Our Chooz Score evaluates 44 factors across reviews, digital presence, and business credentials. Here's what stands out for Advantage Paint Services
Western New York homeowners know how quickly Buffalo-area weather can wear down a home's exterior and interior surfaces. Peeling paint, faded siding, and aging popcorn ceilings are problems that grow worse with every passing season. Advantage Paint Services was built to solve those problems head-on. Owner Zachary Guthrie and his in-house crew of trained painters handle residential and commercial projects across Buffalo, Amherst, Clarence, Tonawanda, Orchard Park, Williamsville, Hamburg, and the surrounding suburbs of Erie County.
The team's scope runs from full interior and exterior painting to cabinet refinishing, popcorn ceiling removal, drywall repair, wallpaper removal, deck and fence staining, and epoxy floor coatings. Every project begins with a free on-site consultation and a transparent written estimate with no hidden fees. As an EPA Lead-Safe Certified firm, a Painting Contractors Association member, and an OSHA-certified operation, the crew follows strict preparation and safety protocols before a single brush hits the wall. Advantage Paint Services backs all completed work with a manufacturer paint warranty and a workmanship guarantee for lasting results.
Updated: 06-11-2026
Customers with older homes face a common headache when popcorn ceilings need to go. The crew masks all furniture and lays heavy paper over every inch of hardwood flooring before removal begins. Nate and his team then scrape, skim-coat, and repaint to a smooth finish. Kenneth Bossert noted his crew masked all furniture and effects requiring him to remove nothing while Luke Borkowski confirmed you could never tell the popcorn ceilings were there after a multi-day whole-house project.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Hidden problems like drywall cracks, soft trim, or peeling layers can surface once walls are exposed. Advantage Paint Services addresses these in real time rather than ignoring them. Charles Accivatti described a project covering popcorn ceilings, walls, trim, doors and cabinetry across multiple floors, praising how Ben and Ian handled every detail with precision and care. Frank DiMaria reported a manufacturer paint issue that arose after completion, noting the owner communicated with him and resolved all issues.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Buffalo's older aluminum-sided homes require thorough preparation before paint goes on. The process involves washing surfaces, scraping loose paint, sanding glossy areas, and filling gaps. Rich Granto described how the crew cleaned up the foundation and porch on a Friday and patched up where it needed it before returning Monday to paint. Beth Lucia, who hired three companies for estimates, said Ben and his painting partner went the extra steps to give her the best looking home on the street.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Managing a commercial paint project means coordinating around tenants, business operations, and tight timelines. Anthony Kozak hired the team to prep a condo for the market and found Ian knew exactly what he wanted and that when the job was finished the condo looked brand new. The commercial painting, interior commercial painting, and exterior commercial painting service pages outline a process that starts with a site assessment and ends with a final walkthrough.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Slow callbacks are a frustration homeowners mention repeatedly when shopping for painters. Several customers highlight speed as a differentiator. Mike, a Local Guide, wrote that Zack was quick to return his call, provide an estimate, and have his team complete the job. Annie Stevenson, who found the company through a Google search, noted that Ian replied quickly and answered all of their many questions. The team uses an online scheduling portal through DripJobs for booking consultations.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
For jobs lasting a week or more, consistent updates prevent the anxiety of wondering what is happening in your home. Nicole Wilcocks was shocked at how reasonable the pricing was and praised how the company communicated with her every step of the way. Mike Wydra, whose 2600-square-foot interior took a full crew several days, said the team even followed up a couple weeks after making sure the job was to their liking.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
New York State does not require a statewide painting contractor license. Advantage Paint Services LLC is a registered Domestic Limited Liability Company with the New York Department of State, DOS ID No. 7710382, filed September 15, 2025, with Active entity status. The company carries full insurance coverage and holds EPA Lead-Safe Certification, Painting Contractors Association membership, and OSHA safety certification.
-Verification Sources: NY Department of State Division of Corporations, BBB Business Profile
Updated: 06-11-2026