6 Best Painters Near Pittsford, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Painting contractors serving Pittsford, NY cover a wide range of projects - from the village's older Victorian and Colonial-era homes to newer construction and commercial spaces throughout the greater Rochester area. The top companies on Chooz Painters have built strong reputations through referrals and repeat business, with customers regularly returning for follow-on projects season after season.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Sekula's Precision Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating, along with 100% recommended on Facebook across over 50 recommendations. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.9% and hold BBB accreditation going back to 2017 - with over 8 years in business serving the Rochester and Buffalo markets. Based in East Rochester, this crew handles everything from single-room interior work to large exterior projects on century-old homes. If you want a company with consistent, named crew members and a structured office team keeping communication running smoothly, Sekula's is a strong choice.

What stands out across the reviews is how consistently customers mention the office alongside the painters. Kaitlyn and Caitlyn in the office are praised for prompt scheduling updates, including weather-related delays that get communicated before customers need to ask. The painters - Ray, Dave, Uriah, Christian, Nick, Brian, and others - keep their tools organized on-site each day and work quietly through multi-day interior projects. Commercial clients appear in the reviews too, including a daycare center and a family retail business.

• Multiple customers describe using Sekula's for their second, third, or even fourth project - Lisa Woodhouse returned three years after an exterior job for a full interior project and found the same standards in place.
• The office communicates schedule adjustments proactively, particularly for weather-affected exterior work, so customers are never left guessing about start dates.
• Crews work quietly and efficiently enough that multiple reviewers noted they barely knew the painters were present during multi-day interior jobs.

"Sekula sent over Uriah and Christian from their team as the painters hired to paint my home. They did a truly wonderful job from start to finish. They were professional, careful, and paid great attention to detail in every room. The colors came out beautifully and completely refreshed the space." - Luanne Strasenburgh, Google Review

For homeowners who want the owner personally on-site from the first estimate through the final walkthrough, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings is a strong fit. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, R&R had over 200 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating - a perfect score across that volume is unusual. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.5%. Owner Mark Rivoli handles estimates personally and stays in contact throughout each project, with crews like Tyler, Donny, Rob, and Bethany appearing by name across independent reviews. If you are looking for a painter who shows up personally when needed and responds quickly to texts and calls, R&R is a good choice.

One pattern worth noting is how Mark handles situations when something doesn't go as planned. After an initial staining mistake, one customer described him taking full accountability immediately and making it right without pushback - a harder thing to find than a great first-pass job. Customers with older city homes cite care given to historic trim, and one reviewer who had a 1922 Dutch Colonial painted noted the project was completed within five days.

• Mark's team extends beyond paint to concrete coatings and specialty surface finishes, giving homeowners a single point of contact for multiple project types.
• Customers in the Highland Park and City of Rochester neighborhoods specifically praised the trim work on finished exterior projects.
• Several reviewers describe Mark as responsive to calls and texts the same day, even after the project is underway.

"We highly recommend R&R painting! They painted the outside of our 1922 Dutch Colonial home within 5-days, and it looks beautiful!! Mark, and his team, pride themselves on quality service and outstanding customer service!" - Joanne Panarisi-Bottone, Google Review

When it comes to Rochester's historic housing stock, Monarch Painting has built a particularly strong track record. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 95 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and earned a Chooz Score of 87.3%. The company has been recognized as a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite in 2021 and 2023, and is fully insured and lead-safe certified for work on pre-1978 homes. Owner Eric Andersen leads a crew that includes Angelica, Brent, Brian, Charlie, and others who appear across years of reviews. If you have plaster walls, old wallpaper, or rooms that have not been painted in decades, this crew does the repair work before picking up a brush.

The scope of what Monarch takes on sets them apart. Customers describe wallpaper removal, textured ceiling removal, hardwood floor refinishing after carpet removal, and the restoration of a 50-year-old mahogany front door. One long-term customer notes having used Monarch for every painting project over 20 years, indoors and out. For customers who were out of town during a project, Eric stayed in contact and sent photos upon completion.

• Monarch works on a wide range of surfaces beyond standard drywall, including plaster, stucco, painted hardwood floors, and aged exterior trim.
• Brent is called out by name across multiple reviews for staying on-site from start to finish on larger multi-day projects, providing continuity for the customer.
• The crew occasionally identifies issues beyond the painting scope - one customer mentioned Eric flagged moss on the roof during a painting estimate visit.
• Customers with early 1900s homes describe walls being completely repaired and sanded, with finished surfaces showing no trace of prior damage.

"Eric Anderson runs his business like a well oiled machine. From the detailed proposal presented to me, the time he and his employee Brian estimated the job will take, everything was spot on! They show up every day on time, and finish with clean up every day, leaving their workspace ready for the next day." - Carole Brice, Google Review

Repeat customers and specialty work set Painting Plus Professionals apart in the Pittsford, NY market. They hold a Chooz Score of 86.5%, with over 75 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau dating to 2016, and 4.8 stars on Angi across over 35 reviews. The 2022 Best of Rochester Award in the painting category rounds out a track record built over nearly a decade. Crew members Tyler, Alex, and Mike appear consistently across reviews spanning multiple years and project types. If you are considering epoxy floor coatings, cabinet refinishing, or a multi-room interior project, this crew has handled all three at a high level.

The epoxy floor work deserves particular mention. Alex has saved multiple clients from costly floor replacements by leveling slopes, filling pitting, and applying professional coatings - one homeowner had been quoted over $9,000 for a full floor replacement and found a better solution through Painting Plus. For cabinet refinishing, Tyler brings physical sample doors to estimate appointments, which multiple reviewers independently describe as the deciding factor in choosing the company. For larger interior jobs, the crew organizes work across rooms in a way that lets homeowners maintain daily routines during the project.

• Tyler's cabinet refinishing process produces finishes customers describe as factory-level in quality, with multiple reviewers saying surfaces are indistinguishable from new cabinetry.
• Alex leads epoxy installations for both residential garages and commercial spaces, including restaurant and dishwashing room projects.
• Prep work is a consistent theme - the crew patches and fills surfaces before painting, with multiple reviewers finding not a drop of paint where it should not be.

"I was skeptical when Painting Plus told me they 'were not like all the others' and take great pride in their work. We've been burned before and were looking for someone we could trust to stain our house as they would if it were their own. Alex was forthright in his initial meeting with us that they do not take shortcuts." - Cathie Wright, Google Review

With over 13 years in business, Golden Boys Painting & Staining brings a level of experience that shows in how they advise customers - not just how they paint. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.0%, with over 75 Google reviews at a 4.8-star rating, 5.0 stars on Angi across over 25 reviews, 94% recommended on Facebook, and 5.0 stars on Yelp. The crew - Aaron, Tadd, Luis, Nicholas, and Nolan - appears across multiple years of reviews. Crew chief Aaron Palmer brings over 20 years of hands-on experience. If you are looking for a company that handles deck staining, exterior wood surfaces, and specialty projects alongside standard painting, Golden Boys covers that range.

One review captures something worth noticing about how this company approaches estimates. A customer with a log cabin home described how other companies wanted to restain the entire structure at nearly double the price - Golden Boys instead recommended addressing only the weathered sections and fixing carpenter bee damage, saving money and avoiding unnecessary work. That honest-input approach appears in other reviews too, with customers noting the company did not push upsells during deck and exterior quotes. Commercial clients have hired the crew for restaurant renovation projects.

• Aaron Palmer has over 20 years of experience as crew chief and is frequently called out by name for going the extra mile on difficult surfaces and detailed trim work.
• The crew handles specialty projects including pergolas, arbors, log cabins, and deck cleaning in addition to standard residential painting.
• Scheduling communication is consistent across the reviews, with customers noting they were informed of timelines from first contact through project close.

"We have a log cabin home and they recommended only doing touch ups and addressing the weathered portions of the home as well as fixing bore holes from carpenter bees. Other companies wanted to re-stain the whole home and were almost twice as expensive." - Erik Stoneham, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Pittsford, NY, Colors of Rochester is one of the few Monroe County MWBE-certified painting companies in this market. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.1%, with over 55 Google reviews at a 4.8-star rating and 100% recommended on Facebook across over 20 recommendations. Owner Hope Worthington, who took over the company in late 2023, holds OSHA 10 Construction certification along with crew credentials in lead awareness, fall protection, and CPR. Hope is personally present on nearly every job, with her name appearing in the majority of reviews alongside crew members Julia, Grace, MaryBeth, Makayla, and Scott. If you prefer working directly with an owner who is on-site rather than managing from a distance, Colors of Rochester is a good choice.

Hope's approach to mid-project changes stands out in the reviews. One homeowner changed their paint color choice on day two of a three-day project, and Hope responded immediately, ordered the new color, and completed the job without issue. For customers who travel or cannot be on-site, the crew managed an out-of-town client's rental repaint and handled unexpected items left behind without a complaint. The crew takes on shutter removal and reinstallation, wallpaper removal, ceiling repair, and radiator painting in addition to standard interior and exterior work.

• Hope actively guides color selection during estimates and has redirected clients mid-project without pressure - at least one reviewer changed colors on day two with no friction.
• The crew handles shutter removal and reinstallation, wallpaper removal, and ceiling repair as part of broader painting projects.
• Several customers note the team cleans up thoroughly at the end of each day, leaving spaces usable overnight during multi-day interior projects.

"From the estimate to cleaning their way out the door, you couldn't ask for more. Attention to detail amazing." - Karen Briggs, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Quality of workmanship is the most consistently praised theme across reviews for painting contractors serving Pittsford, NY. Monarch Painting earns strong marks for work on older plaster walls and historic surfaces, with reviewers describing finished walls where no prior damage is visible after thorough sanding and patching. Customers in the Highland Park and Park Avenue neighborhoods describe exterior stucco repair, cedar shake replacement, and careful color matching on century-old homes. Sekula's Precision Painting customers on exterior projects note that scraping, covering, and surface preparation happen before any paint is applied - with one customer describing a 100-plus year old house calling the crew complete professionals throughout.

Specialty workmanship also appears across the reviews for this market. Painting Plus Professionals customers describe cabinet refinishing finishes that look factory-made, with surfaces customers say are indistinguishable from new cabinetry. Golden Boys Painting & Staining exterior and deck customers note multiple coats, thorough prep, and cleanup at the end of each day that extends the life of the finish. Colors of Rochester reviewers call out precise edge work and careful trim handling, with several noting the crew's ability to address chipping paint on older surfaces without leaving rough spots. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings customers in the Highland Park neighborhood cited exterior trim work as a standout element that earned compliments from neighbors after the project wrapped up.

"Eric and his crew are outstanding! Brent, Brian, Ben, Jimmy and the rest of the team are tremendous to work with. Professional, friendly, and meticulous to the smallest detail. Thank you for making our home look great." - Roger Smith, Google Review"We could not be more happy with the work of Dan's team. All members of his team were professional, polite and they cleaned up after each day they were here. We are so happy with the finished product - the attention to detail and communication throughout the job really set them apart." - K Koetter, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Communication is a consistent strength across the top painting contractors in the Pittsford, NY area. Sekula's Precision Painting customers praise both the crew and the office staff - Kaitlyn and Caitlyn in the office are mentioned by name for keeping clients updated on schedules, including weather delays for exterior work. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings owner Mark Rivoli is consistently described as same-day responsive to texts and phone calls, and several customers note he checks in on the project without needing to be asked. Monarch Painting owner Eric Andersen makes periodic visits during larger jobs and stays in contact with clients who are away from home during the project, sending photos when the work is done.

For homeowners who want structured communication built into the process, Painting Plus Professionals crews are described as checking in at the start of each day to walk through what was completed and what comes next. Golden Boys Painting & Staining customers note owner Dan's clear upfront communication on project scope and timeline, with final invoices closely matching estimates. Colors of Rochester owner Hope Worthington's direct style comes up repeatedly - she is described as accommodating mid-project questions, color changes, and schedule adjustments without friction. For customers who want to stay informed without having to follow up, any of these companies show up well in that area.

"Kaitlyn was prompt and clear in answering all our questions. An overall great experience." - David Martins, Google Review"The quoting process was fast and detailed. We have an old house with a good amount of chipping trim, and they handled it with care and expertise." - Andrea P., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Thorough prep work and daily cleanup are recurring themes across reviews for the top painting contractors serving Pittsford, NY. Painting Plus Professionals customers describe a consistent approach where every hole, dent, and scratch gets filled before painting begins - one reviewer who had a kitchen done noted that not a drop of paint landed where it should not be across a full multi-day project. Monarch Painting treats surface repair as a standard part of the process: customers with plaster walls, water-damaged ceilings, and decades-old paint describe thorough spackling of nail pops, careful sanding, and patching before any color goes on. For one job on a 1954 ranch home with significant plaster damage, the crew used a vacuum sander that left virtually no dust behind during the repair phase.

Daily cleanup habits also stand out across the reviews. Sekula's Precision Painting customers note that crews keep their tools neatly organized on-site each day and leave spaces functional overnight during multi-day interior projects. Golden Boys Painting & Staining exterior crews clean up at the end of each workday - a detail multiple customers mention as particularly appreciated on longer projects. Colors of Rochester customers describe the team cleaning up as they go, with spaces ready to use each evening. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings customers describe furniture being carefully covered and delicate items moved before painting begins, with the space restored before the crew departs each day.

"Most amazing was their attention to detail in the prep work. There was not even a drop of paint on the appliances or the floor or anywhere where it shouldn't be. The end result was dazzling." - James Maxwell, Google Review"A great deal of attention was paid to nail pops which required spackling. I had painters in my home over a 3-week period to do multiple rooms and everything was done beautifully." - Nancy Kaproth, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Showing up on time and finishing within the promised window are areas where the top contractors serving Pittsford, NY consistently earn positive feedback. Sekula's Precision Painting customers describe crews arriving each morning as scheduled and completing projects at or before the estimated end date - including one large exterior job on a two-family dwelling managed through a difficult rainy season. The office team communicates proactively when weather affects exterior scheduling, so customers are not left guessing about adjusted start dates. Monarch Painting customers describe project timelines that match the proposal closely, with one reviewer noting the time estimate given at the proposal was spot on - the crew arrived daily and finished cleanup on schedule throughout.

For customers with firm deadlines, Painting Plus Professionals completed one homeowner's exterior project just in time for a wedding rehearsal dinner hosted at the property, meeting a hard target under pressure. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings owner Mark Rivoli completed an entire 1922 Dutch Colonial exterior within five days. Golden Boys Painting & Staining customers note consistent scheduling communication from first contact through project close, with no surprises on start or end dates. Colors of Rochester owner Hope is specifically praised for giving accurate arrival windows and keeping customers informed when timing needs to shift. If your project has a specific deadline, any of these companies have demonstrated they can work to a schedule.

"They were on time every morning and completed the job when they said they would. The crew was very friendly and respectful of the items in our home. They covered items, moved furniture out of the way, and returned the furniture back to its place." - Makini Beck, Google Review"They were organized and efficient from start to finish. The owner, Dan, and the employees who did the job were all friendly and comfortable to be around. Plus, the pricing was excellent." - Jeanne Randall, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Fair pricing and value for quality come up frequently across reviews for contractors in the Pittsford, NY area. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings customers note that Mark's pricing was competitive among several quotes, with one reviewer describing R&R as offering the best price while delivering the highest quality of any company compared. Golden Boys Painting & Staining draws specific praise for transparent pricing without upselling - one customer noted the company recommended a smaller scope of work on a log cabin restaining rather than pushing for a full job that would have cost nearly double. Monarch Painting customers consistently describe the company as reasonably priced relative to the quality delivered, with one noting the work exceeded expectations at a very reasonable cost.

Painting Plus Professionals customers in the cabinet refinishing and epoxy floor categories note significant savings compared to full replacement - one homeowner was quoted over $9,000 by other contractors for a floor replacement and found a better solution at a lower price through Painting Plus. Sekula's Precision Painting customers describe pricing as fair for the level of professionalism and crew quality delivered. Colors of Rochester is repeatedly described as offering very reasonable rates in the reviews, with at least one customer citing this as a deciding factor in booking a multi-room project. Across most of the top companies, customers note that final invoices aligned closely with the original estimates, with no surprise charges at the end of the job.

"The project was done in a timely manner and the finished product turned out great at a very reasonable price. Would recommend." - Victor Ianni, Google Review"Monarch Painting is an incredible company to work with in so many ways! They do exceptional work, they are extremely kind and responsive, they go above and beyond and always offered to help with additional tasks as they arose, and they are VERY reasonably priced." - Cami Goldowitz, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Rochester's housing stock skews older, and many homes in and around Pittsford, NY date to the early 1900s through the 1950s - with the specific challenges those homes bring. Monarch Painting is lead-safe certified for work on pre-1978 homes and has completed projects on century-old Craftsman-Tudor homes, 1920s colonials, and mid-century ranches throughout the Highland Park and Park Avenue neighborhoods. Customers describe surface preparation that includes plaster repair, stucco patching, and careful sanding before any paint goes on. Sekula's Precision Painting has worked on homes built well over a century ago and brings the same prep standards to older cedar and wood siding exteriors. One customer who had a 100-plus year old house painted described the crew as polished throughout.

Colors of Rochester customers with 1920s and older homes note the crew's ability to navigate architectural challenges including radiators, non-standard trim profiles, and surfaces with chipping paint neglected for years. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings completed a 1922 Dutch Colonial exterior in five days, with reviewers citing attention to historic trim details. Golden Boys Painting & Staining reviewed a log cabin and recommended targeted repair work over a full restaining, preserving the character of the home at a lower cost. For any pre-1980 home, confirming your contractor holds lead-safe certification upfront is worth doing - Monarch Painting is specifically noted for this credential in their company profile.

"We just had a great experience with Colors of Rochester doing our Kitchen and Hallways. 1924 house with lots of unique challenges and they handled it perfectly. They were on time each day, cleaned everything up each night, and were very professional throughout." - John Ward, Google Review"Eric and his crew of skilled painters are outstanding. They powerwashed, patched and repaired the stucco, and then painted the entire exterior of our challenging 103 year old Craftsman-Tudor home and garage in the Park Avenue neighborhood of Rochester. Their work was superior." - Andrew Cooke, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google