6 Best Painters Near Mendon, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Mendon, NY have access to a strong field of painting contractors throughout the greater Rochester area. The reviews consistently highlight careful prep work, named crews who show up reliably, and owners who stay personally involved. Based on Chooz Score analysis, here are the top-rated painters currently serving the Mendon, NY area.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Sekula's Precision Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating and 100% recommended on Facebook across over 50 Facebook recommendations, earning a Chooz Score of 87.9%. The same crew names - Ray, Jake, Patrick, Nick, and Alexander - appear independently across years of reviews from different customers, indicating a stable in-house team. The company holds an accreditation with the Better Business Bureau since 2017, earned Greater Rochester Chamber of Commerce Business Person of the Year recognition, and has over 8 years in business. If you value a company with proven in-house crews and strong repeat-customer loyalty, Sekula's is a strong fit.

• Named crew members appear across reviews spanning multiple years, with customers requesting the same painters on return visits
• Office staff are mentioned by name in reviews for smooth scheduling and clear communication from estimate through completion

"We enjoyed working with the Sekula's Team from start to completion. The organization, planning, follow through, and professionalism of the staff were exceptional." - PIETER LEROUX, Google Review

Also serving Mendon, NY, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings earned a Chooz Score of 87.5% with over 200 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating. Owner Mark Rivoli handles estimates, works alongside his crew, and follows up after each project. The company handles interior and exterior painting, deck staining, concrete coatings, and commercial work. Prep work is the defining theme in reviews - one customer moved to Mark specifically because the quality of surface preparation made an immediate difference. If you want an owner-operated company with a broad service range and a large review base, R&R is a good fit.

• A Sherwin Williams store manager hand-picked Mark for her parents' exterior over competitors she had access to, citing trust in his prep approach
• The crew completed a historic-district job requiring cedar shake replacement before painting all three stories of the home

"We originally hired a 'painter' who turned out to be a 'guy who can paint'... There is a BIG DIFFERENCE. Painting is mostly about the prep work. And Mark and his team did a fantastic job." - Nicholas Benedetto, Google Review

For homeowners with older or historic properties, Monarch Painting has earned a clear specialty in Mendon, NY. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% with over 95 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating. Owner Eric Andersen has run the business for over 5 years, recognized as a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite in 2021 and 2023. Monarch is fully insured and lead-safe certified for pre-1978 homes, and registered with the New York Department of State since 2020. If you have an older home with surfaces that need thorough attention before paint goes on, Monarch is well suited for that kind of project.

• Lead-safe certified for pre-1978 homes - a relevant credential for older Rochester-area housing stock
• One homeowner had textured ceilings removed while out of town for the winter, with Eric sending photos and updates throughout the project

"Eric and his crew are outstanding! Brent, Brian, Ben, Jimmy and the rest of the team are tremendous to work with. Professional, friendly, and meticulous to the smallest detail." - Roger Smith, Google Review

When it comes to kitchen cabinet refinishing and specialty floor coatings, Painting Plus Professionals stands out in the Mendon, NY market. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 75 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, 4.8 stars on Angi across over 35 Angi reviews, and Better Business Bureau accreditation since 2016, earning a Chooz Score of 86.5% and the 2022 Best of Rochester Award. Tyler's practice of bringing physical sample cabinet doors to every estimate is called out independently by multiple customers. If you're focused on a cabinet refresh or an epoxy garage floor coating, Painting Plus Professionals is a focused fit.

• Tyler brings physical sample cabinet doors to estimates so homeowners can see and feel the finished product before committing
• Alex helped a homeowner avoid a projected $9,000 floor replacement through a targeted epoxy coating solution

"Tyler brought over sample cabinet doors when he came to do our estimate and was the only company to do so. Seeing a finished product and being able to feel the quality before committing was really impressive." - Emily Audet, Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for A & L Painting. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 80 Google reviews with a 4.8-star rating, 100% recommended on Facebook across over 85 Facebook recommendations, and 5.0 stars on Angi, earning a Chooz Score of 84.3%. The company has been accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2017 and has over 10 years in business. Owner Matt Coniglio handles estimates personally and stays on-site throughout projects. Their clearest specialty is kitchen cabinet painting - multiple customers describe a full cabinet job completed in a single day, with several returning for second and third projects. If you want an experienced cabinet painting team with a long track record in the Rochester market, A & L is a proven choice.

• Matt and a crew of five typically complete a full kitchen cabinet paint job in a single day
• During winter months, the crew sets up in customers' heated garages to sand cabinet doors, keeping quality consistent regardless of weather

"Matt and his team were excellent. We had them paint the entire interior of our house. Matt went over the entire scope of work. There were no messes or cleanup needed after the job was completed." - Otto Soechtig, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Mendon, NY, Bates Brothers Painting is a newer company that has built a strong early reputation. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 60 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, 100% recommended on Facebook, and 5.0 stars on Angi, earning a Chooz Score of 80.6% with nearly 3 years in business. Owner Max Bates personally handles every estimate, delivers a detailed written itemized proposal on the spot, and maintains daily communication throughout each project. If you prefer a newer company with owner-led communication and a clear scope of work from day one, Bates Brothers is worth contacting. Note: one reviewer described continued follow-up after declining an estimate, so it's worth setting your timing preferences with Max upfront if collecting multiple quotes.

• Max delivers a written itemized estimate during the initial visit - independently mentioned by multiple reviewers as distinguishing him from other contractors
• Daily communication is mentioned across a large share of reviews, with customers describing consistent text and call updates throughout

"Max and his crew were fantastic. Max communicated daily, stopped over frequently and his crew was more than professional. Our house has never looked better." - Marie Hildreth, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Angi, BBB

Across the painting contractors serving Mendon, NY, quality shows up in reviews through specific observations. With R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings, reviewers credit thorough surface preparation as the defining factor - one customer moved away from a previous painter to Mark Rivoli specifically because the prep made an immediate difference in the finished result. At Monarch Painting, reviewers with historic homes in the Highland Park and Park Avenue areas describe results on plaster walls and century-old woodwork that prior painters hadn't achieved. Sekula's Precision Painting customers frequently describe results exceeding their expectations, including a cedar home exterior with a drastic color change that came out exactly as the homeowner envisioned.

For specialized finishes, Painting Plus Professionals draws consistent praise for cabinet results described as factory-applied in appearance. At A & L Painting, reviewers note the crew identified and addressed wall imperfections before painting rather than working over them. Bates Brothers Painting customers on exterior projects describe thorough preparation on weathered wood siding and cedar, noting the prep was more extensive than anticipated.

"Many thanks to Mark Rivoli and his great crew at R&R Painting & Stain for their terrific work. The painting, especially the trim work, was done with the highest level of craftsmanship and care." - William McLane, Google Review"Their attention to detail and thoroughness set a high standard. The walls are prepped perfectly before painting begins." - Kathryn Fiske, Google Review (Monarch Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Angi, BBB

Owner-led communication is a common thread across the top-rated painters serving Mendon, NY. At Bates Brothers Painting, owner Max Bates's daily check-in habit is mentioned across the majority of reviews - multiple customers describe receiving updates each day the crew was on site, with Max personally stopping by to review progress. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings owner Mark Rivoli follows a similar pattern, reaching out proactively when anything came up rather than waiting to be asked. At Sekula's Precision Painting, communication spans the full project from office scheduling through on-site crew updates, with reviewers noting consistent professionalism across every touchpoint.

For customers who travel or have full schedules during projects, proactive outreach matters. One Monarch Painting customer had an entire ceiling-removal project completed while out of town for the winter, with Eric sending photos and updates throughout. A & L Painting customers describe Matt answering calls directly and responding to texts quickly during projects. Painting Plus Professionals reviewers note the crew checked in at the start of each work day to confirm the plan before beginning.

"This company runs as a business should - prompt response time, great communication from start to finish. Team arrives on time, does professional work and neatly stores their tools each day." - Suzanne Calia, Google Review (Sekula's Precision Painting)"From the quick response to my estimate request to the final walk through, the experience with Bates Brothers has been fantastic! Max and his team were thorough with communicating throughout the entire project." - Sandy Skillman, Google Review (Bates Brothers Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Angi, BBB

Prep work quality is a recurring topic across the painting contractors serving Mendon, NY. Monarch Painting reviewers are especially detailed: customers describe plaster patching, drywall repair, and careful sanding all completed before any paint goes on, with one customer noting that a vacuum-equipped sander left virtually no dust in the house during a large project. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings customers describe Mark starting exterior jobs with power washing, scraping, and mildew treatment before opening the first paint can - something several reviewers describe as different from prior painters they'd hired. For cabinet work, A & L Painting sets up in customers' heated garages to sand cabinet doors in controlled conditions, and multiple reviewers describe finding zero drips or mess after the crew finished.

Painting Plus Professionals reviewers consistently note the crew covered every surface before work began and left no paint marks outside the designated area - a detail multiple customers brought up as a contrast to past painters. At Sekula's Precision Painting, reviewers on longer projects describe crews keeping equipment neatly stored each day and leaving spaces cleaner than expected. Bates Brothers Painting customers on exterior jobs note careful surface preparation on older wood siding before staining or painting began.

"At R&R Painting it's not just about painting! The prep work - patching, filling holes, sanding - on 30-year-old walls and kitchen cabinets revived them. Everything looks like a new install!" - Cindy Smalley, Google Review (R&R Painting)"They made sure to cover every square inch of floor, counter, cabinets, etc. and we have not found a stray splatter anywhere." - Nicole Nezelek, Google Review (Monarch Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Angi, BBB

Staying on schedule is a recurring theme in positive reviews across the painting contractors serving Mendon, NY. Sekula's Precision Painting reviewers frequently note crews arriving on time each morning, with the office proactively communicating weather-related adjustments for exterior work during Rochester's unpredictable seasons. At A & L Painting, speed is a consistent theme: the crew regularly completes kitchen cabinet jobs in a single day and full interior projects in two days, a turnaround multiple reviewers describe as faster than expected without sacrificing quality. Bates Brothers Painting customers describe projects completed on time and within budget, with Max providing daily timeline updates and one reviewer noting the crew finished an exterior job just ahead of a summer party deadline.

Painting Plus Professionals reviewers on exterior jobs describe a company that set a two-week goal and finished early. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings customers note that Mark's ability to start and finish on the committed date was a key factor in their experience. At Monarch Painting, reviewers describe crews arriving on time each day and cleaning up at the end of every work session without being asked.

"We had one of the first house paints of the season and had a goal time of two weeks and they crushed it. We had our wedding rehearsal at our house the next day after they were done!" - Courtney Bishop, Google Review (Painting Plus Professionals)"The Bates Brothers Painting team was punctual, professional, and detail oriented from start to finish. Communication was smooth throughout, and the project was completed on time and within budget." - Scott Wallman, Google Review (Bates Brothers Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Angi, BBB

Value and pricing come up regularly in reviews for painting contractors in Mendon, NY, with customers consistently describing competitive pricing alongside results that justify the cost. At R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings, multiple reviewers note that R&R came in with the best pricing of several estimates while delivering high-quality results. A & L Painting reviewers describe pricing as very reasonable, particularly for kitchen cabinet work that compares favorably to full cabinet replacement costs. One reviewer described two competitors who said her 1960s cabinets couldn't be saved - A & L completed the job at a fraction of replacement cost with results that exceeded her expectations.

Sekula's Precision Painting reviewers describe pricing as fair and competitive on both interior and exterior projects. Bates Brothers Painting customers describe pricing as neither the highest nor the lowest of estimates received, with several noting the detailed written estimate helped them understand exactly what they were paying for. Painting Plus Professionals epoxy floor reviews highlight savings compared to full floor replacement, a value point multiple customers describe independently. Monarch Painting reviews frequently pair praise for quality workmanship with notes that the company is very reasonably priced.

"Much more affordable than replacing the cabinets - I would highly recommend this company for any painting projects." - Jennifer Buscemi, Google Review (Painting Plus Professionals)"They beat everyone else's pricing and the attention to detail is second to none. Fully would recommend them to anyone and everyone." - Dustin Marcello, Google Review (R&R Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Angi, BBB