6 Best Painters Near Honeoye Falls, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Honeoye Falls, NY have access to several highly reviewed painting contractors serving the greater Rochester area. These companies stand out for consistent crew quality, owner involvement, and strong customer loyalty across hundreds of verified reviews.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Sekula's Precision Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.9%, with 100% recommended on Facebook across over 50 recommendations and an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau. What stands out in the reviews is how many customers mention leaving the house entirely while the crew works, a sign of deep trust. Owner Chris Sekula is involved from the estimate through final walkthrough, and customers frequently describe the crew exceeding expectations on exterior projects. If you're looking for a painting team with over 8 years in business and a stable roster of named crew members, Sekula's is a strong option for both interior and exterior work.

Several reviewers describe bringing Sekula's back for second and third projects after positive initial experiences, and the company also handles commercial work for local remodeling contractors who trust them with high-end homes.

• Customers regularly mention crew members Dave, Ray, and Christian by name, pointing to a consistent in-house team rather than rotating subcontractors
• Multiple reviews highlight how the crew kept equipment neatly organized over multi-week exterior projects
• The company handles both residential and commercial painting, including storefront setups for local businesses

"If I could give them more stars, I would! Chris and his team are consummate professionals. They ticked every box: prompt, hard-working, skilled, friendly, and respectful of our home." - Elizabeth Palmer, Google Review

For homeowners who want a perfect review record and hands-on ownership, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings has built an impressive presence. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.5% with over 200 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, a perfect score across that volume. Owner Mark Rivoli personally handles estimates, color consultations, and regularly works alongside his crew. If you value working directly with the owner from first call to final walkthrough, R&R is a good fit.

What comes through in the reviews is how many customers describe Mark correcting small details the next morning before anyone had to ask. Crew members Tyler, Donny, and Rob appear across dozens of independent reviews spanning years, confirming a stable team.

• Several customers hired R&R specifically after a bad experience with a previous painter, noting the difference in professionalism and finish quality
• Deck staining and exterior projects on older Rochester homes are a frequent specialty, with reviewers praising careful prep on aging wood
• Trim work receives particular praise, with one customer describing edges as "perfectly cut-in"

"We have had a number of painters through the years. R&R really listened to us the customer, the paint job looks astounding, we are getting so many compliments!" - Alison B, Google Review

When it comes to older homes with plaster walls and decades of layered paint, Monarch Painting stands out. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% with over 95 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating. With over 5 years in business, the company is lead-safe certified and has been named a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite. Owner Eric is present on nearly every job and customers describe a collaborative process where he checks in daily. If you have an older Honeoye Falls, NY home that needs careful surface preparation, Monarch is a good choice.

Reviewers consistently describe booking their next project before the current one wraps up, and multiple customers mention wallpaper removal and door refinishing as standout services alongside standard wall painting.

• Crew members Bob, Rachel, Shanique, and Sean are named across reviews, showing consistent staffing
• Projects on homes in the Highland Park and Park Avenue neighborhoods of Rochester appear frequently, suggesting experience with historic properties

"You want professional? Choose Monarch! You want precision lines? Choose Monarch! You want quality? It's Monarch all the way. Our home has never looked better!" - Jessica Metras, Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Painting Plus Professionals. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 75 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, plus 4.8 stars on Angi across over 35 reviews and an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau. What makes this company different is Tyler's cabinet refinishing process, where he brings physical sample doors to the estimate so homeowners can see and feel the finish before committing. If you're considering cabinet painting as an alternative to full replacement, Painting Plus Professionals is a strong pick.

• Several reviewers describe choosing this company specifically after comparing cabinet replacement costs and finding refinishing far more affordable
• Prep work is the most praised element, with customers noting not a single drop of paint found on floors or appliances
• The company won the 2022 Best of Rochester Award in the Painting category

"Tyler did a wonderful job on my kitchen cabinets! I'm so impressed with his craftsmanship. He was very professional and communicated with me every day on his plan." - Jennifer Buscemi, Google Review

With nearly 50 years in business, Whelehan Painting is the longest-running operation on this list. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.0% with over 175 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating, 98% recommended on Facebook, and 5.0 stars on Yelp. Founded in 1977 by Chuck Whelehan and now run by the next generation, this family business operates with 16 in-house employees who work as established teams. If you want a proven, family-owned company with deep roots in the Rochester area, Whelehan is a reliable choice.

What reviewers notice most is how quickly the crew completes exterior work. One customer noted that competing contractors quoted two weeks for the same job Whelehan finished in two and a half days, and neighbors offered compliments and thumbs-up during the project.

• Customers describe Pat and Jeff as responsive communicators who follow through on every commitment
• Exterior painting, including barns, dormers, and full house exteriors, is a frequent project type in the reviews
• Several reviewers mention receiving helpful suggestions on color and product selection

"The price was fair and reasonable comparatively. They completed the job in 2 1/2 days. The other recommended painting contractors estimated 2 weeks to complete the job." - Howie Less, Google Review

A hands-on owner who shows up on every job defines A & L Painting. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.3% with over 80 Google reviews at a 4.8-star rating, 100% recommended on Facebook across over 85 recommendations, and an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau. Owner Matt Coniglio handles estimates personally and works alongside his crew on site. With over 10 years in business, A & L has become known for kitchen cabinet refinishing, with reviewers describing their 1990s oak cabinets looking completely new after the process. If you want an owner who personally ensures your satisfaction before leaving the job site, A & L is a good fit.

• Multiple customers describe Matt moving project timelines up when renovations finished early, showing scheduling flexibility
• Cabinet projects are completed quickly, with some customers reporting full kitchen cabinet jobs done in just two days

"Matt was super easy to work with from requesting a quote, to scheduling and moving our project up when our kitchen renovations were finished early. His crew was in and out and left a very impressive and tidy finished project." - Julie Messier, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Honeoye Falls, NY, Bates Brothers Painting has built a strong reputation quickly. They earned a Chooz Score of 80.6% with over 60 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating and 100% recommended on Facebook. Owner Max Bates personally handles every estimate, takes on-site photos and detailed notes, and presents itemized estimates on the spot. If you appreciate a contractor who communicates daily and follows up every evening until the project is complete, Bates Brothers is worth a call.

• Customers who collected multiple bids consistently describe Max as the most thorough and detailed during the estimate process
• Evening follow-up calls are the most repeated pattern, with homeowners noting they always knew what was happening next

"Typically I do everything myself, but when it comes to painting particularly something as difficult as cabinets I want nothing to do with it. Max has been amazing. Not the typical contractor, he communicated with me daily." - Nick Isler, Facebook Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Angi, BBB

Painting quality is the most frequently praised topic across reviews for contractors serving Honeoye Falls, NY. Customers consistently describe finished results that exceed their expectations, with particular attention to edges, smooth finishes, and careful color matching.

R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings receives repeated praise for trim work and edge quality. One reviewer described the edges as perfectly cut-in, leaving walls ready for hanging pictures immediately. Monarch Painting is frequently chosen for challenging surfaces, including plaster walls and older homes with layered paint, where thorough surface preparation makes the difference in the final result. "Quality work done in a timely manner, with frequent updates and clear communications. Bob and Rachel were a delight to work with: neat, tidy and respectful of our home." - Steve Johnson, Google Review. Painting Plus Professionals earns praise specifically for cabinet refinishing quality, with customers noting flawless spray finishes. "Most amazing was their attention to detail in the prep work. There was not even a drop of paint on the appliances or the floor or anywhere where it shouldn't be." - James Maxwell, Google Review. Sekula's Precision Painting and Whelehan Painting both receive strong marks for exterior work, where prep and product selection determine how long the paint job holds up. "The results were great, we could not be more pleased. The team worked hard and was on time each day." - Julie Boyd, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Communication is the second most frequently mentioned quality across painting reviews in the Honeoye Falls, NY area. Customers value contractors who respond quickly, explain the process clearly, and keep them informed throughout the project.

Bates Brothers Painting owner Max Bates sets a high standard by following up with customers every evening and discussing next steps until the project wraps up. "Max Bates was one of the most professional painters I've had the pleasure of working with. Great communication skills and expert painting equal a 5 star business." - Jane Chambers, Google Review. A & L Painting owner Matt Coniglio answers calls directly, responds to texts quickly, and adjusts schedules when customers need flexibility. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings owner Mark Rivoli is described as patient during color consultations and willing to reschedule around weather for the best results. "Mark and his crew at R&R painting are great. They were detail oriented, neat and very friendly to work with." - Thomas Stess Johnston, Google Review. Whelehan Painting customers describe Pat and Jeff as easy to reach from first contact through job completion. "Whelehan Painting was great to work with from first contact to job completion. Very professional, did exactly what they said they would do." - J Barczykowski, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Angi

Punctuality and schedule reliability are among the top concerns for homeowners hiring painters, and contractors serving Honeoye Falls, NY generally earn high marks in this area. Reviewers frequently note crews arriving at the scheduled time each morning and completing projects within or ahead of the quoted timeline.

Sekula's Precision Painting customers describe the crew arriving on time every morning and finishing when promised. "Amazing work! They were on time every morning and completed the job when they said they would. The crew was very friendly and respectful of the items in our home." - Makini Beck, Google Review. Whelehan Painting stands out for speed, with one customer reporting a job completed in two and a half days that other contractors estimated at two weeks. Monarch Painting customers mention Eric and his team arriving on time and providing daily updates on progress. "Eric and team arrived on time, cleaned up daily and were always friendly. I already booked them for our next project!" - Jessica Metras, Google Review. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings also earns praise for meeting deadlines, with one customer highlighting that the crew finished just days before a birthday party they were hosting. "He was able to start the job on time, which was huge because he got it done just a few days before my son's birthday party." - Eric Ekstrom, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Cleanup and workspace protection are common themes across reviews for painters serving Honeoye Falls, NY. Customers notice when crews cover furniture and flooring carefully, keep work areas organized during multi-day projects, and leave homes spotless when the job is done.

Painting Plus Professionals receives some of the strongest cleanup praise, with reviewers reporting zero paint found on appliances, floors, or surfaces where it should not be. "We had several companies give us quotes for our kitchen cabinets, but we ultimately went with Painting Plus Professionals and could not be happier with our choice." - Emily Audet, Google Review. Sekula's Precision Painting customers note the crew covered items carefully and moved furniture as needed, with equipment kept neatly organized over multi-week exterior jobs. A & L Painting reviewers describe Matt's crew leaving behind tidy, finished spaces with no cleanup needed afterward. Whelehan Painting earns praise for leaving job sites well-organized, with one barn painting customer noting they cleaned up thoroughly after the work. "They painted attic dormers and did a great job. Easy to work with and they did what they said they would do. Cleaned up well after the job." - Howard Grossman, Google Review. Monarch Painting customers describe crews cleaning up daily during multi-room interior projects.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, BBB

Value and pricing come up regularly in reviews for painting contractors near Honeoye Falls, NY. Customers generally describe receiving fair, competitive estimates that match the final invoice without surprise charges.

Whelehan Painting earns some of the strongest value mentions, with several customers describing the price as fair and reasonable compared to other bids. "We were very satisfied with the job they did and felt the price was very fair. The hard working crew was respectful, organized and efficient." - J Warren, Google Review. Bates Brothers Painting owner Max Bates provides itemized estimates on the spot, and customers who collected multiple bids describe his pricing as competitive and transparent. Painting Plus Professionals is frequently described as a more affordable alternative to full cabinet replacement, with reviewers noting significant savings while achieving results that look brand new. "Much more affordable than replacing the cabinets, I would highly recommend this company to anyone wanting to update their kitchen." - Jennifer Buscemi, Google Review. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings and A & L Painting both receive mentions for providing accurate estimates that held through project completion, with no surprise additions to the bill.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB

Cabinet refinishing is a popular specialty among several painting contractors serving Honeoye Falls, NY. Homeowners looking to update their kitchens without the cost of full cabinet replacement have multiple well-reviewed options in the area.

Painting Plus Professionals stands out for their cabinet process. Tyler brings physical sample cabinet doors to every estimate so homeowners can see and feel the finished product before committing. Reviewers describe the results as a complete refresh of dated oak and builder-grade cabinets. "We had several companies give us quotes for our kitchen cabinets, but we ultimately went with Painting Plus Professionals and could not be happier with our choice. Tyler brought over sample cabinet doors when he came to do our estimate." - Emily Audet, Google Review. A & L Painting owner Matt Coniglio has built a strong reputation for cabinet work, with customers describing their 1990s oak cabinets looking completely new. Some projects are completed in as little as two days. "I had A&L paint kitchen cabinets, crown molding, baseboard, and ceilings in my main living area recently. They were able to push through it in two days." - Shawn Keeler, Google Review. Bates Brothers Painting also handles cabinet projects, with customers praising Max's daily communication and careful approach to a notoriously difficult painting surface.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB