6 Best Painters Near Hilton, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Hilton, NY have access to several highly rated painting contractors who consistently earn praise for their professionalism, attention to detail, and reliable results. Whether the job involves refreshing interior walls, repainting the exterior of an older home, or refinishing kitchen cabinets, the top-rated companies serving the Hilton area stand out for strong customer satisfaction across multiple review platforms.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings had over 200 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, which is rare at that volume. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.5%. Owner Mark Rivoli runs a crew that includes familiar names like Tyler, Donny, and Bethany, and reviewers regularly describe a hands-on approach where Mark personally assists with color selection and walks through the finished work. Several customers who own older Rochester-area homes mention how the crew replaced worn cedar shakes and handled complex exterior surfaces with care. If you want an owner-operated company where the same team shows up every time, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings is a strong choice.

Beyond the paint work itself, reviewers frequently describe how comfortable they felt leaving the crew unsupervised in their homes, with one commercial client noting how the crew completely changed the look of their building's garage doors. R&R also offers concrete coatings and deck staining services, backed by a satisfaction guarantee.

• Customers with historic district homes praise the crew's ability to work with original materials and complete multi-story exteriors in under two weeks
• Multiple reviewers highlight Mark's willingness to correct small imperfections the very next day without being asked
• The company also handles commercial projects, with business owners describing the same level of care as residential clients

"Mark and his team are the best of the best. Honest, Trustworthy, Hardworking. They beat everyone else's pricing and the attention to detail is second to none." - Dustin Marcello, Google Review

For homeowners with older Rochester-area properties that need careful prep work and experienced hands, Monarch Painting has carved out a strong reputation. Monarch Painting earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% with over 95 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Eric Andersen leads a team that regularly takes on century-old homes in neighborhoods like Highland Park and Park Avenue. They are lead-safe certified and fully insured, and were named a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite in both 2021 and 2023. If you have plaster walls, water damage, or decades-old wallpaper to deal with, Monarch is a good fit.

A pattern that stands out in reviews is the number of repeat customers and multi-room projects. Several homeowners describe booking Monarch for one room and then immediately scheduling additional work because they were so pleased with the results. One customer who was away for the winter had Monarch handle ceiling texture removal, furniture moving, and cleanup while they were out of state, with Eric sending progress photos throughout.

• Crew members like Angelica, Brian, Brent, and Rob are named across dozens of independent reviews, showing consistent staffing
• Reviewers with 1910s-era and 1920s-era homes specifically mention the team's comfort working with plaster, old trim, and challenging surfaces
• Multiple customers describe Eric offering helpful suggestions for additional improvements they had not considered

"They took their time to make sure the job was done well and done right, with impeccable attention to detail." - Eli Stein, Google Review

When it comes to kitchen cabinet refinishing, Painting Plus Professionals stands out. Painting Plus Professionals earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 75 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating. They hold an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau (accredited since 2016) and earned 4.8 stars on Angi across over 35 reviews. They also won the 2022 Best of Rochester Award in the painting category. If you are considering a cabinet refresh instead of a full kitchen replacement, this company is worth a call.

What sets them apart in the cabinet space is the estimate process itself. Tyler, who handles many of the cabinet projects, brings physical sample doors to the estimate so homeowners can see and feel the finished product before committing. Reviewers consistently describe an orbital sanding and priming process that leaves surfaces perfectly smooth before paint ever goes on.

• Floor-to-ceiling protection is standard on every project, with reviewers noting not a single drop of paint found where it should not be
• Several customers mention choosing Painting Plus after comparing multiple quotes, citing the thoroughness of the initial consultation as the deciding factor

"Tyler did a wonderful job on my kitchen cabinets! I'm so impressed with his craftsmanship. He was very professional and communicated with me every day on his plan." - Jennifer Buscemi, Google Review

A husband-and-wife-style operation with a personal touch, Colors of Rochester takes a hands-on approach that shows in their reviews. Colors of Rochester earned a Chooz Score of 85.1% with over 55 Google reviews and a 4.8-star rating. They are 100% recommended on Facebook with over 20 recommendations. Owner Hope Worthington took over the business in late 2023, and the company holds Monroe County MWBE certification along with OSHA 10 Construction credentials. If you value working directly with the owner and a small, dedicated crew, Colors of Rochester is a good match.

Reviewers describe Hope as genuinely engaged with each project, from initial color consultation through final walkthrough. Crew members Julia, Grace, MaryBeth, and Scott appear by name in reviews, and customers with older homes (including a 1924 house with unique trim challenges) praise the team's patience and expertise.

• Multiple customers highlight same-day or next-day responsiveness from Hope during the quoting process
• Several reviewers mention recommending the company to friends immediately after their project wrapped up
• Dog-friendly and accommodating of customers with mobility limitations, according to multiple reviews

"Working with Hope and her crew was a breeze! The quoting process was fast and detailed. We have an old house with a good amount of chipping trim, and they handled it with care and expertise." - Andrea P., Google Review

With roots stretching back to 1977, Whelehan Painting is a family business with nearly 50 years in the community. Whelehan Painting earned a Chooz Score of 85.0% with over 175 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. They also maintain 98% recommended on Facebook and 5.0 stars on Yelp. With 16 in-house employees working in established teams, this is a company built for larger exterior and whole-house interior projects. If you want a well-established local company with decades of history in the Hilton, NY area, Whelehan is a reliable pick.

What stands out in the reviews is the speed and efficiency of the crews. One homeowner noted that competing contractors quoted two weeks for an exterior job that Whelehan completed in two and a half days. Repeat customers are common, with several reviewers describing multiple projects over the years, including one who has used them for cabinets, exterior, and interior work on the same home.

• Crew members Paul, Karen, Tommy, and James appear by name across years of reviews, confirming the same teams work together consistently
• Owner Pat Whelehan and project manager Jeff are both praised for clear communication from estimate through completion
• Multiple reviewers describe the crew moving and covering all furniture, then putting everything back in place when finished

"Whelehan Painting painted the entire interior of my home in just 3 days! The crew assigned to my job was incredible. They were professional, fun, and worked well together." - Kathie Ryan, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Hilton, NY, Level Up Painting handles both residential and historic property projects across the Rochester area. Level Up Painting earned a Chooz Score of 84.5% with over 275 Google reviews and a 4.8-star rating. Co-owners Jacob Rabideau and Clyde Miller have built the company over 8 years in business, and the team holds EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification for work on pre-1978 homes. If you own an older home that needs specialized exterior work, Level Up is a solid option.

A distinguishing detail in reviews is the company's brush-only approach to exterior painting, with no spraying, which produces cleaner lines on complex older surfaces. Customers with Queen Anne houses, cedar-shingled exteriors, and 100-plus-year-old homes specifically praise the crew's ability to adapt techniques to challenging conditions.

• Crew members Rebecca, Josh, Jonathan, and Calvin are praised by name for both interior and exterior projects
• Reviewers describe the crew scraping, vacuuming, caulking, and removing gutter downspouts before a single coat goes on

"Level Up painted the outside of my 125-year-old house and did a great job. They quoted me just what I needed and accomplished the job quickly and professionally." - Doug Kelley, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB, Angi, Yelp

Quality and workmanship are the most frequently praised qualities among painting contractors serving Hilton, NY. Across hundreds of reviews, customers describe results that make their homes look brand new, with particular emphasis on how well crews handle prep work before any paint goes on. Companies like Monarch Painting, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings, and Painting Plus Professionals earn consistent praise for smooth finishes, clean lines, and careful attention to surfaces that need extra repair before painting can begin.

For homeowners with older properties, the quality of surface preparation makes a significant difference. Monarch Painting reviewers describe walls that looked rough and damaged being brought back to a smooth, even surface before a single coat was applied. "The walls came out so smooth! You would have no idea how terrible and rough they looked beforehand." - Stephanie Leonardo, Google Review. Whelehan Painting customers describe crews that go beyond just painting, with one reviewer noting, "Paul and Karen worked magic today turning gouged up walls bright and pristine!" - Beth Holahan, Google Review. A & L Painting also earns praise for pointing out wall imperfections that homeowners had not even noticed. "They pointed out spots in my walls that needed to be fixed that I didn't even know about." - Gregory Karras, Google Review. Whether the project involves a 1920s colonial or a modern split-level, the top-rated contractors in the Hilton, NY area share a commitment to getting surfaces right before the brush ever touches the wall.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB

Communication is one of the most consistent strengths across the top painting contractors serving Hilton, NY. Reviewers frequently describe owners who respond quickly to initial inquiries, provide detailed estimates, and stay in contact throughout the project. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings owner Mark Rivoli is praised for responding promptly to texts and phone calls, while Whelehan Painting's Pat and Jeff earn recognition for keeping homeowners informed from the first estimate through final walkthrough. Colors of Rochester owner Hope Worthington is described as genuinely engaged, with customers noting her personal follow-ups and willingness to accommodate scheduling changes.

Several contractors go beyond basic communication with daily progress updates and evening check-ins. Bates Brothers Painting owner Max Bates follows up every evening until a project is complete, a pattern that appears in numerous reviews. "Max was one of the most professional painters I've had the pleasure of working with. Great communication skills and expert painting equal a 5 star business." - Jane Chambers, Google Review. Monarch Painting owner Eric Andersen is described as checking in periodically during projects, and one customer who was out of state received progress photos throughout their job. "Eric was in contact with me to keep me informed of the project and sent photos after completion." - Ann Pompa, Google Review. For homeowners who value knowing exactly what is happening with their project at every stage, the contractors serving Hilton, NY set a high standard.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Timeliness is a recurring strength among painting contractors in the Hilton, NY area. Reviewers consistently describe crews arriving on schedule each morning and completing work within the estimated timeframe, and in some cases ahead of schedule. Whelehan Painting stands out for speed, with one homeowner noting that competing contractors quoted two weeks for an exterior job that the Whelehan crew finished in two and a half days. "They completed the job in 2 1/2 days. The other recommended painting contractors estimated 2 weeks." - Howie Less, Google Review. A & L Painting customers describe Matt and his team pushing through multi-room projects in just two days, while Bates Brothers Painting reviewers note projects finishing ahead of schedule.

Monarch Painting and R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings also earn praise for sticking to timelines. Monarch Painting customers describe crews that show up on time every morning and work steadily through the day. "Eric and his guys did a great job. The painting was done quickly and with minimal disruption." - Suzanne Clayton, Google Review. Level Up Painting reviewers note that the company met or exceeded scheduling expectations, even on large exterior projects. For homeowners who need work completed within a specific window, the top contractors in Hilton, NY have a strong record of delivering on their promises.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Pricing and value come up frequently in reviews for painting contractors serving Hilton, NY. The consistent theme is that the top-rated companies may not always be the cheapest option, but customers describe the results as well worth the investment. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings reviewers note competitive pricing, with one customer stating the company beat other contractors' quotes while delivering superior results. Whelehan Painting customers describe pricing as fair and reasonable, especially given the speed and quality of the finished work. "The price was very fair. The hard working crew was respectful, organized and efficient." - J Warren, Google Review.

Monarch Painting reviewers use phrases like "very reasonably priced" and "you get what you pay for," with several noting the company offers strong value given the level of prep work and detail involved. "They are VERY reasonably priced. We cannot recommend this company highly enough." - Cami Goldowitz, Google Review. Painting Plus Professionals customers highlight the cabinet refinishing service as a cost-effective alternative to full kitchen replacement, and Bates Brothers Painting owner Max Bates is praised for providing detailed, itemized estimates on the spot. For homeowners comparing quotes in the Hilton, NY area, the general pattern is that the highest-rated companies offer transparent pricing and deliver results that justify the cost.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB

Cleanup and site protection are standout qualities among the top painting contractors serving Hilton, NY. Reviewers across multiple companies describe crews that cover floors, furniture, cabinets, and countertops before starting work, and leave the space spotless when finished. Monarch Painting earns some of the most detailed praise in this area, with customers describing floors and countertops completely covered and not a single stray drop of paint found after the job. "They cleaned up afterwards as well, so definitely a 5 star rating!" - Suzanne Clayton, Google Review. One 20-year repeat customer noted that Eric and his team "clean up everything and even get the house back in order for us." - Joan Termini, Google Review.

Whelehan Painting crews are praised for moving all furniture, covering everything, and returning it all to its original position when finished. A & L Painting reviews describe Matt's team leaving no messes or cleanup needed after completion. Painting Plus Professionals takes prep work seriously enough that reviewers specifically note the absence of paint on appliances, floors, or anywhere it should not be. For homeowners concerned about the disruption of a painting project, the top contractors in Hilton, NY make cleanup a priority, not an afterthought.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Kitchen cabinet painting is one of the most popular services offered by contractors in the Hilton, NY area, and reviews reflect high satisfaction with the results. Painting Plus Professionals is frequently recommended for cabinets, with Tyler's process of bringing physical sample doors to estimates earning praise from multiple homeowners. Customers describe cabinets that look factory-finished, with careful sanding, priming, and a numbering system to ensure every door goes back in the right place. "Much more affordable than replacing the cabinets. I would highly recommend this company!" - Jennifer Buscemi, Google Review. A & L Painting also earns strong reviews for cabinet work, with owner Matt and his team completing kitchen projects in as little as two days.

Whelehan Painting has handled cabinet projects for repeat customers, with one reviewer describing multiple projects on the same home including cabinets, exterior, and interior work. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings customers describe quick and efficient cabinet work, while Level Up Painting reviewers note that their kitchens look brand new after refinishing. "My kitchen looks brand new! All of the painters were incredibly respectful, arrived on time, worked super efficiently." - Jennifer Leone, Google Review. For homeowners considering a kitchen refresh without the expense of full cabinet replacement, the painting contractors serving Hilton, NY offer a proven, budget-friendly alternative.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB