6 Best Painters Near Hamlin, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Hamlin, NY have access to several well-reviewed painting contractors serving the western Monroe County area. Whether you need interior walls refreshed, kitchen cabinets updated, or a full exterior repaint, local crews consistently earn praise for showing up on time, communicating clearly, and delivering clean finished results.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings had over 200 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 87.5%. Owner Mark Rivoli runs a crew that handles everything from residential interiors to commercial spaces and deck staining. What stands out in the reviews is how many customers mention Mark helping them pick colors, offering product recommendations, and working right alongside his team. If you want an owner-operated company where the person giving the estimate is also on the ladder, R&R is a good choice.

Several customers describe hiring R&R after a bad experience with another painter and being relieved by the difference in quality. Reviewers regularly mention the crew finishing on schedule, even under tight timelines like pre-party deadlines or home sale preparations. Mark is known for addressing small imperfections without being asked and following up after completion.

• Customers with new drywall praise Mark for smoothing and correcting issues left by other tradespeople before painting
• Commercial clients, including an orthodontic office and an auto shop, note the same level of care as residential projects
• Multiple reviewers describe Mark fitting rush jobs into the schedule on short notice without sacrificing quality

"We originally hired a 'painter' who turned out to be a 'guy who can paint.' We moved on from him and hired Mark, who is a professional painter. There is a BIG DIFFERENCE." - Nicholas Benedetto, Google Review

For homeowners with older Rochester-area homes that need careful prep work, Monarch Painting has built a strong reputation for handling plaster walls, water damage repairs, and decades-old paint. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% with over 95 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating. Owner Eric Anderson, a SUNY Brockport graduate, launched the company in October 2020 and brought his experienced crew with him. Monarch is also lead-safe certified for work on pre-1978 homes. If your project involves a historic property or surfaces that need serious preparation before paint goes on, Monarch is a good fit.

Reviewers consistently mention the same crew members by name across different seasons and project types, which speaks to a stable, in-house team rather than rotating subcontractors. Customers with century-old homes in neighborhoods like Highland Park and Park Avenue describe results they did not think were possible given the condition of their walls.

• Deck staining and exterior projects earn praise for patience with weather scheduling and thorough power washing
• Daily cleanup is mentioned repeatedly, with one homeowner reporting not finding a single stray paint speck after a ceiling project
• Recognized as a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite in both 2021 and 2023

"Eric and his crew of skilled painters are outstanding. They powerwashed, patched and repaired the stucco, and then painted the entire exterior of our challenging 103-year-old Craftsman-Tudor home and garage." - Andrew Cooke, Google Review

When it comes to kitchen cabinet painting specifically, A & L Painting stands out. Owner Matt Coniglio and his crew have turned cabinet refreshes into their signature service, with dozens of reviews describing full cabinet jobs completed in a single day. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.3% with over 80 Google reviews at a 4.8-star rating and 100% recommended on Facebook across over 85 Facebook recommendations. With over 10 years in business and an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau, A & L brings a well-established track record. If you have been thinking about updating your kitchen cabinets without the cost of a full replacement, A & L is a good choice.

Repeat customers make up a noticeable share of their reviews, with several homeowners hiring Matt back for second and third projects after seeing the cabinet work. Crew members like Andre, Bob, and Brian appear across multiple reviews, and customers frequently describe the team as working like a well-coordinated unit.

• Cabinet doors are numbered, sanded in the garage, and reinstalled with new hardware as part of their standard process
• Multiple reviewers mention cabinets still looking great a year or more after the original project
• Matt personally follows up after completion to confirm satisfaction and handles touch-ups promptly

"I was absolutely blown away with their process and the result! They work like a well-oiled machine and the finished job was perfect." - Sue Wahl, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Hamlin, NY, Bates Brothers Painting has built a strong presence quickly. They earned a Chooz Score of 80.6% with over 60 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, 100% recommended on Facebook, and 5.0 stars on Angi. Owner Max Bates is hands-on from the first estimate through the final walkthrough. If you value detailed written estimates, daily progress updates, and an owner who checks in every evening until the project wraps, Bates Brothers is a good fit.

Customers who obtained multiple quotes frequently describe Max as the most professional and communicative of the contractors they met. The crew handles everything from aging cedar siding to interior walls and kitchen cabinets, and reviewers with older homes praise their ability to restore surfaces that had not been properly maintained in years.

• Max presents itemized estimates on the spot with photos and detailed notes from the walkthrough
• Crew members Joe, Shay, and Will are mentioned by name for careful prep work on exterior projects
• One reviewer hired Bates Brothers on impulse after a stranger knocked on her door, then was pleasantly surprised by the professionalism

"Hiring Bates Brothers Paint was the best decision I made for my home projects. The owner not only offers budget-friendly pricing but also delivers professional, detailed work." - Yi-Jen Huang, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB, Angi

Painting contractors serving Hamlin, NY consistently earn praise for the quality of their finished work. Across hundreds of reviews, customers describe clean lines, smooth surfaces, and results that hold up well over time. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings receives frequent compliments on staircase and railing work, with reviewers noting precision on trim and edges. "The painting, especially the trim work, was done with the highest level of craftsmanship" - William McLane, Google Review. Monarch Painting earns recognition for wall preparation that makes older surfaces look new, with one homeowner noting their 90-year-old Dutch colonial received careful attention to worn cedar shakes and damaged trim. "They paid great attention to detail on our home and garage" - Jim Murphy, Google Review.

Kitchen cabinet painting is where quality really shows, and both A & L Painting and Bates Brothers Painting deliver results customers compare to brand-new installations. A & L Painting customers describe cabinets that still look fresh a year later, with one reviewer noting their 1960s oak cabinets received a complete update from top to bottom. "Every room looks stunning" - Ashley Lapi, Google Review, describing R&R Painting's interior work. Bates Brothers Painting customers with older cedar siding report their exteriors look better than they have in decades after thorough prep and careful application. "Our house came out phenomenal! The finished product, attention to detail, and communication were all on point" - Ross Griswold, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Communication is one of the most frequently praised qualities among painters near Hamlin, NY. Owner-operators set the tone at each company. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings owner Mark Rivoli is known for responding quickly to texts and phone calls, and multiple reviewers describe him providing feasible timelines and keeping customers informed throughout. "Mark provided me with options on paint products, provided a feasible timeline, and followed through on it" - Corey Gefell, Google Review. At Bates Brothers Painting, owner Max Bates follows up with customers every evening until the project is complete, a pattern mentioned across dozens of reviews. "Great experience. Quick, excellent workmanship, and you're kept informed at every step" - Jon Tollerup, Google Review.

Monarch Painting owner Eric Anderson checks in daily during projects, and his crew earns praise for being friendly and courteous even in busy commercial environments like dental offices. "They were able to work around our patients and our busy schedule, which was super helpful!" - Zugner & Pedersen, Google Review. A & L Painting owner Matt Coniglio makes himself available by text and phone throughout the process, and several reviewers note he was the most responsive contractor they contacted during the quoting phase. "Matt was one of the most communicative contractors we have worked with during this renovation process" - Bridget Roney, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Timeliness is a strong point for painting contractors near Hamlin, NY. A & L Painting is particularly known for speed on cabinet projects, with multiple customers describing full kitchen cabinet jobs completed in a single day. One reviewer noted the entire project was done in under four hours. "They showed up on the scheduled day and finished a day early" - Annette Kohl, Google Review. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings receives praise for fitting rush projects into the schedule, including one customer whose exterior needed to be finished days before a birthday party. "He was able to start the job on time, which was huge because he got it done just a few days before my son's birthday party" - Eric Ekstrom, Google Review.

Monarch Painting crews arrive on time consistently and wrap up large-scale projects like two-story foyers and cathedral ceilings with minimal disruption. "Not only did they do a great job, but it was done quickly and with minimal disruption" - Suzanne Clayton, Google Review. Bates Brothers Painting completes exterior projects efficiently even with rain delays, and customers note the crew communicates proactively about weather-related rescheduling. "They were responsive, prompt and professional at all times" - Massimo Martinucci, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Surface preparation and cleanup are among the most praised qualities of painters serving Hamlin, NY. Monarch Painting is especially known for thorough prep on older homes, with customers describing wall repairs, plaster patching, and careful sanding before any paint is applied. One homeowner with a 1954 ranch was impressed that a specialized sander with a vacuum attachment left virtually no plaster dust in the house. "They were very respectful of our home and belongings" - Liz Bunger, Google Review. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings earns similar praise, with customers noting Mark addresses drywall issues and smooths surfaces that other tradespeople left unfinished. "He took the time to make sure that all the walls were smooth and handled any issues that the drywall guy may have missed" - Toula Beane, Google Review.

A & L Painting crews leave workspaces spotless, with several reviewers noting no cleanup was needed after the team left. "There were no messes or cleanup needed after the job was completed" - Otto Soechtig, Google Review. Bates Brothers Painting crews handle power washing, sanding, scraping, and protecting surrounding areas before painting begins, and customers describe careful masking and covering of surfaces not being painted. "They kept me updated every day they were there. Very professional, clean and reliable" - Susan Polcyn-Dorgan, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Customers hiring painters near Hamlin, NY generally describe pricing as fair and competitive. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings receives frequent mentions for beating competitors on price without sacrificing quality. "They beat everyone else's pricing and the attention to detail is second to none" - Dustin Marcello, Google Review. Bates Brothers Painting owner Max Bates presents itemized estimates on the spot, and customers who compared multiple quotes describe his pricing as aligned with the scope of work. "The owner not only offers budget-friendly pricing but also delivers professional, detailed work" - Yi-Jen Huang, Google Review.

A & L Painting customers describe the value as strong, particularly for cabinet work where the alternative would be a full kitchen renovation. One reviewer noted that two other respected local painters declined the job before Matt took it on and delivered excellent results. "Reasonable price. Matt and the team did fantastic work" - Justin Hawley, Google Review. Monarch Painting customers acknowledge that thorough prep work is worth the investment, with several noting the difference between a cheap paint job and one where walls are properly repaired and sanded first. "You could tell they all liked what they were doing and liked working for Monarch" - Thomas Chew, Google Review, reflecting the crew pride that contributes to consistent results.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google