6 Best Painters Near Rochester, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

The painting contractors earning top marks in Rochester, NY share several qualities that show up consistently across hundreds of customer reviews: organized operations, named crews that show up reliably, strong prep work, and a willingness to return and correct anything that falls short. Whether you are working with a century-old plaster home in Highland Park, an aging cedar exterior in the suburbs, or kitchen cabinets in need of a refresh, the companies below represent some of the strongest options in the area based on verified customer reviews.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Sekula's Precision Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating and was 100% recommended on Facebook across over 50 recommendations. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.9%, the highest among contractors in our Rochester, NY analysis. Recognized as the Greater Rochester Chamber of Commerce Business Person of the Year and BBB accredited since 2017, this East Rochester-based company has built a loyal customer base spanning both the Rochester and Buffalo markets. If you want a well-organized operation from first call through final walkthrough, Sekula's is a strong choice.

What stands out across their reviews is the breadth of project types the team handles: single rooms, full-home interiors, complex exteriors on century-old homes, and commercial spaces like daycare centers and retail stores. Office staff like Kaitlyn are cited by name for responsive communication, while crew members Ray, Dave, Nick, and Evan earn recognition on the job site. Customers who call for exterior work tend to come back for interior projects, and several reviews describe multi-phase jobs planned and completed across multiple seasons.

• The crew typically works quietly, stores tools neatly at the end of each day, and cleans up thoroughly - multiple reviewers note they could not find a trace left behind when the job wrapped up.
• A dedicated office team handles scheduling communication, keeping customers informed of weather delays and updated project timelines - particularly helpful during Rochester's unpredictable spring painting season.
• Commercial referrals appear alongside residential ones, including a remodeling contractor who regularly refers his own clients to the Sekula's team with full confidence.

"If I could give them more stars, I would! Chris and his team are consummate professionals. They ticked every box: prompt, hard-working, skilled, friendly, and respectful of our home. The job was finished sooner than expected, and everything was perfect." - Elizabeth Palmer, Google Review

While Sekula's serves customers across a wide geographic range, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings has built one of the most impressive Google profiles in the area. Over 200 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating is genuinely rare for a local contractor, and the company earned a Chooz Score of 87.5%. Owner Mark Rivoli is personally present on every estimate and frequently works alongside his crew on site. For a project where you want direct owner involvement from start to finish, R&R is a good fit.

The scope of work R&R handles goes well beyond interior walls. Cabinet refinishing, deck staining, patio staining, concrete coatings, and garage door repaints all appear across independent reviews. Several customers describe calling R&R after a previous contractor left unsatisfactory results, and Mark's handling of those situations draws particularly strong praise. One customer whose deck had peeled entirely after a previous poor stain job describes Mark's patience through months of emails while they were out of town, followed by results that far exceeded expectations.

• Mark walks through the finished project before leaving and has been described returning the next morning to correct small imperfections without being asked.
• Crew members Tyler, Bethany, Rob, and Donny appear by name across independent reviews, including a shoutout from a Sherwin-Williams store manager who handpicked the crew for her own parents' home.
• The company's concrete coating and staining capabilities draw customers who have been let down by general painters not equipped for specialty surfaces.

"We highly recommend R&R painting! They painted the outside of our 1922 Dutch Colonial home within 5-days, and it looks beautiful!! Mark, and his team, pride themselves on quality service and outstanding customer service!" - Joanne Panarisi-Bottone, Google Review

For homeowners in Rochester's older neighborhoods - Park Avenue, Highland Park, East Avenue - Monarch Painting has built a reputation for tackling historic home complexity with care. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3%, with over 95 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, recognized as a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite in both 2021 and 2023. The company is fully insured and lead-safe certified for work on pre-1978 homes. If you own an older property with plaster walls, water-damaged ceilings, or original architectural details requiring careful handling, Monarch is worth calling.

Owner Eric Andersen has been running the business for over 5 years and shows up at projects consistently - checking in during the work and following up after completion. Crew members Brent, Jimmy, Brian, Charlie, and Angelica appear across reviews spanning multiple seasons and project types, confirming a stable team rather than rotating workers. Project types range from floor painting after carpet removal to textured ceiling removal to the full restoration of a 1910 home that needed significant repair from the ground up.

• Jimmy is praised specifically for detailed trim work, including hand-painting 39 original storm windows on a century-old home - a task requiring patience most crews would avoid.
• One long-term customer has used Monarch for both interior and exterior projects across 20 years, describing the same high standards maintained consistently throughout.
• Eric's team regularly handles wallpaper removal and transitions directly into prep and painting, saving customers from coordinating a separate contractor.

"You want professional? Choose Monarch! You want precision lines? Choose Monarch! You want quality? It's Monarch all the way. Our home has never looked better! Eric and team arrived on time, cleaned up daily and were always friendly. I already booked with them again!" - Jessica Metras, Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Painting Plus Professionals, which has built a following around specialized services most painting companies do not offer. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5%, with over 75 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, a BBB accreditation going back to 2016, and 4.8 stars on Angi across over 35 reviews. The company also won the 2022 Best of Rochester Award in the Painting category.

Two names appear most often in the reviews: Tyler for cabinet refinishing, and Alex for epoxy floor coatings. Tyler's approach to estimates includes bringing physical sample doors so customers can see and feel the finished product before committing - a detail several reviewers highlight as the reason they chose Painting Plus over competitors. Alex's epoxy work has saved customers thousands of dollars over full floor replacement, including one whose floor had been quoted for complete replacement at over $9,000 by other contractors. For homeowners considering cabinet refinishing, garage floor coatings, or exterior painting on complex older properties, Painting Plus Professionals is a strong fit.

• Tyler re-stains and re-sands when material is not taking the finish properly, completing the step correctly even when it falls outside the original scope.
• Alex is described as thorough in concrete prep for epoxy floors, including leveling severe slope issues other contractors had written off as unfixable.
• The crew coordinates well across multiple rooms simultaneously, allowing customers to continue living in the home during multi-day projects without major disruption.

"I highly recommend Painting Plus! Tyler is professional, punctual, trustworthy and has a keen eye for detail. He works with state of the art equipment. If you're home during the day, you wouldn't even notice he's there." - Barb Smith, Google Review

With over 13 years in business, Golden Boys Painting & Staining has built a track record that draws customers back for second and third projects. The company earned a Chooz Score of 86.0%, with over 75 Google reviews at a 4.8-star rating, along with 5.0 stars on Angi across over 25 reviews, 94% recommended on Facebook, and 5.0 stars on Yelp. They are also a three-time Angie's List Super Service Award winner, taking the honor in 2014, 2015, and 2016.

Owner Dan's team is known for honest assessments that show up in multiple independent reviews. One log cabin homeowner describes being told that only targeted touch-ups and carpenter bee repairs were needed rather than a full re-stain - a recommendation other companies did not make, and one that saved significant money. Project types span interior and exterior painting, deck and arbor staining, wallpaper removal, kitchen cabinet refinishing, and even a restaurant renovation. Crew chief Aaron Palmer brings over 20 years of experience, and Tadd Tilton has been with the company since its founding.

• The crew cleans up at the end of each workday and customers note the site remains tidy throughout the project, not just at completion.
• Customers who hire them for exterior or deck work regularly return for interior projects, with the same crew names appearing across both project types.
• Honest pricing is a recurring theme - estimates are accurate, there is no upselling, and labor and material costs are communicated clearly upfront.

"We received a fair estimate with honest feedback on painting certain types of material. They did not try to up sell, and were up front with pricing for labor and material costs. We had our deck stained, front door painted. And some trim touched up. The work and clean up was amazing!" - A B, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Rochester, NY, Colors of Rochester is a woman-owned company with a hands-on approach that reads clearly through customer reviews. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.1%, with over 55 Google reviews at a 4.8-star rating and 100% recommended on Facebook across over 20 recommendations. Owner Hope Worthington holds Monroe County MWBE certification, OSHA 10 Construction certification, and crew credentials in Lead and Silica Awareness, Fall Protection, and CPR/AED/First Aid.

Hope took over the business in late 2023 and has maintained the company's reputation while adding her own hands-on, communication-forward style. She personally handles estimates, assists with color selection, and works alongside her crew on projects. One reviewer who changed their mind about a paint color midway through day two of a three-day job describes Hope accommodating the switch same day at minimal added cost. The company handles a broad scope of work: interiors, exteriors, garage interiors, basement drylocking, wallpaper removal, and cabinet painting - with a crew that includes Julia, Grace, MaryBeth, and Makayla.

• Hope engages with customers throughout each project rather than just at the estimate stage, which several reviewers describe as rare among painting contractors.
• The same crew member names - Julia, MaryBeth, Grace - appear across independent reviews covering different project types and seasons.
• The company has worked in homes dating to the 1920s, handling original radiators, chipping trim, and plaster walls with consistent results.

"We just had a great experience with Colors of Rochester doing our Kitchen and Hallways. 1924 house with lots of unique challenges and they handled it perfectly. They were on time each day, cleaned everything up each night, and were very professional." - John Ward, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Workmanship quality is the most frequently mentioned theme across reviews for Rochester, NY painting contractors, and the details customers provide go well beyond generic praise. For Monarch Painting, quality shows up in specialty situations - plaster repair, water-damaged ceiling restoration, and original architectural details on homes dating back over a century. One customer who hired the company to remove textured ceilings while away for the winter returned to find everything done to their satisfaction based entirely on progress photos Eric sent during the project. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings earns consistent praise for trim-level precision, with one customer describing the crew as "painting artisans" after a full exterior project on a Highland Park home.

For Painting Plus Professionals, workmanship stands out most in cabinet and floor coating results - customers describe kitchen cabinet finishes that look factory-fresh and epoxy garage floors so polished that one reviewer said they almost did not want to drive onto them. Whelehan Painting draws praise for full exterior projects completed efficiently without any sacrifice to quality, with neighbors stopping to compliment the results as the job wraps up. Across all companies in Rochester, NY, the pattern is consistent: customers are writing detailed five-star reviews because the finished work is visibly and noticeably better than what they expected going in.

• "Quality work done in a timely manner, with frequent updates and clear communications. Bob and Rachel were a delight to work with: neat, tidy and respectful of our home." - Steve Johnson, Google Review (Monarch Painting)
• "Mark and his team are the best of the best. Honest, Trustworthy, Hardworking. They beat everyone else's pricing and the attention to detail is second to none." - Dustin Marcello, Google Review (R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings)
• "Whelehan painting came in as the low ball amongst the companies I took bids from; the product is so not that. Fantastic, phenomenal, honks and thumbs up from the neighbors." - Brad T., Google Review (Whelehan Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Prep work is one of the most consistently praised aspects of painting contractors in Rochester, NY, and the level of detail customers describe goes well beyond a quick surface wipe. For Monarch Painting, prep includes spackling nail pops, patching plaster, and sanding walls to a smooth finish before any paint is applied - one customer with a 1954 ranch home was amazed that a specialized sander with a vacuum attachment left virtually no plaster dust in the house during a weeks-long project. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings customers describe Mark's crews handling full power washing, thorough scraping, and protecting all furniture, floors, railings, and outlet covers before work begins - with one reviewer noting the distinction between a true professional painter and a "guy who can paint" is entirely in the prep.

For Painting Plus Professionals, prep on cabinet work includes orbital sanding, priming, and filling every dent and scratch before any finish coat goes on. Alex's epoxy floor prep process includes leveling significant slope issues and filling deep pitting that other contractors had written off as irreparable. Sekula's Precision Painting customers describe exterior prep that includes careful scraping of old paint, proper masking, and consistent protection of surrounding property throughout the project. Across all companies in Rochester, NY, the quality of prep work is what separates contractors who deliver lasting results from those who simply apply paint to a surface.

• "We had to remove very old wallpaper and glue, then sand and smooth the walls, and then paint the 2 rooms. Very pleased with everything, and highly recommend this company." - Dona Hazen, Google Review (Whelehan Painting)
• "We received regular updates on projected start and completion dates (accurate), great communication, careful prep work and stellar painting job." - Anonymous, Google Review (Sekula's Precision Painting)
• "Our almost 40 yr old cedar siding looks stunning for the first time in many years! Their attention to detail was phenomenal!" - Alyssa M., Google Review (Bates Brothers Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Communication is a standout theme across reviews for Rochester, NY painting contractors, covering every phase of a project rather than just the estimate. For R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings, Mark Rivoli is praised for responding to texts and calls promptly, maintaining communication through multi-week projects, and staying patient through rounds of questions from customers managing projects remotely. Sekula's Precision Painting draws repeated praise for their office team - particularly Kaitlyn - who handles scheduling, color coordination, weather delay updates, and billing questions with consistent responsiveness. Multiple reviewers describe Sekula's as operating the way a business should specifically because of how clearly and reliably they communicate at every stage.

For Colors of Rochester, owner Hope Worthington communicates directly throughout each project - including accommodating a same-day paint color change mid-project when a customer had second thoughts. Painting Plus Professionals crews check in with customers each morning to recap work completed and explain which rooms they will be working in, which reviewers describe as rare among contractors. A & L Painting owner Matt Coniglio is frequently cited for answering calls directly, responding to texts quickly, and proactively following up after project completion to confirm the work holds up over time. Across all companies in Rochester, NY, strong communication is consistently linked to the overall satisfaction customers describe.

• "The communication from getting a quote to job completion was timely and professional. The team does quality work and was easy to work with." - Colaruo, Google Review (A & L Painting)
• "Great communication from Dan and his team the entire process, reasonable pricing, and great workmanship." - Eric Potter, Google Review (Golden Boys Painting & Staining)
• "Excellent communication, work ethic and attention to detail! Look no further, call Bates Brothers for an estimate today!" - Ellen LaPorte, Google Review (Bates Brothers Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Timeliness and schedule reliability appear consistently across reviews for Rochester, NY painting contractors. For Monarch Painting, customers describe crews arriving on time each morning throughout multi-week projects and cleaning up before leaving each afternoon - a rhythm that holds even across projects stretching over months of coordination. Sekula's Precision Painting earns praise for completing jobs on or ahead of quoted timelines, including a large two-family exterior project finished on schedule despite spring rain delays that required regular weather-related communication. Multiple reviewers across different companies mention that painters showed up exactly when they said they would, which they describe as notable compared to other contractors they have worked with.

For Painting Plus Professionals, one reviewer describes the crew completing a full exterior project in time for a wedding rehearsal the following day - well ahead of a two-week target. Whelehan Painting customers note the company completed an exterior job in 2.5 days that other contractors had estimated would take two weeks. Bates Brothers Painting owner Max Bates follows up with customers each evening until the project is finished, a scheduling rhythm that keeps clients informed day by day. Across companies in Rochester, NY, consistent on-time arrival and realistic timeline estimates are among the most common reasons customers describe choosing to hire these contractors again.

• "They were on time every morning and completed the job when they said they would. The crew was very friendly and respectful of the items in our home." - Makini Beck, Google Review (Sekula's Precision Painting)
• "Howie Less: They completed the job in 2.5 days. The other recommended contractors estimated 2 weeks to complete the job weather permitting. The Whelahan gang did excellent work. They were efficient." - Howie Less, Google Review (Whelehan Painting)
• "Max followed up every evening and discussed next steps until project was completed. They said what they were going to do, and did what they said!" - S G L., Google Review (Bates Brothers Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Value and pricing come up frequently in reviews for Rochester, NY painting contractors, and the pattern is consistent: customers who compared multiple quotes frequently describe these companies as fair and competitive without being the cheapest option available. Golden Boys Painting & Staining earns specific praise for transparent estimates - reviewers describe receiving itemized quotes with clear labor and material breakdowns, no upselling, and final invoices that matched the original estimate exactly. Whelehan Painting is described by at least one customer as the lowest bidder among several competing quotes, with the finished result being far higher quality than the price suggested.

For Monarch Painting, customers note that Eric's pricing is very reasonable given the level of quality, and that the added value to their homes more than justified the investment. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings customers describe Mark's crew beating competitor pricing while delivering superior results. Painting Plus Professionals earns credit for saving customers significant money over full floor replacement with professional-grade epoxy alternatives. For homeowners in Rochester, NY considering painting projects, multiple reviewers across different companies describe the experience as well worth the cost - with several noting they had been putting off the work and wished they had called sooner.

• "Great job done by these guys. Job was done in a timely fashion at a great price. I was also impressed with their attention to detail. I will definitely use them again." - John Bonaldi, Google Review (Painting Plus Professionals)
• "I had a great experience with Golden Boys cleaning and staining a deck with an arbor. They were organized and efficient from start to finish. Plus, the pricing was excellent. The deck looks terrific." - Anonymous, Google Review (Golden Boys Painting & Staining)
• "I had a great, affordable experience with Monarch Painting. They painted my apartment and the entire process was smooth from start to finish. Eric was easy to work with and made everything stress-free." - Anonymous, Google Review (Monarch Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Repeat customers are one of the clearest indicators of long-term contractor quality, and they appear throughout reviews for Rochester, NY painting companies. Monarch Painting has customers who have used them continuously for over 20 years - one reviewer in the Highland Park area describes calling Eric's team back for both interior and exterior projects since they moved in, finding the same high standards held every time. Whelehan Painting, founded in 1977, counts customers spanning 17 or more years of continuous use, and multiple reviewers describe coming back for a third or fourth project with the same crew they trusted the first time.

For Sekula's Precision Painting, loyalty shows up in customers who describe returning for a second or third project after a strong first experience - several booked follow-up work before the current project had even wrapped up. A & L Painting and Golden Boys Painting & Staining both have reviewers who describe completing a second interior or exterior project after a positive first experience. One of the clearest signals in the data is how many reviewers across Rochester, NY describe immediately referring family members and friends after their own projects finish - a word-of-mouth pattern that runs through every top-rated company in the area.

• "It is always a pleasure to have Eric and his team at our home. Their work is exceptional, and they are professional and down to earth. They are always our first choice for any painting needs." - Anonymous, Google Review (Monarch Painting)
• "I've hired Whelehan 3 times over the last 6 years. I keep coming back for many reasons: high quality results, very reasonable pricing, excellent communications, timely performance." - Greg R., Google Review (Whelehan Painting)
• "Outstanding company to work with. I have had numerous jobs done by Matt and his crew and it's of the highest quality, and everyone involved is a pro." - David S., Google Review (A & L Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google