Best Painters Near Sterling Forest, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

The painting contractors serving Sterling Forest, NY take on a wide variety of projects - from cedar and log exteriors common in this wooded corner of Orange County, to kitchen cabinet refinishing, historic home restoration, and deck staining. Chooz Painters analyzed hundreds of reviews across five companies to identify the top-rated options for homeowners and businesses in the area.

CertaPro Painters of Orange County, NY leads the list with a Chooz Score of 87.6%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 175 Google reviews with a 4.8-star rating, along with 4.9 stars on Angi with over 20 Angi reviews and over 15 Yelp reviews. Based in Warwick with over 12 years in business, CertaPro holds Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite recognition for 2022 and 2023 and is a member of the Warwick Valley Chamber of Commerce. What stands out most in the reviews is the pattern of returning customers - people who started with one exterior project and kept coming back for deck staining, power washing, kitchen cabinets, and interior rooms across multiple seasons. Owner Brendan McManus and painter Askold are called out by name across dozens of reviews. If you want a contractor with a deep track record in the region and a team you can rely on year after year, CertaPro Painters of Orange County, NY is a strong fit.

• Commercial projects appear regularly in the review history, including rectories, office buildings, and commercial facades alongside residential work.
• Painter Askold receives specific praise for kitchen cabinet refinishing so precise that neighbors assumed the finished cabinets were brand new.
• Office coordinator Joanne Stefanacci is consistently praised for rapid call-backs and scheduling communication when Brendan is on-site.
• The crew has handled specialty surfaces including log cabins, stamped concrete patios, and brick fireplaces.

"CertaPro Painters of Warwick are the only painters we've used multiple times over multiple years because there's no drama, just a great paint job." - Jerry Zimmerman, Google Review

Also serving Sterling Forest, NY with a matching Chooz Score of 87.6%, Pro Painting Plus operates out of Monroe and brings a hands-on ownership approach to every project. Owner Rob McRae visits job sites daily to review progress and check in with customers - a detail that comes up across review after review. The crew handles exterior and interior projects including cedar siding, deck restoration, historic structures, kitchen cabinet refinishing, and wall repair. When one customer was left without a painter four days before their move-in, Rob stepped in within an hour of the call and had crews on site the next morning. If you want an owner who is personally present throughout a project and not just at the estimate stage, Pro Painting Plus is a good choice.

• Deck staining and restoration appears throughout the reviews, with customers describing dramatic improvements on weathered or damaged wood surfaces.
• The crew has handled unusual projects including an 1865 tin roof and a community church exterior, each requiring careful material selection.
• Crew members Luis and Miguel are named across multiple interior reviews for wall repair and thorough prep work.

"Rob was exact with what could be done to fix it and gave us a very generous quote. His team arrived at our home on time and worked diligently, sanding the old paint off before applying a fresh coat of the correct stain." - Eric Eng, Google Review

While CertaPro and Pro Painting Plus lead at the top, MGP Painting Inc. is close behind with a Chooz Score of 87.2%. Based in Orangeburg, at the time of our analysis they had over 200 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, 5.0 stars on Angi, and 96% recommended on Facebook. Owner Moises has been building the company since incorporating in Rockland County over 13 years ago, and customers describe him as personally involved from initial estimate through final walkthrough. MGP covers a wide project range: interior rooms, exterior painting, deck staining, wallpaper installation, cabinet refinishing, and specialty finishes. One customer noted that Moises identified a cost-saving approach on a townhome project that saved her family over $2,000 - the kind of proactive problem-solving that shows up throughout the review record. If you have a complex or multi-room project and want an owner who actively problem-solves on the job, MGP Painting Inc. is worth reaching out to.

• Wallpaper installation, including patterned and specialty finishes, appears across multiple reviews as a genuine niche strength for this crew.
• Office manager Rachel earns separate praise for keeping customers informed on scheduling, color selections, and project timelines.
• Moises personally responds to virtually every Google review with specific follow-up tied to each individual project.

"I have worked with Moises and his people for 3 big home painting projects over the last 5 years. They consistently do a professional and reliable job." - Barbara Strauss, Google Review

With a family history in the painting trade spanning over 90 years and a New York corporation active since 1980, George Apap Inc. is one of the most established painting operations in the Hudson Valley. Their Chooz Score is 85.1%, and the last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 450 Google reviews with a 4.8-star rating, 4.6 stars on Angi with over 140 Angi reviews, 90% recommended on Facebook, and over 25 Yelp reviews. Based in Patterson with a showroom in Ridgefield, CT, the company handles interior and exterior painting alongside carpentry, deck work, power washing, and soft washing. Each project receives a dedicated Project Manager - Leah, Erika, Annika, and Liz all appear by name in reviews - keeping communication organized even on large or multi-phase jobs. Crew leaders DJ, Frank, Wayne, Leon, and Sean appear consistently across years of reviews, reflecting stable, experienced teams. If you want a full-service, multi-trade company with structured project management and a proven long track record, George Apap Inc. is a strong fit.

• A dedicated Project Manager is assigned to each job, providing a single point of contact from scheduling through completion.
• Carpentry and painting are handled by separate specialized teams, allowing the company to address deck repairs, rotted wood, and trim work alongside paint jobs.
• Customers describe trusting the crew to complete large, multi-room projects independently while traveling or at work.

"I had to be out of town and the crew completed all of the detailed work that needed to be done while I was gone. I trust the entire team implicitly." - Richard Hudson Jr., Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Sterling Forest, NY, KB Quality Painting earned a Chooz Score of 83.2% with over 120 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating across every review on file. Owner Kevin operates out of Highland Mills, works exclusively with Benjamin Moore products, and has been known to contact paint manufacturers before a job to confirm the right application method for a specific surface. Multiple landlords managing rental properties appear in the reviews, and several customers describe projects finishing ahead of the projected schedule. If you want a tight-knit, owner-operated crew with a perfect review record and a careful approach to product selection, KB Quality Painting is worth a call.

• Kevin completed a two-tier deck staining project in a day and a half against a three-day estimate, without cutting corners on prep or finish work.
• Multiple landlords and property investors appear in the reviews, reflecting consistent rental and multi-unit work in the area.
• Crew member Caesar is specifically recognized for focused interior detail work on larger residential jobs.

"Kevin and his team exceeded all of my expectations. My house came out absolutely flawless - and their attention to detail is highly impressive. They were on time, professional, polite, and an amazing example of a dedicated team - all at an outstanding price." - Noel McGuinness, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Workmanship quality is the most consistently praised attribute across hundreds of reviews for painters serving Sterling Forest, NY. Customers describe results that go beyond expectations - surfaces prepared carefully, edges clean, and finished products that make rooms and exteriors look genuinely refreshed.

CertaPro Painters of Orange County, NY earns consistent praise for detailed work across diverse surfaces, from kitchen cabinet refinishing to log cabin exteriors and brick fireplaces. Pro Painting Plus draws strong reviews for exterior cedar and wood siding work, with owner Rob's daily site visits keeping quality on track at every stage. MGP Painting Inc. customers regularly highlight thorough prep work before any paint is applied - floors protected, furniture covered, ceilings and walls patched carefully - and the finished results reflect it. George Apap Inc., with a family tradition of craftsmanship stretching over 90 years, draws reviews from customers who call it the best painting experience they have ever had. And KB Quality Painting earns its perfect 5.0-star rating through results that leave customers describing their homes as looking completely new after the job is done.

"Askold painted my 30 year old kitchen cabinets and everyone thought they were brand new! He is a true artist!" - Dianne Latterman, Google Review (CertaPro Painters of Orange County, NY)
"The prep work, painting and detail painting is beautiful. Everything in my home was well protected and the team was careful not to damage anything." - Mary Farrell Murphy, Google Review (George Apap Inc.)
"He showed up on time, he helped me to pick the right color, which I really appreciated, and he did an amazing painting job! I was impressed by how fast he did it without sacrificing quality." - Luciana Freitas, Google Review (KB Quality Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Clear, prompt communication from estimate through final walkthrough is a strong theme across reviews of painters serving Sterling Forest, NY. Customers describe contractors who respond quickly to calls and texts, keep homeowners informed about scheduling, and follow up after the job to confirm satisfaction.

CertaPro Painters of Orange County, NY owner Brendan McManus handles estimates and maintains contact throughout projects, with office coordinator Joanne Stefanacci fielding calls and emails when Brendan is on-site - reviewers describe responses arriving within minutes. MGP Painting Inc. owner Moises is praised for issuing detailed, itemized quotes the same day of a first contact, and for staying reachable throughout every project. Office manager Rachel earns her own mention in reviews for keeping customers updated on timing, materials, and color selections. Pro Painting Plus customers highlight owner Rob McRae's daily site check-ins as a key differentiator - customers always know exactly where the project stands. For George Apap Inc., the dedicated Project Manager system gives each customer a named point of contact for the entire job, with Leah, Erika, Annika, and Liz all appearing by name as examples of effective project coordination. KB Quality Painting owner Kevin earns consistent praise for responding quickly to texts and calls, helping customers choose colors, and following up after completion.

"Moises and the MGP team are so professional starting from their office to the field. The office did a really great job keeping me posted on dates, paint brands and colors." - Scotty Hernandez, Google Review (MGP Painting Inc.)
"The organization and communication, through Erika, made everything so easy. Team leader Leon was just amazing and his team as well." - Valarie Vennard, Google Review (George Apap Inc.)
"Kevin is SO knowledgeable, helpful, and professional. He quoted me a fantastic price and I was more than happy working with him from start to finish. Clear communication, promising, and honest." - Nina Morris, Google Review (KB Quality Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Prep work and cleanup are two of the most consistently praised aspects of painters serving Sterling Forest, NY. Customers repeatedly describe arriving home after a day's work to find their space spotless - furniture protected, floors covered, surfaces properly patched, and all debris removed before the crew left for the day.

Pro Painting Plus customers specifically call out the company's prep work as a defining strength, noting it is what produces the professional final finish. Crew members Herbie and Juan are named in reviews for repairing cracks, nail pops, and wall seams before any painting begins. MGP Painting Inc. customers describe careful protection of newly refinished floors, covered furniture, and patched ceiling holes as standard practice before a drop of paint is applied. Crew members Alex and Walter have been recognized for working thoroughly while protecting every surrounding surface. At CertaPro Painters of Orange County, NY, multiple reviewers describe leaving for work and returning to a completed, clean job - including one customer whose three huskies the crew navigated around all day without incident. George Apap Inc. customers describe crews that cover landscaping before exterior work begins, and KB Quality Painting customers note their yard was cleaned at the end of every day during a multi-day deck staining project.

"They took great care prepping the interior and our newly refinished floors to avoid any damage to them. Our ceilings, walls, doors and trim all look brand new." - Valerie Gruber, Google Review (MGP Painting Inc.)
"I am always impressed with the prep work - which gives that professional finish. Plus Rob visits the site, reviews the work and has any imperfection corrected." - Tracey Brooker, Google Review (Pro Painting Plus)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

On-time arrivals and adherence to project timelines are recurring themes across reviews of painters serving Sterling Forest, NY. Customers describe crews that show up when they say they will, communicate ahead of time if anything changes, and finish on or ahead of the estimated schedule.

KB Quality Painting owner Kevin completed a two-tier deck staining project in a day and a half against a three-day estimate - without skipping any prep or finish steps. CertaPro Painters of Orange County, NY earns specific praise for finishing interior projects before the projected timeline, including one job completed while homeowners were away that came in ahead of schedule. Pro Painting Plus stepped in when another contractor bailed four days before a customer's move-in date - Rob had crews on site the next morning. MGP Painting Inc. customers describe projects starting within days of signing a contract and progressing on the timeline outlined at the estimate stage. George Apap Inc. assigns a Project Manager to each job, which keeps timelines organized even on large, multi-room projects - customers describe crews arriving at 7 a.m. and working full days to hit completion targets.

"They completed the job before the given timeline. Which typically is unheard of." - Heather Solari, Google Review (CertaPro Painters of Orange County, NY)
"Kevin said it would take about 3 days to complete. Not only did he and his crew do an amazing job with the deck, they finished it in a day and a half." - NerfgunTimmy, Google Review (KB Quality Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Value and pricing are a recurring theme across reviews of painters serving Sterling Forest, NY. Customers across all five top-rated companies describe estimates that came in fair, quotes explained clearly, and final invoices that matched expectations without unexpected add-ons.

KB Quality Painting is frequently described as "reasonably priced" or offering "great pricing," with multiple customers noting that Kevin's estimate came in below what they expected for the quality delivered. MGP Painting Inc. owner Moises earned direct credit for a suggestion that saved one customer's family over $2,000 on a townhome project - a pattern of transparent, client-first pricing that runs through the reviews. One customer even noted that the crew fixed a damaged window sill during the job without raising the cost. Pro Painting Plus draws praise from customers who note they received quality work at a fair and clearly explained price, including a very generous quote on a deck repair job another contractor had made more complicated. CertaPro Painters of Orange County, NY is consistently described as competitive on price relative to the level of service, with multiple reviewers noting strong value on large-scale, multi-service projects. George Apap Inc. is noted by some reviewers as a higher-price option, though those same reviewers typically note that the structured project management, dedicated crews, and multi-trade capabilities justify the investment.

"Great pricing, very clean after the fact and Kevin is such a nice guy. Will use again in the future." - Rich Agnello, Google Review (KB Quality Painting)
"They fixed any studs showing, and even fixed a damaged window sill without raising the cost. I will definitely be back." - Claudia Brennan, Google Review (MGP Painting Inc.)
"Multiple ceilings and 2 rooms were painted and repaired to perfection. Incredible work. You will not regret working with them. Also very fair pricing." - Lyn Nelson, Google Review (Pro Painting Plus)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi