7 Best Painters Near Lancaster, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Lancaster, NY have access to several highly rated painting contractors serving the greater Buffalo and Western New York region. Across hundreds of verified reviews, the top companies stand out for crew consistency, honest communication, and results that keep customers coming back.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Sekula's Precision Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating and 100% recommended on Facebook across over 50 recommendations. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.9%. Owner Chris Sekula runs a crew-based operation where the same painters show up project after project, and reviewers frequently describe finishing ahead of schedule. If you want a company where the owner personally handles estimates and the crew treats your home like their own, Sekula's is a strong choice.

• Multiple reviewers hired Sekula's for both their home and their business, citing the same care in commercial settings
• Crew members are described as arriving early, communicating throughout the day, and checking in before making changes

"If I could give them more stars, I would! Chris and his team are consummate professionals. They ticked every box: prompt, hard-working, skilled, friendly, and respectful of our home." - Elizabeth Palmer, Google Review

When it comes to specialty plaster work and ceiling repair, Carrigan Painting has carved out a reputation few competitors can match. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.7% with over 50 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating and are 94% recommended on Facebook. With over 15 years in business, Dave Carrigan and his cousin Stacy handle every project personally. If you have an older home with plaster walls or need ceiling repair done right, Carrigan is a standout option.

• Customers with water-damaged ceilings describe Carrigan erasing all evidence of prior failed repairs
• Dave provides written estimates with every detail spelled out, rather than verbal ballpark figures
• Several reviewers note that Dave correctly diagnosed issues other contractors missed entirely

"Dave and Stacy did a terrific job with the exterior painting of our home. The work included first and second stories stucco on the front exterior, plus vinyl siding on the rear addition." - Frank Conway, Google Review

For homeowners looking for a painter who handles everything from interior repaints to drywall repair and power washing, Queen City Painting & Wash offers a versatile approach. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 150 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating. Jeff, the primary painter, personally handles each job alongside his wife Missy. If you need a reliable crew who keeps things simple and gets the work done right, Queen City is an excellent fit.

• Customers describe hiring Jeff for two, three, and even four separate projects over the years
• Wallpaper removal, drywall repair, and popcorn ceiling work are frequently praised alongside standard painting

"I've worked with Jeff at Queen City Painting several times and have been so pleased with the results. He is honest, hard-working, professional and personal at the same time." - Christine Schurkus, Google Review

A true father-and-son operation, Painting by Robertson takes a hands-on approach that shows in their reviews. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.4% with over 75 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating and are 96% recommended on Facebook. With over 30 years in business, Tom Sr. and Tom Jr. handle jobs personally from estimate to final walkthrough. If you value working directly with the people painting your home, Robertson is a great match.

• Reviewers describe the Robertsons advising against painting certain areas to save money rather than upselling
• Multiple customers hired Robertson to get homes market-ready on tight timelines, including in cold weather

"I can't say enough good things about Painting by Robertson. They came through for me when I was in a pinch, taking on exterior painting in less-than-ideal (cold!) weather so I could get my house on the market." - Ally Liebel, Google Review

With nearly 20 years in business as a franchise and local roots dating back to 1991, CertaPro Painters of WNY brings the resources of a national brand to the Lancaster, NY area. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.5% with over 540 Google reviews at a 4.7-star rating, accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2006. If you have a larger project or need a company that handles multi-room interior work and full exterior repaints on a set schedule, CertaPro is a solid option.

• Reviewers frequently mention individual crew members by name and describe requesting the same painters for follow-up projects
• Popcorn ceiling removal and skim coating are highlighted as particular strengths

"We had a fantastic painter, Alex. He did an excellent job and made our former popcorn ceiling look amazing. Alex knew what we wanted and worked hard to make sure we were totally satisfied." - Patty Cookfair, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Lancaster, NY, Northeast Pro Painting & Restoration handles everything from residential repaints to full exterior color changes and historical home restoration. They earned a Chooz Score of 83.0% with over 150 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating and 5.0 stars on Angi. Owner Thomas Clark personally manages estimates and checks in during active projects. If you have an older Buffalo-area home needing both painting and carpentry restoration, Northeast Pro is worth a call.

• Customers describe Thomas adapting project scope when circumstances change, without hassle or added charges
• The team stays late on dry weather days to maximize progress during unpredictable spring seasons

"We worked with Northeast Pro Painting for a color change on the exterior of our house. They were great - extremely professional from the first meeting through the final walkthrough." - Miranda Barell, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Across hundreds of reviews, painting customers in Lancaster, NY consistently describe results that exceed their expectations. Whether the project involves a simple room repaint or a full exterior color change, the top-rated contractors earn praise for smooth finishes, careful edge work, and results that hold up over time. Several reviewers mention that their freshly painted spaces look better than when the home was new.

Sekula's Precision Painting earns particular praise for exterior work, with customers describing even, consistent coverage on challenging surfaces. "Amazing work! We are very happy with the painting done throughout our home. The crew was very friendly and respectful of the items in our home." - Makini Beck, Google Review. Carrigan Painting stands out for plaster and ceiling repair quality, with reviewers describing seamless patches impossible to spot once painted. "We recently hired Carrigan Painting to paint our whole upstairs area including walls, ceilings and lots of trim. We are so happy with the results!" - Jennifer Masterson, Google Review. CertaPro Painters of WNY receives consistent praise for specialty ceiling work, and Painting by Robertson draws frequent compliments for wallpaper removal followed by flawless repainted surfaces. "Tom worked efficiently and took down wallpaper in almost every room in our new house and painted each room all within a week." - Megan Pearce, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Professionalism and clear communication are among the most frequently praised qualities across painting contractor reviews in Lancaster, NY. Customers describe contractors who answer calls promptly, provide detailed written estimates, and keep homeowners informed throughout every stage of the project.

Queen City Painting & Wash earns frequent praise for Jeff's responsive quoting process and Missy's communication support. "Jeff and Missy at Queen City Painting truly gave 5 star service. They are responsive and professional through the quoting process." - Shawn Sicchio, Google Review. Northeast Pro Painting & Restoration customers describe owner Thomas Clark writing out detailed estimates and following up personally. "I spoke with Thomas and he was very professional, wrote out a concise estimate, and was very warm and concerned that I would be happy with the job." - Becky, Google Review. Painting by Robertson reviewers highlight the father-son team's honesty, with one customer describing how they were advised against painting certain areas to save money. "Competency and most of all honesty. Midway through they asked me outside to look at the eves and overhangs. They told me it really wasn't necessary to paint that area." - Larry Fallon, Facebook Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Timeliness is a consistent strength among the top-rated painting contractors serving Lancaster, NY. Reviewers frequently describe crews arriving early or right on schedule, and several customers note that projects wrapped up ahead of the estimated timeline.

Queen City Painting & Wash is frequently praised for fast turnarounds without sacrificing quality, with customers describing entire interior repaints completed in a single day. Sekula's Precision Painting customers note that crews arrive on time every morning and complete work when promised. "100% recommend! Chris and his team quoted the work, showed up on time, and executed the work as promised. No surprises and easy to work with." - Hadi Sattari, Google Review. Painting by Robertson earns praise for completing full interior repaints, including wallpaper removal, within days. "Communicated throughout the whole process. Very easy to work with. Completed our job in a day and a half." - Mark Blachowicz, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Cleanup and preparation are areas where the best painting contractors in Lancaster, NY consistently earn high marks. Reviewers describe crews that cover furniture, protect flooring, tape edges carefully, and leave each room cleaner than they found it at the end of every workday.

BEE Pro Painting & Contracting LLC receives standout reviews for daily cleanup habits, with customers describing crews returning furniture to its original position and leaving workspaces spotless. "Ryan and Bianca painted the walls and ceilings of several rooms. They moved furniture and carefully covered what could not be moved." - Robert Osiewicz, Facebook Review. Sekula's Precision Painting customers describe items being covered, furniture moved, and everything returned after each session. CertaPro Painters of WNY reviewers note thorough surface preparation including scraping, sanding, and taping before any paint is applied. Painting by Robertson earns praise for keeping homes neat during multi-day projects. "They came to our rescue and did a great job painting our vinyl siding. Their price was very reasonable, they came when promised, and prepped the area as needed." - Denise Crowley, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB

While pricing varies by project scope, customers across Lancaster, NY painting contractor reviews frequently describe receiving fair, competitive quotes and feeling they got strong value for the finished results. Several reviewers mention comparing multiple estimates before choosing their contractor, and a number describe being pleasantly surprised that the final cost matched the original quote.

Painting by Robertson receives frequent mentions for reasonable pricing on labor-intensive work like popcorn ceiling removal and wallpaper stripping. "Reasonably priced as well for the hard work they put in." - Megan Pearce, Google Review. Queen City Painting & Wash customers highlight Jeff's straightforward pricing with no surprise charges. "I recently had Jeff power wash my house and deck. He did an excellent job at a reasonable price." - Karen Hurley, Google Review. BEE Pro Painting & Contracting LLC earns praise from budget-conscious homeowners, and Northeast Pro Painting & Restoration customers describe competitive estimates with the added value of receiving painting and carpentry repair from a single contractor.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB

Beyond standard interior and exterior painting, contractors serving Lancaster, NY offer a range of specialty services. From popcorn ceiling removal to plaster repair, wallpaper stripping, deck staining, and power washing, the top-rated companies bring skills that go well beyond a basic repaint.

Carrigan Painting is the standout choice for authentic plaster repair and ceiling restoration, matching original textures so repairs blend seamlessly. "After I tried to repair a water-damaged ceiling and failed spectacularly, Dave and his cousin Stacy came to the rescue, erasing all evidence of my mistakes." - Sue B., Google Review. Queen City Painting & Wash handles wallpaper removal, drywall repair, popcorn ceiling removal, and power washing alongside painting. "They have done many different jobs for us: Painting, Drywall, even Popcorn Ceiling removal and everything always turned out amazing." - Evan Quinn, Google Review. Northeast Pro Painting & Restoration offers in-house carpentry and historical home restoration for older Buffalo-area homes. Painting by Robertson is frequently hired for popcorn ceiling removal and wallpaper stripping, with reviewers praising the smooth finish left behind.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook