4 Best Painters in Santa Teresa, NM - Chooz Score Ranked

Why Customers Choose New Mexico's Painting Specialists

Hundreds of Happy Customers

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, New Mexico's Painting Specialists had over 65 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, along with 5.0 stars on Yelp and 100% recommended on Facebook. This company earned a Chooz Score of 89.5%. A flawless rating across every major platform is exceptionally rare in the painting industry:

• A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau, accredited since October 2022
• Won Albuquerque The Magazine's "Best of the City" recognition three consecutive years: 2022, 2023, and 2024

"I can't recommend New Mexico Painting Specialists highly enough! They painted my entire home in just ONE day, and the results were nothing short of incredible. My expectations were already sky-high, and somehow, they still managed to exceed them." - Andra K., Google Review

Their Team, Not Random Subs

The company explicitly states on their website that they hire only full-time professionals with no subcontractors. The Chooz Score's in-house crews component confirms this: the same crew names appear across reviews spanning two years. Customers praise Chris, Riley, Nick, Mekhi, Alex, Christian, and Elijah by name repeatedly:

• Multiple customers describe requesting the same painters for return projects, noting their consistency and attention to detail
• Three generations of family painting expertise, with master craftsman Gilbert Gaxiola contributing over 60 years of experience to select projects

"Christian, Mekhi, Riley, and Oscar are an outstanding team! I can't say enough about the attention to detail and how friendly they were. Eddie and Mandy the owners made this experience a pleasure." - Megan S., Google Review

A Familiar Face in the Community

What sets them apart is the family atmosphere combined with serious community recognition. Owners Eddie Gaxiola and Mandi Loudenback remain personally involved in projects, and customers consistently mention feeling like more than just another job:

• Eddie and Mandi personally handle estimates, color consultations, and follow-up, building relationships that lead to repeat business
• Reviews mention using the company multiple times for different projects, from cabinet refinishing to full exterior transformations

"Eddie and Mandi are an absolute joy to work with. Hiring any sort of contractor is hard and very nerve racking. Eddie and Mandi made it so easy from start to finish." - Jessie H., Google Review

Why Customers Choose Knight's Painting

Hands-On Leadership

Owner Gary Knight stays personally involved in every project from estimate to final walkthrough. The Chooz Score's owner engagement indicators are strong: Gary is mentioned by name in the majority of reviews and responds to customer feedback with personalized messages that reference specific project details, customer names, and even their pets. This level of attention is rare in the painting industry:

• Gary personally provides estimates, explains the process step-by-step, and checks in with clients daily during projects
• Customers consistently describe Gary's manner as professional, kind, and personable, building trust from the first meeting

"Gary gave a thorough estimate with photos that pointed out important touchup areas. He checked work done by the painting crew and was easily accessible for any questions throughout the process." - Candace B., Google Review

Familiar Faces, Consistent Results

The same crew names appear across dozens of reviews, a sign of genuine in-house teams rather than rotating subcontractors. High marks on the Chooz Score's in-house crews component: Bear and Eric Carnero, supervisor Ernesto, project manager Juan, and crew members like Jose, Adam, and Rene are praised repeatedly for their craftsmanship and professionalism:

• Bear and Eric handled historic home restorations including properties over 100 years old with what customers call "attention to detail, professionalism, and knowledge of the art of painting"
• Ernesto and his crew receive consistent praise for showing up at 7:00 AM sharp, working efficiently, and completing projects on or ahead of schedule

"Bear and Eric were extremely friendly, easy to talk to, and very professional throughout the process. They showed up on time, kept me updated, and made sure I was 100% happy with the finished product." - Joe P., Google Review

The Reviews Speak for Themselves

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Knight's Painting had over 110 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 88.0%. With 9 years in business serving Las Cruces and surrounding communities, they've built a reputation that extends across multiple platforms:

• Strong presence on HomeAdvisor with 4.5+ stars and over 15 reviews praising their stucco repair expertise and fair pricing
• Nextdoor Favorite status with over 12 recommendations from local neighbors

"This is the 2nd time we have used Knights painting. They are simply the best. On time. On budget. Always pleasant to work with. Would recommend without reservation." - Joseph M., Google Review

Why Customers Choose Innovative Coatings LLC

Customers Keep Coming Back

High marks on the Chooz Score's customer retention indicators: multiple reviewers mention returning for second, third, and even fourth projects with this company. For a contractor founded in 2019, this return rate indicates work that holds up over time:

• Heather Hume describes Josh and his crew completing their "third job" for her household
• Multiple customers mention planning future projects before current ones finish

"Josh and his crew just completed their third job for us. There's a reason my husband and I keep going back for our professional painting needs. They're always organized, punctual, communicative, and the quality of work is top-notch." - Heather H., Google Review

A Reputation Built Over Time

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Innovative Coatings LLC had over 125 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 85%. Insurance companies in the Las Cruces area actively refer clients to this contractor for damage-related work, suggesting reliability that extends beyond typical customer reviews:

• Over 10 new reviews in the last 3 months alone confirm active project completion
• Nextdoor Favorite recognition with 7 neighborhood recommendations

"Professional and courtesy top notch. Fair cost and completed with full satisfaction." - El Padre M., Google Review

Easy to Reach, Quick to Respond

Owner Josh Santos personally handles estimates and responds to virtually every review with specific details about the project and customer. The Chooz Score's review response quality component reflects how Josh handles feedback, with personalized replies rather than copy-paste responses:

• Austin Vega received a same-day quote and next-day project completion
• Susan Rexroth noted Josh responded to her inquiry within 24 hours

"Great company to work with! Came same day for a quote next day project was fixed! Recommend them for any restoration project!" - Austin V., Google Review

Why Customers Choose El Paso Paint Kings

The Boss Shows Up

Owner Albert Ordunez doesn't just send crews - he personally handles every estimate, guides color selection, and checks in throughout projects. The Chooz Score's owner engagement indicators are strong: Albert is mentioned by name in the majority of reviews, often alongside praise for his hands-on approach:

• Albert provides free consultations with detailed spec sheets, paint warranties, and insurance documentation
• Customers note he "helped me select a color" and "used his experience to help in our paint selection"

"Albert was a true professional in the business. He was extremely knowledgeable, addressed all our concerns and provided us with detailed spec sheets of what would be completed during the project." - rpmaestas, Google Review

No Mess Left Behind

Cleanup isn't an afterthought - it's part of the service. Customers consistently describe crews who clean the work area daily, secure materials each evening, and leave properties spotless upon completion. One reviewer noted the crew even washed windows after finishing the paint job:

• Daily cleanup is standard practice, with crews "cleaned up the site and secured the materials" each day
• Multiple customers mention the team "kept our property clean as they did the job"
• Final cleanup includes power washing dust from surrounding areas

"Cleanup after completion of the project was something we have never experienced with any other painting companies. The area around the home was power washed from all dust and all the windows were washed and cleaned." - rpmaestas, Google Review

A Reputation Built Over Time

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, El Paso Paint Kings had over 55 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 81.1%. With 7 years in business, they've established themselves as the go-to for stucco restoration in the desert Southwest:

• Behr certified crew using products backed by a 5-year warranty, with Home Depot paints carrying a lifetime warranty
• Serves both El Paso and Las Cruces markets, traveling to Albuquerque for larger projects

"The pricing for our project was extremely reasonable compared to all other companies we were thinking of hiring." - rpmaestas, Google Review

Questions to Ask El Paso Paint Kings

Warranty follow-up timeline

Some customers reported delays when requesting warranty service, though issues were eventually resolved. One reviewer noted it took "well over 6 months" to complete warranty work, though the company did ultimately honor the commitment. Ask them directly: "If I need warranty service, what's your typical response time and process for scheduling the work?"

"With follow up and working VERY hard and over a long period of time for Albert to make good on his warranty, it totally drips to 3 stars. I had to text, call, and submit documents to get Albert to make good on his work." - Cathie K., Google Review (no owner reply)