We evaluated every painting company that serves West Haverstraw, NY. One scored 80 or higher. Each Chooz Score weighs 44 factors across customer reviews, review quality and engagement, digital presence, and business authority.
Monroe, NY · (845) 764-0536
Services: Interior painting · Exterior painting · Cabinet painting · Commercial painting
Want us to do the work for you and find you the best painting contractor?
Get StartedFREE SERVICEHomeowners in and around West Haverstraw, NY have access to several well-reviewed painting contractors, each earning strong marks on Chooz Painters across platforms including Google, Facebook, Yelp, and Angi. From detailed interior repaints to full exterior projects, deck staining, cabinet refinishing, and specialty repair work, the top-rated companies in this area cover a wide range of residential and commercial needs.
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, C.E.T. Painting had over 240 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and earned a Chooz Score of 90.9%. The company also holds a 100% recommended on Facebook rating and 4.7 stars on Yelp, and is accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2022. Based in Elmsford and led by owner Carlos, the team is known for arriving on time, keeping job sites tidy each day, and frequently finishing work ahead of the projected completion date. The scope of work in their reviews is wide: home offices, exterior stucco on a nearly century-old house, library spaces, auto businesses, and full interior repaints. If you need a contractor who handles residential and commercial projects with the same standard of care, C.E.T. is a strong choice.
Also serving the West Haverstraw, NY area, Pro Painting Plus has built a following around owner Rob McRae's hands-on involvement throughout every job. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.6% and have collected over 75 Google reviews. What sets this company apart in the reviews is Rob's pattern of visiting the site each day, personally reviewing the finished work, and having any imperfections corrected before the crew leaves. The team also takes on unusually demanding specialty projects - a historic tin roof from 1865, a 52-year-old lakeside dock restoration, and epoxy garage floors have all appeared in customer reviews. If you want an owner-involved experience with strong attention to detail from estimate through final coat, Pro Painting Plus is a good fit.
With over 13 years in business, MGP Painting, Inc. has expanded from their Orangeburg base across Rockland County and Westchester into New Jersey, earning a Chooz Score of 87.2%. At the time of our analysis, they had over 200 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, along with 96% recommended on Facebook and 5.0 stars on Angi. Owner Moises runs a full-service operation with an in-house office team - reviewer Tara Culwell specifically praised Rachel in the office for seamless scheduling and coordination. Customers with specialty surface needs like patterned wallpaper, cabinet resurfacing, or spray finishes will find that MGP handles these in-house. If your project involves multiple surfaces or a more complex scope, MGP is a reliable and thorough option.
Rounding out the top contractors serving West Haverstraw, NY, Aquinas Painting Contractors brings nearly 40 years of experience dating back to 1987. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.3% and hold over 80 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi. Founded by Jim Dugandzic and now led by Alex Solis, the company is based in Valley Cottage and serves Rockland County, Westchester County, and Bergen County NJ. Aquinas handles both interior and exterior scopes with the same crew, making them a convenient option for homeowners who don't want to coordinate separate contractors. Their Rockland County Home Improvement Contractor License is verified, and all painters carry OSHA certification. If you're looking for a company with deep community roots and a long record of satisfied customers, Aquinas has the history to back it up.
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi
Across all four top-rated companies on Chooz Painters serving West Haverstraw, NY, one theme runs through review after review: the finished results consistently exceed what customers expected going in. C.E.T. Painting earns this praise across a wide variety of project types. Michael Miller hired Carlos and his crew to paint the exterior of a stucco house that "had never been painted since being built almost 100 years ago" and reported that the team was thorough with prep work and made sure the details were right throughout. Laura Buckley's review described an exterior "in poor condition" after 12 years unpainted as genuinely renewed after C.E.T. finished. For Pro Painting Plus, quality recognition focuses on the depth of prep work before a brush is ever picked up. Tracey Brooker, a returning customer, writes that she is "always impressed with the prep work - which gives that professional finish," and notes that Rob personally reviews the work and corrects imperfections on-site.
MGP Painting, Inc. earns quality marks particularly on specialty surfaces and complex projects. Valerie Gruber noted that the crew "seamlessly patched all of the holes in our ceiling and walls and took great care prepping the interior and our newly refinished floors to avoid any damage." Cindy Ferramosca wrote that her kitchen cabinet results "surpassed my expectations" entirely. For Aquinas Painting Contractors, quality praise often comes alongside comments on how quickly excellent results are delivered. T Pizarro described a bathroom with "cracks, chipping, rough patches, and other problem areas" and said the painter was "exceptionally skilled, professional, and clearly took pride in the work." Brian Ecclefield praised Aquinas for tackling a "difficult paint and prep that had decades of paint neglect" and delivering quality work from start to finish.
~Review Snippet Sources: Google
Professionalism and clear communication are among the most frequently mentioned strengths across painting companies serving West Haverstraw, NY. At C.E.T. Painting, owner Carlos serves as the primary point of contact from estimate through final walkthrough. Angela Frere described "exceptional communication and professionalism" from the team, noting that Carlos was "prompt" from the first interaction. Alex Lindquist, who has used CET for multiple projects, writes that Carlos and the team "communicate effectively" on every job and that "each job has been done well, on time, and with no issues." Pro Painting Plus stands out for owner Rob McRae's daily presence during jobs. Shannon Bostwick called communication and follow-through "top notch from start to finish," and Jean Kenny, a returning customer, notes that Rob guided her through color choices with a specialist before the team got to work - making the whole process feel personal and thorough.
Owner involvement in communication is a consistent pattern at MGP Painting, Inc. as well. Moises provides detailed estimates before starting, responds to virtually every Google review with personalized replies, and drops by mid-project to discuss progress and answer questions. Susan K. wrote that "Moises came promptly to evaluate our project and provided a detailed estimate at a fair price," with the crew completing the task ahead of schedule. Aquinas Painting Contractors earns communication praise specifically at the scheduling and quoting stage. Conor Kennedy called the team "responsive and quick" while still delivering "an excellent job," and Valinda Brady described Alex as making "the entire process seamless." Samantha H., who had significant patching work alongside painting, noted that "Alex was very communicative and the team completed the job quickly and neatly."
~Review Snippet Sources: Google
Cleanup standards are a recurring topic in reviews for painters serving West Haverstraw, NY, and the feedback is consistently strong. C.E.T. Painting reviewers frequently mention daily cleanup as a standard practice. Cathy Demarchis noted the team showed "great attention to detail" and "left each day with area cleaned up," while Michelle Kupper wrote that "everything was back in its place" after the work finished. Jeannette Boccini described how the painter "protected my floors leading to both bathrooms, worked diligently throughout the day and finished promptly." For Pro Painting Plus, protection of surrounding areas earns specific praise. Christine Weber noted that "furniture and other rooms were protected so that there would be no dust in these rooms" during sanding work, while Andrea Volpe highlighted that the crew "protected all of my plants, cleaned up afterwards" on a deck staining job. Cathie Swyka described the Pro Painting crew as leaving finished areas "clean every day" on a multi-session interior project.
MGP Painting, Inc. reviewers highlight both pre-work protection and post-work cleanup. Kay Chin noted the crew "made sure to drape" throughout and "arrived every day at the time they said." Eric Dallendorfer wrote that the crew "cleaned up like they were never there" and handled punch list items quickly. Aquinas Painting Contractors is particularly recognized for this aspect of their work. Cindy Lynch described the team going "above and beyond to be sure everything was to our liking and left the house spotlessly clean and lovely." Robbi Anderson noted they "returned furniture to its proper place after completion," calling the experience easier than expected in every way. FRANK CATALDO, who used Aquinas three times in a year and a half, specifically noted that "the job gets done quickly with no messes left behind."
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook
Fair pricing and strong value come up consistently in reviews for painting contractors serving West Haverstraw, NY, and the overall message is that these companies deliver results worth the investment. C.E.T. Painting customers frequently note that estimates are accurate and final invoices match what was quoted. Holly Palmer described the team as "extremely professional" with pricing she called "somewhat reasonable in today's market," while David Palmer highlighted that six rooms were painted at "a reasonable price" with no surprises at the end. Laura Buckley described Carlos's estimate as "itemized, detailed" and comprehensive, with "every question answered." Pro Painting Plus earns value praise from customers who compare it favorably against other bids they received. Lyn Nelson described "incredible work" at "very fair pricing" on a ceiling and room painting job, and Ryan T. summarized his experience as quality work, attention to detail, efficient, professional, and courteous at "an affordable price."
MGP Painting, Inc. has a strong reputation for competitive, transparent pricing across its service area. Erik Doebler noted that MGP delivered "excellent, professional service for a very reasonable price," and Adam Stuart reported that after getting three quotes, "MGP was a clear winner." Scotty Hernandez added that they "are also really affordable." Aquinas Painting Contractors reviews echo this pattern. Rick Doherty described a condo project completed "neatly on time at a reasonable price" and added there was "no reason to shop around." Joan Facelle called the job "prompt, courteous and excellent" at "a reasonable price," and Brian Ecclefield praised Aquinas for giving "a fair price from the start" on a project with complex prep requirements that had decades of paint buildup to address.
~Review Snippet Sources: Google
Repeat customers are a defining feature across the top-rated painting contractors serving West Haverstraw, NY, showing up throughout the review histories of all four companies on Chooz Painters. At C.E.T. Painting, the loyalty pattern is striking. Peter Frankel describes working with Carlos "for many years" and notes he "never disappoints." Elyse Hawkey writes that she has "had Carlos and his team out several times for painting and trim work." Stephanie notes that the team has completed "a few jobs on our house, including painting the entire exterior" and that "every time we have asked Carlos and his team to complete work for us, we have been satisfied." Mike Myllek describes using CET twice and says it was "a great experience both times." For Pro Painting Plus, Ralph Rivera describes this as his "second time using Pro Paint Plus" and returns because "they care about the quality of their work." Jean Kenny, another repeat customer, notes her "decision to hire again was easy" based on a positive first experience, and Christine Brighton reviewed the company twice - once for a house paint and once for an epoxy garage floor.
At MGP Painting, Inc., the repeat customer base spans years of relationship with owner Moises. Barbara Strauss has worked with the company on "3 big home painting projects over the last 5 years" and describes consistently "professional and reliable" results each time. Maria Lizarzaburu reports that MGP "did two separate jobs for us over the past year" and plans to work with them again in the future. Savannah Lopez reviewed MGP twice - once for exterior work and once for kitchen cabinets - writing positively about both experiences. At Aquinas Painting Contractors, the longevity of customer relationships is remarkable. Robert Williamson describes having "used Aquinas Painting for many years" across house painting and interior renovations. Michael Tedesco first hired Aquinas years ago for a full house paint and recently returned for a porch project, reporting "great job" on both occasions. FRANK CATALDO used the company three times within a year and a half, calling the work "excellent" every time.
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook
Every painter listed on this page has been evaluated using the Chooz multi-step quality process. We combine data analysis with human review to identify companies that consistently deliver strong results for property owners in West Haverstraw, NY.
The Chooz Score is a 100-point rating built on platform reviews, review quality and engagement, website and digital presence, and business authority and operations. We use the same scoring framework nationwide while evaluating each contractor's performance specifically within West Haverstraw, NY.
