Best Painters Near Monsey, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

The Monsey, NY area is served by painting contractors with strong track records across interior, exterior, and specialty work. All three companies reviewed here serve Rockland County and the surrounding region, with customers consistently reporting careful prep work, clear communication, and crews that treat their homes with care. Here is how they compare based on our Chooz Score analysis.

Pro Painting Plus leads the field with a Chooz Score of 87.6% and over 75 Google reviews, nearly all at 4.9 stars. Owner Rob McRae takes a hands-on approach, visiting job sites throughout each project and personally reviewing finished work before sign-off. The team handles a wide range of projects: interior rooms, kitchen cabinet refinishing, exterior siding, cedar homes, tin roofs, historic church shingles, and epoxy garage floors. If you need a team that can handle specialty surfaces and unusual scopes alongside standard painting, Pro Painting Plus is a strong fit.

The company has a pattern of stepping in to rescue jobs that other contractors left unfinished or handled poorly - a sign of both confidence and capability. Crew members including Luis, Miguel, Dario, and Oscar appear by name in multiple independent reviews for workmanship and professionalism while in the home. At least one customer described the team as her "go-to painters" after years of consistent results.

• Owner Rob McRae is described in multiple reviews as visiting the job site throughout each project and addressing imperfections before the work is signed off, not after.
• Cabinet refinishing durability holds up over time - one customer noted the finish looked perfect six months after completion with no chipping or wear in an active kitchen.
• The team has worked on surfaces as varied as a tin roof original to 1865 and cedar homes with mixed wood types including teak and pine.

"Always a pleasure to have Rob and Pro Painters Plus on-site. I am always impressed with the prep work - which gives that professional finish. Plus Rob visits the site, reviews the work and has any imperfection corrected. All of the painters were easy to work with, respectful and professional. PPP are my go-to painters. I don't call anyone else." - Tracey Brooker, Google Review

For homeowners and commercial customers looking for a well-organized operation with a deep cross-platform review record, MGP Painting Inc. is worth a close look. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 200 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, 96% recommended on Facebook, and 5.0 stars on Angi with over 10 reviews. Based in Orangeburg and serving the broader Monsey, NY region, the company has been in business for over 13 years and earned a Chooz Score of 87.2%.

What distinguishes MGP from many competitors is a professionally staffed front office - reviewers call out Elena, Mabel, and Rachel by name for keeping projects on schedule and handling questions promptly. Owner Moises Penafiel personally visits sites during larger jobs, and the crew handles a full range of work: interior rooms, kitchen cabinets, wallpaper installation, deck staining, power washing, and commercial spaces including libraries and business interiors. Detailed initial estimates and a crew that delivers on every line item appear consistently throughout the review history.

• The company has handled historically complex projects including an exterior restoration of a landmarked home built in the late 1700s, where significant prep and repair work preceded any painting.
• Crew members Galo, Orlando, and Carlos appear by name across independent reviews for careful attention to edges, trim, and detail work on complex surfaces.
• Moises responds to virtually every review and visits sites mid-project on larger jobs to confirm the work is meeting expectations.
• The front office coordinates scheduling and client questions with a level of organization reviewers describe as rare among home service companies.

"They left the house cleaner than they found it. When the real estate agent saw the work they did she suggested we increase our price." - Clythie F., Yelp Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Monsey, NY, Aquinas Painting Contractors brings nearly 40 years in business since 1987 to every project, now led by Alex Solis. At the time of our analysis, they had over 80 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, along with 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi with over 9 reviews. They hold a verified Rockland County Home Improvement Contractor License and all painters carry OSHA certification. The company earned a Chooz Score of 86.3%.

Long-term loyalty defines Aquinas more than any single project outcome. Frank O. has worked with the company for over 20 years across interior and exterior projects. Robert Williamson describes using them for many years and recently brought them into a condo renovation. Frank Cataldo hired the team three times in a year and a half. Alex Solis is consistently praised for flexibility - rearranging his schedule to meet client timelines and accommodating mid-project changes without complaint. If you are looking for a painting company to call year after year, Aquinas Painting Contractors has built that kind of reputation across Rockland and Westchester Counties.

• The crew has handled commercial and institutional projects including a warehouse space and a convent exterior, alongside standard residential interior and exterior work.
• Crew members Pablo, Walter, Miguel, and Manuel appear by name across independent reviews, each praised for skill and care while on-site.

"They are the best painters I have ever worked with. So professional, reliable and immaculate. The work is outstanding. I wish I could do ten stars." - Robert Ebel, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Professionalism and communication stand out as top themes across all three painting contractors serving the Monsey, NY area. Reviewers describe responsive owners, clear estimates, and crews that follow up throughout the project and after completion.

At Pro Painting Plus, owner Rob McRae is frequently described as visiting the job site personally, answering calls and texts promptly, and staying in touch from estimate through final sign-off. Multiple customers describe how that hands-on involvement changed their expectations for what a painting contractor could be. MGP Painting Inc. is notable for the professionalism of its entire operation - from the front office staff who reviewers call out by name to owner Moises Penafiel, who appears on larger job sites to review progress and is known for detailed, same-day responses to questions. At Aquinas Painting Contractors, Alex Solis earns consistent praise for clear communication and a scheduling process customers describe as easy, pleasant, and follow-up driven throughout the project.

"Professional, punctual and attentive to detail are three descriptions among others to describe the Pro Painting Plus team. Because I had a good prior experience with Rob's company, my decision to hire again was easy." - Jean Kenny, Google Review"Moises communicates clearly, sticks to the projected timeline and does a great job!" - Sally Goldberg, Google Review"I also want to highlight how professional and reasonable the owner, Alex, was throughout the entire process. Communication was clear, pricing was fair, and every question or concern was handled with care and respect. It's refreshing to work with a company that truly values quality and customer satisfaction." - Yetunde, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Quality of workmanship is a defining theme across painting contractor reviews in the Monsey, NY area. Customers describe results that go well beyond a standard coat of paint - prep and repair work is thorough, finishes are precise, and jobs consistently hold up well over time.

At Pro Painting Plus, prep work is a recurring observation. Reviewers describe crews filling nail pops, patching cracks, caulking joints, and sanding surfaces smooth before any paint is applied. The owner's daily site visits appear directly connected to this standard - imperfections get addressed before the project closes, not after. MGP Painting Inc. brings the same approach to complex jobs: reviewers describe a challenging project involving popcorn ceilings, multi-level staircases, high ceilings with fixtures, and wall-mounted TVs that was handled "precisely" without a single item being missed. Aquinas Painting Contractors applies the same care to repair and restoration work - customers describe bathroom ceiling and wall repairs that left surfaces looking like new construction, with no visible trace of prior damage.

"5 Stars is not enough for the impeccable service this painting company offers. The preparation of my rooms were thoughtful and careful, the crew was swift and detail oriented. We had some tricky historical trim work that needed removal and replacement. There was water damaged sheetrock in a bathroom which was removed and replaced. All of the work was ultra clean!!" - C R Bradbury, Google Review"Just had my house painted by MGP. I rate this company a 10 plus from the initial estimate through completion. The estimate was on a Thursday, the work was started that Monday! They patched and spackled every hole. Honestly, these guys didn't miss a thing! The paint job was precisely executed." - Helene Clemenza, Google Review"The painter was exceptionally skilled, professional, and clearly took pride in the work. They also left the space spotless afterward - you would never know any repairs had been done." - T Pizarro, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Pricing feedback across the Monsey, NY area painting contractors points to companies that are upfront about costs and deliver quality that customers feel justifies the price. Reviewers across all three companies describe fair estimates, no surprise charges, and results that often exceed initial expectations for what they spent.

Pro Painting Plus customers frequently pair terms like "affordable price" and "fair price" with descriptions of high-quality results - and several describe adding scope mid-project without significant cost increases. At MGP Painting Inc., Moises Penafiel provides detailed written estimates with clear line items, and one repeat customer noted the owner's cost-saving suggestions on a home sale project reduced her spend by over $2,000 without any reduction in quality. Aquinas Painting Contractors earns consistent mention for fair pricing alongside a decades-long track record - multiple reviewers note they have returned specifically because the combination of quality and value has remained consistent year after year.

"Quality work, attention to detail, efficient, professional, and courteous. They do a great job at an affordable price." - Ryan T, Google Review"The owner made suggestions for the town home that ended up saving us over $2000. The painters were neat, fast and very nice. I am so glad MGP Painters was referred to us." - Barbara McConnell, Google Review"Prompt, courteous and excellent job for a reasonable price - very pleased." - Joan Facelle, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Prep work and daily cleanup are consistent themes across painting contractor reviews in the Monsey, NY area. Customers describe crews that protect furniture and flooring before work begins, clean up thoroughly at the end of each day during multi-day projects, and leave homes in better condition than they found them.

At Pro Painting Plus, prep work is frequently cited as the reason the finished product stands out. Crews fill and sand all wall blemishes before any paint is applied, and daily cleanup includes wiping down floors in areas where work was completed. MGP Painting Inc. crews take particular care protecting floors and furniture before painting begins - multiple reviewers note the crew left no visible trace after finishing, with not a drop of paint where it shouldn't be. Aquinas Painting Contractors customers describe furniture being returned to its exact placement at the end of each day, floors and belongings protected throughout, and a consistent standard of care across both interior and exterior projects.

"Pro Painting Plus did an excellent job painting the first floor rooms and hallways in our home. Herbie and Juan repaired cracks, seams, nail pops, and other wall blemishes. Each time an area was finished, any dust or debris was thoroughly cleaned up including wiping down the floors. Our 45-year old walls now look like new construction." - Cathie Swyka, Google Review"MGP took great care prepping the interior and our newly refinished floors to avoid any damage to them. They cleaned up and left no trace behind! Not even a single speck of paint - true professionals!" - Valerie Gruber, Google Review"The team was punctual, clean, careful and did an excellent job. They cleaned up and returned furniture to its proper place. I had a change with the color and they were so easy to work with." - Robbi Anderson, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google