Homeowners in Fairport, NY have access to several highly rated painting contractors, each with strong customer feedback across multiple platforms. Whether you need interior walls refreshed, kitchen cabinets updated, or a full exterior repaint, the contractors below have earned their reputations through consistent results and responsive service.
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Sekula's Precision Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.9%, with 100% recommended on Facebook across over 50 recommendations and an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau. Owner Chris Sekula founded the company in 2017 and was named Greater Rochester Chamber of Commerce Business Person of the Year. Reviews consistently highlight how comfortable customers feel leaving the crew unsupervised in their homes, with several noting they ran errands while the team worked. If you want a company with a stable, named crew that shows up in branded vehicles and finishes ahead of schedule, Sekula's is a strong fit.
Several reviewers mention that the crew completes work sooner than expected, with one customer noting the job finished days early. Customers also describe the team keeping equipment organized throughout multi-week projects, which stands out in a field where job sites often get messy.
- Multiple reviewers describe the crew arriving promptly each morning and working quietly without disrupting household routines
- Commercial clients, including a local remodeling company, trust Sekula's enough to refer their own customers to the team
- Customers frequently mention Dave, Ray, and other crew members by name for going above and beyond on prep work like spindle and wall preparation
"This has been a great experience from the first time someone came out to give an estimate. This company runs as a business should - prompt response time, great communication from start to finish." - Suzanne Calia, Google Review
For homeowners who want a perfect score backed by volume, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings stands out. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.5% with over 200 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, a rare perfect score across that many reviews. Owner Mark Rivoli is hands-on with every project, from color consultations to final walkthroughs. If you need someone who will personally guide your color decisions and show up to correct small details the next day, R&R is a great choice.
What comes through in the reviews is how many different project types Mark handles well. Customers describe everything from garage door refreshes for commercial buildings to full exterior repaints of historic Rochester homes, and the praise stays consistent. A Sherwin-Williams store manager chose Mark's crew for her own parents' home, which says something about how industry professionals view the quality.
- Crew members Tyler, Donny, and Bethany are named across separate reviews for consistent interior and exterior work
- Several customers who had bad experiences with previous painters describe R&R fixing and completing the work to a higher standard
- Mark offers color recommendations and helps homeowners preparing to list their houses for sale
"We have had a number of painters through the years. R&R really listened to us the customer, the paint job looks astounding, we are getting so many compliments!" - Alison B., Google Review
With over 5 years in business and a perfect 5.0-star rating across over 95 Google reviews, Monarch Painting has built a following among owners of older Rochester homes. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3%. Lead-safe certified and experienced with plaster walls, water damage, and decades-old surfaces, Monarch is a natural fit if you own a pre-war home with character - and challenges. Owner Eric is mentioned by name in nearly every review.
What stands out in the reviews is how many customers describe Monarch handling complex prep work that other companies might skip. Reviewers with homes from the 1920s through the 1950s describe wall repairs, plaster patching, and wallpaper glue removal that left rooms looking completely renewed. A dental practice hired Monarch and praised the crew's ability to work around patients and a busy schedule.
- Customers consistently name Jimmy, Brent, Brian, Charlie, and Angelica across separate projects, suggesting a stable in-house team
- One homeowner describes having used Monarch for over 20 years and still finding the same quality standards
"Eric and his crew did an amazing job painting our 2 story foyer, great room with cathedral ceiling, family room and dining room! Not only did they do a great job, but it was done quickly and with minimal disruption." - Suzanne Clayton, Google Review
When it comes to cabinet refinishing and epoxy garage floors, Painting Plus Professionals stands out. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 75 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, plus 4.8 stars on Angi across over 35 reviews and accreditation with the Better Business Bureau since 2016. Winner of the 2022 Best of Rochester Award in painting. If your kitchen cabinets look dated but the bones are good, this company's cabinet process is worth exploring.
Reviewers describe a process where senior painter Tyler brings physical sample doors to the estimate so homeowners can see and feel the finish before committing. Multiple independent customers mention this detail, which suggests it is standard practice rather than a one-off. Epoxy floor customers also praise crew member Alex for leveling severe slopes and saving thousands compared to full floor replacement.
- Prep work is the most praised element across reviews, with customers describing every dent, scratch, and hole being fixed before any paint goes on
- Several reviewers say you would not know their cabinets were painted rather than factory-finished
- The crew covers floors heavily on every project, and multiple reviewers note finding zero paint where it should not be
"My cabinets are solid wood and good quality but definitely looked outdated. Tyler did an amazing job of painting the kitchen cabinets to create a new look. The paint surface looks like it came from the factory." - Beth, Google Review
With over 13 years in business, Golden Boys Painting & Staining has built a loyal following in the Fairport, NY area. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.0% with over 75 Google reviews at a 4.8-star rating, 5.0 stars on Angi with over 25 reviews, and 94% recommended on Facebook. Owner Dan leads a crew including Aaron, Tadd, and Luis who appear by name across years of reviews. If you have a deck, exterior, or cabinet project and want a team with deep experience, Golden Boys is worth a call.
Customers describe a crew that is flexible with scheduling around other contractors working in the home, which is a practical benefit reviewers call out specifically. One log cabin homeowner praised Golden Boys for recommending targeted touch-ups instead of a full repaint, saving money while still protecting the wood. That kind of honest guidance runs through the reviews.
- Cabinet customers describe seamless blending between new doors and existing frames, with one noting you cannot tell where old ends and new begins
- Exterior and deck projects draw praise for multiple coats and thorough daily cleanup
"We could not be more happy with the work of Dan's team. All members of his team were professional, polite and the finished product is incredible." - K Koetter, Google Review
A hands-on operation led by owner Hope Worthington, Colors of Rochester brings personal attention to every project. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.1% with over 55 Google reviews at a 4.8-star rating and 100% recommended on Facebook with over 20 recommendations. Hope took ownership in late 2023 and has maintained the company's longstanding reputation. If you value working directly with the owner from estimate through final walkthrough, Colors of Rochester fits that preference.
Reviewers describe Hope as someone who engages personally with homeowners, including accommodating schedule changes on short notice. Multiple customers with older homes praise her work on chipping trim and wall blemishes. The company holds Monroe County MWBE certification and OSHA 10 Construction credentials.
- Several reviewers mention same-day project completions for kitchen and bedroom painting
- Crew members Julia, MaryBeth, and Makayla are praised by name for being personable and taking pride in their work
- Customers describe Hope adjusting plans mid-project when cold weather required rescheduling without any issues
"MaryBeth, Julia and Scott were great! Very personable, professional and take pride in the work they do. The rooms and hallway look great, so much brighter and fresh looking!" - Sandra Simpson, Google Review
Rounding out the top contractors serving Fairport, NY, Whelehan Painting is a family business founded in 1977, bringing nearly five decades of experience. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.0% with over 175 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating, 98% recommended on Facebook, and 5.0 stars on Yelp. With 16 in-house employees working as established teams, this is the company for homeowners who want the same crew every time. If you have a large-scale project like a full interior or an 1880s exterior, Whelehan has the crew size and experience to handle it efficiently.
What stands out in the reviews is how fast this team works relative to competitors. One customer described getting bids where other companies estimated two weeks, and Whelehan finished in two and a half days. Multiple reviewers with full interior projects, including ceilings, closets, and trim, describe the work being completed in just a few days. Owner Pat keeps customers updated throughout the process.
- Customers describe crews arriving in force and working efficiently as a coordinated team
- Wallpaper removal is a frequent project type, with reviewers praising the crew's ability to strip old paper, smooth walls, and paint to a clean finish
- Neighbors have stopped to compliment finished exterior work, according to multiple reviewers
"Whelehan Painting painted the entire interior of my home in just 3 days! The crew assigned to my job was incredible. They were professional, fun, and worked well together." - Kathie Ryan, Google Review
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB, Angi, Yelp
