3 Best Painters Near North Massapequa, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

When it comes to hiring painters in North Massapequa, NY, homeowners have a strong field of options - contractors with deep community roots, high review volumes, and consistent results across interior and exterior projects. Based on our Chooz Score analysis, which weighs review volume, platform diversity, star ratings, and business credentials, here are the top-rated painting contractors serving the North Massapequa, NY area.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC had over 160 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating - an impressive total at that volume. The company earned a Chooz Score of 89.0%, the highest among painting contractors serving North Massapequa, NY, backed by 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi. Owner Todd Rumfola has been building his reputation across Nassau and Suffolk County for over 10 years in business, holding a Suffolk County Home Improvement License verified active through 2027 and a lead-safe certification for work on older homes. Whether the project is interior rooms, power washing, or exterior prep, Todd and his crew bring the same level of care from start to finish.

What stands out from the reviews is how quickly Todd responds - multiple customers describe reaching out on a Sunday afternoon or evening and hearing back within the hour. Painter Jerry is cited nearly as often as Todd himself, and reviewers consistently note the crew is trustworthy enough to leave working in an empty house. If you want a small, owner-operated team where the same familiar faces show up from estimate through completion, South Bay is a strong pick for homeowners in North Massapequa, NY.

• South Bay handles both painting and power washing, making them a convenient single call for homeowners who need exterior cleaning and fresh paint in the same season.
• Reviewers frequently describe Todd walking the property before and after each job, explaining the process and confirming the customer is satisfied before packing up.
• Several reviews come from customers who found South Bay through a neighbor or family referral - a consistent signal of strong word-of-mouth across the Long Island South Shore.

For homeowners dealing with more involved or specialty painting projects, Teall Painting has built a following that runs well beyond standard bedroom-and-ceiling work. The company earned a Chooz Score of 87.6%, with over 75 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Charlie Cascio leads the company with over 12 years in business, and all work is backed by a 2-year workmanship warranty and 100% Satisfaction Guarantee. A Nassau County Home Improvement License is verified active, and all painters on staff carry a minimum of five years of professional experience with background checks completed before joining the team.

The review record at Teall shows a company comfortable with challenging work - mahogany door refinishing that two previous painters could not get right, stucco exterior painting, western red cedar home restoration, wainscoting installation, and commercial space renovations alongside standard interior and exterior jobs. Owner Charlie provides detailed, itemized estimates upfront, delivers daily project updates during multi-day work, and follows up after jobs are completed. If you have a specialty or larger-scale project, Teall Painting is a well-prepared choice.

• Teall has completed salon and fitness studio renovations alongside residential homes, which speaks to the crew's comfort with commercial-level prep and precision finishing.
• Charlie's estimates are described as itemized and thorough - reviewers consistently note there were no surprises when it came to pricing or scope once the project began.
• Several customers are already on their second or third project with Teall, with one reviewer booking a third job before the second was even finished.

With the largest review footprint in this group, Frank's Painting of LI LLC has clearly built a strong reputation across Nassau and Western Suffolk Counties. At the time of our analysis, the company had over 200 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Angi with over 340 Angi reviews, 4.7 stars on Yelp with over 70 Yelp reviews, and 98% recommended on Facebook. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.6%, and their Nassau County Home Improvement License has been verified active through November 2027 with zero complaints and zero violations on file. Since 2015, Frank's team has completed over 3,000 residential projects.

A few things stand out in the reviews. Frank's offers access to an interior designer and color specialist named Dyane - a value-add that several customers specifically mention as helpful during the planning phase. Multiple homeowners describe hiring Frank's to fix or redo work left behind by a previous contractor, which points to strong skill in prep work, spackle repair, and wall restoration. The company explicitly does not subcontract - Jose, Alfredo, Danny, and Marcelo are full-time employees whose names appear consistently across platforms. For homeowners with larger interior projects, wallpaper removal, or cabinet refinishing needs, Frank's Painting of LI is a thorough and well-rounded option.

• Frank's also handles power washing, with dedicated crew members handling deck, patio, and cedar shingle cleaning - useful if you want painting and exterior prep covered by the same company.
• Owner Frank has a strong pattern of personal follow-up on any post-job concerns; multiple reviewers note he addressed questions or touch-ups promptly and without hassle.
• Customers who start with a single room frequently return for whole-house projects - the review record includes several third and fourth-time clients, with one reviewer on their second whole-home job with Frank's.

Owner Denis Erazo of Big Expert Painting LLC takes a hands-on approach that comes through clearly in the review record. The company earned a Chooz Score of 87.0%, with over 130 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. A Suffolk County Home Improvement License is verified active through 2027, and the company holds EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification - an important credential for homeowners in communities with mid-20th century housing stock. Denis personally handles every estimate and stays in direct contact throughout each project, with reviewers describing same-day responses even on weekends.

One pattern that stands out across Big Expert reviews is scope expansion mid-project. Customers who hire Denis for two or three rooms often end up adding more before the project is finished, simply because they are happy enough to keep going. Beyond standard painting, the company's services include sheetrock installation, crown molding, cabinet resurfacing, pool painting, and power washing. For North Massapequa, NY homeowners who want one contractor to handle several types of work, Big Expert offers both the range of skills and the owner involvement to make that work well.

• The company's service list goes well beyond paint: reviews mention marble flooring, gym floor installation, kitchen cabinet resurfacing, and TV mounting alongside drywall and painting work.
• Denis is known for fast callbacks, including on weekends - a detail that appears across multiple reviews from customers who appreciated not waiting days for an estimate response.
• Big Expert's lead-safe certification is a practical advantage for North Massapequa homes built before 1978, making the company a responsible choice for older residential properties.

Rounding out the top contractors serving North Massapequa, NY, Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting brings over 25 years in business and one of the deepest review records on Long Island. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Walker had over 245 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, along with 4.8 stars on Yelp with over 25 Yelp reviews, 5.0 stars on Angi with over 80 Angi reviews, and 16 Faves on Nextdoor. The company earned a Chooz Score of 85.7% and holds both a Nassau County Home Improvement License (zero complaints, zero violations) and a NYC DCWP Home Improvement Contractor License. Most employees have been with Walker for over 15 years, and the consistency shows in reviews where the same crew names appear across unrelated projects from different customers.

Project manager Sal Sciame is the name customers encounter most, handling estimates, walkthroughs, and project oversight from start to finish. Reviews describe Sal as reliably responsive - typically returning calls the same day and scheduling estimates for the following day. The loyal customer base here is notable even by Long Island standards: Karen Berrios has hired Walker four times for exterior painting, a full kitchen including cabinets, and other projects; Charles Alaimo has lost count of how many projects they have done together; and one reviewer describes using the company across over 20 years of homeownership. If you are looking to build a long-term relationship with a painting contractor, Walker has the track record to support it.

• Walker handles interior and exterior painting, cabinet refinishing, deck staining, wallpaper removal, and plastering - a broad range that helps explain why customers keep returning for different project types.
• The company has a strong pattern of extended family and neighbor referrals - multiple reviewers mention siblings, adult children, or neighbors all becoming Walker customers after hearing about their experience firsthand.
• Sal is known for offering color suggestions during the estimate process, which several reviewers found genuinely helpful when selecting paint for kitchens and cabinetry.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi, Nextdoor

Quality and attention to detail are consistent themes across reviews for painting contractors serving North Massapequa, NY. At South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC, reviewers describe painter Jerry as focused and precise - with several customers noting that he addressed any area that did not meet their expectations before leaving the job. Teall Painting customers frequently use words like flawless and perfect to describe finished rooms, and owner Charlie has drawn consistent praise for tackling specialty challenges - from deep wall cracks to stucco surfaces - that other contractors were unwilling or unable to handle properly.

At Frank's Painting of LI LLC, the prep work receives as much attention as the paint itself. Several reviewers hired Frank's specifically to redo work left behind by other contractors, and the crew's ability to skim coat, spackle, and repair older plaster walls before painting is mentioned across Google, Facebook, and Angi reviews. Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting customers echo similar praise, with multiple reviewers describing crew members as perfectionists whose careful prep and sanding work is what sets the final result apart. Big Expert Painting LLC customers highlight Denis's eye for detail - one reviewer was so impressed with a ceiling sheetrock repair that she immediately booked Denis for her kitchen cabinets on the same visit. Across all of these contractors, quality appears to be consistent rather than occasional.

• "Working with Charlie and his crew at Teall Painting was an absolute pleasure. Their work was top quality at a fair price. On time, on budget and extremely responsive. The crew cleaned up after themselves every day and left my house looking remarkable." - Nicholas C., Google Review

• "It's about the prep and the time they took filling holes, sanding and skimming where necessary that made all the difference. Our walls look like new!" - Anne C., Google Review (Walker Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Cleanup and daily organization are among the most consistently praised qualities across painting contractors serving North Massapequa, NY. Customers of Frank's Painting of LI LLC describe crews hanging dust barriers between rooms, covering furniture and floors with drop cloths, and leaving spaces cleaner than they found them - a phrase that appears in multiple variations across Google, Facebook, and Angi reviews. At Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge, the approach is similar: one customer who handed over a house key for a six-day whole-home renovation described arriving home each evening to a clean, usable house - furniture back in place and every surface tidied before the crew left for the day.

South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC customers regularly note that painter Rich leaves spaces spotless after each session, and several reviews mention that the crew cleaned not just their direct work area but surrounding surfaces that picked up incidental dust during prep. Teall Painting reviewers highlight daily cleanup as a consistent strength, with customers noting that even during multi-day projects they could use their kitchens and living spaces each evening. Big Expert Painting LLC customers describe Denis's crew moving and covering all furniture carefully before starting and restoring everything to its original position before leaving. Across all of these companies, prep work and property protection appear to be standard practice rather than an occasional extra effort.

• "Frank and his team were kind and professional. Frank's team, led by Danny, took great care of our household items and put everything back when they were done." - Kerry T., Google Review (Frank's Painting of LI LLC)

• "Start to finish, less than 2 days! Everything looks perfect, we are so happy with the professional and personal care given to us. Any furniture was moved and wrapped up, put back to its original spot, and the place was left immaculately cleaned up." - Patti L., Google Review (Precision Painting Plus)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Angi, Yelp

Communication and professionalism are among the most frequently mentioned strengths for painting contractors in North Massapequa, NY. At South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC, owner Todd Rumfola is described as someone who responds to calls and texts within hours, including weekends and Sunday afternoons. Multiple reviewers note that Todd texted the night before and the morning of the job to confirm timing, and stayed in communication throughout each project. Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting customers point to Sal Sciame as the company's communication anchor - he handles estimates, provides detailed walkthroughs, stays available by phone throughout projects, and follows up after completion to confirm the customer is satisfied.

Teall Painting reviews consistently mention that owner Charlie Cascio provides daily updates during multi-day jobs, telling customers what stage the crew is at and what to expect the following day. Reviewers who hired Teall for whole-house or complex exterior work describe the communication as one of the things that made a potentially stressful process feel straightforward. Frank's Painting of LI LLC is particularly noted for Frank's personal follow-up on post-job questions or concerns, with multiple reviewers describing a fast and direct response when they called after the project was finished. Big Expert Painting LLC's Denis Erazo is consistently described as someone who answers calls directly, provides same-day estimates when possible, and keeps customers involved throughout the project. Each of these contractors treats communication as part of the job rather than an afterthought.

• "Working with South Bay was such a great experience! I reached out for a quote on a Sunday afternoon and received almost an immediate response. Todd came the very next day, provided the quote within an hour or so of being at our home, and made the booking process so simple and easy." - Julia S., Google Review

• "Charlie was the best, fair, honest and very customer oriented. Renee and Oscar were great painters - very punctual, courteous and respectful. The final touch-up and walkthrough was a great experience. I would highly recommend Charlie and his team at Teall Painting." - Jim G., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Pricing satisfaction is a recurring theme across reviews for painting contractors in North Massapequa, NY. Customers of Big Expert Painting LLC frequently cite competitive pricing as both the reason they chose Denis and the reason they came back - with one reviewer noting that a full exterior paint job completed in the heat of summer stayed on schedule and came in at a very reasonable cost. At South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC, Todd's pricing is consistently described as fair for the quality delivered, and one reviewer noted that Todd added gutter cleaning to a power washing job at no extra charge during a visit prompted by a separate service request.

Teall Painting's owner Charlie provides detailed, itemized estimates upfront, and multiple reviewers specifically praise this practice for removing uncertainty about cost. One customer described comparing multiple painters before a home sale and choosing Teall specifically because the pricing was competitive while the 2-year workmanship warranty added real value to the quote. Frank's Painting of LI LLC and Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting customers similarly describe pricing as fair and in line with expectations, with Frank's earning particular mention for keeping to the quoted amount without add-ons once work was underway. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge reviewers also cite competitive pricing relative to the local market, with multiple customers noting they collected several estimates before choosing Precision. Across all of these contractors, the prevailing sentiment is that the quality of work justified the price paid.

• "I hired Precision Painting after getting 3 estimates. They are by far the most reasonably priced." - Helen G., Google Review (Precision Painting Plus)

• "We had about a half dozen painters come by and look at the job and they were all crazy expensive. We decided to go with Charlie from Teall Painting... I could not have been more pleased." - Greg S., Google Review (Teall Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Punctuality and reliability with scheduling are consistently strong marks across painting contractors in North Massapequa, NY. Customers of Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting describe Sal Sciame as someone who typically returns calls the same day, schedules estimates for the next, and arrives exactly when promised. One reviewer who called Walker for the first time noted she received an appointment and estimate the same day she reached out, with painting scheduled quickly after. At South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC, Todd's scheduling process includes a text the night before and a confirmation message the morning of the job - a small practice that multiple reviewers specifically called out as a mark of professionalism that is not always found with home improvement contractors.

Teall Painting earns consistent praise for arriving on time across multi-day projects, with reviewers noting that crew members showed up at the expected time each morning and worked full days without cutting hours short. Frank's Painting of LI LLC customers echo the same pattern - one reviewer noted a crew arrived not only on time but early, and another described a multi-room project completed faster than expected without any drop in quality. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge customers describe the team as consistently punctual throughout projects that ranged from a single day to a full week, with one customer noting the job was finished earlier than the original estimate. For homeowners in North Massapequa, NY managing tight timelines around moves, sales, or renovations, these contractors have a strong track record of showing up and following through.

• "From the initial visit with Charlie to Victor coming to complete this job, everything ran very smoothly and professionally. Victor was right on time and a pleasure to work with. The job turned out beautifully and was completed in less time than expected." - Barbara R., Google Review (Teall Painting)

• "Their crew came that Wednesday not only on time but early. They were so polite. We left the house and totally trusted them. They finished painting 4 rooms in 3 days. Their work was excellent and the price was excellent." - Randy C., Google Review (Frank's Painting of LI LLC)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Repeat business is one of the most telling signals in the review records for painting contractors serving North Massapequa, NY. At Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting, the loyalty runs deep: Karen Berrios has hired the company four times for exterior painting, a full kitchen including cabinets, and other projects; Charles Alaimo has hired them so many times he has lost count; and one reviewer describes using the company across over 20 years of homeownership. At South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC, Joanna Castagnaro has relied on the company for several years running, and Judy Fischer returned for a complete redo of three bedrooms and an office - noting she is already looking forward to the next project in the spring.

Frank's Painting of LI LLC shows a similar pattern - Ed P. used them for the fourth time on his most recent job, Doreen B. has hired them three times, and multiple reviewers describe a cycle of returning for progressively larger projects after being satisfied with a smaller one. Big Expert Painting LLC customers follow the same trend: Michael Curley has relied on Denis for over 7 years across projects ranging from porch columns to full interior repaints, and Sara Galante hired Denis for three rooms, was so satisfied she immediately added two more, and plans to call again for future work. Teall Painting and Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge show consistent repeat customer patterns in their review records as well. For homeowners in North Massapequa, NY looking for a long-term painting relationship rather than a one-time hire, these contractors have demonstrated the kind of consistency that builds lasting loyalty.

• "We've contracted Walker 4x. They're great. Always professional, work cleanly, thorough and clearly take pride in the work. Sal is always available and gives good suggestions." - Karen B., Google Review (Walker Painting)

• "Todd is extremely reliable and does a great job with all projects. We have been using him for several years now and never disappoints in quality and communication as well. Will keep going back year after year!" - Joanna C., Google Review (South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi