Advantage Paint Services
About Advantage Paint Services
Owner Zachary Guthrie founded Advantage Paint Services in 2019, building the company from his Tonawanda workshop with a team that now brings over 28 years of combined painting experience to Western New York homes and businesses. Foreman Ben oversees most residential projects, leading crew members including Nathan, Tyler, and Eric. Customer communication coordinator Selina manages scheduling and client updates throughout each project.
The company handles interior and exterior residential painting, with particular expertise in popcorn ceiling removal, cabinet refinishing, deck staining, and commercial transformations. Projects range from single-room refreshes to complete whole-house renovations and multi-unit apartment complexes. One customer noted they "handled the asbestos at no extra charge" when discovered during a popcorn ceiling removal project.
The fully insured team is EPA Lead-Safe Certified and OSHA Certified, with active membership in the Painting Contractors Association. Advantage Paint Services maintains a 3+ year paint manufacturer warranty on all projects using premium Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore products. They serve Buffalo, Amherst, Clarence, Tonawanda, Orchard Park, Williamsville, Hamburg, and surrounding Western New York communities.
Updated: 12-19-2025
Q&A Based On What Customers Are Saying About Advantage Paint Services
Q: Does Advantage Paint Services show up on time like reviews mention?
Punctuality stands out across reviews. Frank DiMaria notes the "crew showed up on time every day" throughout his project. Kathleen Wydra confirms they "were on time and actually finished early." Luke Borkowski adds that "they arrived on time" as promised. Multiple customers highlight consistent scheduling with no unexpected delays or missed appointments.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How thorough is Advantage Paint Services with cleanup after projects?
Cleanup receives consistent praise in reviews. Edward Wood states he "expected to have to do a lot of cleanup but they cleaned up after themselves better than I do." Brittany Zaccaria confirms "they left everything spotless!" John Seymour notes the crew was "neat, fast and kept everything clean" throughout the project.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What do customers say about Advantage Paint Services' popcorn ceiling removal work?
Popcorn ceiling removal is a frequently praised specialty. Rebecca Sherry says they "did wonderful work on our popcorn ceilings" and were "very professional and quick." Chris Golinski reports "Zach did an amazing job with our ceiling." Paula Schmidt adds they "did an outstanding job painting my ceiling." Judy Phakousonh notes they handled unexpected asbestos discovery at no extra charge.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Who leads Advantage Paint Services' painting crews on job sites?
Foreman Ben leads most residential projects alongside crew members Tyler, Nathan, and Eric. Brittany Zaccaria specifically praises that "Ben, Tyler and their crew were so professional" and notes "everyone was so personable." Beth Lucia highlights that "Benji was very professional, extremely polite and great at what he does." Reviews consistently mention crew members by name with positive feedback.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How responsive is Advantage Paint Services during the estimate and project process?
Communication receives strong marks overall. Thomas Camizzi was "very impressed with how responsive and professional they were." Frank DiMaria notes "they came out same day for estimate." Bryan Carvajal found them "responsive and willing to answer any questions." Fengli Zhao describes them as "very responsive and patient" throughout the process.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How did Advantage Paint Services handle the scheduling complaint from Adam Kessler's review?
The 2022 review describes a project that "dragged on about 5 months" with communication issues. However, Adam acknowledged the "work they did was very good" despite scheduling frustrations. This isolated incident contrasts with dozens of subsequent reviews praising punctuality and communication. No owner response was posted to address the concerns publicly.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Does Advantage Paint Services work on commercial projects and with other contractors?
The company handles commercial work including government buildings. PAINT TIGERS, a fellow contractor, hired Advantage Paint Services for overflow work and reports "they were responsive, easy to work with" and states "we highly recommend" them. The website features dedicated pages for restaurants, warehouses, apartment complexes, and places of worship.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What do customers say about Advantage Paint Services' attention to detail?
Detail work receives exceptional praise. Hunter Waild notes "attention to detail was amazing." Sara Karki describes their "attention to detail was impeccable and the quality of work was top-notch." Sophia Gordon found them "so thorough and paid such attention to detail." Derek Guarino calls the experience "nothing short of fantastic" with the crew being "extremely professional and detail-oriented."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Updated: 12-19-2025