Maxwell, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Communication is one of the most frequently praised qualities among painting contractors serving Brighton, NY. Owner-operated companies dominate this market, and customers consistently describe working directly with the person in charge. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings owner Mark Rivoli is described as personally responsive throughout every project, while Bates Brothers Painting owner Max Bates follows up with customers every evening until the job is complete.

Sekula's Precision Painting customers note that owner Chris Sekula is accessible from estimate through final walkthrough, and A & L Painting reviewers describe owner Matt Coniglio answering calls directly and adjusting schedules on short notice. Colors of Rochester owner Hope Worthington earns praise for prompt text responses and clear arrival time updates. "Max followed up every evening and discussed next steps until the project was completed." - S G L., Google Review. "Hope gave helpful advice regarding colors and was excellent at communicating arrival times." - Kathleen T., Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB

Customers across the Brighton, NY area generally describe painting prices as fair and competitive. Several reviewers mention getting multiple quotes before choosing a contractor and finding their selected company's pricing reasonable for the quality delivered. Golden Boys Painting & Staining customers specifically praise honest estimates and no upselling, while Colors of Rochester reviewers describe excellent work at reasonable prices for both interior and exterior projects.

Painting Plus Professionals earns attention for cabinet refinishing that costs a fraction of full cabinet replacement. Bates Brothers Painting reviewers describe detailed, itemized estimates presented on the spot, and Sekula's Precision Painting customers call their pricing very fair. "We found their prices to be very fair and they were a breeze to work with." - Elaina Caven, Google Review. "The pricing was perfectly fair and aligned to the job." - Thomas M. B., Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Punctuality and schedule reliability are common themes in reviews for Brighton, NY area painters. Customers of Sekula's Precision Painting describe crews arriving on time every morning and completing work within the quoted timeline. Monarch Painting reviewers note that Eric and his team work efficiently on challenging jobs like two-story foyers and full exterior repaints, often finishing sooner than expected.

R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings customers highlight Mark's ability to hit deadlines, with one reviewer praising the crew for completing an exterior job days before a birthday party. A & L Painting is known for same-day kitchen cabinet completions with crews working in coordinated stages. "They were on time every morning and completed the job when they said they would." - Makini Beck, Google Review. "The job was finished sooner than expected, and everything was perfect." - Elizabeth Palmer, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Cleanup is a consistent strength among the top-rated painting contractors serving Brighton, NY. Reviewers of Sekula's Precision Painting describe crews covering furniture, protecting floors with drop cloths, and leaving rooms cleaner than they found them. Golden Boys Painting & Staining customers note that the crew cleans up thoroughly at the end of each work day, not just at the end of the project.

Monarch Painting reviewers mention daily cleanup and minimal disruption even on large whole-house projects, and R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings customers describe neat job sites throughout. A & L Painting earns praise for leaving no trace of work behind. "They cleaned up their mess and only left us with a beautifully painted exterior." - Jennifer Kruschwitz, Google Review. "They left the area cleaner than when they arrived." - Scott Wolf, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Repeat business is a strong pattern among painting contractors in Brighton, NY. Sekula's Precision Painting has multiple reviewers describing second, third, and even fourth projects with the same company, with some customers booking future work before the current project wraps up. Monarch Painting has at least one customer who reports using the company for over 20 years of painting at the same home.

Level Up Painting has a reviewer who has hired them six separate times, specifically requesting the same crew leader each visit. Golden Boys Painting & Staining customers describe returning for interior work after a positive exterior experience, and A & L Painting reviewers mention multiple jobs over the years. "This is the sixth time we have used this company and we have always been extremely impressed with their work." - Mary Ross, Google Review. "We've used them for two interior painting jobs now and we can't say enough about the skills, professionalism and attention to all details." - Peter Zuris, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook