3 Best Painters Near Lima, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Lima, NY looking for reliable painting contractors have several strong options serving the area from the greater Rochester market. The companies below have earned standout ratings across multiple platforms by consistently delivering on both craftsmanship and customer service.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Sekula's Precision Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating, and is 100% recommended on Facebook across over 50 Facebook recommendations. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.9% and were recognized as the Greater Rochester Chamber of Commerce Business Person of the Year. Based in East Rochester and serving both the Rochester and Buffalo markets, Sekula's handles everything from exterior repaints to detailed interior trim work. Commercial clients show up in their reviews too - owner Chris and his team painted a retail store during its setup, earning praise for professionalism in a business setting. If you're looking for a company with consistent office communication and a named crew you can trust on site, Sekula's is a solid choice.

• Office staff like Caitlyn are called out by name for keeping scheduling organized and communication clear from first contact through project completion.
• Crews handle both interior and exterior projects, including spindle detail work and door painting, with multiple reviewers noting thorough prep before paint touches the walls.
• The company serves residential and commercial clients alike, making them a good option for customers with business spaces as well as homes.

For homeowners in the Lima, NY area who need painting services that extend beyond walls - including deck staining and concrete coating work - R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings is worth a look. With a Chooz Score of 87.5% and over 200 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating, their volume of reviews at that level is notable. Owner Mark Rivoli is on the job personally, and several reviewers describe him rescheduling work patiently around weather conditions to get the best results - particularly for exterior and deck staining projects. If you have a deck, stairwell, or outdoor surface that needs careful preparation and proper timing, R&R brings that hands-on flexibility.

• Mark is willing to reschedule around weather conditions for staining projects, prioritizing quality results over convenience.
• Reviewers describe R&R's pricing as reasonable and the staff as clean and professional throughout the job.
• Multiple customers mention planning to hire the team again, pointing to satisfaction that goes beyond just the finished product.
• The crew - including Tyler, Donny, Rob, Tom, Bethany, Jose, and Janice - is consistently named across reviews, suggesting the same team shows up rather than rotating strangers.

Rounding out the top painting contractors serving Lima, NY, A & L Painting earned a Chooz Score of 84.3% with over 80 Google reviews at a 4.8-star rating. They are 100% recommended on Facebook across over 85 Facebook recommendations, hold a 5.0-star rating with the Better Business Bureau, and carry strong marks on Angi as well. Owner Matt Coniglio handles estimates personally and is present throughout projects. A & L has built a particular following for kitchen cabinet painting, with customers describing same-day completions and cleanup that leaves no trace of the work. With over 10 years in business, they've developed a loyal repeat customer base across the Rochester area. If you're considering a cabinet refresh instead of a full replacement, A & L is a particularly good fit.

• Customers describe fast turnarounds on cabinet jobs, with some projects wrapped in a few hours and hardware reinstalled the same day.
• The cleanup standard gets specific praise - reviewers note the crew leaves no materials or mess when they're done.
• Matt's personal follow-up after project completion appears across multiple reviews, with customers noting he contacts them to confirm the work held up.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB, Angi

Professionalism and communication stand out as recurring strengths among painters serving Lima, NY. At Sekula's Precision Painting, customers mention the experience starting from the very first phone call. Office staff are referenced by name, with reviewers describing smooth scheduling, prompt answers to questions, and crews that keep homeowners informed throughout the project. One reviewer noted being confident in the company's professionalism before a single painter had set foot on site, based on the quality of that initial office contact alone. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings earns similar praise, with owner Mark Rivoli described as responsive and transparent at every stage - reviewers highlight that he keeps customers updated as the project progresses and personally confirms they're comfortable with the work before wrapping up.

"We were given estimates quickly and put on the schedule in a timely manner. The painters who worked were friendly, very knowledgeable and kept disruption to a minimum." - Roberta D., Google Review. A & L Painting's owner Matt Coniglio takes a similar approach. Multiple reviewers describe Matt answering calls directly, adjusting schedules when needed, and following up after the job to confirm the results held up. The communication pattern across all three companies serving Lima, NY points to customers who expect the contractor to be reachable, honest about timelines, and proactive about keeping homeowners in the loop.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Cleanup and prep consistently appear as positive themes in reviews for painters serving Lima, NY. At Sekula's Precision Painting, reviewers describe crews cleaning up at the end of each workday during multi-day projects, so the home doesn't sit in disarray overnight. Prep work gets specific attention too - customers note that surfaces were checked and corrected before paint was applied, with one reviewer pointing out crew member Dave's care in readying walls and spindles before any painting began. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings draws similar observations, with reviewers calling out the clean working style of the crew on both interior and exterior jobs.

"The crew was respectful and thorough, they double checked everything with us, cleaned everything up at the end of each day, and did an amazing job!" - SRZ, Google Review. At A & L Painting, the cleanup standard on cabinet jobs draws consistent attention. Reviewers describe the crew removing hardware, staging doors carefully during the work, painting, and reinstalling - leaving no materials or mess behind when they finish. For homeowners in Lima, NY who don't want to spend days cleaning up after a paint crew, all three companies have set an expectation of jobsite tidiness that carries through their reviews.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Timeliness runs through reviews for all three painting contractors serving Lima, NY. At Sekula's Precision Painting, customers describe jobs starting on schedule and finishing within the promised timeframe. One reviewer noted the company stayed on budget and on time for a complete exterior repaint, and commercial clients have praised the crew for executing the work exactly as quoted - no surprises, no delays. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings takes a different approach to scheduling that still earns strong marks: owner Mark is willing to push back start dates around weather conditions for staining projects, and reviewers consistently frame that flexibility as evidence of doing the job right rather than rushing to completion.

"Chris and his team quoted the work, showed up on time, and executed the work as promised. No surprises and easy to work with." - Hadi S., Google Review. At A & L Painting, customers describe quick project completions, with some cabinet jobs finished in just a few hours. That kind of turnaround tends to surprise reviewers who expected longer disruption - several describe being impressed by how efficiently the crew worked through each stage. Across all three companies, the consistent feedback from Lima, NY area customers is that these crews show up when they say they will and complete projects without drawn-out delays.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Value comes up regularly in reviews for painters serving Lima, NY. At Sekula's Precision Painting, customers describe the pricing as making sense for the level of quality delivered, with one reviewer specifically noting the company provides high-quality work at an affordable price. The company's practice of delivering exactly what was quoted - no surprises on scope or cost - builds trust around pricing as much as the estimate itself. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings draws similar observations - multiple reviewers call the pricing reasonable, and the combination of a professional crew, clean worksite, and personal owner involvement makes the value clear. Several customers who mention competitive pricing also describe planning to return for future projects.

"Reasonable price. Great work and great service! Super efficient and great attention to detail." - Derek S., Google Review. A & L Painting positions particularly well on value for cabinet refinishing, where customers compare what they paid for a painted finish against the cost of full cabinet replacement. Reviewers describe results that exceeded expectations, with several noting the finished work looked better than they thought a paint-based update could achieve. For homeowners in Lima, NY weighing the cost of painting against renovation or replacement, all three companies have built reputations for delivering results that make the investment feel worthwhile.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google