16 Best Painters Near Laurel Hollow, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Laurel Hollow, NY have access to several highly reviewed painting contractors serving the North Shore of Long Island. Across hundreds of verified reviews, customers consistently highlight crew reliability, thorough prep work, and the kind of communication that keeps projects running smoothly from estimate through final walkthrough.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Teall Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.6%, along with 5.0 stars on Yelp and active profiles on Angi and Nextdoor. Owner Charlie Cascio runs the company out of Massapequa Park with over 12 years in business, and reviews reveal a pattern of customers feeling comfortable enough to leave their homes while the crew works. Multiple reviewers describe handing over their keys and returning to find rooms spotless and finished. If you have a specialty project like cedar restoration or cabinet refinishing that other contractors have struggled with, Teall Painting is a good choice.

What stands out in the reviews is how often customers mention Charlie checking in during the project to make sure everything is on track. Several first-time homeowners describe feeling guided through the process, from color selection to final touch-ups. The company holds Nassau County Home Improvement Contractor License No. 204692 and backs all work with a 2-year Iron-Clad Warranty.

• Customers frequently mention individual painters by name, including Gavin, Victor, Renee, and Jose, suggesting consistent in-house crews rather than rotating subcontractors
• Several reviews describe Teall handling projects other contractors turned down or failed to complete properly, including mahogany door refinishing and stucco exterior work
• The company offers virtual estimates, which reviewers say speeds up the booking process significantly

"As first time homeowners my wife and I were a little anxious having our western red cedar home and deck restored and restained. The color was bleeding and some shingles had damage from previous bad work. Charlie and his team exceeded our expectations." - Rhoderick Blasco, Google Review

With over 200 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating, Frank's Painting of LI LLC has built one of the largest verified review records of any painter in the area. They also earned a Chooz Score of 87.6%, with over 340 reviews on Angi at 5.0 stars, over 70 Yelp reviews at 4.7 stars, and 98% recommended on Facebook. Frank has been operating since 2015 and explicitly states the company does not sub-contract jobs. If you want a larger operation with multiple crews available and a free interior designer color consultation included with bigger projects, Frank's Painting is a good choice.

A recurring theme across reviews is the trust factor. Multiple customers describe leaving their homes entirely while Frank's crew worked inside, returning to find furniture back in place and floors vacuumed. The company also handles older homes well, with several reviewers specifically mentioning plaster repair, wallpaper removal, and skim coating on walls that were in rough shape. Nassau County Home Improvement Contractor License No. H3811120000 is verified active.

• Repeat customers appear frequently in the reviews, with some on their third or fourth project, often expanding from a single room to full-home interior jobs
• The free color consultation with an affiliated interior designer is mentioned positively by several reviewers who found it helpful for choosing modern palettes
• Cabinet painting and kitchen refreshes are a common specialty, with reviewers noting the sprayed finish looks factory-new

"I spoke with the owner on Thursday and his crew came that Wednesday not only on time but early. They were so polite. We left the house and totally trusted them in our home." - Randy Charles, Google Review

For homeowners who value long-term relationships with their contractor, Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting has been serving the area for over 25 years. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.7% with over 245 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, plus over 80 Angi reviews at 5.0 stars and over 25 Yelp reviews at 4.8 stars. Owner David Walker founded the company in 1995, and Sal Sciame manages day-to-day operations and estimates. If you are looking for a company where most employees have been on staff for over 15 years and you can request specific crew members for return projects, Walker Painting is a good choice.

The loyalty pattern in Walker's reviews is hard to miss. Multiple customers describe using the company across several homes or returning five or more times over the years. Neighbors recommending Walker to each other is a thread that runs through dozens of reviews. The company also handles crown molding installation, base molding, and carpentry alongside painting, which reviewers appreciate as a one-stop solution for room refreshes.

• Sal is praised across nearly every review for same-day or next-day estimate turnaround and clear, upfront pricing
• Crew members Hugo, Miguel, Luis, and Juan appear by name in dozens of reviews spanning multiple years
• Several reviewers mention Walker bringing their own porta potty for exterior jobs, a detail that distinguishes them from other contractors

"My house was in great need of an overhaul, the front and back doors were peeling and the 25 year old shutters were very faded. Dave and his team power washed the house, walkway and patio and put down new mulch before starting to paint. Everything looks amazing." - Jane Arena, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Professionalism and communication are the most frequently praised qualities among painting contractors serving Laurel Hollow, NY. Customers of Teall Painting regularly highlight how owner Charlie keeps them updated throughout the project, with one reviewer noting that Charlie checked in daily to confirm satisfaction before the crew moved to the next area. Frank's Painting of LI LLC earns similar praise for responsiveness during the estimate phase, with multiple reviewers describing same-day callbacks and detailed written quotes. "Frank was a pleasure to deal with and very professional. Marcelo my painter was a sweetheart and exceeded my expectations." - Anna Marie Lombardi, Google Review. "Charlie was prompt and professional during the consultation. His estimate was detailed and addressed all our concerns." - Kyle Plati, Google Review

Walker Painting stands out for the consistency of their communication structure. Sal handles all estimates and scheduling while David stops by active job sites to check progress. Reviewers describe receiving quotes within hours of an initial walkthrough, which is notably faster than competitors. Several customers across all three companies mention that crews explained each step of the process before starting, which helped set expectations for timeline and disruption. "From first contact with Sal to the painters Juan, Martin and Ivan. What a magnificent, clean, precise job." - Deirdre Noonan, Google Review. "Very accommodating friendly business. A fantastic professional job." - Annamarie Gutierrez, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Quality and attention to detail are consistently praised across reviews for painters serving Laurel Hollow, NY. Customers of Teall Painting frequently describe finished walls and ceilings that look flawless, with several reviewers noting that crack repairs and spackle work were invisible once painted over. Frank's Painting of LI LLC draws similar praise for their ability to handle older homes with plaster walls and uneven surfaces, with one reviewer describing how the crew identified and repaired problem areas the homeowner had not even noticed. "The amount of work that needed to be completed in my house was done promptly and his crew was awesome. I can't believe how clean the house was even after the work was complete." - frank maringelli, Google Review. "My kitchen looks brand new! Excellent work. The crew was fantastic, arrived early, stayed late, cleaned up daily." - Rita Linchitz, Google Review

Walker Painting reviewers emphasize the prep work as a distinguishing factor, with customers describing how the crew fills every crack, sands every surface, and applies primer before any paint goes on. Multiple reviewers compare the finished result to new construction. Cabinet painting is a specialty across all three companies, with customers describing sprayed finishes that look factory-applied. "They did such a wonderful job. The cabinets look new again!" - Christina Regnault, Google Review. "Had our kitchen cabinets painted and they look fabulous!" - Mary Cleary, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Timeliness is one of the strongest themes in reviews for Laurel Hollow, NY area painters. Walker Painting receives particularly consistent praise for punctuality, with reviewers describing crews arriving on or before the scheduled start time every single day of multi-day projects. Sal's ability to provide quick turnaround on estimates is also a frequent highlight. Teall Painting customers note that Charlie provides clear timelines upfront and keeps the project on track, with several reviewers mentioning that work was completed ahead of schedule. "They came when they said they were coming and completed the job when they said they would." - Eileen Leddy, Google Review. "Showed up every single day on time. They cleaned up every day." - an Angi reviewer for Walker Painting

Frank's Painting of LI LLC also draws praise for efficiency, with multiple reviewers expressing surprise at how quickly crews completed large projects. Several customers mention that jobs they expected to take a week were finished in two or three days without any drop in quality. Across all three companies, the pattern is clear: crews arrive when promised and communicate promptly if anything changes. "They were on time, on budget and extremely professional." - Nicholas Bryan Contardo, Google Review. "Got the job done much faster than we expected." - Natalie Kovach-Anta, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Angi

Cleanup and property protection are among the most frequently mentioned positives for painting contractors near Laurel Hollow, NY. Frank's Painting of LI LLC is especially well-known for leaving homes cleaner than they found them. Reviewers consistently describe drop cloths throughout, furniture carefully covered, and daily vacuuming before crews leave for the day. Teall Painting earns similar praise, with customers highlighting how crews use plastic sheathing and builder's paper to protect finished floors and surfaces before any work begins. "They covered everything, cleaned up every day, and I barely knew they'd been there." - a Facebook reviewer for Frank's Painting. "He was professional and extremely careful when moving items in the kitchen. He cleaned up and was a pleasure to have in my home." - Marie Walkowiak, Google Review

Walker Painting reviewers describe crews that restore rooms to their original order each evening, moving furniture back into place after completing a section. Several customers note that there was no paint on floors, trim, or fixtures after the project was finished. Across all three companies, the care taken with customer property appears to be a point of pride rather than an afterthought. "The painters were on time, polite and friendly, cleaned everything up before they left." - Nina Justin, Google Review. "Very pleased with every aspect. Miguel and crew are careful to cover and protect everything starting at the front door." - an Angi reviewer for Walker Painting

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Angi