David Allyn launched Allyn Painting in Fairport, New York after transitioning from a career as a New York State Department of Corrections counselor, channeling more than two decades of painting experience built since age 18. David makes a point to be on-site for every job. Crew leader Greg oversees large exterior projects while Dave Lyle manages interior residential work. The team maintains a diverse employee and client base, proudly serving the local LGBTQ community and welcoming veterans and active-duty personnel. All crew members live a life of sobriety.
The company handles both interior and exterior residential painting, with particular expertise in full exterior transformations, cabinet refinishing, and staining. Projects range from single-room refreshes and wallpaper removal to multi-day exterior jobs covering siding, trim, doors, and wood repairs. Customers consistently highlight the crew's thorough preparation process, which includes pressure washing, sanding, and surface repairs before any paint is applied.
Allyn Painting LLC serves the Rochester metropolitan area throughout Monroe County, including Brighton, Fairport, Greece, Pittsford, Penfield, Rush, Henrietta, and Webster.
Updated: 04-06-2026
David Allyn brings over 20 years of painting experience to his Fairport company, a craft he started at 18 and built alongside a career as a New York State Corrections counselor. Crew leader Greg handles large exterior jobs while Dave Lyle focuses on interior residential work. David McMorrow gave a specific "shout out to Greg and all the crew" after a two-story exterior, while Lisa Hilfiker called Dave Lyle her "go-to" painter after using the company more than once.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
The preparation process defines Allyn Painting jobs for customers who notice it. Michael Tetamore called the crew "very detailed with the prep work," praising the sanding and repairs done before any painting began. KATSAR described the prep as "second to none" after the team washed, sanded, and completed repairs throughout the exterior. Erik Stone highlighted the crew's sanding during a challenging wood shakes project, noting extra coats were applied to ensure proper coverage.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Multiple customers reference three-day timelines for full exterior projects. Joseph Perkins described Allyn Painting transforming his home "in only 3 days" from something he called an embarrassment to something his family could be proud of. Judie Hart and Renee each confirmed similar timeframes. Renee noted the crew "arrived early each day and completed the work promptly" while cleaning up on every visit, keeping the project moving without sacrificing prep or quality.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Cabinet refinishing consistently earns strong reactions. Terry Fiorica described Allyn Painting transforming dark kitchen cabinets to white, saying the result made the kitchen look "so much bigger and brighter." Kim Joslyn called the cabinet work "impeccable" and said her entire project "came out beautiful." Both customers mentioned recommending the company to friends and family after their refinishing experience, and Fiorica added plans to call the crew for future paint jobs.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Crew behavior draws attention across Allyn Painting reviews. Judie Hart noted workers maintained "no smoking or swearing" with music "appropriate for little ears at a reasonable volume" throughout the project. Sara McElroy called the crew "friendly, hard working and clean" and praised their attentiveness with her dogs, noting gates were never left open. Nick Russell described every crew member as "respectful and personable throughout the entire job."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Homeowner trust is a repeated theme in Allyn Painting reviews. Bethany L stated she would "trust this crew in my home when I'm not in the house," calling them "very trustworthy and reliable." Bill Katerle described David's crew of four as "polite, well mannered, pleasant, and quiet" while working in his mother-in-law's condo. Alyson Ulrich became a repeat customer for that same reason, noting she would hire no one else to paint her home.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Pricing is described positively across multiple Allyn Painting reviews. Judie Hart called the estimate "more than competitive" for a full three-day exterior project. Bindu Kasarla praised the company for being "very honest with the pricing" across projects spanning several years. Sara McElroy noted David came to the property in person before providing any quote, and Alyson Ulrich became a repeat customer after her first experience, calling the results "exceptional."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
New York State does not require a state-level painting contractor license. The Town of Perinton and Monroe County, where Allyn Painting operates, have no municipal or county painting contractor license requirements. Allyn Painting LLC is registered with the New York State Division of Corporations as a Domestic Limited Liability Company, DOS ID 5815824, Active status, filed August 19, 2020. The entity's biennial statement is currently past due.
-Verification Sources: New York State Division of Corporations
Updated: 04-07-2026