Homeowners in East Amherst, NY have access to several well-reviewed painting contractors serving the greater Buffalo and Western New York area. Across hundreds of verified reviews, customers consistently highlight reliable communication, careful prep work, and crews that treat homes with respect. Here are the top-rated painting companies based on Chooz Painters data.
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Sekula's Precision Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.9%, the highest among contractors serving East Amherst, NY. They are 100% recommended on Facebook across over 50 recommendations and hold recognition as the Greater Rochester Chamber of Commerce Business Person of the Year. Owner Chris Sekula has been building the company since 2017, and what stands out across the reviews is how many customers describe feeling comfortable leaving painters in their home unsupervised. If you want a crew that will check in with you throughout the project and finish ahead of schedule, Sekula's is a strong fit.
Several reviewers point to the company's ability to handle older homes with care. One customer had the crew work on a 100-plus year old house and noted the team's respect for the property's character. The office side of the operation also gets frequent praise, with Kaitlyn mentioned by name for prompt, clear communication on estimates and scheduling.
- Customers regularly describe the crew storing tools neatly on-site during multi-day projects, keeping the property organized
- Multiple homeowners mention receiving virtual color mock-up consultations before the project started
- Repeat business is a strong pattern, with several reviewers returning for second and third projects years later
"If I could give them more stars, I would! Chris and his team are consummate professionals. They ticked every box: prompt, hard-working, skilled, friendly, and respectful of our home." - Elizabeth Palmer, Google Review
For homeowners who also need power washing, deck staining, or exterior cleaning alongside their paint job, Queen City Painting & Wash offers a combined service approach. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.1% and maintains a BBB A+ rating with zero complaints since accreditation in 2014. Owned and operated by Jeff and Missy Cammarata, Queen City has been serving the Buffalo area for over 14 years. Every job is completed by in-house W2 employees who have passed background checks, never subcontractors. If you value having the business owner personally on your job site, Jeff's hands-on style stands out in almost every review.
What comes through in review after review is the depth of the customer relationships Jeff has built. Several reviewers describe working with him across multiple homes and multiple decades. The company also holds EPA Lead-Safe Certification for work on pre-1978 homes, which is relevant for many of the older properties in the East Amherst, NY area.
- Customers frequently mention Jeff offering helpful design suggestions and color recommendations beyond just painting
- The company handles wallpaper removal, drywall repair, and popcorn ceiling removal in addition to painting
- Multiple reviewers describe Jeff completing unexpected small extras at no additional charge
"Jeff and his crew transformed my home! Beautiful clean lines, nice neat drywall repair, and left the house clean! Extremely professional and high quality work." - Rachael Plotner, Google Review
With nearly 20 years as a CertaPro franchise and local roots dating back to 1991 under Ventresca Painting, CertaPro Painters of WNY brings the largest operation on this list. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.5% with over 540 Google reviews and a 4.7-star rating. Reviews span multiple platforms, including 4.5 stars on Yelp and a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite designation. They are accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2006. If you have a large-scale project or need work done on short notice, CertaPro's bench of experienced crews makes them a practical choice.
The standout pattern in CertaPro's reviews is how often customers mention individual painters by name. Alex, Norberto, Bert, and Edwin appear across dozens of reviews spanning months, suggesting consistent crew assignments rather than rotating workers. Several homeowners also praise the virtual project scoping process, which allows estimates to happen quickly without scheduling delays.
- Multiple customers describe having specialty work done, including popcorn ceiling removal, skim coating, and wallpaper removal
- Project manager Juan Leon receives frequent praise for coordinating multi-day jobs and conducting final walkthroughs
- Neighbors regularly stop by during exterior projects to ask for the company's contact information, according to several reviewers
"We have lived in our home for 40 years and have had it painted a few times. This company has by far surpassed any painting company we have used." - Michael Mclaughlin, Google Review
Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Northeast Pro Painting & Restoration. This company earned a Chooz Score of 83.0% with over 150 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. Owner Thomas Clark personally handles estimates and checks in on active projects. With over 5 years in business, they hold a BBB accreditation since 2025, a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite designation, and 5.0 stars on Angi. If you own a historic or older Buffalo-area home and want a contractor who understands period-accurate restoration, Northeast Pro specializes in exactly that.
What separates this company from standard painting contractors is their in-house carpentry capability, including a wood milling shop for custom trim fabrication. Several customers who own early 1900s homes describe trusting the team with sensitive restoration work. The company also offers a five-year workmanship warranty that can be extended to seven years through their Annual Service Plan.
- Commercial clients, including school administrators, describe hiring Northeast Pro for multi-facility projects and being impressed by the crew's professionalism
- Several reviews describe full exterior color changes completed in under four days
"Thomas and his crew did a thorough, beautiful job on our Victorian 'painted lady' in Parkside! We highly recommend their service." - Kate Haq, Google Review
Rounding out the top contractors serving East Amherst, NY, BEE Pro Painting & Contracting LLC earned a Chooz Score of 82.8% with over 60 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. Co-owners Ermir and Edjon Krasniqi run the operation hands-on, showing up on job sites daily and working alongside their crew. They are accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2023 and are 100% recommended on Facebook. If you are looking for a contractor who will personally walk you through the estimate and be present throughout the work, BEE Pro fits that description.
Several reviewers note that the owners accommodated mid-project changes without adding charges or creating hassle, which suggests a flexible, customer-first approach. The company also handles carpentry, drywall, power washing, and gutter work, making them a one-stop option for homeowners with multiple exterior needs. They hold a City of Buffalo Light Commercial Contractor license as well.
- Customers describe the crew moving furniture carefully, covering items thoroughly, and returning everything to its original position after the job
- One homeowner hired BEE Pro to repair woodpecker damage to their siding and was impressed by the restored appearance
- Multiple BBB reviewers specifically highlight the daily cleanup routine as a standout feature
"Would definitely recommend! Professional, kind, and hard working crew that turned my drab siding into something that makes me smile when I get home everyday." - Melissa Hosey, Google Review
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB
