6 Best Painters Near North Chili, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Finding a reliable painting contractor in North Chili, NY takes some research, but the good news is there are several well-reviewed companies actively serving the area. The contractors below have built strong reputations through consistent work on everything from century-old Rochester-area homes with original plaster walls and wood siding to commercial projects and specialty staining jobs. Here are the top-rated painters in North Chili, NY based on their Chooz Scores.

R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings leads the list with a Chooz Score of 87.5%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 200 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, which is a rare achievement at that volume. Owner Mark Rivoli takes on a wide range of projects - residential interiors, deck and porch staining, railings, staircases, and commercial work for businesses and medical offices. Several reviewers came to R&R after a previous painter left them with a botched job, and the contrast they describe is striking. If you have a tricky project or need someone who can handle both commercial and residential work, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings is worth a call.

• Mark works alongside his crew and is cited by name across nearly every review, with customers noting he walks through the project at the start and end of each day to verify results.
• Named crew members - Tyler, Donny, Rob, Bethany, and Tom - appear consistently across reviews, indicating regular in-house staff rather than rotating subcontractors.
• Concrete coatings are a specialty alongside painting, making them a versatile choice for homeowners who want a single contractor for multiple surface types.
• Multiple reviewers describe Mark stepping in to fix problems left by a previous painter, from a deck that peeled right away to surfaces that weren't properly prepped the first time.

"Mark and crew are stand up guys - they do what they say and follow through. It was a pleasure to work with them. Honest, thorough and they go the extra mile to make sure you are completely satisfied with the job!" - Elaine Dancy, Google Review

Also serving the North Chili, NY area, Monarch Painting earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% with over 95 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating. Owner Eric and his crew have a strong track record on older homes - 90-year-old Dutch colonials, century-old Craftsman homes in the Park Avenue neighborhood, and properties with water-damaged plaster walls all appear regularly in their review history. They are lead-safe certified for pre-1978 homes, a meaningful credential in a market like Rochester where older housing stock is widespread. Repeat customers and word-of-mouth referrals show up frequently in their reviews. If you have an older home that needs careful surface prep and repair before painting, Monarch Painting stands out.

• Lead-safe certified for pre-1978 homes and fully insured, with the company registered as an active Domestic Business Corporation in New York since October 2020.
• Named crew members including Rachel, Bob, Angelica, Charlie, Sean, Shanique, and Jimmy appear across multiple reviews, showing a consistent team over time.
• The company handles carpentry and structural repairs alongside painting - replacing worn cedar shakes and repairing wood trim on aging exteriors - as part of larger projects.
• Recognized as a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite in 2021 and 2023.

"Eric and his team were incredible to work with. Always responsive, professional, and he went above and beyond to touch up the porch a week after they had finished. I would recommend Monarch to anyone looking for indoor or outdoor painting." - Elliott Altland, Google Review

When it comes to staining and specialty exterior work, Golden Boys Painting & Staining has earned a Chooz Score of 86.0%. With over 13 years in business, owner Dan has assembled a crew whose names - Aaron, Tadd, Luis, Nicholas, and Nolan - appear across years of reviews for consistent results. One pattern that stands out is Dan's honest approach to estimates: for a log cabin homeowner, he recommended targeted touch-ups and repairs rather than a full re-stain when another company had quoted a full job at twice the price. If you're looking for a straight assessment and long-term thinking on a staining or exterior project, Golden Boys Painting & Staining is a solid pick.

• Crew chief Aaron Palmer brings over 20 years of experience, and the team consists of master painters and apprentices, according to the company.
• Returning customers are a recurring pattern - multiple reviewers mention having Golden Boys back for a second or third project on the same property.
• Projects range from kitchen cabinet refinishing and interior condo painting to full exterior repaints, deck staining, pergola repair, and log cabin touch-ups.

"We couldn't be happier with the job done. The painters were friendly, courteous and a joy to work with. They were careful and neat. We would refer them to anyone. Thanks Tadd, Aaron and Luis!" - Fran Valone, Google Review

For homeowners with historic or complex properties, Level Up Painting earned a Chooz Score of 84.5%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 275 Google reviews with a 4.8-star rating and were 84% recommended on Facebook. Co-owners Jacob Rabideau and Clyde Miller have built the company around in-house crews over 8 years in business. A quality that comes up on both Yelp and Google is their brush-only approach to exterior painting - no spraying - which multiple reviewers credit for producing better results on the older homes common in the Rochester area. If you have a historic or challenging property and want a crew comfortable with complex surfaces, Level Up Painting is worth contacting.

• EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certified for pre-1978 homes, with $1,000,000 in liability insurance and full workers compensation coverage.
• Crew members Anthony, Jon, Rebecca, Calvin, and Clyde appear consistently across years of reviews, reflecting stable in-house staffing.
• One reviewer described using Level Up for the sixth time, and several others returned for additional projects on the same property months or years later.
• Their brush-only exterior painting technique is specifically praised for producing cleaner lines and better coverage on older home exteriors.

"This is the sixth time we have used this company and we have always been extremely impressed with their work and courteous manner. Anthony is a pleasure to work with and we will always use this company." - Mary Ross, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in North Chili, NY, Bates Brothers Painting earned a Chooz Score of 80.6% with over 60 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating. At the time of our analysis, they were also 100% recommended on Facebook and held 5.0 stars on Angi. Owner Max Bates provides detailed, itemized estimates on the spot during the initial visit - multiple reviewers describe this transparency as standing out from competitors who took days to respond or never sent a quote at all. The company has completed large historic projects including an 1800s house and carriage house with wood siding. If you want a clear, upfront estimate and strong communication from start to finish, Bates Brothers Painting is a good choice.

• Max's color consultation is noted across multiple reviews - homeowners describe him helping match paint colors from inspiration photos and making suggestions that improved the final result.
• The crew cleans up at the end of every workday and Max makes multiple in-person check-ins throughout the project, not just at the start and end.
• Despite being newer to the market (nearly 3 years in business), the company has built a strong review presence quickly across Google, Facebook, and Angi.

"Max and his crew did a great job painting my house. The estimate is very detailed. You know exactly what to expect. I really liked that they were always on time and cleaned up every day when they were done. Max was in contact with me daily with updates. Great job!!" - Ed Glasgow, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Angi, Yelp, Nextdoor

Quality and craftsmanship come up repeatedly across reviews for painting contractors in the North Chili, NY area. Reviewers don't just give a generic thumbs up - they describe specific results: edges cut in cleanly, plaster walls smoothed before any color goes on, and surfaces repaired or primed before the first coat is applied. Monarch Painting earns repeated praise for prep work on older homes, with one reviewer noting their powder room had been painted sloppily years ago and now looks completely different. Level Up Painting is frequently praised for brush-only exterior application that produces tighter lines on complex wood surfaces. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings regularly earns mentions for the finished quality of railings, staircases, and both interior and exterior surfaces - including commercial spaces like orthodontic offices and auto businesses.

The clearest signal of lasting quality is repeat business, and it shows up across multiple companies here. Golden Boys Painting & Staining has multiple reviews from customers who came back for a second or third project. "They just finished their second interior painting job for us and we can't say enough about the skills, professionalism and attention to all details. We're very happy with both projects." - Peter Zuris, Google Review. Bates Brothers Painting customers describe neighbors stopping to ask who did the work after seeing the before and after. "Highly highly recommend this painting company. Old fashioned painters that use brushes, no spraying. Exceptional eye to detail with a pride in their work that is hard to come by these days." - Rebecca S., Yelp Review. Whether you're refreshing a newer interior or tackling a century-old exterior in the North Chili, NY area, all five companies on Chooz Painters come with strong track records for finished results.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Communication is one of the most consistently praised qualities across reviews for painting contractors serving North Chili, NY. Homeowners describe contractors who respond quickly to texts, provide detailed written estimates during the first visit, check in daily during multi-day projects, and follow up after the job is done. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings owner Mark Rivoli is described as responsive throughout the process, with customers noting he addresses concerns and corrects any imperfections promptly. Monarch Painting owner Eric earns consistent praise for staying reachable and going back to finish small details - including a porch touch-up completed a week after the main job was done. "Eric and his coworkers were great to work with. They were prompt, courteous and knowledgeable and the paintjob was superb. I would recommend them with my highest enthusiasm." - Arnold Tank, Google Review.

Level Up Painting has a structured communication approach that reviewers appreciate - phone messages updating customers on scheduling in the days before the job starts, a call on the morning the crew arrives, and crew leads who keep homeowners informed if anything changes. Golden Boys Painting & Staining customers frequently cite owner Dan's communication as a reason they'd hire again, noting he keeps them updated on scheduling, progress, and any issues that come up. Bates Brothers Painting owner Max provides itemized written estimates on the spot and follows up daily with homeowners during the project. "From the quick response to my request for an estimate to the final walk through, the experience with Bates Brothers has been fantastic! Max and his team were professional, personable, and thorough with communicating with us throughout the project." - Scott Skillman, Google Review. For homeowners in North Chili, NY who've dealt with contractors who disappear after signing a contract, these companies show a different pattern.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Prep work and daily cleanup are areas where painting contractors in the North Chili, NY area consistently earn high marks. Reviewers describe thorough processes before a brush is picked up: scraping old paint, vacuuming scrapings, caulking gaps, nailing loose siding, removing gutter downspouts, and covering furniture and floors before any painting begins. Level Up Painting is particularly noted for its prep-heavy approach on exterior projects, with reviewers mentioning crews who removed gutter downspouts and primed surfaces carefully before applying paint. Their brush-only exterior technique - rather than spraying - also reduces overspray and cleanup issues that can come with spray applications. Monarch Painting customers note that floors, counters, and cabinets are fully protected during interior work, with one reviewer reporting they found no stray spots of paint anywhere after the crew finished. "They made sure to cover every square inch of floor, counter, cabinets, etc. and we have not found a stray spot of paint anywhere." - Nicole Nezelek, Google Review.

Golden Boys Painting & Staining earns repeated mention for applying multiple coats and working cleanly throughout the job, with crews cleaning up at the end of each workday on exterior projects. "They paid attention to the details, put on multiple coats, and worked cleanly. I'd hire them again in a heartbeat." - Eric Potter, Google Review. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings owner Mark is noted for smoothing out new drywall issues before painting, going beyond the scope of a standard paint job when the surface needs it. Bates Brothers Painting customers describe the crew as respectful of the home throughout - protecting surfaces, leaving the space clean at the end of each day, and notifying homeowners immediately if any issues arise. For homeowners in North Chili, NY who've dealt with messy crews in the past, the prep and cleanup standards across these companies are a clear strength.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Timeliness and reliability come up consistently in reviews for painting contractors serving North Chili, NY. Homeowners describe crews that show up when they said they would, communicate ahead of time about scheduling, and finish projects on or ahead of the originally discussed timeline. Level Up Painting uses a structured scheduling communication approach - notifications in the days before the job, a call the morning work begins - that reviewers appreciate for eliminating uncertainty. One reviewer with a large Queen Anne house noted the crew met or exceeded every scheduling benchmark on a complex multi-day job. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings is frequently praised for starting on schedule, with one customer noting this mattered because the job needed to be done before a move-in date. "These guys were great! Got the job done on time, communication was amazing. I've already recommended them to a couple people." - Andy Ryck, Google Review for Golden Boys Painting & Staining.

Bates Brothers Painting customers repeatedly note that Max and his crew arrived on time and kept to their word throughout the project, including handling rain delays on exterior work without dropping the ball on scheduling. One reviewer noted the project was completed on time and within budget despite weather complications. Monarch Painting reviews describe crews that arrived when scheduled, with minimal disruption to the household during multi-day interior projects. "The Bates Brothers Painting team was punctual, professional, and detail oriented from start to finish. Communication was smooth throughout the process and completed the project on time and within budget." - Scott Wallman, Google Review. For homeowners in North Chili, NY looking for contractors who actually show up when they say they will, the companies listed on Chooz Painters have strong records.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Value and pricing come up across reviews for contractors serving North Chili, NY, and the general theme is that the companies earning the strongest reviews are competitive without being the cheapest option available. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings draws specific mentions of pricing that beats competitors while maintaining quality. "Mark and his team are the best of the best. Honest, Trustworthy, Hardworking. They beat everyone else's pricing and the attention to detail is second to none. Fully would recommend them to anyone and everyone." - Dustin Marcello, Google Review. Golden Boys Painting & Staining earns repeated mentions of reasonable pricing paired with thorough workmanship - and their honest approach to estimates, like recommending touch-ups instead of a full re-stain when that's the right call, reflects well on their overall value proposition. "Great communication from Dan and his team the entire process, reasonable pricing, and great workmanship." - Eric Potter, Google Review.

Level Up Painting customers describe pricing as fair for the quality and experience delivered, with several noting they got multiple quotes before choosing Level Up and felt the investment was well justified by the results. Bates Brothers Painting positions its estimates as transparent and itemized, so homeowners know exactly what they're paying for before work begins. One reviewer noted the pricing was competitive - not the highest or lowest - and they chose the company based on the thoroughness of the estimate and attention to detail during the walkthrough. "The owner not only offers budget-friendly pricing but also delivers professional, detailed work. He listens to clients needs and provides expert suggestions." - Yi-Jen Huang, Google Review. Across the board in North Chili, NY, the strongest-reviewed contractors tend to land in the mid-range of quotes, which homeowners generally describe as money well spent.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google