Our Chooz Score evaluates 44 factors across reviews, digital presence, and business credentials. Here's what stands out for Advantage Paint Services
When homeowners in Western New York contact Advantage Paint Services, they reach owner Zachary Guthrie directly. Founded in 2019 as a family-owned company based in Tonawanda, Guthrie schedules consultations personally, reviewing project scope and walking clients through a transparent written estimate. Each job is then assigned a dedicated project manager who coordinates daily communication from start to final walkthrough.
The company handles interior and exterior residential painting, popcorn ceiling removal, wallpaper removal, cabinet painting, deck and fence staining, drywall repair, and both interior and exterior commercial painting. Residential and commercial flooring, including epoxy coatings, rounds out the service menu. For older homes, the crew is EPA Lead-Safe Certified and equipped to identify and address hazardous materials during the pre-project assessment.
The fully licensed and insured team holds Painting Contractors Association membership and carries OSHA certification. All work is backed by a 3-plus-year paint manufacturer warranty and a workmanship guarantee. Advantage Paint Services serves Buffalo, Amherst, Clarence, Tonawanda, Orchard Park, Williamsville, Hamburg, and surrounding Erie County communities.
Updated: 04-06-2026
Response speed is a recurring theme. Mike (Local Guide) noted Zack was "quick to return my call, provide an estimate" and have his crew complete the work promptly. Beth Lucia described being "surprised at how fast AFS got back" to her after inquiring. Nicholas Bossert called the responsiveness "very refreshing" after struggling with other contractors who would not return calls. Owner Zachary Guthrie conducts estimates directly, covering scope, timeline, and pricing in one visit.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Clients consistently express surprise at how complete the results are. Kandice Dennis wrote "you could never tell they were ever textured," while Luke Borkowski described the finished surface as "smooth" with edges and moulding carefully attended to. On a large first-floor removal, Kenneth Bossert noted crew leader Nate "masked all of our furniture and effects requiring me to remove nothing" before work began. All three reviewers said they would hire Advantage Paint Services again.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Multiple reviewers describe above-standard protection measures. Luke Borkowski noted the crew "covered and taped every inch" of his hardwood floors with heavy paper rolls before a large popcorn removal, then carefully returned all furniture afterward. Mike Wydra praised that throughout a 2,600-square-foot project the crew "were also very neat" and replaced wall art after moving it. George Cotroneo confirmed crews "cleaned up after themselves" on completion without being prompted.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Large multi-room jobs appear to be a company strength. Chris Golinski arranged a 2,000-square-foot whole-house popcorn removal and repainting, calling it "a BIG job" handled over more than a week. Mike Wydra scheduled a 2,600-square-foot interior repaint with four painters working daily, noting the team "went beyond what we asked" without charging extra. Corky Kemp described project communication as clear "from start to finish" on a comparable multi-room transformation.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Punctuality and arrival updates appear consistently across reviews. Grace wrote the crew was "always on time" and kept in contact before each arrival. Mike (Local Guide) described the team as "professional, punctual and detail oriented." Beth Lucia noted that foreman Benjamin arrived reliably each morning and explained the day's plan before crews began work. George Cotroneo added they were "very polite" and cleaned up thoroughly after completing his interior project without any prompting.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
One 2-star review from Adam Kessler describes a porch and handrail project from 2022 where communication delays pushed work back five months after a deposit. He also noted his garden was damaged by drop cloths during the job. While Kessler acknowledged "the quality was decent" at completion, the wait and lack of proactive updates were frustrating. No owner response is visible on that review, and it represents the one notable service concern across an otherwise five-star record.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Two contractor businesses left public Google endorsements, which is uncommon in residential painter reviews. PAINT TIGERS referenced a "huge government project" where Advantage Paint Services led coordination and "beat the clients expectations" despite an unrealistic workload. Insta Painting, a PCA member contractor based in Florida, praised Advantage as a "reputable company" after connecting their own customer with Zach for local service. Peer endorsements from competing professionals signal credibility that customer reviews alone cannot replicate.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
New York State does not require a state-level painting contractor license. However, the City of Buffalo requires a General Contractor License for contractors operating within city limits. Advantage Paint Services LLC is a Domestic Limited Liability Company registered with the New York Department of State, DOS ID No. 7710382, filed September 15, 2025, in Erie County, with Active status. The registered address on file is 440 Northwood Dr STE 1, Buffalo, NY 14223.
-Verification Sources: NY Department of State Division of Corporations
Updated: 04-07-2026