Best Painters Near Tyler, TX Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Tyler, TX have access to several highly rated painting contractors, each bringing different strengths to interior and exterior projects. Whether you need a whole-house repaint, cabinet refinishing, or deck staining, these companies have earned strong reputations through consistent quality and responsive service.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Lomax Custom Painting had over 115 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.9%. Owner Chase Lomax runs a faith-based operation out of Palestine that serves the greater Tyler, TX area. Reviewers frequently mention how comfortable they feel leaving the crew unsupervised, with several noting they ran errands while painters worked in their homes. If you value a company where the owner personally handles estimates and follows through on every commitment, Lomax Custom Painting is a solid choice.

Chase and his team handle everything from interior repaints to exterior staining, and multiple customers have praised how quickly they respond to inquiries. The crew includes regulars like Angel and Taylor who show up across different reviews, suggesting stable employment and consistent quality control.

• Customers describe Chase as someone who does exactly what he says he will do, when he says he will do it
• Several reviewers mention the team's willingness to return promptly to address minor touch-ups
• The company holds BBB accreditation with an A- rating and zero complaints

"If you are looking for the best quality, reliable, friendly painting service, look no further than Chase and Angel at Lomax Custom Painting. I insist on hiring people who are dedicated to giving one the best service possible." - Bob Miller, Google Review

For homeowners who need quick turnaround without sacrificing results, Prestige Pro Painters has built a reputation for same-day and next-day project completion. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.2% with over 105 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. Owner Raul and foreman Carlos coordinate closely with customers throughout each project, and reviewers consistently mention how the crew cleans up daily before leaving.

With over 15 years in business serving both the Dallas-Fort Worth metroplex and East Texas, Prestige Pro Painters handles everything from popcorn ceiling removal to cabinet refinishing. They maintain 5.0 stars on Angi and are 100% recommended on Facebook. If you have a tight deadline or need painters who can work around your schedule, this company consistently delivers.

• Multiple reviewers mention getting quotes within 48 hours and work starting the same week
• The crew protects floors, removes fixtures, and leaves job sites spotless at the end of each day
• Commercial and residential projects both receive the same attention to detail

"From start to finish, the experience was absolutely amazing. The owner, Raul, and his entire crew were incredibly kind, respectful, and professional. They took the time to fix all the cracks throughout my home and completed everything in under 5 days." - Cameron Bates, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Tyler, TX, Reeves Painting has developed a loyal following of repeat customers who describe owner Josh Reeves as their "lifetime painter." They earned a Chooz Score of 85.1% with nearly 100 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. Based in Lindale with over 13 years in business, Reeves Painting holds an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau.

Josh and his crew specialize in cabinet refinishing, and several reviewers share before-and-after stories of dated kitchens getting completely refreshed. The company uses premium suppliers including Sherwin-Williams, Benjamin Moore, and Behr. If you want a painter you can build a long-term relationship with for multiple projects over the years, Reeves Painting fits that profile.

• Customers mention hiring Josh for second, third, and even fourth projects across different properties
• The team sends progress updates during multi-day jobs and protects all surfaces with drop cloths
• One reviewer noted Josh spotted a fuel leak in their barn during an exterior job and called immediately

"This is my 2nd job with Reeves. The finished job, crew and cost are ALL PERFECTION. Reeves is our lifetime painter." - Scott Fulkerson, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Communication ranks among the most praised qualities in reviews for painting contractors serving Tyler, TX. Customers frequently describe painters who answer questions promptly, explain their process clearly, and keep homeowners informed throughout each project. At Lomax Custom Painting, reviewers mention that Chase responds to inquiries quickly and shows up for estimates when promised. One customer noted they had been searching for months before finding a painter who actually followed through on initial contact.

Prestige Pro Painters receives similar feedback, with foreman Carlos earning specific praise for explaining each step and helping customers make informed decisions along the way. "Professional, proficient, and on time! Carlos the foreman explained every step, then let me make informed decisions." - Traci Rogers, Google Review. At Reeves Painting, owner Josh Reeves maintains direct communication with clients, and reviewers describe him as someone easy to trust with their homes. "Very professional, timely, great work, and I felt totally comfortable with them in my home when I was there and when I wasn't." - Laura Johnson, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Preparation and cleanup receive consistent attention in reviews for Tyler, TX painting companies. At Lomax Custom Painting, customers describe crews who keep job sites tidy throughout multi-day projects. One reviewer specifically mentioned that Chase and his team kept a clean site even while using a lift during exterior work. "This crew kept a clean job site and were very thorough in their preparation." - Tish Erdmann, Google Review. Reviewers also note that the team returns promptly to address any concerns after project completion.

Prestige Pro Painters earns praise for their systematic approach to protection, with customers noting how carefully the crew covers floors, removes fixtures, and masks areas that could be affected by overspray. "They were very careful with covering the floors. Lights and fans removed for complete coverage. Things that could not be removed were masked. No mess left behind." - Tony Lewis, Google Review. Reeves Painting follows similar practices, with reviewers describing thorough drop cloth coverage and daily cleanup. One customer mentioned finding "not one drip of paint anywhere" after their cabinet project was completed.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Quality and attention to detail appear throughout reviews for top-rated painting contractors in Tyler, TX. Customers describe finished work with smooth surfaces, clean edges, and no visible brush marks. At Lomax Custom Painting, reviewers mention that Chase handles challenging spaces where precision matters, including tight corners and detailed trim work. "He is very detailed. There were some tight spots for him to paint and his work was flawless." - Holly Lovell, Google Review. Multiple customers also praise the wood staining work by crew members Taylor and Dakota.

Reeves Painting receives particularly enthusiastic feedback for cabinet refinishing projects. Customers share before-and-after experiences where dated yellow cabinets became bright white kitchens. "They knew exactly what to do with some odd interior painting and made it look completely new." - Abigayle Haynes, Google Review. At Prestige Pro Painters, reviewers describe work that still looks excellent years after completion, with one customer noting their home "still looks immaculate" after using the company several years ago. The combination of proper preparation and premium materials contributes to results that hold up over time.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Customers across Tyler, TX painting companies consistently describe pricing as fair and competitive. At Lomax Custom Painting, reviewers mention receiving clear bids that match final invoices, with one customer specifically praising the company for offering a "fair bid" and delivering exactly as promised. "Mr. Lomax gave us a fair bid, showed up when he said he was going to and did a great job painting our house." - John Richbourg, Google Review. The combination of reasonable rates and reliable follow-through appears frequently in feedback.

Prestige Pro Painters earns praise for providing detailed estimates that cover all aspects of each project, allowing customers to understand exactly what they're paying for before work begins. "Raul helped us determine the work that needed to be done, provided a contract listing all of the work and made sure that all work was done to our satisfaction." - Benjamin King, Google Review. Reeves Painting customers describe getting quality results without breaking their budget, with several noting that the value exceeded their expectations. Multiple reviewers across all three companies mention they would hire the same painters again, suggesting the pricing aligns with the quality of work delivered.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google