Our Chooz Score evaluates 44 factors across reviews, digital presence, and business credentials. Here's what stands out for Keith's Painting and Powerwashing Inc
When Robert Ponzi needed his three-story home painted during a sweltering summer, painter Angel showed up at 7 AM to beat the heat, sending text updates throughout the six-month project. Ponzi called Keith "on the top of my list because of his honesty, communication skills and workmanship." This attention to customer needs defines how Keith Barbone has run his painting operation for over 25 years.
Keith founded the company from his Nesconset roots, building it into a recognized name across Suffolk County's North Shore. His wife Kerri manages scheduling and client communication while Keith personally conducts every estimate and maintains daily presence on job sites. Foreman Dimas leads crews that include painters Angel, Fernando, Rolando, Christopher, and Marlon, the same team customers frequently request by name for repeat projects.
The fully licensed and insured company handles interior and exterior residential painting alongside soft washing, paver cleaning and sealing, deck staining, cedar shake restoration, gutter cleaning, and holiday lighting installation. Keith and Kerri offer a one-year labor warranty on all work and serve communities within approximately 20 miles of Nesconset.
Updated: 04-06-2026
Punctuality appears in nearly every review. Gina described how the crew "showed up on time every day" during her multi-room interior project. Catherine noted they were "on time, completed in one day as promised." Keith provides specific arrival windows and crews communicate when en route, with lateness complaints essentially non-existent across reviews.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Reviews consistently praise the same team members project after project. Foreman Dimas appears in dozens of reviews for leadership and quality control. Michelle noted Dimas was "professional and hardworking" while managing her exterior project. Painters Angel, Fernando, Rolando, and Marlon receive individual recognition, with many customers requesting the same crew for repeat work.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Yelp
Protection and cleanup receive constant praise. Nancy found her home "cleaner than when they started" after interior painting. Crews use plastics and drop cloths on all surfaces, move furniture carefully, and perform daily cleanup rather than leaving debris until project completion. Multiple reviewers mention crews even vacuuming after finishing work.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Unlike companies where owners disappear after the sale, Keith remains hands-on throughout. Donna described how Keith "personally came to give the estimate and check on progress" during her project. Multiple reviews mention Keith visiting job sites daily, performing final walk-throughs, and handling touch-up requests himself rather than delegating to crews.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Multiple customers mention comparing quotes before choosing Keith. Andrea stated the pricing was "very fair for the quality of work" after getting three estimates. Anthony called it the "most fair estimate and included the paint." Reviews describe value-oriented rates without hidden upcharges or surprise additions to final invoices.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Yelp
The single negative review involved a drainage concern from power washing. Keith responded professionally, offering "a free re-wash" and direct phone contact rather than becoming defensive. This pattern of accountability over argument appears consistently when issues arise, with Keith prioritizing resolution over defending the company's reputation.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Word-of-mouth drives significant business after 25+ years in the same area. Patricia hired them after "multiple neighbors recommended them" following work on her street. Linda found them through her "sister who was thrilled with her house" painting. With decades serving Nesconset, Keith has painted multiple homes on the same blocks, creating visible proof for prospective customers.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Yes. Keith's Painting and Powerwashing holds Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License No. H-50074, issued May 2, 2012, in the Painting category. The license is currently active with status "About to Expire" and expiration date of May 1, 2026. The company is fully insured and has been licensed continuously for over 13 years. License verification is available through Suffolk County Department of Consumer Affairs at https://ca.suffolkcountyny.gov/dcasearch.
-Verification Sources: Suffolk County DCA License Database
Updated: 04-07-2026