6 Best Painters Near Irondequoit, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Irondequoit, NY have access to a strong selection of painting contractors, many of whom have earned high marks for reliability, clean workmanship, and clear communication. Whether the project is a full exterior refresh or a single-room interior update, the top-rated companies in this area consistently earn repeat business and referral-driven reviews.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Sekula's Precision Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.9%, with 100% recommended on Facebook across over 50 recommendations. Owner Chris Sekula has been recognized as the Greater Rochester Chamber of Commerce Business Person of the Year, and the company has been accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2017. What stands out in the reviews is how many customers describe leaving their homes entirely in the crew's hands, comfortable enough to run errands while work was underway. If you value a team that treats your home with the same care as their own, Sekula's is a strong choice.

• Multiple reviewers highlight that the crew moves furniture carefully, covers carpets, and sweeps or vacuums at the end of each day
• Commercial clients, including a local daycare center and a remodeling company, rely on Sekula's for consistent results on professional spaces
• Several customers report the crew finishing ahead of the estimated timeline without cutting corners

"If I could give them more stars, I would! Chris and his team are consummate professionals. They ticked every box: prompt, hard-working, skilled, friendly, and respectful of our home." - Elizabeth Palmer, Google Review

For homeowners who want an owner personally involved from estimate through final walkthrough, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings delivers exactly that. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.5% with over 200 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating - a rare achievement at that volume. Owner Mark Rivoli is mentioned by name in the vast majority of reviews, and customers frequently describe him walking through projects before and after completion. R&R also offers concrete coatings with a limited lifetime warranty, making them a good fit if you need both painting and garage or patio floor work.

• Customers with older homes in historic districts praise the crew's ability to work with original materials, including cedar shake replacement
• Several reviewers describe Mark returning the next day to address even minor imperfections without being asked
• The company handles both residential and commercial projects, including storefronts and garage doors

"We originally hired a 'painter' who turned out to be a 'guy who can paint.' We moved on from him and hired Mark, who is a professional painter. There is a BIG DIFFERENCE." - Nicholas Benedetto, Google Review

When it comes to older Rochester-area homes with plaster walls and decades-old paint, Monarch Painting stands out. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% with over 95 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. With over 5 years in business and lead-safe certification for pre-1978 homes, the company has handled projects on Dutch colonials, Craftsman-Tudors, and mid-century ranches throughout the area. If your home has tricky surfaces or wallpaper removal needs, Monarch is a solid option.

• Customers with 90-year-old homes describe the crew replacing worn cedar shakes and repairing wood trim as part of the painting process
• Wallpaper stripping is frequently mentioned, with reviewers noting clean results even on walls that had been papered for decades
• Owner Eric is named in nearly every review, and customers describe him returning to touch up areas even when the issue was not caused by his team

"Eric and his team were so great to work with, from the estimate through completion. They stripped wallpaper and painted multiple rooms. The work is impeccable. None of the splatters or drops I've seen from other painters." - Liz Bunger, Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Painting Plus Professionals. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 75 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, plus 4.8 stars on Angi across over 35 reviews. The company is accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2016 and won the 2022 Best of Rochester Award in the Painting category. What sets them apart is their cabinet refinishing process - Tyler brings physical sample doors to estimates so homeowners can see and feel the finished product before committing. If you are considering painting your kitchen cabinets instead of replacing them, this company is worth a call.

• Multiple reviewers independently describe the sample door practice during estimates, calling it a deciding factor in choosing the company
• The crew's prep work draws consistent praise, with customers noting not a single drop of paint found on floors, appliances, or countertops

"Tyler brought over sample cabinet doors when he came to do our estimate and was the only company to do so. Seeing a finished product and being able to feel the finish made it easy to imagine in our kitchen." - Emily Audet, Google Review

With roots stretching back decades under previous ownership, Colors of Rochester earned a Chooz Score of 85.1% with over 55 Google reviews and a 4.8-star rating. The company is 100% recommended on Facebook with over 20 recommendations. New owner Hope Worthington took the reins in late 2023 and has maintained the company's reputation. The business holds Monroe County MWBE certification and OSHA 10 Construction credentials. If you have an older home with chipping trim and radiators that need attention, Hope and her crew have the experience to handle it.

• Customers with homes built in the 1920s describe the team handling unique challenges with care, including wallpaper removal and plaster repair
• Reviewers frequently describe Hope's personal involvement, from color consultation to daily check-ins during the project
• Several customers note the crew's willingness to work around pets, scheduling changes, and tenants still in the space

"Working with Hope and her crew was a breeze! We have an old house with a good amount of chipping trim, and they handled it with care and expertise." - Andrea P., Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Irondequoit, NY, Level Up Painting earned a Chooz Score of 84.5% with over 275 Google reviews and a 4.8-star rating. Co-owners Jacob Rabideau and Clyde Miller built the company over 8 years in business, and the team holds EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification for pre-1978 homes. Level Up is known for their brush-only approach on exteriors, which several reviewers say produces cleaner lines on complex older surfaces. If you own a century-old home with tricky architectural details, Level Up has a track record with exactly that kind of work.

• One customer describes Level Up painting a very large Queen Anne house, praising their lead-safe practices and rapid progress
• A repeat customer on their sixth project with the company says they will always use Level Up, citing crew member Anthony's above-and-beyond approach
• Exterior projects on homes over 100 years old are a recurring theme, with crews adapting techniques for cedar shingles and historic trim

"Level Up painted the outside of my 125-year-old house and did a great job. They quoted me just what I needed and accomplished the job quickly and professionally." - Doug Kelley, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB, Angi

Professionalism and communication are the most frequently praised qualities across painting contractors serving Irondequoit, NY. Customers consistently describe crews who explain the process upfront, check in daily, and keep homeowners informed about timelines and any changes. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings stands out for owner Mark Rivoli's hands-on communication style, with reviewers noting he responds promptly to texts and phone calls throughout the project. Painting Plus Professionals earns similar praise, with Tyler described as someone who communicates daily plans and keeps clients informed at every step. A & L Painting owner Matt Coniglio is mentioned by name across dozens of reviews for answering calls directly, adjusting schedules on short notice, and following up after completion to confirm satisfaction.

Several customers describe the difference between these contractors and less professional options. "We originally hired a 'painter' who turned out to be a 'guy who can paint.' We moved on from him and hired Mark, who is a professional painter. There is a BIG DIFFERENCE." - Nicholas Benedetto, Google Review. Monarch Painting owner Eric receives similar praise for returning to touch up areas without being asked. "Eric even came back to touch up any area that was damaged after they completed the work, not their fault." - Liz Bunger, Google Review. Bates Brothers Painting owner Max Bates follows up with customers every evening until the project wraps, a pattern noted across many of his reviews. "Matt and his entire team were on-site for four weeks tackling an enormous job. Every single day, they showed up ready to work with the same energy." - Matthew Sharman, Google Review about A & L Painting.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB

The quality of finished work is a defining feature across the top painting contractors near Irondequoit, NY. Reviewers frequently describe results that make rooms look brand new, with clean lines, smooth finishes, and no visible drips or brush marks. Monarch Painting consistently draws praise for handling challenging surfaces in older Rochester homes, including plaster repair, wall smoothing, and careful sanding before any paint is applied. Sekula's Precision Painting customers describe the crew's work as flawless, with several noting that the finished result exceeded what they had imagined. "Best paint job we've ever seen. Five stars well deserved." - Effortlessly Healthy, Google Review about Sekula's Precision Painting.

Painting Plus Professionals has built a reputation specifically around cabinet refinishing quality, with customers describing finishes that look and feel factory-fresh. "The product is amazing! We continue to sit in our kitchen and just admire it." - Mike Altieri, Google Review. Colors of Rochester customers with homes from the 1920s describe the team handling unique trim details and radiators with skill. Level Up Painting earns high marks for exterior work on historic properties, where their brush-only approach produces clean coverage on complex surfaces like cedar shingles and ornate trim. "The work quality was excellent: lead-safe practices, rapid progress, attention to detail, follow-through, on-site tidiness were all top-shelf." - Jim Fraser, Google Review about Level Up Painting.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Cleanup and preparation are among the most consistently praised qualities of painting contractors serving Irondequoit, NY. Customers across multiple companies describe crews who protect floors, cover furniture, tape off fixtures, and leave homes cleaner than they found them. Sekula's Precision Painting reviewers describe the crew covering carpets, moving furniture carefully, and sweeping or vacuuming after finishing each area. "They covered items, moved furniture out of the way, and returned the furniture when they were done. They also work very clean, meaning no messes were left behind." - Makini Beck, Google Review. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings customers describe Mark's crew tarping all floors, taping off railings, outlet covers, and thermostats before work begins.

A & L Painting is frequently described as leaving job sites spotless, with owner Matt and his team cleaning up as if they had never been there. "They did our kitchen cabinets in under 4 hours. Very professional, detailed oriented and cleaned up like they were never there." - Michael Doty, Google Review. Monarch Painting draws praise for the absence of splatters or drops, which multiple reviewers compare favorably to experiences with other painters. Colors of Rochester customers note the crew tidies up every evening, which is especially appreciated on multi-day projects. Level Up Painting crews are described scraping, vacuuming scrapings, and protecting landscaping before any painting begins on exterior projects.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB

Timeliness is a strong suit for painting contractors near Irondequoit, NY. Across hundreds of reviews, customers describe crews arriving on time each morning, meeting or beating estimated timelines, and communicating proactively about scheduling. Sekula's Precision Painting reviewers frequently note the crew showing up promptly and finishing ahead of schedule without cutting corners. "They showed up on time and left on time. They completed the work and more than what they expected to have to do, still within the timeframe they quoted us." - Danielle Privitera, Google Review. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings customers describe Mark fitting projects into tight timelines, including one reviewer whose entire exterior, including cedar shake replacement, was completed in a week and a half.

Level Up Painting earns praise for keeping homeowners in the loop about scheduling well before work begins, with one reviewer noting they received updates days before the start date and a morning call on the first day. Painting Plus Professionals handled a project under a time crunch for new carpet installation, working extra hours to meet the deadline. "We were under a time crunch because we were getting new carpet installed, and they worked diligently to get the job done." - S G, Google Review. Bates Brothers Painting stands out for owner Max Bates providing same-day estimates and keeping projects on an aggressive timeline with daily check-ins.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Pricing is mentioned positively across reviews for painting contractors near Irondequoit, NY, with customers frequently describing quotes as fair, reasonable, and competitive. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings reviewers note that Mark provides transparent, itemized estimates and that his pricing often beats competitors while delivering superior results. "They beat everyone else's pricing and the attention to detail is second to none." - Dustin Marcello, Google Review. Painting Plus Professionals customers describe the cabinet refinishing price point as much more affordable than full cabinet replacement, with Tyler explaining the process and justifying costs during the estimate. A & L Painting is described as very reasonable by multiple reviewers, with one customer noting that competing painters quoted higher prices for the same scope of work.

Monarch Painting customers highlight reasonable pricing paired with efficient timing, making projects feel like strong value overall. Bates Brothers Painting reviewers describe owner Max as transparent with pricing, providing detailed on-site quotes that align with the final cost. "The differentiator was Max himself. He was timely, transparent, knowledgeable and professional and the pricing was perfectly fair and aligned to the job." - Thomas M. B., Google Review. Level Up Painting customers note that the company quoted exactly what was needed rather than upselling unnecessary work, which several reviewers appreciated for older homes that might have invited inflated estimates.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB

Kitchen cabinet painting is a popular specialty among contractors serving Irondequoit, NY, and several companies have built strong reputations specifically for this work. Painting Plus Professionals is widely regarded for their cabinet refinishing process, with Tyler bringing physical sample doors to every estimate so homeowners can see and feel the finish before committing. "Much more affordable than replacing the cabinets, I would highly recommend this company for any painting projects." - Jennifer Buscemi, Google Review. Customers consistently describe a smooth, factory-like finish that holds up well over time.

A & L Painting has made cabinet work a core part of their business, with owner Matt Coniglio and his team completing full kitchen cabinet projects in as little as one day. Their process involves removing doors, sanding in the garage, and painting everything on-site, with a numbering system to ensure doors return to the correct cabinet. Repeat customers who had their cabinets done years ago describe the finish still looking great. "Matt and his team gave our 1960s kitchen a complete face-lift. They painted it from top to bottom and replaced all of our original hardware." - Marney Horvath, Google Review. Level Up Painting also handles cabinet work, with customers describing kitchens that look brand new after the project. For homeowners weighing cabinet painting versus replacement, these contractors offer a significantly more affordable path to a refreshed kitchen.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB