7 Best Painters Near Grand Island, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Grand Island, NY have access to several highly rated painting contractors serving the island and surrounding Western New York communities. Reviews across these companies highlight punctuality, fair pricing, and a willingness to go beyond standard painting to handle drywall repairs, plaster work, and pressure washing.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Queen City Painting & Wash had over 100 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.1% and holds an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau. Jeff handles all painting and pressure washing personally, while his wife Missy manages scheduling and client communication. Every job is completed by in-house employees, never subcontractors. If you are looking for a reliable one-crew operation where the same person handles your estimate and your project, Queen City is a strong choice.

• Repeat customers are common, with several homeowners describing three or four projects over the years and returning each time based on previous results
• Missy responds quickly to inquiries and keeps homeowners updated on scheduling, creating a smooth experience from first contact to completion
• Whole-home interiors are regularly finished in as few as three days

"Jeff does excellent work & does not leave a mess. He also doesn't 'nickel & dime' you. We had a great experience & are delighted with our fully re-painted townhouse." - Tracy Bramwell, Google Review

For homeowners dealing with cracked plaster ceilings or water damage in older homes, Carrigan Painting offers authentic plaster repair using real plaster, not drywall compound. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.7% with over 50 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 94% recommended on Facebook. Owner Dave Carrigan is a third-generation plasterer who works alongside his cousin Stacy on every project. With over 15 years in business and over 125 documented case studies on their blog, they bring a level of transparency rare in the industry. If you have an older home with original plaster, Carrigan Painting is a good fit.

• Dave personally writes detailed estimates and walks homeowners through what needs to happen before work begins
• Several reviewers describe Dave correctly diagnosing plaster issues that other contractors misidentified
• Popcorn ceiling pattern matching is a recurring highlight, with seamless blending that leaves no visible evidence of the original damage

"After I tried to repair a water-damaged ceiling in one of our bedrooms (and failed spectacularly), Dave and his cousin Stacy came to the rescue, erasing all evidence of my mistakes." - Sue B., Google Review

With over 30 years in business serving Western New York, Painting by Robertson has built a loyal following through a true family operation. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.4% with over 75 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating and 96% recommended on Facebook with over 20 reviews. Tom Sr. and Tom Jr. handle everything from estimates to cleanup. If you want a company where the owners are on-site doing the work every day, Painting by Robertson delivers that consistency.

• Popcorn ceiling removal is a standout service, with customers describing smooth, even results on ceilings textured for decades
• The team also paints vinyl siding, giving homeowners a cost-effective alternative to full replacement

"So many great things to say about Painting by Robertson. First, they were so quick to respond when I first contacted them, from initial contact, to the quote, the scheduling, and completion was just over a month." - Kelly, Google Review

When it comes to sheer volume of completed projects, CertaPro Painters of WNY stands out with over 540 Google reviews and a 4.7-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 84.5%. With nearly 20 years in business as a CertaPro franchise and local roots dating back to 1991, they offer the resources of a larger operation while keeping named crew members consistent across projects. They back all residential work with a two-year warranty. If you have a larger project or need work done on a tight timeline, CertaPro has the crew depth to handle it.

• The same painters appear across dozens of reviews spanning months, and customers regularly request specific crew members like Alex and Norberto
• Project managers conduct final walkthroughs to catch any missed spots before signing off
• Long-time homeowners describe CertaPro's work as the best painting they have received across multiple companies over decades

"I'm well into my 70's and Stephen didn't hesitate to move furniture around as he needed. He spent his evening at home researching stains to match our 1956 woodwork." - Sue Oliver, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Grand Island, NY, Northeast Pro Painting & Restoration earned a Chooz Score of 83.0% with over 150 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. Owner Thomas Clark personally handles estimates, and the company holds a City of Buffalo Light Commercial Contractor License. With over 5 years in business and a five-year workmanship warranty extendable to seven years, they specialize in historic home restoration alongside standard painting.

• Thomas is personally named in a large number of reviews, with customers praising his hands-on involvement from estimate through final walkthrough
• The company operates a wood milling shop for custom trim fabrication, setting them apart from standard painting contractors
• Commercial clients describe the same quality standards applied to institutional projects as residential work

"I couldn't be more pleased with the work accomplished by Thomas and his team at Northeast Pro Painting. The crew really did their due diligence to make sure I was happy with the work they had done." - Tyler Woodard, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB

Customers across Grand Island, NY area painting contractors consistently describe finished results that exceed their expectations. Quality shows up in the details: clean lines along trim, smooth ceiling finishes after popcorn removal, and careful prep work that prevents peeling down the road.

Carrigan Painting earns some of the most specific quality-related praise, particularly for plaster ceiling restoration. One reviewer described how Dave correctly diagnosed a failing rock lath ceiling that two other contractors wanted to cover with drywall, ultimately saving the homeowner from a repeat failure. "Excellent work and attention to detail. The plaster ceiling patching and restoration they did is amazing!" - Rob, Google Review. CertaPro Painters of WNY draws praise for specialty interior work, with customers highlighting smooth skim coat finishes and careful edge work on trim. "The crew did an excellent job of removing wallpaper, skim coating, and priming. Their work was professional, clean, with quite a perfect result." - Iseveryoneinsane, Google Review. Northeast Pro Painting & Restoration stands out for exterior craftsmanship, with one homeowner noting the paint application process gave them confidence the finish would last. "The process by which they put up the paint gave me a lot of confidence it will last a long time." - Kevin Heffernan, Google Review. Queen City Painting & Wash customers frequently describe Jeff's ability to handle drywall repairs and surface prep alongside painting, delivering professionally finished results.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Punctuality and efficient project timelines are among the most frequently praised qualities across painting contractors serving the Grand Island, NY area. Homeowners consistently report crews arriving when promised and completing work faster than expected.

Queen City Painting & Wash draws repeated praise for speed, with one customer reporting a full home interior completed in just three days. "Great experience. They worked around my schedule to get the job done." - Mark Moulin, Google Review. Painting by Robertson impresses customers with responsive scheduling from first contact through completion. "They were punctual, polite, professional and did an incredible job." - S P, Google Review. CertaPro Painters of WNY handles larger projects with crew depth that allows tight timelines, including one exterior job completed over a holiday weekend. "Expeditious is the term that best describes the CertaPro Crew that painted the Exterior of my Home this week." - Lynnette Hicks, Google Review. BEE Pro Painting & Contracting LLC also earns praise for showing up exactly when promised and finishing quickly. "They also arrived on time and all work was done in a timely manner." - Jackie Giomundo, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB

Cleanup and property protection are consistently highlighted across painting contractors serving Grand Island, NY and the surrounding Buffalo suburbs. Customers describe crews who cover furniture, protect floors, and leave homes looking better than they found them.

BEE Pro Painting & Contracting LLC receives some of the most detailed cleanup praise, with commercial and residential customers alike noting daily cleanup as standard practice. "They were mindful of our customers coming and going. And they returned all chairs and flower pots to their original spots." - Michaela Schmidbauer, Google Review. CertaPro Painters of WNY customers describe thorough protection of flooring and furniture throughout multi-day projects. "They covered all furniture and flooring." - Jim Groski, Google Review. Carrigan Painting earns specific praise for containing mess during plaster and ceiling repair work. "They were particular in their prep work, to contain the mess." - Bonnie Lotz, Google Review. Queen City Painting & Wash customers note that Jeff leaves spaces clean at the end of each day without leaving debris for homeowners to manage.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB

Clear, responsive communication is a recurring theme across painting contractors serving the Grand Island, NY area. Customers value contractors who return calls promptly, explain their process, and keep homeowners informed throughout the project.

Carrigan Painting stands out for how Dave explains his diagnostic process, particularly with plaster repairs. "Dave and Stacey did fantastic work. They took the time to explain everything and why a previous repair failed." - Sean Fettes, Google Review. Northeast Pro Painting & Restoration owner Thomas Clark earns praise for detailed estimates and direct contact throughout projects. "They were great - extremely professional from the first meeting through the final walkthrough." - Miranda Barell, Google Review. Painting by Robertson customers appreciate the father-son team's straightforward communication. "Communicated throughout the whole process. Very easy to work with." - Mark Blachowicz, Google Review. Queen City Painting & Wash benefits from Missy's role managing all client coordination, ensuring calls and scheduling questions get answered quickly.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Fair, transparent pricing comes up frequently in reviews across painting contractors serving Grand Island, NY and the broader Western New York area. Customers describe receiving competitive quotes, honest estimates, and final invoices that match what was promised.

Queen City Painting & Wash draws some of the most consistent pricing praise, with multiple customers mentioning reasonable rates and no surprise charges. "Jeff and Missy at Queen City Painting truly gave 5 star service. They are responsive and professional through the quoting process." - Shawn Sicchio, Google Review. BEE Pro Painting & Contracting LLC customers note competitive proposals that often come in lower than other quotes. "I used them to paint my porch. They did a beautiful job and didn't charge an arm and leg, like others!" - Melissa Lee, Google Review. Painting by Robertson reviewers describe the team's pricing as fair for the quality delivered. "Honest, timely, fairly priced and efficient. From start to finish, no complaints." - Lindsay Clark, Google Review. Carrigan Painting customers note that Dave provides written estimates with everything spelled out, giving homeowners a clear picture of costs before work begins.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB