Best Painters Near Thiells, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Painting contractors serving Thiells, NY and the broader Rockland County area maintain some of the strongest review records in the region, with customers repeatedly pointing to high-quality results, reliable crews, and owners who stay personally involved from estimate through completion. Three companies have earned Chooz Scores above 86% for homeowners in the Thiells, NY area.

Pro Painting Plus holds the top spot with a Chooz Score of 87.6%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 75 Google reviews with a strong 4.9-star rating. Owner Rob McRae is a consistent presence throughout every project - he personally conducts walk-through estimates that catch issues other contractors miss, visits job sites daily, and keeps clients updated on progress. The company handles an impressive range of surfaces: cedar, teak, and pine siding; a historic tin roof dating to 1865; lake docks; gutters; deck staining; kitchen cabinet refinishing; and full interior and exterior jobs. If you have a specialty or challenging surface project in Thiells, NY, Pro Painting Plus is well worth a call.

Multiple reviewers describe named crew members - Dario, Oscar, Luis, Miguel, Herbie, and Juan - showing up on time and working with careful attention. One customer described Rob responding within an hour after a prior contractor abandoned a job just four days before a scheduled move-in and completing the project on time.

• Takes on specialty surfaces including historic tin roofing, cedar and teak siding, and lake docks - a broader range than most local painting crews
• Owner Rob McRae visits each job site daily and personally checks in with clients throughout the project
• Named crew members appear repeatedly across independent reviews, indicating a consistent core team

"Rob told me he would make my house beautiful, but I could never believe what they have done with my cedar house and different woods cedar, teak and pine - I can not believe this is the same house." - Mike Jergensen, Google Review

Also serving the Thiells, NY area, MGP Painting, Inc. brings a Chooz Score of 87.2% and one of the deepest review records in Rockland County. At the time of our analysis, they had over 200 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, along with 5.0 stars on Angi and 96% recommended on Facebook. Owner Moises founded the company in Orangeburg, NY over 13 years ago, and the company covers a wide range of projects - from standard interior and exterior painting to wallpaper installation, kitchen cabinet resurfacing, and commercial properties including libraries and professional studios. Repeat customers tell the story for MGP Painting, Inc.: Bob Spence describes his entire family as long-term repeat customers, and several reviewers mention hiring the company for a second, third, or fourth project. If you want a contractor with a broad track record and the ability to handle complex multi-room or multi-surface work, MGP Painting, Inc. is a reliable choice.

Office coordinator Rachel is mentioned by reviewers for keeping clients posted on scheduling and paint brand selections. Moises personally responds to nearly every Google review with details specific to the project, not boilerplate replies. Specialized crew members also handle wallpaper installation, custom closet painting, and commercial finishes for professional spaces.

• Handles wallpaper installation and patterned paper in addition to standard painting services
• Office coordinator Rachel named by reviewers for clear communication and smooth scheduling
• Commercial clients include libraries, hair studios, and multi-unit residential properties
• Owner Moises responds personally to reviews with project-specific details

"I noticed the professionalism and detail-oriented crew of MGP painting my local library; I went in to hire the company to paint part of my house. The price was fair for the work done." - Loretta Jara, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Thiells, NY, Aquinas Painting Contractors brings nearly 40 years in business - founded in 1987 and now run by partner Alex Solis, who carries on the reputation built by founder Jim Dugandzic. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.3%, and the last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 80 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, along with 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi. All painters carry OSHA certification, backed by a Rockland County Home Improvement Contractor License. Beyond standard residential work, reviewers describe Aquinas Painting Contractors handling pool deck power washing, commercial warehouse painting, bathroom ceiling repairs after water damage, and small acts of care - like replacing exterior light bulbs that were too high for the homeowner to reach. For customers who want a long-established contractor that genuinely goes beyond the scope of the job, Aquinas Painting Contractors is a strong fit.

The loyalty pattern at Aquinas is striking - one client describes over 20 consecutive years of use, starting with founder Jim and continuing with Alex and the current crew. Veronica Mendez brought the team in across multiple properties including a convent exterior and interior bedrooms, and Frank Cataldo hired them three times in a single year and a half.

• All painters carry OSHA certification, backed by a Rockland County Home Improvement Contractor License
• Handles commercial projects including warehouses, institutional exteriors, and multi-property clients
• Customers return year after year - some for over two decades across multiple properties

"Aquinas painting went above and beyond including repair work having nothing to do with painting. As an example, they replace bulbs for outside lighting that were too high for me to reach." - Valerie Egana, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Quality of finished work is the theme that runs through nearly every review for painting contractors in the Thiells, NY area. Pro Painting Plus draws consistent descriptions of results that exceed expectations - one customer described a cedar and teak house as completely unrecognizable in the best possible way after Rob and his crew finished, and another noted a 52-year-old lake dock looked nearly new after sanding, staining, and power washing. For MGP Painting, Inc., quality praise spans a wide variety of finishes: standard wall painting, patterned wallpaper, spray-applied matte specialty paint, and cabinet resurfacing. One reviewer checked back in six months after a cabinet job and reported being just as impressed as on the day it was finished - a detail that speaks to the durability of the work, not just the initial appearance.

At Aquinas Painting Contractors, prep work emerges as a defining quality indicator in the reviews. T Pizarro described cracks, chipping, rough patches, and other problem areas in a bathroom that were carefully addressed before a drop of paint went on, while Samantha H noted a significant amount of patching on walls and ceilings that Aquinas completed without cutting corners on the finish. Jodi Frisch called the results on a full interior roofline project "impeccable" and noted everything was spotless when the crew left. In Thiells, NY and the surrounding communities, workmanship quality is consistently the reason customers from all three of these companies return for their next project.

"It's been six months since they painted our cabinets, and I'm still just as impressed as I was on day one. From start to finish, they did an absolutely amazing job." - Ian Bramlett, Google Review (Pro Painting Plus)"Alex and his team painted our entire interior roofline while also ensuring everything was spotless afterward. Their work was impeccable." - Jodi Frisch, Google Review (Aquinas Painting Contractors)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Across the top-rated contractors serving Thiells, NY, professionalism and communication are consistently mentioned as what separates a good painting experience from a great one. At MGP Painting, Inc., the communication structure runs both through the office - where coordinator Rachel is named by reviewers for keeping clients posted on scheduling and paint brand details - and through owner Moises, who personally calls in throughout active projects. Tara Culwell described MGP as easy to work with from first inquiry through project completion, and Deborah Broderick noted in her review that finding a contractor who takes the same care you would yourself is rare - and that MGP delivered on that standard. At Pro Painting Plus, Rob McRae's daily site visits and consistent client check-ins are a recurring theme, with customers noting they were never left wondering about the status of their project.

Aquinas Painting Contractors earns specific praise for communication during unexpected mid-project situations - Judee Toriello described Alex responding quickly after a refrigerator delivery crew damaged a wall and archway, handling repairs that fell entirely outside the painting scope without making it a complicated process. Conor Kennedy described consistent communication "throughout the entire process" as a standout feature of his Aquinas experience. Samantha H noted Alex stayed communicative even during a project that involved a significant amount of unplanned patching. For homeowners in Thiells, NY who have dealt with contractors who go quiet after signing a contract, all three of these companies represent a noticeably different standard.

"Moises communicates clearly, sticks to the projected timeline and does a great job!" - Sally Goldberg, Google Review (MGP Painting, Inc.)"We are very happy. They were responsive and quick but did an excellent job. Consistent communication throughout the entire process." - Conor Kennedy, Google Review (Aquinas Painting Contractors)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Pricing transparency and value come up frequently in reviews for painting contractors serving Thiells, NY, and the pattern across all three top-rated companies is consistent: detailed estimates upfront, fair pricing relative to the quality delivered, and no surprise charges when scope adjustments arise. MGP Painting, Inc. is particularly noted for its proposal process - multiple reviewers describe receiving itemized written estimates with a clear breakdown of what is and is not included before any work begins. Mahendra De Silva described interviewing several painters before selecting MGP and credited the detailed written quote and competitive pricing as key factors in his decision. Owner Moises is also described as flexible when small additional requests come up mid-project, without tacking on unexpected costs.

At Pro Painting Plus, fair pricing is frequently mentioned alongside the quality observation - Susan Kowalczyk, who was referred by family members, called the pricing "reasonable," and Ryan T described the company as doing "great work at an affordable price." At Aquinas Painting Contractors, Brian Ecclefield noted the estimate was fair from the start, and when secondary repairs came up during the project, the team was accommodating without making pricing a point of friction. Joan Facelle called the result "prompt, courteous and excellent at a reasonable price." For homeowners in Thiells, NY comparing estimates, all three companies have strong records of delivering what they quoted without changing the number at the end.

"MGP Painting, Inc. had over 200 Google reviews and was selected after a detailed quote - Moises and his crew did a great job for the right price." - N M, Google Review (MGP Painting, Inc.)"The Aquinas team was awesome - fair price from the start, quality work, and they were very accommodating with secondary repairs and replacements that came up along the way." - Brian Ecclefield, Google Review (Aquinas Painting Contractors)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Prep work and post-job cleanup are recurring themes in reviews for painters serving Thiells, NY, and customers consistently describe crews that protect the home and leave it clean. At Pro Painting Plus, Cathie Swyka described Herbie and Juan carefully repairing cracks, seams, nail pops, and other wall blemishes before painting - thorough prep work that reviewers credit for the professional-looking finish. Kate Crouse noted the crew cleaned up after a living room and flooring project so thoroughly that the space was immaculate when they left. Rob Cuite praised the crew as "neat and professional" throughout an exterior job, from estimate to completion.

At Aquinas Painting Contractors, reviewers consistently note that furniture is covered, floors are protected, and the space is left in order when the crew departs. Robbi Anderson described expecting a complicated cleanup and instead finding the team returned furniture to its proper place when finished. Sean McGowan described the crew as "thorough, clean, quiet and respectful of our belongings" - a line that echoes the tone of many other Aquinas reviews. At MGP Painting, Inc., Savannah Lopez noted the crew "worked cleanly" throughout a week-long project, and Eric Dallendorfer described a crew that cleaned up "like they were never there" and addressed all punch-list items quickly. For homeowners in Thiells, NY concerned about the disruption that comes with a painting project, all three contractors have strong records of keeping the job site clean and orderly.

"Herbie and Juan meticulously repaired cracks, seams, nail pops, and other wall blemishes. They were hardworking and I would definitely recommend." - Cathie Swyka, Google Review (Pro Painting Plus)"They were thorough, clean, quiet and respectful of our belongings. We highly recommend them." - Sean McGowan, Google Review (Aquinas Painting Contractors)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook