Best Painters Near Garnerville, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Garnerville, NY have access to several highly rated painting contractors, each with strong track records for quality finishes, clear communication, and reliable scheduling. Whether you need kitchen cabinets refinished, a full interior repaint, or exterior work on your deck, the top-rated companies serving the Garnerville area consistently earn praise for treating customers' homes with care.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, NYCA Contractors, LLC had over 115 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating. They earned a Chooz Score of 88.9%, along with 5.0 stars on Angi with over 40 reviews and 100% recommended on Facebook. NYCA specializes in cabinet refinishing, using an off-site spray process that produces a factory-quality finish. Review after review describes guests mistaking refinished cabinets for brand new replacements. If you are looking to update aging kitchen cabinets without the cost of a full remodel, NYCA Contractors is a strong choice.

Owner Al (Albano) is named in the majority of reviews, and several customers highlight how quickly he provides detailed quotes by text or phone. Customers with older cabinets, including those over 20 and 30 years old, consistently describe results that exceeded their expectations. Romino handles on-site installation, and the two-person team is praised for keeping kitchens functional throughout the process.

• Multiple reviewers describe completing the entire cabinet refinishing project in under two weeks, with minimal disruption to daily routines
• Several customers in co-op and condo buildings note that NYCA worked smoothly with building management requirements and weekend-only schedules
• Repeat customers appear in the reviews, including one who returned for a second project after being impressed with the first

"I am beyond thrilled with how beautiful my kitchen came out. I could not do an entire renovation and new cabinetry was out of the question. Albano and his company saved the day for an affordable price." - Madalyn Frank, Google Review

For homeowners in the Garnerville, NY area looking for a full-service painting contractor with deep roots in the Hudson Valley, Pro Painting Plus earned a Chooz Score of 87.6% with over 130 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating. A family-owned business based in Monroe, NY with over 40 years in business, Pro Painting Plus handles everything from interior repaints and cabinet spray finishes to deck staining, exterior work, and even historic restorations. Owner Rob McRae (Bobby) is mentioned by name in nearly every review, and customers describe his hands-on approach to estimates, daily check-ins, and follow-through.

What stands out in the reviews is the range of project types. One customer hired them to restore an original 1865 tin roof. Another had them refinish cabinets with a spray finish that still looked flawless six months later. Deck staining, cedar home refinishing, and wallpaper removal are all well-represented. If you need a painter who can handle unusual or large-scale projects, Pro Painting Plus is a good fit.

• Named crew members like Dario, Herbie, Juan, Luis, and Miguel appear across reviews, suggesting a stable and experienced team
• Customers frequently mention that Rob personally visits the job site daily to check on progress and address any concerns
• Several reviews highlight the quality of prep work, including wall repairs, crack patching, and surface preparation before painting begins

"It's been six months since they painted our cabinets, and I'm still just as impressed as I was on day one." - Ian Bramlett, Google Review

Also serving the Garnerville, NY area, MGP Painting Inc. earned a Chooz Score of 87.2% with over 200 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. At the time of our analysis, they also held 5.0 stars on Angi with over 10 reviews and were 96% recommended on Facebook. Based in Orangeburg with over 13 years in business, owner Moises leads a team that handles interior and exterior painting, deck staining, cabinet refinishing, and wallpaper installation. If you want a contractor with a large review history and consistent results across a wide variety of project types, MGP Painting is a solid option.

One pattern that stands out in the reviews is how many customers first encountered MGP Painting by seeing their work in the community. One reviewer hired them after watching the crew paint her local library. Others describe returning for second, third, and even fourth projects over the years. Crew members Galo, Caesar, and Orlando are praised by name, and office coordinator Rachel receives credit for smooth scheduling.

• Customers with complex projects, including popcorn ceilings, multi-level staircases, and high ceilings with recessed lighting, describe results that exceeded expectations
• Wallpaper installation appears as a specialty, with reviewers praising both patterned wallpaper and specialty finishes like black matte paint

"I noticed the professionalism and detail oriented crew of MGP painting my local library; I went in to hire the company to paint part of my house. The price was fair for such a quality job." - Loretta Jara, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Garnerville, NY, Aquinas Painting Contractors earned a Chooz Score of 86.3% with over 80 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. They also hold 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi with over 9 reviews. With nearly 40 years in business since 1987, Aquinas has built the kind of customer loyalty that speaks for itself. Based in Valley Cottage, they serve Rockland County, Westchester, Bergen County NJ, and Orange County NY. If you value a painting contractor with decades of community roots and a crew that treats your home with genuine respect, Aquinas is worth calling.

The depth of repeat business in the Aquinas reviews is striking. Multiple customers describe hiring them across different properties and returning year after year. Owner Alex Solis, who took over from founder Jim Dugandzic, is praised for quick, reasonable quotes and flexibility in scheduling. Crew members Miguel and Manuel are noted for their speed and precision, and several reviewers mention that the team went beyond the painting scope to help with small extras like replacing hard-to-reach light bulbs.

• Customers consistently note that Aquinas crews leave spaces cleaner than they found them, with furniture moved back into place after completion
• Reviews describe successful work on everything from warehouse conversions and convent exteriors to bathroom ceiling repairs and pool deck power washing
• The company holds Rockland County Home Improvement Contractor License No. H-25-030, and all painters carry OSHA certification

"Best painting staff in the tri-state area! Alex was extremely professional from the first contact. I have always been leery of contractors in my home." - John Viola, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Customers across Garnerville, NY consistently praise the quality of finished work from local painting contractors. Whether the project involves kitchen cabinet refinishing, full interior repaints, or exterior deck staining, reviewers describe results that meet or exceed professional standards. NYCA Contractors, LLC receives particular praise for their factory-level cabinet finishes, with customers describing results so polished that visitors assume the cabinets were replaced entirely. "Excellent work combined with professionalism. This is how you get an incredible kitchen from these wonderful and experienced guys." - Georgia Panagiotakos, Google Review. Pro Painting Plus earns similar praise for both interior and exterior projects, with one reviewer noting that a cedar home exterior looked completely renewed. "My wife and I were very pleased with the painting project performed by Pro Painting Plus. They were timely, neat and took good care of our furniture." - Theodore Goetz, Google Review

MGP Painting Inc. draws praise for handling difficult projects with care. Customers describe successful results on popcorn ceilings, high walls, and detailed trim work. "We worked with MGP Painting after sourcing a few quotes from different painters. During the process, MGP and their team was extremely careful, intentional, and responsive to our requests even when they came at the last minute." - Adan Horta, Google Review. Aquinas Painting Contractors also earns consistent marks for quality, with customers noting clean lines, smooth finishes, and careful repair work on walls and ceilings before painting. "Aquinas painted the entire interior of my townhome and I was very pleased with the final product. My home feels brand new." - George Moraitis, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Strong communication is one of the most frequently praised qualities among painting contractors serving Garnerville, NY. NYCA Contractors, LLC owner Al responds to phone and text inquiries quickly, often providing same-day quotes with photos. Customers describe clear explanations of timelines and the refinishing process from start to finish. "Al and his team were extremely communicative from the very beginning about the process, timeline and what they needed us to do to prep." - Tim Reid, Google Review. Pro Painting Plus owner Rob McRae takes a similar approach, with reviewers noting daily site visits and consistent updates throughout each project. "From the very beginning until completion, communication and follow through was top notch!" - Shannon Bostwick, Google Review

MGP Painting Inc. provides detailed written estimates and maintains regular contact through their office coordinator Rachel. Owner Moises is praised for following up personally during and after projects. "Moises communicates clearly, sticks to the projected timeline and does a great job!" - Sally Goldberg, Google Review. Aquinas Painting Contractors owner Alex Solis earns praise for responsive scheduling and clear project updates. "We are very happy. They were responsive and quick but did an excellent job. Consistent communication throughout the entire process." - Conor Kennedy, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Cleanup and preparation are among the most commonly praised aspects of painting contractors in Garnerville, NY. NYCA Contractors, LLC reviewers frequently note that the team left their homes spotless after cabinet work, with no dust or debris. "Their work is clean. There was no dust all over my house, so so professional." - Esther LaPera, Google Review. Pro Painting Plus earns similar praise, with customers noting that furniture was carefully protected and spaces were tidied each day before the crew left. "They took great care to keep the rest of my home clean from the work being done." - Charlotte Mifsud, Google Review

MGP Painting Inc. customers describe thorough protection of floors, furniture, and fixtures before painting begins, with careful cleanup at the end of each day. "Work was done professionally and left perfectly clean. Workers were amazing and accommodating to specifications." - Helene, Google Review. Aquinas Painting Contractors goes a step further, with multiple reviewers noting that the crew returned furniture to its original position after completion. "The team was punctual, clean, careful and did an excellent job. They cleaned up thoroughly when they were done." - Robbi Anderson, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Pricing comes up frequently in reviews for painting contractors serving Garnerville, NY, and the feedback is overwhelmingly positive. NYCA Contractors, LLC customers describe their cabinet refinishing as a cost-effective alternative to full kitchen renovations. Several reviewers mention that the pricing was fair given the quality of the spray finish and the turnaround time. "Nyca's prices are fair and in line with the time and effort that was invested in the job." - Yossi Pinkas, Google Review. Pro Painting Plus also receives consistent praise for reasonable pricing, with customers noting competitive quotes and no surprise charges. "Quality painting at a fair price." - Stacey Punch, Google Review

MGP Painting Inc. is frequently described as competitively priced, with many reviewers noting that they received multiple quotes and chose MGP based on the combination of value and quality. "A wonderful experience from start to finish. Pricing was very fair." - Gail Saretto, Google Review. Aquinas Painting Contractors rounds out the value picture, with customers regularly describing fair estimates and no unexpected costs. "Prompt, courteous and excellent job for a reasonable price." - Joan Facelle, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google