5 Best Painters Near Rush, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Rush, NY have access to a strong group of painting contractors through Chooz Painters, with four companies consistently earning high marks for their workmanship, reliability, and customer communication. From large exterior projects on century-old homes to specialty epoxy floors and cabinet refinishing, the painters serving this area have built reputations that hold up across hundreds of independent reviews.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Sekula's Precision Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating, along with 100% recommended on Facebook across over 50 Facebook recommendations. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.9%, and have been BBB accredited since 2017 with over 8 years in business serving the Rochester area. What stands out when reading through their reviews is the role their office staff plays - Kaitlyn is mentioned by name in multiple reviews for keeping customers updated on scheduling and responding promptly to questions. That kind of back-office support is rare, and it shows in how smoothly jobs run from estimate to final walkthrough. Sekula's also deploys larger crews for bigger exterior jobs, keeping projects on track even when working around seasonal weather. If you want a company with the structure to manage big jobs without losing accountability, Sekula's is a strong choice.

Their client base spans commercial and residential work - from daycare centers to 100-year-old homes - with named crew members like Uriah, Christian, and Alex showing up across reviews for different types of projects.

• Office staff, including Kaitlyn, are named in multiple reviews for proactive communication around scheduling updates and estimate follow-up
• The company fields larger crews for exterior projects, with reviewers describing teams of five or six working through multi-day jobs despite weather
• Commercial clients including family businesses and childcare facilities return with the same level of satisfaction as repeat residential homeowners
• Recognition as the Greater Rochester Chamber of Commerce Business Person of the Year reflects the company's standing in the local business community

"They were professional, careful, and paid great attention to detail in every room. The colors came out beautifully and completely refreshed the space." - Luanne Strasenburgh, Google Review

For homeowners who want the owner working alongside the crew from first contact to final walkthrough, R&R Painting & concrete coatings is worth a close look. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 200 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating - that level of consistency at that volume is uncommon. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.5%. Owner Mark Rivoli is described across reviews as present at nearly every stage of a job, from walking the property before work begins to returning the following day to address details that weren't quite right. What stands out is how often customers describe Mark catching and correcting small imperfections before they even had to ask. If you want a contractor who stays engaged throughout rather than handing off once the job starts, R&R fits that model well.

Mark's crew handles a wide range of services alongside standard painting - deck staining, concrete coatings, cabinet refinishing, and commercial projects. Customers describe him personally helping with color decisions and adjusting the schedule around weather to protect the quality of finished surfaces.

• Mark personally reschedules around weather conditions rather than risking quality by working through poor painting days
• The crew handles deck staining, concrete coatings, cabinet refinishing, and commercial jobs alongside standard interior and exterior painting
• A Sherwin-Williams store manager hand-picked Mark and his crew for her own parents' home, with specific praise for Tyler and Bethany - a strong endorsement from someone in the industry
• Customers who gathered several quotes before choosing R&R consistently describe the pricing as competitive and fair, with no surprises after the job began

"At R&R Painting it's not just about painting! The prep work (patching, filling holes, sanding, etc.) on 30 yr old walls and kitchen cabinets revived them - everything looks like a new install! All done over freshly installed hardwood floors. The care and clean up taken were appreciated." - Cindy Smalley, Google Review

When it comes to specialty finishing work, Painting Plus Professionals stands out from the field. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5%, with over 75 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating and a 4.8-star rating on Angi across over 35 Angi reviews. The company holds a BBB accreditation dating to 2016 and won the 2022 Best of Rochester Award in the painting category. Tyler, who leads cabinet refinishing, is the only contractor reviewers independently describe bringing finished sample doors to estimates - a practice that lets homeowners see and feel the product before committing. That level of pre-job transparency appears repeatedly and seems to be a deliberate part of how they operate. If you're weighing whether to refinish or replace your cabinets, Painting Plus is a sensible first call.

Their epoxy flooring service, led by Alex, has saved customers significant money by rehabilitating floors that other contractors said needed full replacement. Beyond specialty work, the company handles full interior and exterior painting for both residential and commercial clients.

• Tyler brings physical sample cabinet doors to estimates so homeowners can evaluate the finish before committing - multiple reviewers cite this as what set Painting Plus apart from competitors
• Alex's epoxy team has rehabilitated severely sloped and heavily pitted floors that other contractors considered beyond repair, with savings reaching into the thousands for some homeowners
• BBB accredited since 2016, named a 2022 Best of Rochester Award winner in the painting category
• The company serves both residential and commercial clients across interior painting, exterior painting, cabinet refinishing, epoxy flooring, and deck staining

"Our floor was heavily pitted, and we were previously told by others that it would need to be completely replaced - at a cost of over $9,000. Thankfully, we found Alex, and he offered an expert alternative." - Howard Brenner, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Rush, NY, Bates Brothers Painting has built a strong following in a short time. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 60 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, plus 100% recommended on Facebook and 5.0 stars on Angi. They earned a Chooz Score of 80.6%. Owner Max Bates conducts every estimate in person and, based on multiple reviews, has a detailed itemized quote ready before he leaves the property. Customers who gathered several bids before choosing Bates consistently note that Max's pricing landed in the middle range, but the estimate itself stood out for its level of detail. If consistent communication and transparency throughout the project are priorities, Bates Brothers is a good fit.

The crew has worked on some of the older housing stock in the Rochester area, including an 1800s home and carriage house with original wood siding, handling the prep demands that come with that kind of project. Daily check-ins from Max are a consistent pattern in the reviews - customers describe knowing exactly where things stand each evening.

• Max prepares detailed, itemized estimates on-site during the initial walkthrough, without waiting for a quote to arrive later by email
• Daily evening check-ins from Max are a consistent pattern in reviews, with customers describing reliable updates through the life of the project
• The crew has worked on 1800s-era homes with original wood siding, navigating the prep demands of older Rochester-area housing
• Customers who compared several quotes often say the estimate process itself - not just the final number - was what made their decision

"They completed our project, a large 1800s house and carriage house with wood siding. They prepped everything thoroughly and the result is absolutely beautiful. Great communication through every step, and excellent job site management." - Kara Spoor, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Angi, BBB

Communication is one of the most consistently praised aspects of working with painters in Rush, NY, and it shows up in reviews across all four contractors featured on Chooz Painters. Sekula's Precision Painting draws repeated mention for the role of their office team - Kaitlyn is named in multiple reviews for keeping customers updated on scheduling, handling color coordination, and responding quickly when questions come up. Several customers note that confidence in the company started with that first phone call, before they ever met anyone from the crew.

Owner-led communication defines the other three contractors. R&R Painting & concrete coatings owner Mark Rivoli texts customers when weather forces schedule changes, follows up after each workday, and makes himself available for questions throughout the project. Painting Plus Professionals maintains daily check-ins with customers through each phase of the project, with Mike and Tyler walking homeowners through what's coming next. And Bates Brothers Painting owner Max Bates is described in review after review as reaching out each evening with updates, with customers noting they never had to wonder where things stood. For homeowners in Rush, NY who have found other contractors hard to reach, all four of these companies show a noticeably different pattern.

"From the first conversation with Caitlyn in the office I was confident that this company was professional. We were given estimates quickly and put on the schedule in a timely manner." - Roberta DiMarco, Google Review"They were communicative and on time. We already plan on hiring them again to paint our new home." - Meghan Jacobsen, Google Review"We never had to worry about delays or issues because the team alerted us immediately. The workers were clean and polite. Everyone worked with an incredible amount of attention to detail." - Michelle LoVetro, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Prep work and cleanup are areas where painting contractors in Rush, NY consistently earn praise, with customers across all four companies noting that the job was well-prepared before any paint touched a surface. Sekula's Precision Painting customers describe crews covering furniture, moving items out of the way, and keeping tools neatly organized throughout multi-day projects. The company's care for how they treat a customer's home - not just the walls they're painting - comes up repeatedly across different project types.

R&R Painting & concrete coatings reviews highlight thorough exterior prep that includes power washing, scraping old paint, and addressing mildew and weathering before starting. Owner Mark Rivoli is described as completing all surface preparation himself alongside the crew, rather than leaving prep to less experienced workers. Painting Plus Professionals is notable for zero-mess interior work - multiple reviewers mention not finding a single drop of paint where it shouldn't be, including on freshly installed hardwood floors. Bates Brothers Painting handles thorough prep on older homes with wood siding, power washing and prepping surfaces before painting begins. For Rush, NY homeowners with aging housing stock, that kind of prep attention matters.

"The crew was very friendly and respectful of the items in our home. They covered items, moved furniture out of the way, and returned the furniture to its original location when the project was completed." - Makini Beck, Google Review"Mark and his team did everything from power washing the siding to scraping off old paint and removing the mildew, all before they opened the first can of paint." - Jim Ver Steeg, Google Review"Most amazing was their attention to detail in the prep work. There was not even a drop of paint on the appliances or the floor or anywhere where it shouldn't be." - James Maxwell, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

On-time performance is a consistent strength across the painting contractors serving Rush, NY, with customers noting that crews arrived when promised and wrapped up within the timelines discussed upfront. Sekula's Precision Painting stands out for managing larger exterior projects through weather delays without letting schedules slip significantly - the office actively communicates any changes as they happen rather than leaving customers to wonder. One reviewer described a large two-family exterior job in difficult May weather that still came in well within expectations.

R&R Painting & concrete coatings customers note that the crew shows up when scheduled and, in some cases, wraps up ahead of the original timeline. Painting Plus Professionals drew specific praise from a homeowner who needed a tight deadline met - the crew completed their exterior project in time for a wedding rehearsal at the same property the following day. Bates Brothers Painting customers describe consistently punctual crew arrivals and projects that finish within the timeframes Max outlines during the estimate. Across all four contractors, customers in Rush, NY are kept informed of any schedule adjustments rather than left waiting for crews that don't show.

"Despite having to fight the rainy weather in May 2025, Sekulas did an excellent job in painting a large two-family dwelling. The task involved a large crew who were diligent and conscientious. Very satisfied with the result." - Jessica Bryant Dean, Google Review"They finished the project even earlier than planned." - Kaily LaForce, Google Review"We had our wedding rehearsal at our house the next day after they were done!" - Courtney Bishop, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Pricing feedback across the four painting contractors serving Rush, NY on Chooz Painters points to a consistent theme: customers who did their homework before hiring generally feel they received solid value. Sekula's Precision Painting customers who mention price consistently describe the final product as worth what they paid, with the quality of prep and finishing justifying the cost. R&R Painting & concrete coatings receives specific praise from customers who gathered multiple quotes before deciding - some reviewers note that R&R came in as the most competitive among seven or more estimates, while still delivering professional results.

Painting Plus Professionals is frequently described as a cost-effective alternative to full replacement - particularly for cabinet refinishing and epoxy flooring, where the savings compared to new installation can be significant. Bates Brothers Painting customers who shopped around before hiring consistently describe Max's pricing as landing in the middle range - neither the cheapest nor the most expensive quote they received - but the detail of the estimate itself as what made the difference. For Rush, NY homeowners trying to make sense of pricing across contractors, the level of detail in the initial estimate is a useful signal of how the job will go.

"The project was done in a timely manner and the finished product turned out great at a very reasonable price." - Victor Ianni, Google Review"...they were by far the most reasonable quote and we gathered 7 quotes before deciding." - Juliana Baratta, Google Review"The owner not only offers budget-friendly pricing but also delivers professional, detailed work. He listens to clients' needs and provides expert suggestions." - Yi-Jen Huang, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google