Homeowners in Kenmore, NY have access to several highly reviewed painting contractors who consistently earn praise for reliable scheduling, clean workspaces, and quality results. Whether you need interior painting, exterior work, pressure washing, or specialty plaster repair, the top-rated companies serving this area stand out for owner involvement, repeat customer loyalty, and strong review histories across multiple platforms.
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Queen City Painting & Wash had over 100 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.1% and holds an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau. Owned and operated by Jeff and Missy Cammarata with over 15 years in business, Queen City stands out because every job is handled by W2 employees who have passed background checks, never subcontractors. If you are looking for a company where the owner is personally on every job site and you want consistent results from a crew you can trust inside your home, Queen City is a good choice.
What comes through clearly in the reviews is how many customers return again and again. Multiple reviewers mention this being their third, fourth, or even fifth project with Jeff. The range of services is also notable, covering everything from full interior repaints and popcorn ceiling removal to drywall repair and power washing.
- Several long-time customers describe a working relationship spanning over 20 years, calling Jeff back for project after project across multiple properties
- Commercial clients, including a medical office and an oral surgery practice, praise the team's ability to work around business hours and coordinate with other trades
- Wallpaper removal and skim coating are highlighted as a specialty, with one reviewer describing an eight-day medical office project handled seamlessly
"Queen City will be the only company we ever use for painting. Jeff was phenomenal. We purchased a home that needed fresh paint throughout and only had a 3 week window between closing and our move-in date. Jeff got it all done beautifully and on time." - Zak Piper, Google Review
For homeowners in the Buffalo suburbs dealing with older plaster ceilings or walls that need authentic restoration rather than a drywall cover-up, Carrigan Painting offers a specialized approach. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.7% with over 50 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 94% recommended on Facebook and 5.0 stars on Angi. Owner Dave Carrigan Jr. and his cousin Stacy have maintained this flawless record across over 15 years in business. If you own a pre-1960s home with original plaster and want a contractor who will actually repair the plaster rather than slap drywall over it, Carrigan is a good choice.
What stands out in the reviews is the educational approach Dave takes with every customer. Reviewers describe him explaining exactly why previous repairs failed and what needs to happen differently. Several customers mention that Dave correctly diagnosed plaster problems that other contractors missed entirely, saving them from costly repeat work down the road.
- Popcorn ceiling removal and pattern matching is a recurring highlight, with customers praising results that leave no visible evidence of the original texture
- Dave provides detailed written estimates on weekends, spelling out every line item rather than offering verbal ballpark figures
- Before leaving any job, the team invites homeowners to inspect completed work and flag anything with identifying tape for touch-ups
"Dave was professional and the work was excellent. I appreciate his care and attention to detail. Great work. We will call again." - Kraig Kurzanski, Google Review
With over 30 years in business serving Western New York, Painting by Robertson has built a generational reputation. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.4% with over 75 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating, plus 96% recommended on Facebook. This father-and-son team of Tom Sr. and Tom Jr. handles everything from first call to final walkthrough personally. If you value dealing with the same people from estimate through cleanup and want a company with decades of proven results, Painting by Robertson is a good choice.
The reviews reveal a company where word-of-mouth referrals drive much of the business. Several customers mention being referred by other local contractors, which speaks to the respect Robertson has earned within the trade. The team's willingness to take on exterior projects in challenging weather to meet a client's deadline also appears in more than one review.
- Fourth-time customers praise the same consistency they experienced on their first project years ago
- One reviewer described the team tackling exterior painting in cold weather to help get a home listed on the market in time
- Color selection guidance is mentioned frequently, with customers appreciating hands-on help choosing the right shades
"So many great things to say about Painting by Robertson. First, they were so quick to respond when I first contacted them, from initial contact, to the quote, the scheduling, and completion was just over a week." - Kelly, Google Review
Rounding out the top contractors serving the Kenmore, NY area, CertaPro Painters of WNY handles large-scale residential and commercial work across the region. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.5% with over 540 Google reviews and a 4.7-star rating, accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2006, with over 560 reviews across platforms including 4.5 stars on Yelp. With nearly 20 years in business as a CertaPro franchise, they bring the infrastructure to handle everything from single-room repaints to full exterior projects on large homes. If you have a bigger project that requires a larger crew and project management support, CertaPro is a good choice.
The reviews consistently highlight named crew members who show up across dozens of projects. Customers frequently request specific painters for follow-up work, and project managers like Cindy and Juan are praised for coordinating multi-day jobs and conducting thorough final walkthroughs.
- Crew members are requested by name for repeat projects, indicating the kind of consistency that builds trust over time
- Popcorn ceiling removal and skim coating are frequently highlighted as standout services
- One long-time homeowner of 40 years noted that CertaPro surpassed every painting company they had used over the decades
"CertaPro WNY was our choice from the four companies we received quotes from. They were professional from the beginning to the end. They show up when they say they're going to show up!" - Karen Scherer, Google Review
When it comes to exterior color changes and historical home restoration, Northeast Pro Painting & Restoration stands out. They earned a Chooz Score of 83.0% with over 150 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Angi. Owner Thomas Clark has built a strong presence in just over 5 years in business, earning BBB accreditation and Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite recognition across multiple Buffalo neighborhoods. If you have a Victorian or early 1900s home that needs period-accurate exterior work or you want a company that also handles carpentry and custom trim fabrication, Northeast Pro is a good choice.
What sets this company apart from standard painting contractors is their in-house carpentry capability. Reviewers describe structural repairs, custom trim work, and full exterior color changes completed in under four days. The team also takes on commercial projects, with one barbershop owner and multiple condo investors praising the results.
- Repeat customers describe coming back for second projects after being impressed by the first, with one reviewer noting this was their second hire
- Weather-related delays are handled with proactive communication, keeping homeowners informed throughout the process
- Cabinet repainting is highlighted as a specialty, with one customer noting a five-day turnaround for a complete kitchen cabinet refresh
"We worked with Northeast Pro Painting for a color change on the exterior of our house. They were great - extremely professional from the first meeting through the final walkthrough." - Miranda Barell, Google Review
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB, Yelp, Angi
