This is an image from Mr. Star Painting Corp, located in New York. The logo for Mr. Star Painting Corp features a green paint-swipe arc with five stars and a black paintbrush graphic beside the text 'Licensed & Insured.

Mr Star Painting Corp

This is an image from Mr. Star Painting Corp, located in New York. The logo for Mr. Star Painting Corp features a green paint-swipe arc with five stars and a black paintbrush graphic beside the text 'Licensed & Insured.
Mr Star Painting Corp gallery image 1
Mr Star Painting Corp gallery image 2
Mr Star Painting Corp gallery image 3
Mr Star Painting Corp gallery image 4

Chooz Score Insights

Scored by
Cher B.
Ed Anthony D.
April 2026

Customers Keep Coming Back

Crews like Jonathan, Michael, and Angel get called out by name in review after review, and so do the owners. But what really stands out is how many customers come back for a second, third, or even fourth project. The Chooz Score's customer retention indicators reflect this clearly: 8 documented repeat customers within the review period, with some relationships spanning nearly a decade:

  • Valerie Stone returned after 8 years and hired them again to paint her entire new home, calling the results "even better than the first time"
  • Joseph Consalazio has hired them 3 times, Scott Wadler twice, and Christopher Eccleston has brought them back for multiple commercial renovation projects over 3 years

"This is the second time I hired Mr. Star Painting. The first time was to paint the exterior of our house and refinish the deck. They did an amazing job! This time I needed my wooden interior steps sanded. Danielle who did the work, is super nice, professional and takes the time and does a great job." - Scott W., Google Review

Years of Consistent Results

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Mr. Star Painting Corp had over 235 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.3%. With 10 years in business serving Nassau and Suffolk Counties, they've built a strong cross-platform reputation:

  • The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, reviews spanned multiple platforms including 100% recommended on Facebook, 5.0 stars on Angi with 9 reviews, and 4.4 stars on Yelp
  • Over 14 new reviews in the last 3 months alone, confirming this is a company actively taking on and completing projects right now

"These are not just craftsmen, they are artists. Perfectly flat and smooth surfaces, cleaned up all the corners and lines, painting perfection!" - E180, Google Review

Crews You Can Trust

What sets Mr. Star Painting Corp apart is crew consistency. The Chooz Score's in-house crews component shows the same names appearing across dozens of unrelated reviews, which is a strong signal of employee retention rather than rotating subcontractors:

  • Jonathan leads crews on-site and is praised by name for communication and attention to detail. Michael, Angel, and Willy appear across interior, exterior, and cabinet projects spanning multiple years
  • Customers like Jayne describe the full team by name, from "owners Ricardo and Mario, to Crew Leader Jonathan, to the incredibly skilled plasterers and painters Michael, Willy and Jericho"

"From day one Ricardo and Mario were efficient and transparent with walk-thru, quotes, timeline, and finish touch-ups. Every staff member came in uniform identifiable and was polite and detail driven. Michael from their team was leading the group at my home and his patience and efforts were evident." - Josh C., Google Review

Worked with this company?

All verified feedback is published, positive or not. Identity and project verified before publication. Direct submissions are unpaid; invited customers may receive a disclosed $50 thank-you that never depends on their answers.

Additional Questions Answered

What stands out about Mr Star Painting Corp's approach to surface preparation before the crew starts painting?

Customers describe a process that goes well beyond a quick tape job. The crew covers floors with painters' paper, moves or wraps furniture, and sands walls between coats. Brian Edwards noted the team worked through prep, taping, spackling, and painting while leaving areas spotless at the end of each day. Rahul Gilani watched Frank do careful spackle and sanding on a bathroom ceiling before David applied the final coat, resulting in a surface that looked brand new.

Source: Google Reviews · Reviewed June 2026
How do Ricardo and Mario stay involved once a project is underway?

Both owners maintain a hands-on role throughout each job. Michelle Bennett observed that Ricardo and Mario visited the site every day to check progress and answer questions. Vita Schillinger described Mario arriving on the first day to oversee setup and returning on the last day to inspect every aspect of the finished work. Howard Goz noted that Ricardo was extremely knowledgeable about the painting process and stayed engaged from start to finish.

Source: Google Reviews · Reviewed June 2026
What kind of results do homeowners report from Mr Star Painting Corp's cabinet refinishing work?

Cabinet projects draw some of the most detailed praise. Howard Goz described Orlin's work as producing a 5 stars factory finish that saved thousands compared to replacement. Carl Greiner said the refinished kitchen cabinets looked better than new, with hinges readjusted so everything worked properly. Tom Drew reported that Orin and Noel arrived in uniform, worked six meticulous days, and delivered a result the family was thrilled with.

Sources: Google Reviews, Facebook · Reviewed June 2026
How does the team handle communication and scheduling on larger whole-home projects?

Reviewers on multi-room and whole-house projects praise the crew's ability to stay on timeline and keep homeowners informed. Justin Lundbye called the experience seamless, from clear communication through flawless execution. Cait Breault described how Ricardo responded quickly to color-change requests, coordinated wallpaper specialists, and still finished on schedule with toddlers, a baby, and a dog in the house. Adam Carlson highlighted same-day delivery of insurance and workers' comp paperwork for a co-op board approval.

Source: Google Reviews · Reviewed June 2026
What do customers say about Mr Star Painting Corp's exterior and deck staining work?

Exterior projects range from full-house siding painting to detailed deck restoration. CHUCK CARTER hired Mr Star after a friend's recommendation to repaint worn vinyl siding and said the house looked like new. Scott, a designer, described how the crew power washed, tapped down every nail, sanded, and hand-brushed Benjamin Moore deck oil, producing results that exceeded his expectations. Peter Bernstein summed up his deck transformation in one line, calling the crew meticulous.

Source: Google Reviews · Reviewed June 2026
How does the company handle the rare situation when a customer raises a concern about pricing?

The single critical review in the profile came from Louis, who felt the estimate was higher than a competitor's but had no work performed. The owner's response acknowledged that pricing varies depending on material quality, prep work, and long-term durability, and wished Louis well with whatever contractor he chose. Multiple other reviewers specifically praised fair and reasonable pricing, including Jeff Fulcoly, Alison Haan, and Billy D., who described getting good value for sharp, clean results.

Sources: Google Reviews, Yelp · Reviewed June 2026
What is Mr Star Painting Corp's licensing and business standing in New York?

The company holds an active Nassau County Home Improvement Contractor license (H3808430000) valid through August 2027, covering painting work for residential and commercial properties. Mr Star Painting Corp is registered as a domestic business corporation with the New York Department of State (DOS ID 4772694) with an active status and a current statement filing. The business maintains an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau.

-Verification Sources: Nassau County Office of Consumer Affairs, NY Department of State Division of Corporations, Better Business Bureau