7 Best Painters Near Amherst, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Amherst, NY have access to several well-reviewed painting contractors, many of whom serve the broader Western New York region. Whether the project involves refreshing an interior, tackling popcorn ceiling removal, or repainting a century-old exterior, these companies consistently earn praise for showing up on time, communicating clearly, and delivering results customers are happy to show off.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Sekula's Precision Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.9%, along with 100% recommended on Facebook across over 50 recommendations and an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau. Owner Chris Sekula personally meets with customers during the estimate process, and his named crews handle projects from start to finish. What stands out in the reviews is how many customers describe feeling completely comfortable leaving the house while the painters worked. If you have a multi-room or whole-house project and want a team that keeps its own schedule without needing oversight, Sekula's is a strong fit.

Several reviewers mention individual crew members by name and describe returning for second and third projects. The company also handles commercial work, with at least one remodeling contractor referring his own clients to Sekula's.

• Customers frequently describe the crew arriving at 8 a.m. sharp each day and keeping the workspace organized throughout multi-day projects
• The company serves both the Rochester and Buffalo markets, giving Amherst homeowners access to a team with wide-ranging project experience
• Multiple reviews mention exterior work on older homes, with special attention to prep and surface condition

"If I could give them more stars, I would! Chris and his team are consummate professionals. They ticked every box: prompt, hard-working, skilled, friendly, and respectful of our home." - Elizabeth Palmer, Google Review

For homeowners dealing with popcorn ceilings or large-scale interior updates, Advantage Paint Services has built a specialty in that area. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.2% with over 60 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Zach Guthrie runs a family-owned operation established in 2019 with PCA membership and OSHA certification. What customers notice most is the level of protection the crew provides before dusty work begins. If you have hardwood floors or furniture you cannot move, this team takes extra steps to cover and protect everything on site.

Two fellow painting contractors left public Google endorsements for Advantage Paint Services, which is unusual in the residential painting world. The company also handles cabinet painting with off-site removal for a quick turnaround, and is EPA Lead-Safe Certified for older homes.

• Crew leaders like Benjamin, Nate, and Eric are praised by name for careful edge work and smooth ceiling finishes after popcorn removal
• Several reviewers describe ceilings that look as though they were never textured after the work was completed
• The company backs all work with a 3-plus-year paint manufacturer warranty and a workmanship guarantee

"Advantage Paint Services removed popcorn from our ceilings in 3/4 of our house, including a two-story cathedral ceiling, and refinished it with a smooth white surface. They did an excellent job from start to finish." - Luke Borkowski, Google Review

With the largest review volume of any contractor in the Amherst, NY area, Queen City Painting & Wash earned a Chooz Score of 87.1% backed by over 95 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. Jeff, the company's lead painter, handles both painting and power washing, and customers regularly describe hiring him for multiple projects over the years. If you need both interior painting and exterior cleaning done by the same reliable person, Queen City keeps things simple.

A recurring pattern in reviews is how quickly Jeff completes work without cutting corners. One customer described having an entire home interior painted in three days, while another highlights drywall repair and ceiling crack fixes completed alongside the paint job.

• Power washing services extend to driveways, decks, fences, and full home exteriors, often booked alongside painting projects
• Customers consistently describe reasonable pricing with no surprise charges or add-ons
• Jeff and Missy coordinate scheduling and communication together, and reviewers praise the responsiveness

"Jeff was fantastic! Friendly, professional, detail oriented, communicated every step of the way with how the project was going. He painted the entire interior of my home in 3 days." - Stephen Carr, Google Review

When it comes to authentic plaster repair, Carrigan Painting stands out as a specialist most contractors in Buffalo will not attempt. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.7% with over 50 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 94% recommended on Facebook. Dave Carrigan and his cousin Stacy handle the work personally, with over 15 years in business. If you own a pre-war home with original plaster and want it restored rather than covered with drywall, Carrigan is the contractor to call.

Reviewers frequently describe Dave correctly diagnosing plaster issues that other contractors misidentified. Several customers also highlight seamless popcorn ceiling pattern matching and a level of care in prep work that keeps dust contained in older homes.

• Dave and Stacy are named in nearly every review, confirming this is a hands-on operation where the owners do the actual work
• Customers describe friendly, honest communication and realistic timelines with no surprises
• The company handles everything from small drywall patches to full interior and exterior repaints

"Dave and his team were always on time, reasonably priced for his expertise and most importantly did real pro work. I give him my highest recommendation." - Seth Oyer, Google Review

A true family business with over 30 years in business, Painting by Robertson is led by a father-son team. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.4% with over 75 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating, plus 96% recommended on Facebook. Tom Sr. and Tom Jr. handle estimates, prep, and painting themselves, and customers consistently describe the pride they bring to each job. If you want to work directly with the people doing the painting from the first phone call to the final walkthrough, Robertson is a reliable choice.

What stands out in Robertson's reviews is honesty. One customer describes how the team stopped mid-power-wash to point out that the siding looked great and the full paint job originally quoted was not needed, saving the homeowner money. That kind of straightforward approach runs through the feedback.

• Popcorn ceiling removal and drywall repair are frequent project types, with customers praising neat, dust-free results
• Repeat customers and referrals from home improvement companies appear regularly in reviews
• Customers describe the father-son dynamic as a standout quality, noting mutual respect and pride in the finished product

"There are SO many positive things that I can say about Painting by Robertson. These men did a FANTASTIC job scraping the popcorn ceilings and painting my new home." - Sarah Falzone, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving the Amherst, NY area, CertaPro Painters of WNY brings franchise-level infrastructure with local roots dating back to 1991. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.5% with over 540 Google reviews and a 4.7-star rating, plus 4.5 stars on Yelp and an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau. With nearly 20 years in business as a CertaPro franchise, the company has dedicated project managers like Juan Leon and Mike who coordinate crews and keep homeowners updated throughout the process. If you have a large or time-sensitive project that needs to get done quickly with professional coordination, CertaPro has the capacity to deliver.

Several reviewers describe crew members going the extra mile, such as one painter who spent an evening researching stains to match 1956 woodwork. Named crew members like Alex, Norberto, Bert, and Edwin appear across reviews for their care with specialty tasks like skim coating and wallpaper removal.

• Project managers handle scheduling and communication so homeowners have a single point of contact
• The company handles both interior and exterior work, including popcorn removal, cabinet painting, and full-house repaints
• Long-time homeowners describe results that surpass previous painting companies they have used over decades

"We can't say enough on how happy we are with the wonderful interior paint job we have from CertaPro. From the day of our estimate with Mike to the beautiful painting done by Norberto. We totally recommend them." - Louise Azzinaro, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Quality and attention to detail are the most frequently praised aspects of painting contractors serving Amherst, NY. Across hundreds of reviews, customers describe results that exceed their expectations, with many noting that the finished product looks better than they imagined possible.

Sekula's Precision Painting customers frequently highlight precise edge work and careful surface preparation. Crew leader Alex earned special recognition for keeping projects on track and delivering excellent workmanship on a multi-room interior. "Every detail is just right. They were also very professional in all our dealings." - Christine Kray, Google Review. Advantage Paint Services is especially praised for ceiling work, with several customers describing popcorn removal results where "you could never tell the ceilings were ever textured." - Kandice Dennis, Google Review. Carrigan Painting earns specific praise for plaster restoration that other contractors cannot match. One customer describes Dave correctly diagnosing a structural plaster issue that two drywall contractors missed. "Dave and Stacey did a remarkable job repairing my lathe and plaster ceilings. They did such a great job matching the existing popcorn texture." - Bonnie Lotz, Google Review. Queen City Painting & Wash customers highlight Jeff's ability to handle drywall repair and ceiling fixes alongside the paint job, delivering a complete finished look in a short timeframe. "He painted the entire interior of our house quickly and cleanly. Very happy with the result." - Shawn Sicchio, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Timeliness is one of the strongest patterns across painting contractor reviews in Amherst, NY. Customers consistently describe crews arriving on time, starting early, and completing projects on or ahead of schedule.

Sekula's Precision Painting crews are described arriving at 8 a.m. daily on multi-day projects, and several customers note work finishing sooner than expected. "The job was finished sooner than expected, and everything was perfect." - Elizabeth Palmer, Google Review. Queen City Painting & Wash stands out for speed without sacrificing quality, with one customer describing a full interior painted in just three days. "Great experience. Great job with very reasonable pricing. They worked around my schedule to get the job done." - Mark Moulin, Google Review. Painting by Robertson customers praise the team's punctuality and clear scheduling from the initial contact through completion. "From initial contact, to the quote, the scheduling, and completion was just over a month. They are two of the nicest people you will ever meet." - Kelly, Google Review. Northeast Pro Painting & Restoration earns praise for fast turnaround times and reliable communication, with owner Thomas Clark personally managing timelines. "Fast communication, great rates and service. They finished the job faster than expected." - Andrew Patszalek, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Clear, responsive communication is a hallmark of top-rated painting contractors in Amherst, NY. Customers describe owners and crew members who answer calls promptly, explain the process in detail, and keep homeowners informed throughout the project.

Advantage Paint Services owner Zach Guthrie is described as highly responsive during the quoting process and throughout the job. "Found Zach to be very responsive and accommodating at review and quote phase. His staff was prompt, professional and focused on a quality finished product." - Edward Wood, Google Review. Carrigan Painting customers highlight Dave's willingness to explain plaster repair options and help homeowners understand why previous fixes failed. "They took the time to explain everything and why a previous repair failed." - Sean Fettes, Google Review. CertaPro Painters of WNY uses dedicated project managers to serve as a single point of contact. "Good communication through the entire process. The exterior of the house was painted in two days and looks great!" - Matthew Gunther, Google Review. BEE Pro Painting & Contracting co-owners Ermir and Edjon Krasniqi answer calls directly and accommodate mid-project changes without extra charges. "They listen to all my concerns about being careful with my plants. GREAT JOB!" - Laura Douglas, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Cleanup and prep work are among the most appreciated qualities of painting contractors serving Amherst, NY. Customers consistently describe crews that protect furniture, cover floors, and leave the home looking better than before they arrived.

Advantage Paint Services crews are especially careful on popcorn ceiling removal jobs, covering hardwood floors with heavy paper rolls and masking all furniture before work begins. "Zach and his team were responsive to phone calls and texts, and attentive to detail while on the job." - Linda Delello, Google Review. BEE Pro Painting & Contracting receives consistent praise for daily cleanup, with crews clearing the work area before leaving each evening. "We're delighted with how our exterior trim turned out. The crew cleaned the work area before leaving each day and made certain that the paint went only where it was supposed to go." - John Glor, Google Review. Painting by Robertson customers note the team keeps the home in workable order during multi-day projects. "I am so impressed with Painting by Robertson. They were efficient, extremely neat, friendly and did an amazing job." - Luann Warkenthien, Google Review. Sekula's Precision Painting also earns praise for keeping equipment neatly organized during extended projects. "The team kept their equipment neatly organized over the weeks they were on site, which we appreciated." - Kathleen Meisenzahl, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Customers across Amherst, NY consistently describe painting services as fairly priced, with many noting that the value exceeded their expectations. Several contractors offer free estimates, and reviewers frequently mention competitive quotes with no hidden fees.

Queen City Painting & Wash is one of the most frequently praised for pricing, with customers using words like "reasonable," "fair," and "great value." "Absolutely perfect. Easy estimates, on time, perfect job. Extremely reasonable pricing." - Eli Hazzan, Google Review. Painting by Robertson customers describe honest pricing with no surprises, and one reviewer highlights the team proactively saving money by recommending less work than originally quoted. "Great father and son duo, exceptional work, great pricing, took care in everything they did." - Dave Zak, Google Review. BEE Pro Painting & Contracting earns praise for competitive rates on both painting and power washing. "They did a beautiful job and didn't charge an arm and leg, like others! The crew was professional and efficient." - Melissa Lee, Google Review. Advantage Paint Services provides detailed written quotes, and customers appreciate that the final cost matches the estimate. "The price was reasonable and the crew was very pleasant and did a great job!" - Rebecca Sherry, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Repeat business is a strong pattern among painting contractors in Amherst, NY. Many reviewers describe returning for second, third, and even fourth projects, and referrals from friends and family run throughout the feedback.

Sekula's Precision Painting has a notably loyal customer base. Multiple reviewers describe hiring the company for exterior work and then returning for interior projects, with some already booking future work before the current job is complete. "We had Sekula come to our 100-plus year old house to give the exterior a refresh. From start to finish, Sekula employees were complete pros." - Abby Kuperstock, Google Review. Queen City Painting & Wash customers describe hiring Jeff for painting, then calling back for power washing, and then booking again the following year. "We used Queen City to paint the inside of our house several years ago. We hired them again for power washing and painting. A beautiful job, both times." - Karen Schauger, Google Review. Carrigan Painting repeat customers describe calling Dave and Stacy for projects across multiple rooms and properties. "We love having Dave and Stacey do work for us. They are such good and honest people. The first time they did a lot of work for us and we were thrilled." - Nancy Fox, Facebook Review. Painting by Robertson earns repeat business partly through referrals from home improvement companies, and customers describe a level of trust that keeps them coming back. "I've been dealing with Painting by Robertson for years and have been repeatedly impressed with their expertise and perfection." - Joe Frawley, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook