6 Best Painters Near West Henrietta, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

The West Henrietta, NY area draws on a solid group of highly reviewed painting contractors serving Henrietta, Rochester, Brighton, and nearby communities - from cabinet refinishing specialists to crews experienced with century-old exteriors. Here's a look at the top performers based on Chooz Painter scores.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings had over 200 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 87.5%. Owner Mark Rivoli handles estimates personally, works alongside his crew, and stays involved through the final walkthrough. The same names - Tyler, Donny, Rob, Tom, Bethany, Jose, and Janice - appear across dozens of independent reviews, pointing to a stable in-house team. If you want consistent crews and responsive communication from estimate to completion, R&R is a good choice.

• Mark is mentioned by name in the vast majority of reviews and is described as addressing finish concerns the following day when something wasn't quite right - without waiting to be asked.
• Beyond interior and exterior painting, the company handles staircases, railings, deck staining, and commercial painting in Rochester.

"We have had a number of painters through the years. R&R really listened to us the customer, the paint job looks astounding, we are getting so many compliments!" - Alison B., Google Review

While R&R leads in review volume, Monarch Painting has built a strong reputation specifically for older and more demanding properties. With 5 years in business and a Chooz Score of 87.3%, Monarch earned a 5.0-star rating across over 95 Google reviews, with every review in the analysis period at five stars. The company is fully insured, lead-safe certified for pre-1978 homes, and has been named a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite in 2021 and 2023. If your home has plaster walls, water damage, or intricate exterior surfaces that need careful prep, Monarch is a strong option.

• Monarch has completed exterior painting on a 103-year-old Craftsman-Tudor, including stucco repair and full power washing before any coat went on.
• Owner Eric is noted for returning to touch up surfaces after full cure, and reviews span interior, exterior, deck staining, and carpentry work alongside painting.

"I am so pleased with the quality of the work, professionalism of the owner and staff, and their communication. My furniture and floors were well protected. They are beyond top notch! My walls look perfect!" - Cynthia Page, Google Review

For homeowners looking to update kitchen cabinets, Painting Plus Professionals is one of the more recognized names in the area for that work. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 75 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, a 4.8-star rating on Angi across over 35 reviews, and BBB accreditation since 2016. They also received the 2022 Best of Rochester Award in painting. If you're weighing cabinet refinishing against full replacement, Painting Plus Professionals is a good fit.

• Tyler brings physical sample cabinet doors to estimates so customers see the finished product before committing - an approach multiple reviewers describe as unique among the contractors they compared.
• The prep process consistently includes fixing every dent, scratch, and hole before any paint goes on, with reviewers describing walls that look completely new afterward.

"Tyler is professional, punctual, trustworthy and has a keen eye for detail. He works with state of the art equipment. If you're home during the day, you wouldn't even know he was there." - Barb Smith, Google Review

With over 8 years in business, Level Up Painting has built one of the larger review profiles in the Rochester area. At the time of our analysis, they had over 275 Google reviews with a 4.8-star rating and are 84% recommended on Facebook, earning a Chooz Score of 84.5%. Co-owners Jacob Rabideau and Clyde Miller run the company with in-house crews, EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification, and $1,000,000 in liability coverage. If you have a historic home and want brush-applied exterior painting rather than spraying, Level Up is worth a call.

• Level Up has painted Queen Anne houses, century-old homes, and cedar-shingled exteriors where spray methods would struggle with the surface complexity.
• Repeat customers appear consistently in the review history - one reviewer returned for a sixth project with the company, and the pattern shows up more than once.

"Highly highly recommend this painting company. Old fashioned painters that use brushes, no spraying. Exceptional eye to detail with a pride in their work that is hard to come by these days." - Rebecca S., Yelp Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving West Henrietta, NY, A & L Painting has been in business for over 10 years with a Chooz Score of 84.3%. They hold over 80 Google reviews with a 4.8-star rating, are 100% recommended on Facebook across over 85 Facebook recommendations, carry a 5.0-star rating on BBB, and have been BBB accredited since 2017. Owner Matt Coniglio works on-site with his crew and follows up after completion. If you want cabinet painting done quickly and cleanly by a team with a long track record, A & L is a strong choice.

• A & L frequently completes full kitchen cabinet painting, including new hardware, in a single day with a full crew on-site.
• Multiple reviewers describe returning for a second or third project after seeing how well the first results held up over time.

"Matt and his whole team were phenomenal. They were efficient, professional, and friendly. They were able to work around our last minute scheduling changes and were able to get all of our kitchen cabinets finished in just one day." - Rachel Pierce, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Strong communication is one of the most consistently praised qualities across reviews for painting contractors serving West Henrietta, NY. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings earns consistent praise for owner Mark Rivoli staying closely in touch from first estimate through final walkthrough - customers describe quick replies, proactive scheduling confirmations, and direct responses when questions come up mid-job. Level Up Painting handles communication at the team level: crew leads, project managers, and co-owners all stay in contact with homeowners, with reviewers describing phone updates even when traveling and not on-site during the project.

At Bates Brothers Painting, owner Max Bates checks in daily and follows up each evening on the next day's plan. A & L Painting's Matt Coniglio responds to texts directly and calls back promptly, adjusting schedules on short notice. Monarch Painting's owner Eric is noted for fast estimate responses and staying attentive throughout the job. Painting Plus Professionals gets credit for Tyler communicating his daily plan each morning and keeping homeowners informed at every stage from estimate through final walkthrough.

"His communication was quick. His workers were professional. And the work was great." - Adrianna D'Alonzo, Google Review"Max communicated daily, stopped over frequently and his crew was more than professional." - Marie Hildreth, Google Review"Communication was smooth from start to finish, and the entire crew was professional, courteous, and respectful of our space." - Steve Gluckman, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Reviewers for painters serving West Henrietta, NY frequently describe results that hold up well and look better than what previous contractors delivered. Painting Plus Professionals earns particular praise for cabinet refinishing - multiple reviewers describe Tyler's finished surfaces as looking like factory-new cabinetry, and customers returning later note the work still looks sharp. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings receives consistent marks for interior precision, with reviewers describing cut lines as flawless and ceilings as smooth to a degree they hadn't experienced from prior painters. Monarch Painting gets called out for tackling demanding surfaces - drywall repairs, plaster patches, and wallpaper residue - and delivering walls that show no trace of the original problem.

On the exterior side, Level Up Painting is praised for results on historic homes and complex surface types, adapting their approach to cedar shingles, Queen Anne woodwork, and weathered siding. A & L Painting's cabinet work draws repeat customers who come back two or three times after seeing how well the first project held up. Across these companies, reviewers note that the finished work holds up to close inspection rather than looking good only from a distance.

"The paint surface looks like it came from the factory." - Beth, Google Review (Painting Plus Professionals)"The painting was of exceptionally high quality - edges perfectly cut-in." - Kate Rubin, Google Review (R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings)"They have an exceptional eye for detail and take pride in their work. This is a quality hard to find in a business these days." - Rebecca Stainton, Google Review (Level Up Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Prep work is a recurring theme in reviews for painters serving West Henrietta, NY, with customers consistently noting how thoroughly these contractors prepare surfaces before any paint goes on. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings earns specific praise for handling new drywall carefully - smoothing surfaces and addressing issues left by prior tradespeople. Monarch Painting is described as thorough on interior prep in older homes, patching holes from wallpaper adhesive, correcting drywall irregularities, and sanding until surfaces are fully smooth.

Painting Plus Professionals draws attention for covering floors, appliances, and furniture completely on every project - multiple reviewers note not finding a single drop of paint where it shouldn't be. Level Up Painting's brush-based exterior approach is paired with detailed surface prep; customers describe crews working through damaged areas and protecting landscaping before any coating goes on. Bates Brothers Painting and A & L Painting both earn consistent praise for daily cleanup - crews tidy up each evening so materials don't accumulate across a multi-day job.

"Since the walls were new drywall, he took the time to make sure that all the walls were smooth and handled any issues that the drywall guy may have missed." - Toula Beane, Google Review (R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings)"I had old wallpaper glue, drywall issues and a ton of holes that needed patching. When they were done, the walls came out so smooth! You would have no idea how terrible rough they looked before." - Stephanie Leonardo, Google Review (Monarch Painting)"Most amazing was their attention to detail in the prep work. There was not even a drop of paint on the appliances." - James Maxwell, Google Review (Painting Plus Professionals)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Pricing across the top contractors serving West Henrietta, NY is generally described as competitive and fair, with several reviewers noting they collected multiple quotes and chose based on a combination of price and professionalism. Bates Brothers Painting's owner Max provides detailed written estimates on the spot during the initial visit - reviewers describe knowing exactly what to expect before work begins, with final invoices matching the quote. Level Up Painting is described as fairly priced relative to other local quotes, with homeowners noting the detail in the estimate helped it stand out from other bids.

Painting Plus Professionals draws specific attention as a lower-cost path for homeowners considering kitchen cabinet updates - multiple reviewers describe results that look like new cabinetry at a fraction of the replacement cost. A & L Painting is praised for completing cabinet painting efficiently, which helps keep costs reasonable even with a full crew on-site. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings and Monarch Painting appear in reviews where customers describe the price as fair given the quality delivered, including from people who had received other bids first.

"The owner not only offers budget-friendly pricing but also delivers professional, detailed work." - Yi-Jen Huang, Google Review (Bates Brothers Painting)"Much more affordable than replacing..." - Jennifer Buscemi, Google Review (Painting Plus Professionals)"After some research and getting several quotes (most of them were pretty much in the same ballpark of each other), I decided to go with Level Up." - Thanh Nguyen, Google Review (Level Up Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

On-time performance is a consistent strength for painting contractors serving West Henrietta, NY. A & L Painting's crew is frequently praised for completing work faster than expected - multiple reviewers describe full kitchen cabinet jobs wrapped up in a single day, with hardware installed and cleanup done before the crew left. Bates Brothers Painting earns consistent marks for punctual arrival and on-budget completion even when exterior work encountered weather delays.

Level Up Painting's crew is described as meeting or exceeding projected timelines on larger exterior jobs, including multi-day projects on historic homes. Monarch Painting's team paces interior work efficiently - larger rooms and challenging ceiling jobs finish without running past the expected end date. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings is praised for start-date reliability, with at least one reviewer noting Mark's ability to begin on schedule was critical for completing work before the weather changed.

"They arrived and started exactly when scheduled. They were done ahead of schedule." - Jackie A., BBB Review (A & L Painting)"Clean lines, no mess, and finished ahead of schedule total pro." - Joseph Martinucci, Google Review (Bates Brothers Painting)"They met or exceeded all scheduling for the job." - Jim Fraser, Google Review (Level Up Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, BBB