What sets Carrigan Painting apart is a specialty most contractors in the Buffalo area won't even attempt: authentic plaster repair. When other companies show up and quote drywall over cracking plaster, Dave Carrigan diagnoses the actual problem and restores the original material. The Chooz Score's review authenticity indicators are strong: reviewers mention specific project details, crew members by name, and realistic timelines that reflect genuine customer experiences:
"After calling several 'plaster repair contractors' and SPECIFICALLY telling them that I wanted original type plaster, and not drywall, many came out and gave me an estimate for drywall and joint compound! Dave Carrigan, on the other hand, understood exactly what I wanted." - Maryjo J., Google Review
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Carrigan Painting had over 50 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating - not a single review below five stars across 15 years in business. This company earned a Chooz Score of 86.7%. That consistency extends across platforms:
"This was the second time we used them, and we will hire them again for our next painting job." - Thomas K., Google Review
Dave and his cousin Stacy get called out by name in nearly every review, and that's because they're the ones doing the work. This isn't a company that sends a random crew to your house. The Chooz Score's owner engagement indicators are strong: Dave is personally mentioned in the majority of reviews and handles estimates, project work, and follow-ups himself:
"We love having Dave and Stacey do work for us. They are such good and honest people and so nice to have around. They work very hard and are so careful about everything." - Nancy F., Facebook Review
Want us to do the work for you and find you the best painting contractor?
Get StartedFREE SERVICECrews like Tom Sr., Tom Jr., and Todd get called out by name in review after review, and that's because this is a true family operation where the owners do the work. The Chooz Score's owner engagement indicators are strong: the father-son team is personally mentioned in the majority of reviews, and the owner responds to virtually every piece of feedback with specific, personalized replies:
"The 'two Toms', a father-son team, were very professional, friendly and respectful of our space. It was obvious they take pride in their work. I actually miss having the two Toms around now that the job is done." - Kathleen F., Facebook Review
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Painting by Robertson had over 75 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 86.4%. With over 30 years in business serving Western New York, they've built a reputation that spans generations:
"The entire experience from initial quote to finishing the project was painless and extremely transparent. The painting work came out great, they communicated clearly and honestly. Wish all contractors operated like this." - Cory M., Google Review
If you're looking for a painter you can call for years to come, this company has built serious loyalty. High marks on the Chooz Score's customer retention indicators: multiple reviewers mention returning for second, third, and even fourth projects:
"I've been dealing with Painting by Robertson for years and have been repeatedly impressed with their expertise and perfection. They have always provided supportive advice every step of the way. They are true gentlemen." - Joe F., Google Review
Crews like Ermir and Edjon get called out by name in review after review, and for good reason. Co-owners Ermir and Edjon Krasniqi don't just manage from a distance - they show up on job sites, conduct walkthroughs, and work alongside their team. The Chooz Score's owner engagement indicators are strong: both owners are personally mentioned in reviews and actively respond to feedback:
"Ermir Krasniqi and his brother Ed Jon, owners of Bee Pro Painting and their team did a remarkable job painting and making significant carpentry repairs to our 1903 Buffalo signature home. Pride and perfection mark the work ethic and final product of the team individually and as a whole." - Thomas Y., Google Review
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, BEE Pro Painting & Contracting had over 60 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating - every single one a five-star review. This company earned a Chooz Score of 82.8%. With nearly 6 years in business serving the greater Buffalo area, they've built a consistent reputation across platforms:
"I found a unicorn; a contracting company that truly delivers what they promise! The team from management to workers are respectful and dedicated to their work. I cannot recommend them highly enough!" - Lynn, Google Review
Customers consistently mention the same thing: BEE Pro crews leave spaces cleaner than they found them. Daily cleanup, furniture protection, and respectful treatment of customer property come up in an unusually high number of reviews across all platforms:
"They brought all their own supplies and followed all my directions precisely. The finished result was absolutely perfect. They also were meticulous cleaning up after themselves and left the spaces they worked on spotless." - William W., BBB Review
Every painter listed on this page has been evaluated using the Chooz multi-step quality process. We combine data analysis with human review to identify companies that consistently deliver strong results for property owners in Newstead, NY.
The Chooz Score is a 100-point rating built on platform reviews, review quality and engagement, website and digital presence, and business authority and operations. We use the same scoring framework nationwide while evaluating each contractor's performance specifically within Newstead, NY.