3 Best Painters Near Canandaigua, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Canandaigua, NY have access to several highly rated painting contractors that serve the Finger Lakes region. Whether you need interior walls refreshed, kitchen cabinets updated, or a full exterior repaint, reviews across Google, Facebook, and other platforms show consistent praise for quality prep work, reliable scheduling, and hands-on owner involvement.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings had over 200 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 87.5%. Owner Mark Rivoli runs the crew himself, and multiple reviewers describe him coming back the next day to address even the smallest touch-up. R&R also handles deck staining, concrete coatings, and commercial projects. If you are particular about prep work and want an owner who personally inspects the finished product, R&R is a strong choice.

What stands out in the reviews is how many customers describe hiring R&R after a bad experience with another painter. Several homeowners note that Mark and his team restored their trust in the trade by showing up on time, working full days, and protecting furniture and flooring throughout the process.

• Customers with older homes praise the crew's ability to handle detailed trim and cedar shake siding on historic Rochester-area properties
• Multiple reviewers mention Mark helping with color selection and rescheduling around weather to ensure the best finish
• Commercial clients, including an auto shop and a property manager, describe R&R fitting in projects on short notice

"We originally hired a 'painter' who turned out to be a 'guy who can paint.' We moved on from him and hired Mark, who is a professional painter. There is a BIG DIFFERENCE." - Nicholas Benedetto, Google Review

For homeowners looking for cabinet refinishing or epoxy flooring alongside traditional painting, Painting Plus Professionals offers a specialized approach. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 75 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, and they hold BBB accreditation since 2016 with 4.8 stars on Angi across over 35 reviews. Owner Mike Mazzochetti leads the operation, while crew member Tyler has built a following among cabinet refinishing customers who describe his work as factory-grade. If you want cabinets that look like they came straight from a showroom, Painting Plus is a good fit.

Reviewers consistently highlight the prep process, with several noting that Tyler brings physical sample doors to estimates so homeowners can see and feel the finished product before committing. The crew also handles epoxy garage floors, with Alex earning praise for saving customers thousands over full floor replacement.

• Winner of the 2022 Best of Rochester Award in the Painting category
• Customers describe the crew fixing every wall imperfection before any paint is applied, with not a drop found where it should not be
• Epoxy floor projects include leveling severe slopes and filling pitting before coating

"Most amazing was their attention to detail in the prep work. There was not even a drop of paint on the appliances or the floor or anywhere where it shouldn't be." - James Maxwell, Google Review

A woman-owned operation with Monroe County MWBE certification, Colors of Rochester is led by owner Hope Worthington, who took over the company in late 2023 and maintained its strong reputation. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.1% with over 55 Google reviews at a 4.8-star rating and are 100% recommended on Facebook with over 20 recommendations. Hope personally handles estimates, works alongside her crew, and follows up after every project. If you value direct communication with the business owner and a smaller, hands-on team, Colors of Rochester is a great option.

What shows up repeatedly in the reviews is Hope's flexibility. One customer changed their color choice mid-project, called Hope in a panic from the paint store, and the team adjusted without missing a beat. The crew, including Julia, Grace, MaryBeth, and Makayla, gets praised by name across reviews for their care with older homes that have unique trim and radiator challenges.

• OSHA 10 Construction certified with additional crew credentials in Lead and Silica Awareness and Fall Protection
• Repeat customers describe booking second and third projects after seeing the initial results

"On day 2 of 3, I decided to change the color, I called them freaking out and they were so accommodating. Their flexibility and personable professionalism is excellent!" - Ann Marie Depoian, Google Review

With nearly 50 years in business, Whelehan Painting is a family operation founded by Chuck Whelehan in 1977 and now run by his son Pat alongside partner Jeff. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.0% with over 175 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating, 98% recommended on Facebook, and 5.0 stars on Yelp. With 16 in-house employees working as established teams, Whelehan brings serious manpower to every project. If you want a large exterior job completed in days rather than weeks, this is the crew to call.

The loyalty among Whelehan customers is striking. Multiple reviewers describe coming back for second, third, and even tenth projects over the years. One customer has been using them for over 17 years. Homeowners with historic properties praise the team's ability to prep surfaces with decades of wear and find the right primer and paint combinations for lasting results.

• Several customers note that Whelehan's estimate came in lower than competitors, while the finished product exceeded expectations
• The crew moves and covers all furniture during interior jobs and puts everything back when finished
• Pat and Jeff are described as accessible and responsive throughout every project

"They painted our 1880s house for the first time ever. We had no idea what to expect, and they did an incredible job that exceeded our expectations." - Thomas Falbo, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Canandaigua, NY, A & L Painting has built a loyal following around kitchen cabinet work. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.3% with over 80 Google reviews at a 4.8-star rating, 100% recommended on Facebook across over 85 Facebook recommendations, and hold an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau with a 5.0-star BBB rating. Owner Matt Coniglio works on-site alongside his crew and personally walks through the finished product before leaving. With over 10 years in business, A & L is a solid pick if you want kitchen cabinets painted in a single day by a coordinated team.

The speed of A & L's cabinet work comes up in nearly every review. Customers describe crews of three to five arriving in the morning, staging doors in the garage for sanding and painting, and having everything reinstalled with new hardware by evening. Several past customers report their cabinets still looking great a year or more later.

• Repeat customers frequently return for additional rooms, exterior work, and bathroom vanity projects after an initial cabinet job
• Matt responds to texts and calls directly and adjusts schedules to accommodate last-minute changes
• Reviewers with many contractors in and out of their homes single out A & L for actually keeping their scheduled date

"We invited them back to do a 2nd project after loving how our kitchen cabinets turned out! Matt and his crew were on time, professional, attentive and Matt truly prioritizes customer satisfaction." - Shelley Garrett Butts, Facebook Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB, Angi, Yelp

Quality and attention to detail are the most frequently mentioned themes across reviews for painting contractors serving Canandaigua, NY. Customers consistently describe results that make rooms, cabinets, and exteriors look brand new, with particular praise for thorough prep work before any paint is applied.

R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings earns repeated praise for the precision of their trim work and edge cutting. One reviewer noted the painting was "of exceptionally high quality, edges perfectly cut-in, leaving a pristine backdrop for hanging my pictures." - Kate Rubin, Google Review. Painting Plus Professionals receives similar feedback, with customers like Jim Bernitt describing Tyler as "very professional and neat" on a cabinet door replacement and painting project. Whelehan Painting customers frequently describe their results as lasting for years. Timothy Fabrizio notes that "their paint jobs last and last, and last!" Meanwhile, Colors of Rochester is praised for the precision of their edge work, with Kathleen T noting that "edges were precise" after Hope and Grace painted three rooms. A & L Painting customers describe cabinet finishes that still look great a full year later, with Nik Simmons confirming their cabinets "after years still look great."

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Value and fair pricing come up frequently in reviews for painters serving Canandaigua, NY. Customers across multiple companies describe getting competitive quotes and feeling the finished product justified the cost.

Whelehan Painting stands out on this topic. Brad T. notes in his Google review that Whelehan "came in as the low ball amongst the companies I took bids from; the product is so not that." Howie Less echoes this, describing the price as "fair and reasonable comparatively" while the job was completed in 2.5 days when other contractors estimated two weeks. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings customers like Dustin Marcello describe the company as beating competitors on price while delivering top-tier detail work. A & L Painting reviewers note that Matt provides clear, upfront quotes, and multiple customers describe the cabinet painting process as far more affordable than full cabinet replacement. Painting Plus Professionals offers a similar value angle on cabinets and epoxy floors, with one customer noting that Alex saved them thousands over a full garage floor replacement that had been quoted at over $9,000 elsewhere. Colors of Rochester is described by multiple reviewers as offering very reasonable rates with professional results.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Angi

Timeliness and efficient scheduling are common praise points across reviews for painting contractors serving Canandaigua, NY. Customers describe crews arriving when promised and completing work faster than expected.

Whelehan Painting frequently impresses customers with speed. Kathie Ryan describes having her "entire interior painted in just 3 days" with the crew moving furniture, prepping, and putting everything back. A & L Painting is known for single-day kitchen cabinet projects, with Bridget Roney noting Matt was "one of very few to keep the date, arrive right on time and finish early." R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings customers like Eric Ekstrom describe Mark starting on time and completing work before a deadline, in his case just days before a birthday party. Colors of Rochester is praised for punctuality, with Amy Toric noting her kitchen and bedroom were "all done in one day." Painting Plus Professionals customers describe organized multi-room projects that allow families to continue daily routines during the work, with Patty Bates calling the experience "a breeze."

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Prep work and cleanup are among the most praised aspects of painting contractors serving Canandaigua, NY. Reviewers frequently describe crews that leave homes cleaner than they found them and invest significant time in surface preparation before painting begins.

Painting Plus Professionals sets a high standard for prep, with customers describing orbital sanding, heavy-duty floor coverings, and wall repair that addresses every dent and hole before a brush touches the surface. John Costello notes that "the attention to detail is what sets Painting Plus apart." Whelehan Painting crews clean up materials every night before leaving and put all furniture back in place after interior jobs. J Warren describes the crew as "respectful, organized and efficient" with helpful suggestions that improved the outcome. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings reviewers like Corey Gefell describe furniture and delicate items being carefully covered and protected throughout the project. A & L Painting customers consistently note that crews leave no mess behind, with Jackie A. from BBB describing them as "polite, leaving absolutely no mess behind." Colors of Rochester earns praise for daily cleanup, with Sandra Simpson noting the crew was "very personable, professional and take pride in the work they do."

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB

Strong communication from the initial estimate through project completion is a consistent theme across reviews for painters serving Canandaigua, NY. Customers describe owners who answer calls personally, provide clear timelines, and check in throughout the work.

R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings owner Mark Rivoli is praised for prompt responses to both texts and phone calls. Anatole Kleiner describes Mark as "a good communicator" who "always responded promptly." Whelehan Painting owners Pat and Jeff are described by Jessica Marino as "responsive" with "great" communication, noting she has used them multiple times and trusts their advice. A & L Painting customers describe Matt answering questions from start to finish, with Kimberly Richards noting that "Matt is responsive and answered all of our questions." Painting Plus Professionals earns praise for daily check-ins during multi-day projects, with Greg Lewin describing how the team reviewed completed work and previewed next steps each morning. Colors of Rochester owner Hope Worthington is praised for clear arrival time communication and prompt follow-ups, with Kathleen T noting Hope was "excellent at communicating arrival times."

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB