Painting contractors serving the Tonawanda, NY area have built strong reputations on consistent quality, reliable scheduling, and hands-on service across interior and exterior projects. Whether homeowners need a full exterior repaint, specialty plaster restoration, or a complete interior refresh, the top-ranked companies below draw praise for their professionalism and clear communication from start to finish.
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Sekula's Precision Painting led the rankings with a Chooz Score of 87.9%, over 75 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating, and 100% recommended on Facebook across over 50 recommendations. They hold a BBB accreditation dating back to 2017 and have been serving the Rochester and Buffalo markets for over 8 years in business. What stands out in a close read of their reviews is the strength of the company's office team - customers repeatedly name staff like Kaitlyn for keeping them updated on scheduling, color coordination, and billing across multi-week projects. If you're hiring for a sizable exterior or interior job and want a company that communicates as well as it paints, Sekula's is a strong choice.
Several customers describe returning for second and third projects across multiple years, with one homeowner coming back three years after a successful exterior job for a full interior repaint. Commercial clients, including a local daycare center and a family retail business, describe the same precision they received on large residential work.
- Named crew members like Ray, Nick, Patrick, and Alexander appear across unrelated reviews spanning multiple years, confirming consistent in-house staffing
- The team regularly handles large multi-crew jobs, including a two-family dwelling with six painters deployed during an extended rainy spring season
- Customers consistently note that furniture is covered, moved, and fully restored to its original position before the crew leaves each day
"From the very first phone call to the last day of painting, Chris and his team was incredibly patient, kind, professional, organized and went above and beyond!" - Amy F., Google Review
Also serving the Western New York market, Advantage Paint Services has earned a reputation as one of the go-to crews for whole-house popcorn ceiling removal. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.2%, and at the time of our analysis, had over 60 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating - a clean record for a company with over 7 years in business. Owner Zach handles the full process personally, from showing up for estimates to following up with customers weeks after the job to confirm everything held. If you have textured ceilings throughout your home and want a crew that handles removal, patching, and repainting together, Advantage is a strong fit.
Two Painting Contractors Association (PCA) member companies left public Google endorsements for Advantage - peer-to-peer recognition that is uncommon in residential painting reviews. When unexpected issues arose mid-project, including the discovery of asbestos material behind wallpaper, Zach resolved it without adding extra charges to the customer.
- Crew members Benjamin, Nate, and Eric are cited by name for their precision on edges, moulding, and drywall patch work
- Multiple customers mention the team places all furniture and personal items back in their original spots after each day's work
- Zach's follow-up calls after project completion are mentioned in several reviews as a sign of accountability beyond the job itself
"After purchasing my home two years ago, I finally decided to get rid of the hideous, textured ceilings in my upstairs area. I was so nervous about how the ceilings would turn out, but you could never tell they were ever textured!" - Kandice D., Google Review
A husband-and-wife operation, Queen City Painting & Wash brings a personal touch that shows across their reviews. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.1%, and at the time of our analysis, had over 100 Google reviews with a consistent five-star record across painting, power washing, and exterior services. Owner Jeff handles the hands-on work while Missy coordinates scheduling and communication, and customers praise both equally. The combination of interior painting, exterior painting, and soft wash services makes this a versatile option for homeowners looking for a single, trusted contractor. If you're looking for a reliable owner-operated business where the same person shows up on every job, Queen City is a good choice.
Repeat business defines this company's review history - one customer has used Queen City for over 20 years, while others describe starting with one service and returning for additional projects across multiple seasons. The company also handles commercial painting, including a medical office renovation that drew praise for working carefully around ongoing patient traffic.
- Jeff handles interior painting, exterior painting, popcorn ceiling removal, wallpaper stripping, deck staining, and soft washing - a broader range than most painting-only crews
- Missy's scheduling coordination and communication draw nearly as many direct compliments as the painting quality itself
- Jeff's ability to match existing paint colors for touch-up work and check in throughout the project come up in multiple reviews
"Jeff and Missy are professional, reliable, and wonderful to work with! Jeff's painting is outstanding - he's quick, detail-oriented, and always leaves the space spotless." - Katie, Google Review
When it comes to authentic plaster repair and specialty ceiling work, Carrigan Painting stands in a category of its own. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.7%, and at the time of our analysis, had over 50 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating - not a single review below five stars across over 15 years in business. They're also 94% recommended on Facebook. Owner Dave Carrigan and his cousin Stacy do the work themselves, and their specialty is diagnosing and restoring original plaster rather than covering it with drywall - something most contractors in the area won't attempt. If you own an older Western New York home with authentic plaster ceilings or walls, Carrigan is the company to call.
Dave has saved customers significant expense by correctly identifying structural plaster issues that other contractors misdiagnosed. One reviewer describes Dave discovering that the rock lath plaster wasn't attached to the floor joists in large ceiling sections - a critical finding two drywall contractors had missed entirely. Customers also note that when unexpected problems surfaced during work, including a dormant wasp nest inside a wall, Dave resolved it without complaint.
- Dave and Stacy handle exterior stucco, barn restoration, lathe and plaster repair, and interior painting - a broader range than a typical painting-only crew
- Customers across multiple reviews describe genuinely missing having Dave and Stacy on-site after the job wrapped, a rare sentiment in contractor reviews
- When jobs run into weather challenges, the team adjusts and communicates the updated timeline proactively rather than going quiet
"Dave Carrigan saved us a lot of trouble by correctly diagnosing what was wrong with our plaster ceiling. Two drywall contractors proposed covering the cracking plaster with drywall. Dave knew better." - David W., Google Review
With over 30 years in business, Painting by Robertson has built the kind of reputation that only comes from consistent, honest work across generations of customers. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.4%, and at the time of our analysis, had over 75 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating and were 96% recommended on Facebook. Tom Sr. and Tom Jr. Robertson handle most work themselves as a father-son team, and repeat customers across four or more projects describe the same reliability each time. If you're looking for a painter who will show up on time, deliver quality results, and tell you honestly when you don't need something done, Painting by Robertson is worth a call.
One of the more striking things in their reviews comes from a homeowner who describes Tom Robertson pausing mid-project to point out areas that didn't actually need painting - recommending the customer save several thousand dollars by skipping unnecessary work. That honesty, combined with a willingness to take on challenging situations like exterior painting in cold weather for listing deadlines, explains the company's strong referral base.
- The team handles wallpaper removal, popcorn ceiling removal, drywall repair, and exterior repaints alongside standard interior painting
- Commercial customers, including a business building owner on his fourth engagement with Robertson, rate the company as highly as residential clients do
- Tom communicates clearly on scope, pricing, and scheduling from first contact, with no surprises at any stage of the project
"Such a pleasure to do business with an honest and hard-working company! They came to our rescue and did a great job painting our vinyl siding. Their price was very reasonable, they came when promised, and there was absolutely no mess left behind." - Denise C., Google Review
Rounding out the top contractors in Tonawanda, NY, CertaPro Painters of WNY brings the reach of a national franchise with the history of a local institution. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.5%, and at the time of our analysis, had over 540 Google reviews with a 4.7-star rating - one of the highest review volumes in the Western New York market. They also carry a 4.5-star rating on Yelp, hold a BBB accreditation dating back to 2006, and earned a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite designation. With nearly 20 years in the region as a CertaPro franchise and local roots tracing back to 1991 under Ventresca Painting, this is a deeply established operation. If you're managing a larger project and want the reliability of structured project management, CertaPro is a strong option.
Project managers like Juan Leon get called out by name for maintaining appointments, keeping communication steady, and pushing through demanding timelines - including working through the July 4th holiday to meet a deadline. One customer describes crew member Stephen spending his personal evening researching stains to correctly match original 1956 woodwork, exactly the kind of initiative that builds long-term customer trust.
- Crew members Alex, Norberto, Edwin, and Juan are cited repeatedly for thorough prep work, skim coating, and precision on specialty surface applications
- The company's systems - from estimate coordination to project management - draw consistent praise for clarity and reliability throughout each job
- Long-time homeowners describe CertaPro's results as the best they've experienced from any painting company over decades of work on their properties
"Effortless. Made the call, estimate the next day. Job scheduled, house painted - mission complete! Juan Leon, the project manager kept all scheduled appointments and ensured we received a high quality job." - Tony, Google Review
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp
