Our Chooz Score evaluates 44 factors across reviews, digital presence, and business credentials. Here's what stands out for Whelehan Painting
Too many homeowners have experienced painting contractors who provide estimates then disappear, show up late, or send different crews every day. Owner Pat Whelehan understands these frustrations and has built Whelehan Painting around reliability and consistency. Founded by his father Chuck Whelehan in 1977, this Hilton-based family business now operates with 16 experienced employees who work as established teams on every project.
The company handles interior and exterior residential painting along with commercial projects, cabinet refinishing, deck staining, power washing, and wallpaper removal. Crew members including Paul, Karen, Tommy, Eric, and James appear repeatedly in customer feedback, demonstrating the team consistency that sets Whelehan apart. Pat personally handles estimates and maintains communication throughout each project.
The fully insured team serves Rochester, Hilton, Greece, Canandaigua, Victor, Henrietta, Pittsford, Fairport, Penfield, Honeoye Falls, and Brockport within the Greater Rochester area. Whelehan Painting operates on a no-deposit policy, with payment due only after customers are satisfied with completed work.
Updated: 04-16-2026
Punctuality emerges as one of the most consistent themes across reviews. Gillian Phillips notes the painters "arrived on time, kept the workspace neat" while Jared Kierecki confirms they "show up when they show up and get the job done when they say they will." Marcia W. on Yelp adds that the crew "arrived exactly on schedule and began work immediately." Pat maintains direct communication with customers throughout.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Yelp
Speed without sacrificing quality appears frequently in feedback. Kristie Murray shares that the team "completed the enormous job in a day and a half" for cabinet refinishing and an entire first floor repaint. Howie Less notes that while other contractors "estimated 2 weeks to complete the job" his exterior painting was finished in just two and a half days. The large crew size enables this efficiency.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Specific crew members earn repeated praise across reviews. Catherine M Moyer highlights "Paul, Rich, Gary and Tommy took excellent care of our home" while Dan lash thanks "Paul, Tommy, and Karen for doing such a great job." Sharon Mchenry specifically praises Karen, noting her work was "flawless" and she "worked late into the night to finish." These consistent team mentions demonstrate crew stability.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Customers consistently praise workspace management. Brad Schreiber notes the crew was "very careful to cover carpets and furniture, extremely neat." Kathie Ryan describes how "all of the furniture was moved and covered, and it was all put back when they finished" adding they "cleaned up and put away all of their materials each night." Vanessa Sheldon confirms they "left everything spotless when they finished."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Pricing fairness comes up repeatedly without prompting. Kyle Merton appreciates that "pricing didn't change after the work was performed" while Brad T reveals Whelehan "came in as the low ball amongst the companies I took bids from" yet delivered exceptional quality. Thomas Falbo adds that for his 1880s historic home restoration "their price was extremely fair." No deposit is required upfront.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Cabinet projects generate enthusiastic responses. Alicia Caiola-Hicks describes how Whelehan "transformed my kitchen cabinets" noting "the attention to detail was beyond impressive." John, a repeat customer, confirms "this is the second time we have hired Whelehan Painting" specifically for cabinet work, stating "they have always gone above and beyond." The company handles both painting and refinishing of existing cabinets.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Customer retention rates are notably high. Greg Rowe states "I've hired Whelehan 3 times over the last 6 years" for both interior and exterior work. Maureen DeVos represents the longest relationship, noting "Whelehan has been painting for us for about 17 years." Nick Pagano declares "Whelehan painting is the only place I will patronize" after using them for cabinets, exterior, and interior projects.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
The company maintains a strong response rate to reviews. When a disputed negative review appeared from Ann Oelheim, owner Pat responded directly, stating this was "a fake review from someone who i never did work for." David S demonstrates the company's commitment to long-term satisfaction, noting that five years after his original project, Pat "responded quickly and took care of" a touch-up request right away.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Whelehan Painting operates as WHELEHAN & FERRO INC., a Domestic Business Corporation registered with the New York Department of State. The corporation was filed on July 20, 2016 with DOS ID 4980142 and maintains Active status. Patrick Whelehan serves as the registered agent at the company's Hilton address. New York State does not require a statewide painting contractor license.
-Verification Sources: New York Department of State Division of Corporations
Updated: 04-16-2026